God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Yrreg, do you have evidence for the existence of the God you defined earlier as "creator of everything man knows about and also man does not know about".

Let's start with that God concept. Do you have evidence for the existence of that God?
 
If you want an answer to the question of "whether there is a God or there is no God", you need to "start from" evidence for the existence of God.
​


Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.


What is your concept of God and where do you get it?


Why is my concept of God relevant?

You have already provided a "concept of God". As has previously been noted, it perfectly fits the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

So, do you have any evidence that the Flying Spaghetti Monster exists?
 
Last edited:
If you want an answer to the question of "whether there is a God or there is no God", you need to "start from" evidence for the existence of God.
​
Got any?
Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.


What is your concept of God and where do you get it?
Again, you're the one proposing the existence of God; we've had your not very useful definition. Do you have anything to support its existence?


Can you also let us know the distinction you are drawing between 'first' and "start from". Which comes first?
 
Speaking of your concept of God, I notice you didn't include the part where the creator of everything incarnates on earth in human form as Jesus, is crucified, and then resurrected. You are a Christian, right?
 
Russell knew that God is not in the realm of teapots, that is why he was dishonest in bringing up a teapot in dealing with the question of God's existence.

He knew that there is no need to bring in a teapot, he could have a good talk about why he could not accept God's existence without bringing in a teapot.

All serious thinkers and writers and speakers don't bring in a teapot in dealing with issues which are of a level above teapots -- unless they have a dishonest streak in their heart and mind owing to their own personal agenda.

And that is also the distracting way of many an argument against God, bringing in things to first divert the attention of the audience.

Yes, you will tell me that he wanted to show that it is impossible to prove a negative proposition, and thus one should not spend time in that effort.

Still he should have first given the concept of God as known to himself from his readings of the concept of God among theists today, i.e., the maker of everything man knows.

And that concept of God does not warrant a negative proposition, but a positive proposition, which then he could admit that he himself could not bring up enough reasons how he could prove the truth of that positive proposition.



You want to answer whether there is a God or there is no God, then start from what people understand as God, not by distracting people with bringing up impertinent things like teapots.

And that is why for being wily, still he and wherefore had made himself a dishonest seeker of knowledge, and intended also to mislead people who were already not interested to hear objective truths but words to like Russell himself confirm or reinforce themselves in their attachment to shallow ideas which are convenient to themselves.


Yrreg

Does anyone else fancy a nice cup of tea?
 
Russell knew that God is not in the realm of teapots, that is why he was dishonest in bringing up a teapot in dealing with the question of God's existence.

He knew that there is no need to bring in a teapot, he could have a good talk about why he could not accept God's existence without bringing in a teapot.

All serious thinkers and writers and speakers don't bring in a teapot in dealing with issues which are of a level above teapots -- unless they have a dishonest streak in their heart and mind owing to their own personal agenda.

And that is also the distracting way of many an argument against God, bringing in things to first divert the attention of the audience.

Yes, you will tell me that he wanted to show that it is impossible to prove a negative proposition, and thus one should not spend time in that effort.

Still he should have first given the concept of God as known to himself from his readings of the concept of God among theists today, i.e., the maker of everything man knows.

And that concept of God does not warrant a negative proposition, but a positive proposition, which then he could admit that he himself could not bring up enough reasons how he could prove the truth of that positive proposition.



You want to answer whether there is a God or there is no God, then start from what people understand as God, not by distracting people with bringing up impertinent things like teapots.

And that is why for being wily, still he and wherefore had made himself a dishonest seeker of knowledge, and intended also to mislead people who were already not interested to hear objective truths but words to like Russell himself confirm or reinforce themselves in their attachment to shallow ideas which are convenient to themselves.




Yrreg

Speaking of dishonest, yrreG, how about you address Russell's actual point and that is that your god is unfalsifiable. However, if you don't like the teapot analogy, we can use Thor, Isis, Poseidon, or any combination of gods that you choose. Please prove that they don't exist.
 
About if God created everything then who created God and who created the God who created God, and on and on...

When theists conceive of God as the creator of everything, they mean everything that is known to man as having a beginning.

Now, time and again I have come across this question, who then created God, and I find it a non-sequitur, because we are talking about God creator, not creator of God.

But the fact is the asker grants that God created everything, in stating that "if God created everything..."

A sequitur question could and should be what about a tsunami and the much sought after by the USA, the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden.

As an aside, that is why it is hard if not almost impossible to engage constructively (meaning among people who really intend to exchange ideas as to come to some consensus -- or admit the existence of an impasse among themselves) with atheists; their behavior consists of distractions and non-sequiturs, when people truly and sincerely want to find out what they know and understand, and see if they can also be receptive to what I know and understand.


Anyway, by way of speculation, if God created everything, who or what created God?

Right away I would say that I have to be a confident of God to know whether God was created by God, just like on the same level and category as I am the confident of my friend and we both are human beings.

You have got to be God to know who if indeed something or someone created the God who created everything.

That is why I am asking atheists who pose that question what is their point.

Nevertheless, I will say that among theists of today God is the ultimate and independent necessary being beyond and above which there is no further being to Himself as a source, origin, or progenitor, or creator.


How do we theists know that?

Because if God created the God who created everything, then the earlier in the order of execution though not in the order of time is the God about Which theists have their concept of God.

Now you will tell me that then there is an infinity of Gods, which however I must remind you that there are no reasons to support an infinity in the world of reality outside the mind of man.

And the fact that man can harbor in his mind the very concept of infinity is a testament to the genius of God, Who has created the mind of man to be so subtle as to be able to think of infinity.

For infinity is an intrinsic impossibility when you already admit that God created everything, wherefore everything as a beginning for being created.


Anyway, I invite the atheists who always bring up that question, who createe God, to tell me, what is your point, so that you can also do some serious thinking instead of always indulging in distractions and in non-sequiturs.



About God being nothing by arguing from concepts and words, I would agree with that kind of nothing for a God who created everything, because atheists who claim that the Big Bang came forth from nothing which nothing they understand to be a one and the only kind of nothing as opposed to all other kinds of nothing from which nothing can come forth.

Okay, I wouldn't mind atheists calling God nothing in that context of nothing is the source, origin, creator of everything that has a starting point in the Big Bang.




Yrreg

Who created your god?
 
If you want an answer to the question of "whether there is a God or there is no God", you need to "start from" evidence for the existence of God.
​


Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.

What is your concept of God and where do you get it?

Aaaand here we go again: "You can't talk about the non-existence of God unless you have a concept of the god that doesn't exist."

BINGO! on my yrreg threads Bingo card.
 
As a reminder: it is good for seekers of knowledge in the matter of God or no God to find out what is wrong with Russell's argument against God from the celestial teapot, because most arguments against God are founded on the same grounds of Russell's celestial teapot.

And I fear that Russell himself knew that he was evading the question of God's existence in resorting to the celestial teapot, which says more about his moral psychology than his intelligence and honesty in delving into the question of God's existence.

Suppose you tell me what is wrong with Russell's teapot by which he justifies for himself that God does not exist.

Well, number one, the teapot isn't an argument against the existence of your god so much as it is a demonstration of the futility of asking someone to prove a negative. Number two, if you can't tell us what's wrong with it, don't pretend that you know the answer.

I say God quintessentially for theists is the:
Creator of everything man knows about and also man does not know about which man can know about -- as man comes to greater and greater acquaintance with creation.
​

And you say that:
If you want to say that man can relate to the mystery of the Universe that we as humans have anthromoporphised as "GOD" then yeah, you can say that. Only you don't need to call it God since it's called "the mystery of the Universe" and yeah welcome to atheism while you're at it.​

I will gladly accept your suggestion that instead of the name God I should us the phrase "the mystery of the Universe."

But it does not follow that I have put myself in the worldview of atheism.


It just confirms for me as also it should for you, that man-made concepts and words cannot exhaust what God knows about Himself, what God is in Himself, but man-made concepts and words can and do convey the most important truth about God as far as man is concerned, namely, the creator of everything man knows about, and man does not know about at present, still he will know in the future -- even though man will never know everything as God knows everything of creation of which He is the author.

Got any dressing for that word salad?

Oh, and also, it can't confirm that your god knows anything, because you haven't confirmed that your god exists.

Anyway tell me, if you cannot accept God as creator of everything that you know to exist, who or what created everything that you know to exist?

Who says that there has to be a reason?

Russell knew that God is not in the realm of teapots, that is why he was dishonest in bringing up a teapot in dealing with the question of God's existence.

He knew that there is no need to bring in a teapot, he could have a good talk about why he could not accept God's existence without bringing in a teapot.

All serious thinkers and writers and speakers don't bring in a teapot in dealing with issues which are of a level above teapots -- unless they have a dishonest streak in their heart and mind owing to their own personal agenda.

And that is also the distracting way of many an argument against God, bringing in things to first divert the attention of the audience.

We bring in things like the teapot and the Flying Spaghetti Monster and Thor/Zeus/Enki/Santa because they are valid arguments. That you do not like them does not change this fact.

Yes, you will tell me that he wanted to show that it is impossible to prove a negative proposition, and thus one should not spend time in that effort.

Still he should have first given the concept of God as known to himself from his readings of the concept of God among theists today, i.e., the maker of everything man knows.

No, because Russell's teapot was not created to argue against your god. It can be used that way, but again, it is only a demonstration of how it is impossible to prove a negative.

And that concept of God does not warrant a negative proposition, but a positive proposition, which then he could admit that he himself could not bring up enough reasons how he could prove the truth of that positive proposition.

:confused:

You want to answer whether there is a God or there is no God, then start from what people understand as God, not by distracting people with bringing up impertinent things like teapots.

Ever heard of an analogy?

And that is why for being wily, still he and wherefore had made himself a dishonest seeker of knowledge, and intended also to mislead people who were already not interested to hear objective truths

HA!

but words to like Russell himself confirm or reinforce themselves in their attachment to shallow ideas which are convenient to themselves.

irony.jpg


If God created everything, who created God and thus on and on?


Well, of course, if you grant that God created everything, then what is your point of asking who created God, then who created the God who created God, and on and on?

So your god created himself, then?

About if God created everything then who created God and who created the God who created God, and on and on...

When theists conceive of God as the creator of everything, they mean everything that is known to man as having a beginning.

Now, time and again I have come across this question, who then created God, and I find it a non-sequitur, because we are talking about God creator, not creator of God.

Yes, but pointing out a big hole in the reasoning of a particular theory for the existence of the universe isn't illegal.

But the fact is the asker grants that God created everything, in stating that "if God created everything..."

I'll take that as a "yes" on the "so your god created himself", then.

A sequitur question could and should be what about a tsunami and the much sought after by the USA, the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden.

Meh?

As an aside, that is why it is hard if not almost impossible to engage constructively (meaning among people who really intend to exchange ideas as to come to some consensus -- or admit the existence of an impasse among themselves) with atheists; their behavior consists of distractions and non-sequiturs, when people truly and sincerely want to find out what they know and understand, and see if they can also be receptive to what I know and understand.

What you know and understand is entirely separate from what you desire and believe.

<*sings* word salad, yummy yummy>

About God being nothing by arguing from concepts and words, I would agree with that kind of nothing for a God who created everything, because atheists who claim that the Big Bang came forth from nothing which nothing they understand to be a one and the only kind of nothing as opposed to all other kinds of nothing from which nothing can come forth.

Okay, I wouldn't mind atheists calling God nothing in that context of nothing is the source, origin, creator of everything that has a starting point in the Big Bang.

Except that there's no point in calling nothing "God".

If you want an answer to the question of "whether there is a God or there is no God", you need to "start from" evidence for the existence of God.
​

Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.

What is your concept of God and where do you get it?

I don't need an exact description of all the different subspecies of leprechauns to deny their existence, do I? Do you have an exact description of all the gods whose existence you deny? Enki? Baal? Marduk? Osiris? Mercury? Odin?
 
Quick point to remember, guys (namely Mojo and RoboTimbo):

yrreg does not understand analogies, and has repeatedly demonstrated an inability to detect them. I do not know if this is language-related or not.

He thinks atheists actually view god as a spaghetti, in order to make a straw man argument against god.
He likely thinks the same of Russel's teapot.

Even when the analogy is explained to him in detail, his posts show that he does not understand the concept.


As much as the teapot analogy is valid here, yrreg will not understand you.
 
Quick point to remember, guys (namely Mojo and RoboTimbo):

yrreg does not understand analogies, and has repeatedly demonstrated an inability to detect them. I do not know if this is language-related or not.

He thinks atheists actually view god as a spaghetti, in order to make a straw man argument against god.
He likely thinks the same of Russel's teapot.

Even when the analogy is explained to him in detail, his posts show that he does not understand the concept.


As much as the teapot analogy is valid here, yrreg will not understand you.

Sad, isn't it? I would like to get inside his mind to see what is holding it together.
 
If you want an answer to the question of "whether there is a God or there is no God", you need to "start from" evidence for the existence of God.
​


Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.


What is your concept of God and where do you get it?




Yrreg

Well i can talk about invisible pink unicorns without them being real. What makes your god-word so special that the mere mention of the name poofs it into existence?
 
About if God created everything then who created God and who created the God who created God, and on and on...

When theists conceive of God as the creator of everything, they mean everything that is known to man as having a beginning.

Now, time and again I have come across this question, who then created God, and I find it a non-sequitur, because we are talking about God creator, not creator of God.
Huh? A question about creation leading to another question about creation is a non-sequitor? I see your brain doesn't allow for any linear pathways. Too busy going around in circles or stopping at dead ends, I see.

But the fact is the asker grants that God created everything, in stating that "if God created everything..."

A sequitur question could and should be what about a tsunami and the much sought after by the USA, the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden.
Double huh? How does Osama bin Laden logically follow from your contention that a god created everything?

<snipped evasions and shifting of the burden of proof>

So basically, you're saying that you don't know, without actually coming out and saying it. "I know that a magical man did some amazing magic, but I can't quite see behind the curtain." And no, we don't need to agree that there really *IS* a magic man behind a curtain to ask you either how he did his magic or where he came from. He's your magic man; it's your job to define him and answer whatever questions you can.

If you would allow yourself to answer "I don't know" to a few questions, you might actually move around and learn something. It seems you'd rather stand still at your dead-end answer, wildly clapping your hands at the sparkly magic.



One last time, in 10 words or less, no evasions or equivocations allowed: Who or what created your god?


Note: "I don't know" is an acceptable answer.
 
First, comprehend the concept of God, then set off and look for Him.

-----------------
Originally Posted by yrreg
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg


-------------------


Agree 100%.

You ask what then? Train people to go beyond words and concepts, to experience through altered states of consciousness.



Here is the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's relation to the universe:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Can you have any acquaintance in your mind with the thought expressed in that concept of God?

No, I am not yet into proving that there is an entity corresponding to that concept of God, just that I invite you to acquaint your mind with that concept.


First, your mind must be accessible to the concept as concept, then you and I can go forth in the universe to seek an entity corresponding to that concept.

Do you comprehend me?




Yrreg
 
...
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


...


OK, I get that, but where did God come from?

If He didn't make Himself, did He evolve? Did He just appear in a puff of magic? What?
 
The concept is here already, where it comes from is another question.

Originally Posted by yrreg
...
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

...

OK, I get that, but where did God come from?

If He didn't make Himself, did He evolve? Did He just appear in a puff of magic? What?


Before anything else, we are talking about the concept of God not the existence of God.


You can acquaint your mind to that concept, it is now in your mind.

You are asking where that concept comes from, for the present we will not go into where it comes from, the fact is that it is here already, and you say that you can have it in your mind.

I have it also in my mind.


What can you say about that concept of God:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Is it a possible concept or an impossible concept, meaning, is there a possibility that there can be an entity in objective reality that corresponds to the concept?

You want to ask me where it comes from, but for the present put that question in abeyance, for the fact is that it is here and I have it in my mind and you also have acquainted your mind with it.

What you and I want to do now is to examine the concept to determine whether it is a possible concept or not, understanding by a possible concept as one that can correspond to a possible entity in objective reality.

Can you comprehend me?



Gerry
 
By universe do you mean just this universe? Does this god exist only within this universe or could it be a being from another universe?

Could this thing you call god be just a college student in another universe who created this universe as part of his thesis project? Could it be that this universe was actually created accidentally by a being or beings in another universe? Could this universe all just be a giant computer simulation that beings from another universe use for entertainment?

Actually, I have no problem conceiving of this universe as being created by some outside being. I'm just not closed minded about what that being or beings might be like.
 
Before anything else, we are talking about the concept of God not the existence of God.


You can acquaint your mind to that concept, it is now in your mind.

You are asking where that concept comes from, for the present we will not go into where it comes from, the fact is that it is here already, and you say that you can have it in your mind.

I have it also in my mind.


What can you say about that concept of God:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Is it a possible concept or an impossible concept, meaning, is there a possibility that there can be an entity in objective reality that corresponds to the concept?

You want to ask me where it comes from, but for the present put that question in abeyance, for the fact is that it is here and I have it in my mind and you also have acquainted your mind with it.

What you and I want to do now is to examine the concept to determine whether it is a possible concept or not, understanding by a possible concept as one that can correspond to a possible entity in objective reality.

Can you comprehend me?



Gerry



Can you think of a Unicorn....a Fairy.... a leprechaun....a Cyclops.... a minotaur.... a Pegasus.... Thor....Zeus....Athena?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom