God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Actually, I was answering your question. The idea that G(god) is a social construction does have bearing on the discussion you are attempting to have with people on this forum. I find it interesting that with so many responding to this thread, you have yet to engage anyone in a sustained, meaningful dialogue, despite the variety of viewpoints and the willingness of so many to participate. Maybe it's because, as with me, you tend to treat most with a patronizing tone and thinly veiled insults. Definitely not my idea of quality intellectual discourse, and I've learned my lesson on yrreg threads.

HG
.
You go, Girl!
You figured out gerry so quickly!
You should be happy here.
 
That was my post, yrreg. I was responding to dlorde, but the bulk of the post, including the agreement to use your definition of god (purely for the sake of moving this discussion along) was me. It even gives my name as the quoted poster.

I think the confusion here comes from how you quote multiple posts. It throws me off sometimes, too.






It sounds like he's gearing up for an bastard child of the ontological argument. We can conceive of something he defines as god, therefore the Christian god exists.





Now, yrreg. Some of us here have agreed to use your definition of god for the sake of argument. Can you please proceed to the next part of your script argument? Don't spend all your time raging at those who don't toe your party line. Just get on with your point.






ETA



I think it's already here:

​


Next thing you know, god will by masturbating guiltlessly. Or maybe that's where we came from. Would explain a lot...






P.S. One final thing caught my eye.



Weak Kitten said god was not contained by the universe, yrreg. Her definition is fully compatible with yours. Now get to the point, already!

God masturbates and the guilt falls on us. You really have to learn more sophisticated theology .:covereyes
 
If you are talking solely about the Christian god than we are getting into a totally different discussion. There have been so many divisions and sects in Christianity by this point that you really need to first define which Christian viewpoint you are describing this god from.

Don't feel bad about the Christian god not being a self evident concept. All gods become like this as they mature. Even the sun goddess Amaterasu has a lot of debate over her nature, including what gender she is and exactly how the Japanese royal family are related to her.

Take your time and try to compose what exactly you mean by the Christian god. Just creator of the universe is not enough of a definition really, the Bible has two different creation stories. Once you have a clearer definition we can begin to discuss it.
 
That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent,
You mean they don't immediately acknowledge the brilliance of your arguments but continue to demand actual evidence for your claims?

wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies,
Terrible. How dare rational people demand you justify your claims when they conflict with reality.

.....when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence,
You mean if they were to abandon reason and blindly accept the nonsense shouted by the god botherers?
they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.
Why you xian god? There's as much evidence for most of the other gods humans have made up over the millennia.

And please oh please don't bring in parallel universes which we have no access to and they to us, and also they according to our fantastic but fake astrophysicists with sleight of the hand math have their each one peculiar to themselves only, laws of physics.
Now, now, just because you can't understand advanced physics is no reason to insult people smarter than you.

Where did I say that God is not contained in the universe according to my concept of the universe?

What I maintain is that God is a part and parcel of the universe and also transcendent to the universe.
Hmmmmm. No.

Well, do more serious thinking, for example, do you see that the air in our biosphere is a part and parcel of your house and also is transcendent to your house?
Ehhh, no.

As a matter of fact, for my own insight God in one state of his existence is identical to the universe, so that the universe in that state of God's existence is convertible with God.
Gibberish.
You cannot comprehend that? Well, that is because you are self-blindered by an un-comprehending brain.
Just because you need to believe in an invisible sky daddy to cope with reality is no reason to insult those who've moved beyond needing such a crutch.
 
And we're back to the nose. Can a penis be far behind?

It's not to far away. First there will be many paragraphs of bloviating and accusations of intellectual dishonesty, that atheists are not worthy, and ultimately the victim in all this Gerrymandering: The English language.
 
It's not to far away. First there will be many paragraphs of bloviating and accusations of intellectual dishonesty, that atheists are not worthy, and ultimately the victim in all this Gerrymandering: The English language.

Then there's the fixation on a newly discovered obscure word and the subsequent screwing it into the ground with nearly every post like the Kids In The Hall 'Ascertain' sketch.
 
If you are talking solely about the Christian god than we are getting into a totally different discussion. There have been so many divisions and sects in Christianity by this point that you really need to first define which Christian viewpoint you are describing this god from.

Don't feel bad about the Christian god not being a self evident concept. All gods become like this as they mature. Even the sun goddess Amaterasu has a lot of debate over her nature, including what gender she is and exactly how the Japanese royal family are related to her.

Take your time and try to compose what exactly you mean by the Christian god. Just creator of the universe is not enough of a definition really, the Bible has two different creation stories. Once you have a clearer definition we can begin to discuss it.

His "maker of heaven and earth" is a word for word quote in the Apostles Creed; This is what he totally uses for his description of "the maker of the universe and everything in it"
 
Then there's the fixation on a newly discovered obscure word and the subsequent screwing it into the ground with nearly every post like the Kids In The Hall 'Ascertain' sketch.

:D Exactly! I ascertain that the word ascertain is suited for everything I ascertained it to be.. Yep! that fits Gerry to a T: The one word that comes quickly to mind is Tergiversator. He beat that one to death in one of his threads.
 
Okay, you are serious and relevant, then say your message again sans the mockery...

Originally Posted by yrreg
You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.



My response was neither mocking, nor parody, nor evasive. Your reply to me, however, is rude.

If you are serious about engaging me in a discussion, reread my post and consider what I have written. I am more than willing to engage you in a serious discussion about this.

If you are merely here to find and fight enemies, however, leave me out of it. There are plenty of forum members for you to engage in such trite battles, and I have much better things to do with my time.

The choice is yours.



Okay, you are serious and relevant, then say your message again sans the mockery, parody, and evasions.

Put on top of your message this inscription in bold font: Yrreg, I am serious, no mockery, parody, and evasions here.


Haven't you noticed the useless prattle going on here with people who do not think but regurgitate useless words with the idea in their naive disingenuous mind that they are saying clever things but actually prattle.


I invite you to do relevant logical productive thinking and writing here, so that in the midst of useless prattle regurgitating wastrels here we can work on the issue God or no God sincerely to arrive at the fact.




Yrreg
 
Now give examples of what can be observed directly or indirectly.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Well, your call then, make a truly founded concept of the universe and its contents.





Easy.

The universe is what can be observed, either directly or indirectly.


Now give examples of what can be observed directly or indirectly.

Don't forget to include the nose in your face.




Yrreg
 
Haven't you noticed the useless prattle going on here with people who do not think but regurgitate useless words with the idea in their naive disingenuous mind that they are saying clever things but actually prattle.

:id:
 
Haven't you noticed the useless prattle going on here with people who do not think but regurgitate useless words with the idea in their naive disingenuous mind that they are saying clever things but actually prattle.

Yes, I have. Want to guess who I think the biggest culprit is?
 
Don't dwell in the past, react to my latest message to you 8 hours earlier.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You make lots of categorical allegations without any logical foundation.

Thanks, I'm trying to follow your masterful example.

Quote:
An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.

A 'possible concept' ? what does that mean in this context? Are you saying an actual entity cannot come into existence unless it's existence is possible?

Is God an actual entity?

Quote:
Okay, do more thinking, and without your overload of grudges against God.

More thinking - you are indeed a hard task master.



Don't dwell in the past anymore, are you not going to reply to my latest message addressed to you, here below, 8 hours earlier, or you really don't care to keep on track?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7725787#post7725787


[ Title of post: That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further. ]

Originally Posted by dlorde
Wow, you've got better eyesight than me - yrreg's argument is still just a vague blur to me...

Problem is, on past experience, even when it's close enough to touch with a barge-pole, it still looks like a blur - much bigger, but still a vague blur



It's his usual argument: Proof of god by redefining god to be something we (atheist illogical unintelligent naive pseudo-thinker ignorant stubborn) accept, therefore Christianity is true.



Oh, and yrreg: You might want to tone down the insults. Maybe you'll be able to make it to the crux of your argument one day without being suspended for rudeness.

To speed you on your way: I will, for the sake of argument, accept your definition of god as the maker of the universe. And I won't delve into the "where did god come from" question.

But be forewarned: the moment you start adding attributes to this god which you have neither explained nor supported, I will jump on your argument like a dog on bacon.



That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further.


At the cost of being accused of repetitiousness, let me just the same repeat the concept of God and the concept of the universe from yours truly, which you elorde have agreed to accept for the purpose of this exercise, to prove the existence of God from the fact of the existence of the universe as evidence.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


Okay, here we go, into the expedition to find evidence in the universe pointing to the existence of God corresponding to the concept as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe, can you agree with me on that?


Yrreg




Please be attentive, otherwise I will suspect very seriously that you are just into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of genuine sincere interaction on the issue of God or no God.

That is why this issue of God or no God never ends with atheists because they are into mockery, parody, and evasions, for example by not being attentive sincerely attentive to the reasoning from people who do take the interest and care to try to reason with them.




Yrreg
 
Please be attentive, otherwise I will suspect very seriously that you are just into mockery, parody, and evasions, instead of genuine sincere interaction on the issue of God or no God.

That is why this issue of God or no God never ends with atheists because they are into mockery, parody, and evasions, for example by not being attentive sincerely attentive to the reasoning from people who do take the interest and care to try to reason with them.




Yrreg

So are you still talking about your god the Big Bang or some other god? Does your god have any other properties or did it only start the universe up?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom