God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

I see you have not tried to solve the paradox.


Can a metaphor create a rock so heavy "he" cannot lift it?


Logic and critical thinking is necessary to figure out what is real and what is not. Understanding god is irrelevant if god does not exist.


Logic and critical thinking will only take you so far. Far enough for some, not far enough for others. Where words and concepts end mysticism begins.

Go away, logic, there's no thinker here,
Nor room for even your finest split hair.
When the day comes, whatever lamp gives light
Is shamed by the face of the sun's bright glare.
-Rumi


Can you resolve the paradox?


No, but I can transcend it and dance.

Live at the empty heart of paradox
I'll dance with you there, cheek to cheek.
-Rumi


Can you state clearly what definition of god it is you believe in?


Maybe, maybe not. But what is clear to one is not clear to another. Frankly I don't see the point of trying, I think you and many of your fellow JREFers are determined to belittle and reject whatever I say.


He is a creationist. You two do not agree on anything.


I agree with what he said in his OP. Beyond that, I can't say.


And one small piece of advice. Many people here have spent more time studying the concept of god(s) than you. Do not presume to think you are telling people things they don't know. Make an argument for your god and start with a definition of what you are discussion or stop wasting our time.


Do you think that studying books about various concepts of god(s) is the key? Study is only part of it, study is blind without mystical experience to illuminate it.

Soul receives from soul that knowledge, therefore not by book
nor from tongue.
If knowledge of mysteries come after emptiness of mind, that is
illumination of heart.
-Rumi

Doubt...if you feel I'm wasting your time and my questions aren't worth answering then do us both a favor and put me on your ignore list.
 
Last edited:
My fear is that when it comes to God, He is like an itch theists and atheists cannot abstain from scratching all the time: theists to wonder at the existence of the itch while atheists to abolish it -- but futilely.


No.

I actually get by just fine in day-to-day life without thinking of god (or for that matter, without dwelling on my lack of belief in god).

It is a non-issue.

Much like you don't go around actively believing or not believing in unicorns.
Irrelevant, and really not needed.

It is theists like you who continue to make bad apologetic s and thinly-veiled insults that get me speaking about god.
I enjoy a good debate (although most of the outspoken theists on this board don't really give much in the way of "good debates").
So I respond, and learn about logic and argumentation and fallacies.
As well as a fair bit about history and theology (a subject I actually find rather interesting).

But you seem to think our responses in this thread mean that we can't stop thinking about god.

That is incorrect.

I merely enjoy the intellectual exercise of finding logical fallacies. And most apologists on this board make that easy.

Much like I work out the change from my purchases to keep basic math skills sharp.






Finally: for the record, your reply to my prior post DID NOT address the point I was making.

Instead, you seem to have re-interpreted (or maybe miss-interpreted?) your own post.

Now please stop insulting everyone. You don't want to get suspended again, do you?
 
So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?

So how are you trying to argue your belief?
 
Last edited:
Well, it's nice to see yrreg admit that he doesn't have any good arguments for the existence of his god, and has now progressed to the "but could you please stop arguing against him" phase.
 
Well, let us all no longer dwell on language problems here and on insults.

If you cannot get my drift, then I guess there is nothing I can do for you aside from giving you some tips on how to understand my language.
Wrong, this is an English speaking forum, thus if you can't write proper English, its your fault.
 
Logic and critical thinking will only take you so far. Far enough for some, not far enough for others. Where words and concepts end mysticism begins.
Mysticism is illogical. Why am I not surprised.:rolleyes:
 
It nibbles at the edge of coherency and flirts with meaning but in the end you're left waiting at the altar.


To quote Beachcomber, "though he tortures the English language, he has never yet succeeded in forcing it to reveal his meaning."
 
Be honest, tell me about the poverty of concepts and words on God, still the drive...

As for myself, I know that man-made concepts and words can never describe adequately God as He knows Himself to be, that is certainty even though some perceptive folks tell us that certainty is a forlorn human ambition.

Next, I will maintain that just the same we can discuss theists and atheists alike respectively, that God does exist as we exist -- understanding existence as opposed to non-existence, or God does not exist, which however atheists must explain what they mean by non-existence.

We know existence because we exist, and that is the experience that informs us on our existence as opposed to non-existence; but when it comes to non-existence it can only be known by reference to existence, in itself it cannot be known for being [sic] non-existing.


If you are still lost, then just tell me do you accept the truism that man-made concepts and words can never describe God adequately as to do Him justice?

Then tell me whether you are just the same engaged as theists or atheists, and addressing atheists in particular here, engaged in discussing arguing respectively that God does exist, or God does not exist.



Don't tell me that you being an atheist are just discussing me, you flatter me though.

It is like a hungry you telling a burger outlet operator that you are just into popular dietetics, as you take a second and a third glance at his patrons munching on beef and bread inside his joint.


Be honest, tell me about the poverty of concepts and words on God, still the drive to talk about God.



Yrreg
 
It is like a hungry you telling a burger outlet operator that you are just into popular dietetics, as you take a second and a third glance at his patrons munching on beef and bread inside his joint.

Say what?
 
...not correct to claim that in Buddhism there is no God or there are no gods...

Originally Posted by Darth Rotor

The second part does not follow. By definition, a religion is a practice discretely untertaken related to a god, or a number gods. Religion is the practical expression by, action and norming, of the relationship between the people and their god, or gods.

​

Buddhism is generally regarded as a religion, but does not (necessarily) involve the belief in or worship of any god or gods.


When you go to Buddha's lands like in Burma or Thailand or pre-Muslim Indonesia, of course in Nepal, in Tibet, societies of the Far East, where you can see statues of Buddha lined up like reflected in mirrors flanking only one Buddha statue, then in Western conception and language, Buddha is a god and they worship him, and pray to him for favors.

So it is not correct to claim that in Buddhism there is no God or there are no gods, in fact there are plenty of gods, and unless I am mistaken you can get to be one by earning good karmas.

To all appearances Gautama the ultimate Buddha got himself into godhood by earning all the good karmas to almost an nth degree.



Yrreg
 
Gerry, many atheists are interested in the concept of gods and their worship because there are many people with whom they share this world who's actions depend a great deal on their theistic beliefs. Some of those theists go so far as to imagine that their gods grant them the authority to dictate the actions of others. It isn't necessarily because the idea of gods is so compelling. After all, you went on and on and on and on about Buddhism for a good long while, yes? Does that make Buddhism an itch that you can't scratch?
 
Last edited:
Has anyone got the words to describe chocolate and do it adequate justice?

No, you just have to give someone a piece of chocolate.

Now if we could find a piece of god to taste. But wait, the Catholics have this covered.

My taste runs to well done and most gods seem to be rare.
 
When you go to Buddha's lands like in Burma or Thailand or pre-Muslim Indonesia, of course in Nepal, in Tibet, societies of the Far East, where you can see statues of Buddha lined up like reflected in mirrors flanking only one Buddha statue, then in Western conception and language, Buddha is a god and they worship him, and pray to him for favors.

So it is not correct to claim that in Buddhism there is no God or there are no gods, in fact there are plenty of gods, and unless I am mistaken you can get to be one by earning good karmas.

To all appearances Gautama the ultimate Buddha got himself into godhood by earning all the good karmas to almost an nth degree.



Yrreg

Where is your proof that karma exists?
 
Karma and the God of the West and Western atheists

Honestly I don't ever wonder what is the evidence for karma in Hinduism and then in Buddhism its offshoot.

What I know from reading and sharing with others in the West from their conversion into Buddhism is that karma is some kind of what I would consider to be metaphysical system covering what we know in the West to be moral goodness to undo moral badness.

So that since you have moral badness lodged in that system or metaphysical order, you have to undo it with moral goodness in your present and succeeding reincarnations, and add to your hoard of moral goodness, then one day in your latest reincarnation you are ready for nirvana.

But you can choose to prolong your stay in that summit latest present reincarnation, in order to help others get to better and better reincarnations and hence also to nirvana.

And that is what Gautama the ultimate Buddha chose to do even though he should have just rested easy in nirvana.


I never honestly look for evidence to prop up Buddhist karma ( and I don't have karma as a premise in my own theistic system of a worldview ), evidence the kind as atheists insist on, and by which atheists do isolate themselves into, socalled empirical evidence.


My impression of elite Buddhism is that it can be prescinding from God in its pure ideology, but the people who do worship its founder, Gautama the ultimate Buddha, still want God and gods and make even Buddha a god to whom they address their dependencies and worship, as we know worship in the West, i.e., of God.


I am honestly again not in the mental habit of constantly unremittingly looking for evidence to know the existence of anything specially of God, the kind of evidence atheists endlessly drum on, socalled empirical evidence.

Many things cannot be validated by evidence, for example, the very principle of atheists' ground for knowledge namely evidence itself is not validable by evidence, the empirical kind that is.



You see ideologues everywhere have this tendency which they don't know about themselves, or they purposely suppress from coming to the surface of their intellectual consciousness, that they choose to put themselves in a self-made dungeon so as to not see the most huge, deep, high picture of reality, thereby to self-assuredly dwell within their self-encapsulated prison of a worldview.

But for what motivations, they only will know once they get out of their self-dungeon.


As regards my topic here asking atheists and of course theists of which I am one, whether we should at all continue to discuss and argue about No God or Yes God, when our concepts and words are inadequate, I will just say that as a father concerned with giving my family good nutrition I am at times worried that they may not be getting the best or most comprehensive nutrition all the time, just the same with the best of intentions and efforts I do exert all myself to get them all the time as delimited by my knowledge and material resources though, the most adequate foods I can provide based on my knowledge of nutrition and as affordable on my resources.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom