About if God created everything then who created God and who created the God who created God, and on and on...
When theists conceive of God as the creator of everything, they mean everything that is known to man as having a beginning.
Now, time and again I have come across this question, who then created God, and I find it a non-sequitur, because we are talking about God creator, not creator of God.
But the fact is the asker grants that God created everything, in stating that "if God created everything..."
A sequitur question could and should be what about a tsunami and the much sought after by the USA, the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden.
As an aside, that is why it is hard if not almost impossible to engage constructively (meaning among people who really intend to exchange ideas as to come to some consensus -- or admit the existence of an impasse among themselves) with atheists; their behavior consists of distractions and non-sequiturs, when people truly and sincerely want to find out what they know and understand, and see if they can also be receptive to what I know and understand.
Anyway, by way of speculation, if God created everything, who or what created God?
Right away I would say that I have to be a confident of God to know whether God was created by God, just like on the same level and category as I am the confident of my friend and we both are human beings.
You have got to be God to know who if indeed something or someone created the God who created everything.
That is why I am asking atheists who pose that question what is their point.
Nevertheless, I will say that among theists of today God is the ultimate and independent necessary being beyond and above which there is no further being to Himself as a source, origin, or progenitor, or creator.
How do we theists know that?
Because if God created the God who created everything, then the earlier in the order of execution though not in the order of time is the God about Which theists have their concept of God.
Now you will tell me that then there is an infinity of Gods, which however I must remind you that there are no reasons to support an infinity in the world of reality outside the mind of man.
And the fact that man can harbor in his mind the very concept of infinity is a testament to the genius of God, Who has created the mind of man to be so subtle as to be able to think of infinity.
For infinity is an intrinsic impossibility when you already admit that God created everything, wherefore everything as a beginning for being created.
Anyway, I invite the atheists who always bring up that question, who createe God, to tell me, what is your point, so that you can also do some serious thinking instead of always indulging in distractions and in non-sequiturs.
About God being nothing by arguing from concepts and words, I would agree with that kind of nothing for a God who created everything, because atheists who claim that the Big Bang came forth from nothing which nothing they understand to be a one and the only kind of nothing as opposed to all other kinds of nothing from which nothing can come forth.
Okay, I wouldn't mind atheists calling God nothing in that context of nothing is the source, origin, creator of everything that has a starting point in the Big Bang.
Yrreg