The Fed is fighting deflation hand over fist, no?
What happened today ($600 Billion QE2)?
Gold will fill the void.
Why gold? Why not other commodities that actually have uses?
Why not equities that represent actual industrial production?
If you've got an ounce of gold, you've got an ounce of gold. But if you've got a sack of potatoes and an acre of fertile land,.... you've got potatoes for the rest of your life.
Why is this controversial?
Because it suggests that gold has magical properties that make it and only it a useful store of value.
Which is wrong at at least two levels. First, gold isn't the only store of value. More to the point, gold isn't even a useful store of value.
Until US housing (and the US economy) bottoms out the Fed will keep devaluing the USD in order to keep the US financial system solvent.
How can this be anything but bullish for USD-priced gold?
Well, first, the Fed is not devaluing the US dollar. The Fed is
trying to devalue the US dollar and failing miserably, which is the whole point of QE2. You don't get zero inflation when the US dollar is being devalued.
But more importantly, as Francesca pointed out, the market has already taken into account the likely consequences of QE2 and such. If you're buying gold now, you're buying gold on the expectation that the Fed will have to devalue the dollar
even more than is already expected.
A company can be doing great and still lose value in the stock price, if it's not doing
as insanely great as analysts expected it to do. Similarly, a company can totally tank and the stock price will do well as long as it tanks
more slowly than the total train wreck everyone expects. (You see that all the time. "XYZ Corp announced a loss of ($0.02)/share, less than the ($0.15)/share analysts expected. The stock jumped 7.5% on the news.")
The people who are buying gold now are buying it with the expectation that it will continue to deliver insane returns. But the only way it can deliver insane returns is if people continue to bid insane prices for it, since gold in and of itself doesn't make money. As soon as goldbugs run out of pigeons, the returns will automatically drop. Once the returns drop, people will realize that gold won't automatically make insane returns, and people will sell it.
It doesn't particularly matter where the USD is at that point. There will always be better dollar-denominated investments out there, because there will always be something that offers a positive RoI.