God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Haha; yeah, I am learning fast. :D

Welcome to the forum Hikaka...A Gerry thread will present you with potentially long ramblings from him (In a third person kind of way) and exuding a pompous attitude while butchering the English language along the way. He forces the discussion in the direction he wants it to go and if he thinks you're attempting to divert the discussion: you are tergiversating via intellectual dishonesty. Enjoy! :)
 
Okay, here we go, into the expedition to find evidence in the universe pointing to the existence of God corresponding to the concept as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe, can you agree with me on that?




Yrreg

In the manner of moving this case forward to a point being made, it is taken into consideration. Continue....
 
You are saying nothing useful, do you at all have a concept of God?

If not and you want to exchange thoughts with me about God, first at least get acquainted with a concept of God.

I recommend the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.




Yrreg

Actually, I was answering your question. The idea that G(god) is a social construction does have bearing on the discussion you are attempting to have with people on this forum. I find it interesting that with so many responding to this thread, you have yet to engage anyone in a sustained, meaningful dialogue, despite the variety of viewpoints and the willingness of so many to participate. Maybe it's because, as with me, you tend to treat most with a patronizing tone and thinly veiled insults. Definitely not my idea of quality intellectual discourse, and I've learned my lesson on yrreg threads.

HG
 
Yes: people.

In continuing my initiation into the forum via a yrreg thread, what does it mean if I got flamed but Mojo didn't, even though we said the same thing? I'm finding the meta-discussion about the thread more interesting than the original topic.

I sure picked a doozy to cut my teeth on... :eek:

HG
 
In continuing my initiation into the forum via a yrreg thread, what does it mean if I got flamed but Mojo didn't, even though we said the same thing? I'm finding the meta-discussion about the thread more interesting than the original topic.

I sure picked a doozy to cut my teeth on... :eek:

HG
It means don't take it too seriously ... it's just a thread on a discussion forum :)

My favorite new fad to look for is "Munchausen's by Internet" :~)
 
My favorite new fad to look for is "Munchausen's by Internet" :~)

Love it! I'm a human behavioral scientist by trade, so I sort of got pulled in by just that dynamic that you're suggesting. I'm fascinated by how people behave in the context of the internet...

HG
 
Love it! I'm a human behavioral scientist by trade, so I sort of got pulled in by just that dynamic that you're suggesting. I'm fascinated by how people behave in the context of the internet...

HG
Can I ask an extremely simple question ?

Why does it fascinate you ? :)
 
Can I ask an extremely simple question ?

Why does it fascinate you ? :)

Absolutely! Not to geek out too much on you, but while a lot of what people do fascinates me, the thing about the context of the internet is how individual self-monitoring is significantly altered by the anonymity it provides.
 
Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.


Try to see the biggest view of incompatibility among the components in my concept of God as namely:

The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

Here, do it this way:

The
maker
of
everything
in
the
universe
that
is
not
God
Himself.
​

See any word that in its conceptual import excludes any other word in its conceptual import?




Yrreg
The
mistake
you're
making
is
that
you
are
thinking
that
the
secondary
relational
characteristic
('maker')
is
a
sufficient
definition
for
this
god
concept
and
it
is
not
.
 
Absolutely! Not to geek out too much on you, but while a lot of what people do fascinates me, the thing about the context of the internet is how individual self-monitoring is significantly altered by the anonymity it provides.
Welcome!

Just a slight nitpick: "...is significantly altered by the perceived anonymity it provides."

:D I'm a computer nerd who is attempting to specialize in computer and information security so I'm well aware that there is very little which is truly anonymous online.

More's the pity.
 
Absolutely! Not to geek out too much on you, but while a lot of what people do fascinates me, the thing about the context of the internet is how individual self-monitoring is significantly altered by the anonymity it provides.
In other words ... the unique masks and personas a person can wear and display that the arena of the internet provides ?

If so ... I find the best place to begin is with a person's username and avatar:) It's says a lot I think ... and can be very telling :), esp in light of what they may or may not claim about themselves ...

Welcome!

Just a slight nitpick: "...is significantly altered by the perceived anonymity it provides."

:D I'm a computer nerd who is attempting to specialize in computer and information security so I'm well aware that there is very little which is truly anonymous online.

More's the pity.
The illusion of anonymity comforts a person's dissonance who creates a facade :)
 
You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.
My response was neither mocking, nor parody, nor evasive. Your reply to me, however, is rude.

If you are serious about engaging me in a discussion, reread my post and consider what I have written. I am more than willing to engage you in a serious discussion about this.

If you are merely here to find and fight enemies, however, leave me out of it. There are plenty of forum members for you to engage in such trite battles, and I have much better things to do with my time.

The choice is yours.
 
In other words ... the unique masks and personas a person can wear and display that the arena of the internet provides ?

If so ... I find the best place to begin is with a person's username and avatar:) It's says a lot I think ... and can be very telling :), esp in light of what they may or may not claim about themselves ...

The illusion of anonymity comforts a person's dissonance who creates a facade :)

So it appears to me that you're a professional whirlygig maker who's shooting blanks.

Seems pretty straightforward to me! ;)
 
You make lots of categorical allegations without any logical foundation.
Thanks, I'm trying to follow your masterful example.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.
A 'possible concept' ? what does that mean in this context? Are you saying an actual entity cannot come into existence unless it's existence is possible?

Is God an actual entity?

Okay, do more thinking, and without your overload of grudges against God.
More thinking - you are indeed a hard task master.
 
That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further.
I would appreciate it if you did not conflate my posts with other people's when quoting. My contribution to the quote you posted was only the first few lines:
Wow, you've got better eyesight than me - yrreg's argument is still just a vague blur to me...

Problem is, on past experience, even when it's close enough to touch with a barge-pole, it still looks like a blur - much bigger, but still a vague blur

If you took more care, perhaps you would make more progress.
 
I would appreciate it if you did not conflate my posts with other people's when quoting. My contribution to the quote you posted was only the first few lines:

If you took more care, perhaps you would make more progress.


I think yrreg's habit of quoting himself may have contributed to his confusion.
 
You are saying nothing useful, do you at all have a concept of God?

If not and you want to exchange thoughts with me about God, first at least get acquainted with a concept of God.

I recommend the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.




Yrreg

My concept of god is the empty set.
 
Talk about God in His fundamental relation to the universe, in the Christian faith.

Don't waste time with other things about God by which other things without His being the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, are worth zilch.


Do you comprehend my point?

Ask yourself if you are an author what is the fundamental concept of an author in relation to his literary works?




Yrreg

Getting paid for them?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom