God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.


If you do not accept the concept of God as I present here:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself,
​
then come up with a concept, and I will see whether you have one that is what Christians know to be the God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


No.

Or you point out precisely and concisely what components in my concept of God cannot be together without cancelling each other out.


Your definition assumes the universe and its contents needed to be made. That is an unfounded assumption.
 
Talk about God in His fundamental relation to the universe, in the Christian faith.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Tell me what part of my concept of God is self-referential?

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.





Make your mind up. Are you talking about the Christian God, or a Deist God? The Christian God is more than just the maker of the universe.


Talk about God in His fundamental relation to the universe, in the Christian faith.

Don't waste time with other things about God by which other things without His being the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, are worth zilch.


Do you comprehend my point?

Ask yourself if you are an author what is the fundamental concept of an author in relation to his literary works?




Yrreg
 
Talk about God in His fundamental relation to the universe, in the Christian faith.

Don't waste time with other things about God by which other things without His being the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, are worth zilch.


Do you comprehend my point?


Wait, now a necessary part of this definition is that God is male?

Hmmm....
 
Before anything else, we are talking about the concept of God not the existence of God.


You can acquaint your mind to that concept, it is now in your mind.

You are asking where that concept comes from, for the present we will not go into where it comes from, the fact is that it is here already, and you say that you can have it in your mind.

I have it also in my mind.


What can you say about that concept of God:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Is it a possible concept or an impossible concept, meaning, is there a possibility that there can be an entity in objective reality that corresponds to the concept?

You want to ask me where it comes from, but for the present put that question in abeyance, for the fact is that it is here and I have it in my mind and you also have acquainted your mind with it.

What you and I want to do now is to examine the concept to determine whether it is a possible concept or not, understanding by a possible concept as one that can correspond to a possible entity in objective reality.

Can you comprehend me?



Gerry
It is not a possible concept as you've outlined, no.


You are saying nothing useful, do you at all have a concept of God?

If not and you want to exchange thoughts with me about God, first at least get acquainted with a concept of God.

I recommend the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​


Otherwise, you are going the direction of atheists who are completely and exclusively into mockery, parody, and evasions instead of rational logical substantially relevant speech in the issue of God or no God.




Yrreg
The mistake you're making is that you are thinking that the secondary relational characteristic ('maker') is a sufficient definition for this god concept and it is not. You're not providing any information with which to make a judgement of whether or not this god concept is even capable of being a 'maker' or of even 'being' (as in, 'existing') at all.

You also fail at demonstrating there is a something that is separate from our universe (the 'made' from the 'maker') in the first place.
 
If you don't have grudges against God in any way, why not go away and have a life?

Originally Posted by yrreg
You are into describing God as from a speaker with grudges against God.


I don't believe in God - having a grudge against God would be like having a grudge against the tooth fairy. OTOH I'm not entirely happy with some the actions and activities of many religious groups in the name of God, but I still wouldn't call it a grudge, as I haven't been personally affronted by them.

Quote:

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
And also the concept from yours truly of the universe:

Universe = The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
Attend to the concepts and examine each to detect whether there are components within each as according to my accounts, that are mutually incompatible as to cancel each other out.
Apart from the obvious 'existence of God' problem, there's clearly and incompatibility between God being maker of the universe and everything that isn't God, and the God being part of the universe that he supposedly created. This is what I pointed out previously.

Quote:
Otherwise I see nothing in your post but mockery, parody, and evasions.
Mockery, yes; but parody? did you think I was parodying you, or a theist philosopher? As for evasions, none was intended - if you'd like to ask me a direct question that is coherent and intelligible, I'd be happy to attempt an answer.



If you don't have grudges against God in any way, why not go away and have a life?


In the meantime take up the psychology of human motivations.


Your words reek of grudges against God.


And don't be into rhetorical questions, just put your logical thoughts in precise concise terms, no grudges whatsoever because these are emotional overloads that do not give you any credit for rational thinking.


Okay, go and examine my concept of God, and give your objections sans the emotional overloads, and don't engage in rhetorical questions.


You mention difficulties with my concept of God and of the universe.

Just keep for the present on God, and tell me again your objections but sans the emotional overload: precisely concisely relevantly.


When we are through with God the concept of, then we can go into the concept of the universe.

And keep in mind that God is not religion and religion is not God, so don't go the evasive way of conflating them.




Yrreg
 
I am most impatient to exchange thoughts with you.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Here is the fundamental concept of God in the Christian faith in God's relation to the universe:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.

Can you have any acquaintance in your mind with the thought expressed in that concept of God?

No, I am not yet into proving that there is an entity corresponding to that concept of God, just that I invite you to acquaint your mind with that concept.

First, your mind must be accessible to the concept as concept, then you and I can go forth in the universe to seek an entity corresponding to that concept.

Do you comprehend me?

Yrreg





Welcome back, Yrreg, long time, no see!

You don't make it easy to comprehend you as you word your paragraphs very oddly, but I believe I understand. 'Maker of everything not God' is a working definition I can agree to for purposes of discussion. It's your topic, and God definitions vary a lot depending on who supposes them, I don't mind going along with yours for the time being. In fact, it's good form for you to spell out what version of God you're talking about.


I am most impatient to exchange thoughts with you.



Yrreg
 
Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Please don't engage in mockery, parody, and evasions.

I have already two concepts propounded here:

God = In the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
Not only the Christian faith, you've described Brahma and a variety of other creator gods as well, including the God of deism and the God of 'we'll call whatever caused the universe God, even if it was just a quantum fluctuation'.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Universe = The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
Your definition of universe includes things that don't exist. If I was arguing your side, I would have gone with 'everything that exists', full stop.

Originally Posted by yrreg
First, we talk about concepts and determine whether they are possible concepts or impossible concepts.
You may run into some problems here. Skeptics usually like to hear some good reason why they should think something might be so in the first place before they start burning brain cells on figuring out whether it's possible or not. The set of possible things is infinitely greater than the set of actual things. Reason alone is not a good basis for determining if something exists, empiricism has to come into play at some point.

Originally Posted by yrreg
This discussion therefore is concerned with God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.
You might want to leave Christianity out of it at this point, and just shoot for getting at any kind of creator god at all.

Originally Posted by yrreg
And the universe is the one where we are living in and are part and parcel of.

Yrreg

May I assume you are referring to a nearly all-inclusive universe, the set of all things which exist? This definition would include other universes if there are any.



Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.


One thing at a time.



Better, think over your objections against my concept of God, and connect them together to get to the real point you want to make, instead of throwing out so many things without any mutual linkage.



Yrreg
 
Why not just define god as the maker of the universe?

If I remember right, that was his first definition - but he was then plagued by questions whether God then made himself, or if not who made God? etc.. That last bit, about not making God part of the universe, was tacked on after that.
 
Sure. if, by blind spot, you mean "can see yrreg's argument coming from 3 miles away".

Wow, you've got better eyesight than me - yrreg's argument is still just a vague blur to me...

Problem is, on past experience, even when it's close enough to touch with a barge-pole, it still looks like a blur - much bigger, but still a vague blur :D
 
yrreg, why are you calling the Big Bang god?

Are you keeping some of the traits of your god secret for now and will spring them on us later?
 
If you don't have grudges against God in any way, why not go away and have a life?
I am away, living my life.

Your words reek of grudges against God.
Wow, you must be right - clearly I'm in denial about being full of grudges against God :rolleyes: so what should I do?

Okay, go and examine my concept of God, and give your objections sans the emotional overloads, and don't engage in rhetorical questions.
I have no particular objections to the concept of God as maker of everything that isn't God. Although I'm curious to know how the concept can be made to work - e.g. if God created spacetime itself, then there wouldn't have been any time in which God could comtemplate the act of creation, and no time in which the act of creation could occur, also there would be nowhere for God himself to exist prior to that. If God exists outside of spacetime (somehow - that would need explaining), then he hasn't created everything that isn't himself, because he hasn't created this place outside spacetime where he exists...

Stuff like that... :)
 
Last edited:
One at a time, if you don't want to appear foolish, unintelligent.

Ok, I can handle the concept of a being or beings who created this universe. I just don't see why we have to limit ourselves to just one being, or one universe for that mater. If we are discussing things for which we have no physical evidence and may never have any physical evidence I see no reason to limit our scope. I like discussing these sorts of cosmologies, the ideas can really be creative and fun. Just don't be all closed minded about the nature and number of gods.

So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?



One at a time, if you don't want to appear foolish, unintelligent.


That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, and with Russell's teapot, when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence, they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.


And please oh please don't bring in parallel universes which we have no access to and they to us, and also they according to our fantastic but fake astrophysicists with sleight of the hand math have their each one peculiar to themselves only, laws of physics.


You ask: "So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?"


Where did I say that God is not contained in the universe according to my concept of the universe?


What I maintain is that God is a part and parcel of the universe and also transcendent to the universe.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, do more serious thinking, for example, do you see that the air in our biosphere is a part and parcel of your house and also is transcendent to your house?

As a matter of fact, for my own insight God in one state of his existence is identical to the universe, so that the universe in that state of God's existence is convertible with God.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, that is because you are self-blindered by an un-comprehending brain.




Yrreg
 
foolish, unintelligent.
foolish or unintelligent,
you are self-blindered by an un-comprehending brain.




Yrreg

You should remember your problem with your control issues and how they have gotten you suspended and put on probation before.

If you have no logical arguments to make, if the best you can do is name-calling people who disagree with you, maybe you're arguing for the wrong thing.

Now, answer the question. Why do you call the Big Bang god?
 
One at a time, if you don't want to appear foolish, unintelligent.


That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, and with Russell's teapot, when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence, they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.


And please oh please don't bring in parallel universes which we have no access to and they to us, and also they according to our fantastic but fake astrophysicists with sleight of the hand math have their each one peculiar to themselves only, laws of physics.


You ask: "So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?"


Where did I say that God is not contained in the universe according to my concept of the universe?


What I maintain is that God is a part and parcel of the universe and also transcendent to the universe.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, do more serious thinking, for example, do you see that the air in our biosphere is a part and parcel of your house and also is transcendent to your house?

As a matter of fact, for my own insight God in one state of his existence is identical to the universe, so that the universe in that state of God's existence is convertible with God.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, that is because you are self-blindered by an un-comprehending brain.




Yrreg

That is what I notice time and again with theists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of orgies of self-congratulations on making stuff up and assuming that it's intelligible. They go around perfectly oblivious to the fact that the stuff they make up is not the same thing that the very next person has made up but since they all like to use the same nonsensical word -- God -- they get to pretend it's deep and thoughtful.











Note: I went with derision after my previous post was ignored.
 
Well, your call then, make a truly founded concept of the universe and its contents.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You are not saying anything useful, except to go into mockery, parody, and evasions.


If you do not accept the concept of God as I present here:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself,
then come up with a concept, and I will see whether you have one that is what Christians know to be the God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

No.

Quote:
Or you point out precisely and concisely what components in my concept of God cannot be together without cancelling each other out.

Your definition assumes the universe and its contents needed to be made. That is an unfounded assumption.



Well, your call then, make a truly founded concept of the universe and its contents.


The whole world is waiting with bated breath to hear about your truly founded concept of the universe and its contents.



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom