God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

yrreg is back! It's a Festivus miracle!
He was back a few days ago with an off-topic rant about angry atheists in the paranormal forum, which you can find in AAH. ;)

I have no idea what the topic is here, but the title should read: God's existence = man-made concept.
 
The opening post may be the smartest thing Yerrg has ever posted here.

Still huge problems. First, it would not be impossible to understand an immortal omnipotent being if it interacts with the universe. The degree of interaction would be directly proportional to the amount of understanding. Although likely to never be completely understood given our limitations.

Second is that a god that does not interact with the universe in any meaningful way is indistinguishable from one that is not there. If this was not true, than a question would present itself; How does a mortal being relate to omnipotent being that will not present itself or explain it's existence? But that is mute since there is vanishingly small chance of interaction.
 
Agree 100%.

You ask what then? Train people to go beyond words and concepts, to experience through altered states of consciousness.
Which does what exactly?

What does this have to do with God?
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?


I don't know whether or not it should, or better yet, ought not be done. However ... How can man believe in what his concepts and words are incapable of describing?

In any case I would be right in pointing out then that there is no God, i.e. that that our ideas referenced by the word "God" do not match anything in the 'outside world.'
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg

But of course the same thing goes for just about everything we talk about.

If you go to a restaurant and eat the best meal you ever had - are there words that describe the experience to the full? I doubt it.

So we could either stop talking about anything - or be upfront about the fact that language has limitations - whatever the subject.
 
The opening post may be the smartest thing Yerrg has ever posted here.

Still huge problems. First, it would not be impossible to understand an immortal omnipotent being if it interacts with the universe. The degree of interaction would be directly proportional to the amount of understanding. Although likely to never be completely understood given our limitations.

Second is that a god that does not interact with the universe in any meaningful way is indistinguishable from one that is not there. If this was not true, than a question would present itself; How does a mortal being relate to omnipotent being that will not present itself or explain it's existence? But that is mute since there is vanishingly small chance of interaction.


Being, non being...there, not there...existence, non existance...

These are pairs of opposites...categories of thought...concepts and words. Go beyond them.
 
I don't know whether or not it should, or better yet, ought not be done. However ... How can man believe in what his concepts and words are incapable of describing?


That's what mysticism is all about. Experiences beyond mere words, direct experience.

Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
there is a field. I'll meet you there.

When the soul lies down in that grass,
the world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase each other
doesn't make any sense.


There is a way between voice and presence
where information flows.
In disciplined silence it opens.
With wandering talk it closes.
-Rumi

The Tao which can be named is not the true Tao. -Lao Tzu

The Spirit supreme is immeasurable, inapprehensible, beyond conception, never-born, beyond reasoning, beyond thought. -Upanishads

That One which is beyond all thought is inconceivable by all thought. -Dionysius the Areopagite

The gnostics know, but what they know cannot be communicated. It is not in the power of the possessors of this most delightful station...to coin a word which would denote what they know. -Ibn 'Arabi


In any case I would be right in pointing out then that there is no God, i.e. that that our ideas referenced by the word "God" do not match anything in the 'outside world.'


Ask a Buddha if there is a God. If the answer is yes or no their Buddhahood is lost.
 
Last edited:
That's what mysticism is all about. Experiences beyond mere words, direct experience.

Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
there is a field. I'll meet you there.

When the soul lies down in that grass,
the world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase each other
doesn't make any sense.


There is a way between voice and presence
where information flows.
In disciplined silence it opens.
With wandering talk it closes.
-Rumi

The Tao which can be named is not the true Tao. -Lao Tzu

The Spirit supreme is immeasurable, inapprehensible, beyond conception, never-born, beyond reasoning, beyond thought. -Upanishads

That One which is beyond all thought is inconceivable by all thought. -Dionysius the Areopagite

The gnostics know, but what they know cannot be communicated. It is not in the power of the possessors of this most delightful station...to coin a word which would denote what they know. -Ibn 'Arabi
Seems like there are an awful lot of words to say something is beyond words.
 
Seems like there are an awful lot of words to say something is beyond words.


:rolleyes:

You need it dumbed down? "It's beyond words." There ya go. Only three. Too many?
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

You need it dumbed down?
You would do well to tone down your arrogance and try to open your ears and mind.

I never said I needed it dumbed down. I said that there are an awful lot of words to say something is beyond words.
"It's beyond words." There ya go. Only three. Too many?
For something that was really beyond words, one would be too many.

What does the "It's" refer to?
 
Last edited:
Being, non being...there, not there...existence, non existance...

These are pairs of opposites...categories of thought...concepts and words. Go beyond them.

You go first. I'll be right behind you. :D
 
What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg

So because we cannot exhaustively describe God using our finite words (a big assumption I do not agree with, thanks to computer science and mathematics) we therefor cannot meaningfully...discuss God's existence?

Even with that assumption, your conclusion is not demonstrated.

And worse, to a certain extent, it's irrelevant. It's morally wrong to throw dogs into a ring where they fight each other. Our world is the same thing, writ large.


So presume God exists, and is the Christian god you worship. That god is a thug and a monster and a plague on reality.

No god, with no ultimate justice, and eternal, true, insensate death is better than a Christian god who will be torturing most people for ever and ever.
 
Everything in the OP applies to neutrinos.
Yet phycisists seem to have functional models of those.
 
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

What then? Shall we all no longer talk for or against the existence of God?


Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.


What do theists and atheists here think ( and you have to use man-made concepts and words to think and to communicate with each other here, that is the only way we can do so ), namely, should no longer talk and argue for God's existence as for His non-existence?



Yrreg

If "god(s)" exist but are incapable of being fully described accurately by our communication we would at least be able to convey partial descriptions that allow us to debate the existence or non-existence of said entity within those parameters.

So I say we continue the debate.
 
yrreg - Gerry, may I call you Gerry? - I'd like to comment on the first few sentence's you composed (as I believe the word 'wrote' - as in 'the sentences you wrote' - doesn't do justice to the particular way you can mangle the english language. These sentences follow:
Man-made concepts and words, they are the only concepts and words we human beings use to talk about God.

But they cannot ever describe to us exhaustively what is God in Himself.

So all our concepts and words used by theists as by atheists to argue for and against the existence of God, they are all short of if not totally missing what is God in Himself.

Yrreg

Your first sentence appears to be based on an false assumption, a logical fallacy. You are using the term God as if everyone else agrees with you on what God is, does - or isn't, and doesn't. Starting with such a sentence will get you nowhere with me (nor, I suspect, with many other atheist's) since we have no belief in God(s), having seen no evidence of it. Of course, you won't see it that way due to the fact that you are fully involved in depending on Faith to a: confirm that god exists, and b: to identify, to your own (rather limited) satisfaction those qualities that make up this 'god'. You do realize , I hope, that 100's of thousands of gods have existed, thousands upon thousands of them in direct conflict with each other, diametrically opposed.
So please, enlighten us - what qualities does this 'God' you are using possess? Regardless of the word limitations, if a bunch of bronze-age sheep herders can come up with a definition - surely yrreg can? So tell us - what's this god thing like? How big is it? What does it do? How do I go about seeing it (and don't go asking Limbo for any advice in this matter, or you might end up with your brain scrambled)...
Then, your second sentence. Since every God I've come across has been man made (strongly suggesting to me that your - yrreg's - god is also man made, heck certainly man-described (if you believe your bible) - well then, your second sentence does not logically follow from the first.
Neither the third from the second.

In summary, it appears to be some new-fangled Word Salad wherein the individual words make sense, and the waft of a familiar flavor is hinted at like fresh cow patties on the wind - when you actually combine the words you are choosing to use, they make no sense.

Non-Sensical.

Just thinking about reading more of the same is making my head spin to dizziness - I shall sit down a spell and recompose

:)
 
Sounds like Yrreg is trying to protect his god by making discussion of him/it off-limits, using the pathetic excuse that "we don't have the words to do so."

Um, yeah. Pathetic.
 
Before I go further I just want everyone here theists -- of which I am one, a Christian theist more specifically -- and atheists, allow me to just remind everyone that God is not religion.

OK, I am with you so far.
You can relate to God without religion. And you can have religion without God.

Would you please try to explain this in a bit more depth?

The second part does not follow. By definition, a religion is a practice discretely untertaken related to a god, or a number gods. Religion is the practical expression by, action and norming, of the relationship between the people and their god, or gods.

DR
 
Last edited:
The second part does not follow. By definition, a religion is a practice discretely untertaken related to a god, or a number gods. Religion is the practical expression by, action and norming, of the relationship between the people and their god, or gods.
Buddhism is generally regarded as a religion, but does not (necessarily) involve the belief in or worship of any god or gods.
 
Buddhism is generally regarded as a religion, but does not (necessarily) involve the belief in or worship of any god or gods.
OK, if by "god" we include the more general case of the spiritual and divine, does Buddhism fit, or is Buddhism more correctly described as a philosophy?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom