God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Personally, I'm convinced science has created the vocabulary that one can reliably depend on.

You can pray to your god all you want, yrreg. Nothing happens. But science, now there's where you will see real progress, real answers, and a real path to a better life.
 
Can a metaphor create a rock so heavy "he" cannot lift it?
Feel free to replace "he" with "it". The pardox is not of my own creation, so the gender was already part of it.

Logic and critical thinking will only take you so far. Far enough for some, not far enough for others. Where words and concepts end mysticism begins.
Ah, no. Mysticism was around for centuries before logic and led no place at all. Logic and critical thinking are part of the intellectual tool set that created the world we live in today.

No, but I can transcend it and dance.
You have transcended nothing. You are dodging. Really, this is not that hard to at least examine the problem with Google. Not the best way to solve it, but at least it could point you in the right direction.

Maybe, maybe not. But what is clear to one is not clear to another. Frankly I don't see the point of trying, I think you and many of your fellow JREFers are determined to belittle and reject whatever I say.
We will start taking you seriously when you start putting forward ideas that have something behind them. So far it looks like you showed up to a gun fight carrying a butter knife. Start with learning the tools of logic and critical thinking.
Do you think that studying books about various concepts of god(s) is the key? Study is only part of it, study is blind without mystical experience to illuminate it.

No personal experience is of any use to us as evidence. Reality cares not for what we feel or desire. And our senses are to easily fooled.
 
Feel free to replace "he" with "it". The pardox is not of my own creation, so the gender was already part of it.


Was it created with a particular conception of God in mind? Perhaps a literalistic conception of God as a being among beings? A being with a name that can be spoken?

"The Tao that can be spoken is not the eternal Tao
The name that can be named is not the eternal name"
-Lao Tzu

What happens to the paradox if God is the stone as well as the would-be lifter? If God is Brahman? Or Ein Sof? What happens to the paradox if God is an intelligible sphere (a sphere known to the mind) whose center is everywhere and circumference nowhere? What happens to it if the subject/object dichotomy is an illusion? If space/time is an illusion?

What happens if God is beyond the words that comprise the paradox?


Ah, no. Mysticism was around for centuries before logic and led no place at all. Logic and critical thinking are part of the intellectual tool set that created the world we live in today.


When seeking 'God', logic and critical thinking will only take you so far. Mysticism will take you farther, if one has the constitution for it. It can be a dangerous path.

What do you think of when you think of mysticism? What sort of mental images and conceptions run through your head? Why do you think it led no place at all?


You have transcended nothing. You are dodging. Really, this is not that hard to at least examine the problem with Google. Not the best way to solve it, but at least it could point you in the right direction.


You sure are hung up on that paradox. Why? Did it rob you of your religion?

No personal experience is of any use to us as evidence. Reality cares not for what we feel or desire. And our senses are to easily fooled.


To 'us'? Who is 'us'? I don't care if my personal experiences are any use to 'us' as evidence. They are of use to me as evidence.
 
Last edited:
Im pretty sure yrreg is ignoring me but anyway,

It seems to me the part of his argument regarding pattern seeking behaviour in humans is scientifically valid, but I don't understand how he then concludes that god must exist.

Is he saying that there is an inherent pattern that is god? and that this produces the behaviour?

Can anyone help?
 
Im pretty sure yrreg is ignoring me but anyway,

It seems to me the part of his argument regarding pattern seeking behaviour in humans is scientifically valid, but I don't understand how he then concludes that god must exist.

Is he saying that there is an inherent pattern that is god? and that this produces the behaviour?

Can anyone help?
I seriously doubt that his analysis is this deep.
 
Next, I will maintain that just the same we can discuss theists and atheists alike respectively, that God does exist as we exist -- understanding existence as opposed to non-existence, or God does not exist, which however atheists must explain what they mean by non-existence.

Some of us really don't care, we just come here to argue!

:)

BTW< non-existance, nope, many of us say non--evidence. because the existance of the universe could be proof it was bought on a store shelf.
 
Im pretty sure yrreg is ignoring me but anyway,

It seems to me the part of his argument regarding pattern seeking behaviour in humans is scientifically valid, but I don't understand how he then concludes that god must exist.

Is he saying that there is an inherent pattern that is god? and that this produces the behaviour?

Can anyone help?


He is not ignoring you, he is just looking for the one or two posts he thinks will further his case, for his newsletter.
 
Honestly I don't ever wonder what is the evidence for karma in Hinduism and then in Buddhism its offshoot.

What I know from reading and sharing with others in the West from their conversion into Buddhism is that karma is some kind of what I would consider to be metaphysical system covering what we know in the West to be moral goodness to undo moral badness.
Just ignoring the many defintions of kamma you were given again. Okay.
So that since you have moral badness lodged in that system or metaphysical order, you have to undo it with moral goodness in your present and succeeding reincarnations, and add to your hoard of moral goodness, then one day in your latest reincarnation you are ready for nirvana.
And ignoring the defintion of nibbana as well. :)
But you can choose to prolong your stay in that summit latest present reincarnation, in order to help others get to better and better reincarnations and hence also to nirvana.
Only in the forms of buddhism that say that, guess what, not all do.
And that is what Gautama the ultimate Buddha chose to do even though he should have just rested easy in nirvana.
Not really, you would have a very hard time supporting that. :)
I never honestly look for evidence to prop up Buddhist karma ( and I don't have karma as a premise in my own theistic system of a worldview ), evidence the kind as atheists insist on, and by which atheists do isolate themselves into, socalled empirical evidence.
Yeah, we know you prefer to manufacture your evidence. :)
My impression of elite Buddhism is that it can be prescinding from God in its pure ideology, but the people who do worship its founder, Gautama the ultimate Buddha, still want God and gods and make even Buddha a god to whom they address their dependencies and worship, as we know worship in the West, i.e., of God.
Except for all the leites buddhists who told you otherwise, now you can't even keep your own terms straight Gerry. Elite buddhists are the ones you decry for not having that traditional belief.

I really worry about you, your style of writing has changed and now you mess up your own terminology. Why aren't you funny anymore?
I am honestly again not in the mental habit of constantly unremittingly looking for evidence to know the existence of anything specially of God, the kind of evidence atheists endlessly drum on, socalled empirical evidence.
Nope, you don't like evidence. Pes Oir Amsus
Many things cannot be validated by evidence, for example, the very principle of atheists' ground for knowledge namely evidence itself is not validable by evidence, the empirical kind that is.
Yup, don't jump off any buildings, okay?
You see ideologues everywhere have this tendency which they don't know about themselves, or they purposely suppress from coming to the surface of their intellectual consciousness, that they choose to put themselves in a self-made dungeon so as to not see the most huge, deep, high picture of reality, thereby to self-assuredly dwell within their self-encapsulated prison of a worldview.
Nope that is people like youself, who pretend we are bound in your cave.
But for what motivations, they only will know once they get out of their self-dungeon.
Mirror, mirror.
As regards my topic here asking atheists and of course theists of which I am one, whether we should at all continue to discuss and argue about No God or Yes God, when our concepts and words are inadequate, I will just say that as a father concerned with giving my family good nutrition I am at times worried that they may not be getting the best or most comprehensive nutrition all the time, just the same with the best of intentions and efforts I do exert all myself to get them all the time as delimited by my knowledge and material resources though, the most adequate foods I can provide based on my knowledge of nutrition and as affordable on my resources.
I live a good life, all without god.
 
My style has changed but not me, I am a gentleman thinker...all the time

Just ignoring the many defintions of kamma you were given again. Okay.

And ignoring the defintion of nibbana as well. :)

Only in the forms of buddhism that say that, guess what, not all do.

Not really, you would have a very hard time supporting that. :)

Yeah, we know you prefer to manufacture your evidence. :)

Except for all the leites buddhists who told you otherwise, now you can't even keep your own terms straight Gerry. Elite buddhists are the ones you decry for not having that traditional belief.

I really worry about you, your style of writing has changed and now you mess up your own terminology. Why aren't you funny anymore?

Nope, you don't like evidence. Pes Oir Amsus

Yup, don't jump off any buildings, okay?

Nope that is people like youself, who pretend we are bound in your cave.

Mirror, mirror.

I live a good life, all without god.


I really worry about you, your style of writing has changed and now you mess up your own terminology. Why aren't you funny anymore?
​

My style has changed but not me, modesty aside I am a gentleman thinker all the time, and I don't bring in spaghetti in thinking about atheists, but they do all the time.

Thanks, David, for worrying about me, appreciate that.

My terminology might appear messed up to you, but remember terminology is only at the service of concepts; see if my concepts have changed, and if I have imprisoned my conceptual mind to only the empirical sphere or level of thinking.


About my understanding of Buddhism, it has many schools and many opinions, but at the end of the day any intelligent thinker will have to make a systematic and intelligible worldview of the whole conundrum of concepts and words, otherwise being logically minded one might have to throw the whole mess overboard from his mental deck.

Unless you want to subscribe to what I read of one Buddhist master that Buddhism is intrinsically not really supra logic but illogical, therein he says lies its merits.

David, do you have any system of metaphysics you ascribe to that you keep to as the ultimate ground for your knowledge of reality?


On a personal note, there are people here whom I always remember on one particular bit of information whenever their name comes forth in my visit here, in your case someone mentioned that you were sexually abused as a kid, is that what really happened and therefore people must accommodate to you, taking that into account?

Then also who is that poster here who accused me of lying for repeating what he or she said about himself or herself that she is not an intelligent being, I can't recall her name -- but she confesses to have the habit of complaining to the mods about my writing (which earns me the distinction of being the most warned poster in this forum), I always have in mind whenever his or her name comes up here when I am around, namely, that he had a what, transsexual change, and therefore people must accommodate to her or his (the heck with all that) owing to this bit of personal circumstance.



Anyway, David, do you subscribe to my statement that concepts and words can never do justice to God as God knows Himself to be?

And shouldn't you determine therefore that as an atheist you should just dispense yourself from talking against God's existence, namely, just keep quiet, and also correspondingly theists should just also stop talking to argue for His existence?

But the fact is that atheists of the most bought kinds among their fellow atheists keep pouring out more and more but essentially the same tiresome arguments against God, but have nothing to say about Santa who is also a big influence in the world today during these otherwise Western theistic holidays.


Tiresome arguments against God... that is why when atheists meet something totally not of their tiresome arguements against God, they are disoriented and can't work up any kind of reaction.




Yrreg
 
"I do not think you know what any of the words you use mean".
Inigo Montoya.. loosely. :)
 
What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg


If I were to believe your assumptions about our abilities to understand I would still say it is valid to argue for the validity of what were are able to conceive.
 
No, but I can transcend it and dance.

Live at the empty heart of paradox
I'll dance with you there, cheek to cheek.
-Rumi
Umm.. Rumi was a 13th century Persian poet was he not? Did he really talk about dancing "cheek to cheek"?

I know a little about the history of dance and this does not seem likely to me.

Is there a cite for this?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom