God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Regardless of whether you are a believer or not a believer, the "concept of God" is a social construction. This is "where we get it." As such, we do describe the concept with sufficient accuracy to conceptualize (G)god, argue philosophically for and against the existence of (G)god, and indeed describe the concept with enough accuracy to be able to conduct scientific testing of claims as to the existence of (G)god. So far none of those claims have withstood scientific study. I think we've already covered the ground that yrreg / Gerry is covering pretty well.

HG
Welcome to the forum! And welcome to a Yrreg thread.
 
Please just attend to the concept of God as per my concept of without your emotional overload, namely:

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

And also the concept from yours truly of the universe:

Universe = The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​



Yrreg

Is that the only property of your thought experiment god - It made everything? It has had no involvement in the universe since that one thing it did?

Ok, I can conceive of something like the Big Bang where the universe was created. Now what?
 
I wonder...

bruto said:
My guess, only a guess of course, is that our temporarily absent friend stews over these ideas, works them up, imagines the exchanges and the way things will go, and then posts a thread thinking that he's really got the master "gotcha" this time. He's thought of all the angles, rehearsed and honed his repartée. Of course it never quite goes that way, things go from bad to worse, the script is departed from, he gets upset and loses his cool, then bails. He takes his tattered argument back to its lair, patches it up and changes its suit, drills and exercises it, and brings it back to the fray a few months later for the next bout.

Just a guess, but I think Yrreg is quite an optimist.
Loss Leader said:
It's nothing nearly as complicated as that. Gerry is a narcissist. He must always feel good about himself. When his real life gives him enough satisfaction, he doesn't need us. But then something will happen to make him doubt his own intelligence. This could be anything. He could be at bible study, explain his personal idea, and the priest says something like, "Thank you, Gerry, but that's not quite what I meant." That would be enough to crush him completely.

That's when he comes here. Our disapproval registers on him as positive, because he feels superior to us. That lasts as long as anyone says anything negative to him. He feeds off it.

Until he gets a Mod warning. Since Mods are people in authority, any disapproval from them is absolutely humiliating. He can't even click on the JREF link anymore.

A couple rejections like that, piled up on top of each other, and he'd be hard-pressed to even get up in the morning. If Gerry has ever sought psychiatric help, it would have been because he misdiagnosed himself with depression.

Eventually, the shame of the mod warning fades and the memory of the victory over our small minds takes over, something in his life goes slightly against him, and he comes back.

Gerry doesn't put any thought whatsoever into his arguments here. It doesn't matter to him what he says, it's guaranteed to be brilliant. And it doesn't matter what we say to him, we'll always be inferior.

He'll be back. He needs us.
 
Tell me what part of my concept of God is self-referential?

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

Make your mind up. Are you talking about the Christian God, or a Deist God? The Christian God is more than just the maker of the universe.
 
You are into describing God as from a speaker with grudges against God.
I don't believe in God - having a grudge against God would be like having a grudge against the tooth fairy. OTOH I'm not entirely happy with some the actions and activities of many religious groups in the name of God, but I still wouldn't call it a grudge, as I haven't been personally affronted by them.


God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

And also the concept from yours truly of the universe:

Universe = The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​

Attend to the concepts and examine each to detect whether there are components within each as according to my accounts, that are mutually incompatible as to cancel each other out.
Apart from the obvious 'existence of God' problem, there's clearly and incompatibility between God being maker of the universe and everything that isn't God, and the God being part of the universe that he supposedly created. This is what I pointed out previously.

Otherwise I see nothing in your post but mockery, parody, and evasions.
Mockery, yes; but parody? did you think I was parodying you, or a theist philosopher? As for evasions, none was intended - if you'd like to ask me a direct question that is coherent and intelligible, I'd be happy to attempt an answer.
 
I can ask what he made the universe from, what building materials did he use if there was nothing to hand and he didn't use his own substance?

Why would god need building materials? He's omnipotent, he could just conjure it fully formed out of nothing.
 
Why would god need building materials? He's omnipotent, he could just conjure it fully formed out of nothing.

Yes. I should have known that.

But then if God can just effortlessly conjure everything from nothing, why does He even need to be there? He sees everything from start to finish, every atom, every star and everything in between, all at once because He is outside Time and Space...

If that is God, He is just an observer, no point praying to or worshipping a concept like that.
 
Here is the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's relation to the universe:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Can you have any acquaintance in your mind with the thought expressed in that concept of God?

No, I am not yet into proving that there is an entity corresponding to that concept of God, just that I invite you to acquaint your mind with that concept.

First, your mind must be accessible to the concept as concept, then you and I can go forth in the universe to seek an entity corresponding to that concept.

Do you comprehend me?

Yrreg

Welcome back, Yrreg, long time, no see!

You don't make it easy to comprehend you as you word your paragraphs very oddly, but I believe I understand. 'Maker of everything not God' is a working definition I can agree to for purposes of discussion. It's your topic, and God definitions vary a lot depending on who supposes them, I don't mind going along with yours for the time being. In fact, it's good form for you to spell out what version of God you're talking about.
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

If there are concepts and words that are not "man-made", I'd quite like to hear what they are.
 
Please don't engage in mockery, parody, and evasions.

I have already two concepts propounded here:

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

Not only the Christian faith, you've described Brahma and a variety of other creator gods as well, including the God of deism and the God of 'we'll call whatever caused the universe God, even if it was just a quantum fluctuation'.

Universe = The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Your definition of universe includes things that don't exist. If I was arguing your side, I would have gone with 'everything that exists', full stop.

First, we talk about concepts and determine whether they are possible concepts or impossible concepts.

You may run into some problems here. Skeptics usually like to hear some good reason why they should think something might be so in the first place before they start burning brain cells on figuring out whether it's possible or not. The set of possible things is infinitely greater than the set of actual things. Reason alone is not a good basis for determining if something exists, empiricism has to come into play at some point.

This discussion therefore is concerned with God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

You might want to leave Christianity out of it at this point, and just shoot for getting at any kind of creator god at all.

And the universe is the one where we are living in and are part and parcel of.

Yrreg

May I assume you are referring to a nearly all-inclusive universe, the set of all things which exist? This definition would include other universes if there are any.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I can handle the concept of a being or beings who created this universe. I just don't see why we have to limit ourselves to just one being, or one universe for that mater. If we are discussing things for which we have no physical evidence and may never have any physical evidence I see no reason to limit our scope. I like discussing these sorts of cosmologies, the ideas can really be creative and fun. Just don't be all closed minded about the nature and number of gods.

So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?
 
You have a blind spot in our mind disabling you from seeing the whole picture.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Tell me what part of my concept of God is self-referential?

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.



Yrreg




I'll give you a hint: It's the bit where you refer to god in your definition of god.

Here, I'll even highlight it for you:

"God [is defined as] the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself"

- yrreg



Have you noticed or you are purposely omitting the fact that in the definition of God the concept of God is first presented, the maker of everything in the universe, then the rest is just already a use of the defined concept of God as the maker of everything in the universe.

Here,
part one: God is the maker of everything in the universe.
part two: [everything in the universe] that is not God Himself.​


So the point you are making is a useless point for the purpose you want to achieve that my definition is a tautology.

The only point you have established is that you have a blind spot in your mind.


Anyway, to accommodate to your blind spot, you can remove the mention of God [the bolded word] in the second part of the statement of the concept of God, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


So, are you acquainted with that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?


If you are not acquainted with that concept of God, what concept of God are you acquainted with?




Yrreg
 
You are saying nothing useful, do you have a concept of God at all?

Originally Posted by yrreg


Don't forget for orderly and thus productive disquisition to prove or disprove the existence of God from evidence or no evidence, you must first have a concept of God.

What is your concept of God and where do you get it?

Yrreg




Regardless of whether you are a believer or not a believer, the "concept of God" is a social construction. This is "where we get it." As such, we do describe the concept with sufficient accuracy to conceptualize (G)god, argue philosophically for and against the existence of (G)god, and indeed describe the concept with enough accuracy to be able to conduct scientific testing of claims as to the existence of (G)god. So far none of those claims have withstood scientific study. I think we've already covered the ground that yrreg / Gerry is covering pretty well.

HG
​



You are saying nothing useful, do you at all have a concept of God?

If not and you want to exchange thoughts with me about God, first at least get acquainted with a concept of God.

I recommend the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.




Yrreg
​
 
So, are you acquainted with that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?


If you are not acquainted with that concept of God, what concept of God are you acquainted with?


How about the concept of God in Pastafarianism:


The Flying Spaghetti Monster is the maker of everything in the universe that is not The Flying Spaghetti Monster Himself.​
 
You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.

Disclaimer: I have not read this thread prior to this point. It is almost 2 years old.


Originally Posted by yrreg
Here is the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's relation to the universe:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
Can you have any acquaintance in your mind with the thought expressed in that concept of God?





This sounds a bit off to me. The verb "to make" implies that I take something and transform it into something else. If you're claiming that God made stuff out of himself (that is, transformed himself into other things), then it's somewhat coherent, but is a bit strange. If you're claiming that God transformed some other thing into some other thing, that gels; but if you're saying that he made everything, then there's a bit of a chicken and egg problem: What did he make it out of? And what did he make that stuff out of?

I would think you'd want to define God as the entity that created everything ex nihilo that wasn't God, and possibly want to add that God himself was not created ex nihilo.

If so, I can hold that concept in my noggin, sure. But if not, I have a problem with the concept per se.

That having been said, the concept of creating something ex nihilo seems foreign to my experience. You're welcome to try to find entities in the universe that match this concept, but I've yet to see anything cause something to come into being. (Even virtual particles don't quite work that way).



You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.


If you do not accept the concept of God as I present here:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself,​

then come up with a concept, and I will see whether you have one that is what Christians know to be the God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Or you point out precisely and concisely what components in my concept of God cannot be together without cancelling each other out.



Yrreg
 
Have you noticed or you are purposely omitting the fact that in the definition of God the concept of God is first presented, the maker of everything in the universe, then the rest is just already a use of the defined concept of God as the maker of everything in the universe.

Here,
part one: God is the maker of everything in the universe.
part two: [everything in the universe] that is not God Himself.​


You did not in any way indicate that those were two separate parts of the definition. The way you wrote it made it seem like one concept.

Without meaning to be rude, this is one of those situations in which your penchant for excess words causes problems.



So the point you are making is a useless point for the purpose you want to achieve that my definition is a tautology.


I just want you to posit a useable definition, so that you don't turn around and equivocate later on. Further, I want you to give a definition that actually describes something, rather than a definition that can apply to anything without meaning a thing. But that comes under the "equivocation" comment.



The only point you have established is that you have a blind spot in your mind.


Sure. if, by blind spot, you mean "can see yrreg's argument coming from 3 miles away".



Anyway, to accommodate to your blind spot, you can remove the mention of God [the bolded word] in the second part of the statement of the concept of God, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Why not just define god as the maker of the universe?



So, are you acquainted with that concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe?


Woah, wait up there speedy. You said nothing about the Christian god. If you want to use your definition to exclusively describe the Christian god (of which there are several irreconcilable concepts) then you had better make that clear in your definition of god.


If you are not acquainted with that concept of God, what concept of God are you acquainted with?


I am acquainted with several*. However, just because I am acquainted with them does not bean I believe in any of them.

* A short list wouldn't be out of place
- The dysfunctional human gods of the Greeks
- A whole slew of specialist-gods from many early cultures.
- The self-contradictory omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent god many Christians describe.
- God concepts incorporating 1 or 2 of the above ideas.
- The god of fuzzy-Christians, who is defined as "undefinable", as though that were a deep, thoughtful idea.
- The god of the deists, who sets new standards for the term "aloof".
- The vengeful, tyrannical god of the Torah, eloquently described by Dawkins.
- The god I made up for a friend for a role-playing game, in which a new preacher class had been created (the god of the night sky; if you were ill-favoured, the stars would be of no help finding your way home).
- Many many others.
 
Last edited:
Now we want to come to agreement on the concept of the universe.

Sure do, now what?


Now we want to come to agreement on the concept of the universe.


Here is my concept of the universe:
Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​


Do you have your concept of the universe? so that we can work out together to come to the common concept of the universe we both can use to arrive at the existence of God from the universe as the evidence.



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom