General questions from a new member...

Which "real flags" would you accept/allow to happen?

Cuban missile crisis perhaps? ooh. how about sept 11 attacks? hmm let's take it out of the American theatre. Falklands was a false flag to re-elect teh thatch maybe. :popcorn1

Well, I think a "bluff" as in something like poker would be acceptable as long as it was used for the safety and well being of our country and didn't involve me loosing any liberty.

But, if it is used for anything other than that, such as power, money, or controll, than I am against it.
 
I know, I said sorry. I should have kept that idea to myself. It just seems as though nobody here can say the government does no wrong and every event that occured that appears that way, people are telling me there is no way it could have happened.

It just seems like allot of faith in something that nobody can be 100% sure of.

Thats just my opinion though and I don't mean any harm.

Your apology is accepted. Your point, however, is still very weak I believe. Whether or not the U.S. government has historically engaged in deception has little bearing on whether or not 9/11 was an inside job. And "nobody can be 100% sure" doesn't cut it -- you have to show proof. Even if you do, so what? Unless you have some evidence implicating the government in 9/11, what may or may not have happened in the Gulf of Tonkin 40 years ago has little bearing on the case.

Your argument might make a little sense if the only rebuttle ever offered to 9/11 CTer claims was "our government would never do such a thing." But that's only a tiny piece of the debunker arsenal. Far more powerful is all the scientific facts and evidence that supports what is commonly called the "official story," and utterly refutes the CTer claims. When you play the "you can't be 100% sure about the government" card, you're losing a game that no one else is even playing.
 
Last edited:
Your apology is accepted. Your point, however, is still very weak I believe. Whether or not the U.S. government has historically engaged in deception has little bearing on whether or not 9/11 was an inside job. And "nobody can be 100% sure" doesn't cut it -- you have to show proof. Even if you do, so what? Unless you have some evidence implicating the government in 9/11, what may or may not have happened in the Gulf of Tonkin 40 years ago has little bearing on the case.

Your argument might make a little sense if the only rebuttle ever offered to 9/11 CTer claims was "our government would never do such a thing." But that's only a tiny piece of the debunker arsenal. Far more powerful is all the scientific facts and evidence that supports what is commonly called the "official story," and utterly refutes the CTer claims. When you play the "you can't be 100% sure about the government" card, you're losing a game that no one else is even playing.

Ok, good but...

you say the "scientific facts" that are in the official story. What makes them the right facts but other experts have wrong facts? Who is to decide what scientist is right if both contradict each other? Oh... the word "official"? :boggled:

Like I said, evidence is in the eye of the beholder. I might not have worded that right but one persons evidence is another persons garbage and there is NO supreme person to say what is right and what is not. Thats why a jury has 12 people (not sided with any one view), the majority is the deciding factor.

Thats the sad thing... we are not in a court of law here with people here to make a decesion that don't have a strong opinion already.
 
Last edited:
ok, then I may go upon my life feeling good about my country and not worry about any lies being told or any wars being started for the wrong reasons or any of my right being taken away?
...

Not at all. Keep an eye on the bastards and keep them at least a little bit honest. Don't go making up crap about them tho', cause that just weakens your case.
 
Ok, good but...

you say the "scientific facts" that are in the official story. What makes them the right facts but other experts have wrong facts? Who is to decide what scientist is right if both contradict each other? Oh... the word "official"? :boggled:

Like I said, evidence is in the eye of the beholder. I might not have worded that right but one persons evidence is another persons garbage and there is NO supreme person to say what is right and what is not. Thats why a jury has 12 people (not sided with any one view), the majority is the deciding factor.

Thats the sad thing... we are not in a court of law here with people here to make a decesion that don't have a strong opinion already.

So umm how many scientists and engineers on the Truther side of things? One or two? How many on the "Official" side? All the rest. That by itself doesn't prove anything, but it is pretty persuasive doncha think?
 
The one at the time it took place.

The version that actually took place is that on 2 August the USS Maddox was attacked by three North Vietnamese torpedo boats in International waters. The Maddox scared the torpedo boats away with its weapons.

On 4 August the USS Maddox and USS Turner Joy were conducting a close in patrol of the North Vietnam coast when they mistakenly thought they had come under attack again. Although the commander quickly determined that it was unlikely any attack was sustained, he still incorrectly maintained that there had been an initial ambush involving one boat firing one torpedo at the USS Maddox. (It is important to note that the commander was on board the Turner Joy not the Maddox).

The USA believing the second attack to have been genuine, initiated attacks against North Korea, and the President took advantage of the incident to justify expanded military operations in Vietnam - an agenda he almost certainly already wished to follow through on.


Then what was the reason?

The USA became involved in Vietnam to maintain the sovereignty of South Vietnam and to prevent the spread of Communism.

So what events do you think were "real" "false flags"?

-Mukden Incident
-Marco Polo Bridge Incident
-Operation Himmler
-Shelling of Mainila
-Lavon Affair
-Operation Ajax
-1999 Russian Apartment Bombings (possibly)


Do you think that if a real large scale "false flag" occured that you would really be able to know?

That would depend entirely on the circumstance.

-Gumboot
 
Well, I think a "bluff" as in something like poker would be acceptable as long as it was used for the safety and well being of our country and didn't involve me loosing any liberty.

But, if it is used for anything other than that, such as power, money, or controll, than I am against it.

furimuff, Thats pretty much the thrust of polytricx. the public don't need to know because we don't want to know (no woo just general apathy)

gives handfull of pretty green.
 
you say the "scientific facts" that are in the official story. What makes them the right facts but other experts have wrong facts? Who is to decide what scientist is right if both contradict each other? Oh... the word "official"? :boggled:


I've been researching 9/11 pretty thoroughly for about 18 months, and in that time I have not seen one single scrap of evidence that any significant aspect of the accepted account of those events is wrong.

If you have access to any such evidence I would be more than happy to look at it.

-Gumboot
 
What makes them the right facts but other experts have wrong facts?
Peer review. Being able to defend an explanation before other people who have been in the field as long or longer. Using proven methods of investigation. Actually having the credentials you claim to have.

Who is to decide what scientist is right if both contradict each other? Oh... the word "official"? :boggled:
Just so you know, this comes off as somewhat flippant.

I might not have worded that right but one persons evidence is another persons garbage and there is NO supreme person to say what is right and what is not.
Scientific investigation is not a democracy. Some people know better than others.
 
So umm how many scientists and engineers on the Truther side of things? One or two? How many on the "Official" side? All the rest. That by itself doesn't prove anything, but it is pretty persuasive doncha think?

Somewhat, but I factor in the strong possibility that if I were to do an investigation on myself I would hire people that would make me look good.

But this investigation was "independant" right?

I tend to listen to the people that have nothing to gain from a situation. Despite what some think, most truthers think they are doing good and are not out to get anyone for the sake of getting someone. But thats my opinion.

Its a fact that the "independant" investigation was leaded by somebody who had ties to the very people that are accused. That, for me, discredits 99% of that investigation. Im not saying I think 99% of the findings are wrong, I am just saying I don't give it much credence.
 
Somewhat, but I factor in the strong possibility that if I were to do an investigation on myself I would hire people that would make me look good.

But this investigation was "independant" right?

I tend to listen to the people that have nothing to gain from a situation. Despite what some think, most truthers think they are doing good and are not out to get anyone for the sake of getting someone. But thats my opinion.

Its a fact that the "independant" investigation was leaded by somebody who had ties to the very people that are accused. That, for me, discredits 99% of that investigation. Im not saying I think 99% of the findings are wrong, I am just saying I don't give it much credence.


The evidence that supports the accepted account of what happened on 9/11 does not come solely from the 9/11 Commission. It comes from a multitude of sources, many independent of the US government, and quite a few who would leap at the chance to reveal evidence of US Government involvement.

-Gumboot
 
I've been researching 9/11 pretty thoroughly for about 18 months, and in that time I have not seen one single scrap of evidence that any significant aspect of the accepted account of those events is wrong.

If you have access to any such evidence I would be more than happy to look at it.

-Gumboot

Still looking for something that would be sufficient "evidence" for somebody like you (Don't take that wrong please).

Its clear that 9/11 will only be a debate until something VERY clear or concerning pops up.

But look at JFK... Its been 40 years and there have been confessions from CIA agents to the actuall assasins and nobody here seems to believe it so maybe I should accept things for the way they are.....

Truthers vs. Debunkers for ever!!!!:)
 
The evidence that supports the accepted account of what happened on 9/11 does not come solely from the 9/11 Commission. It comes from a multitude of sources, many independent of the US government, and quite a few who would leap at the chance to reveal evidence of US Government involvement.

-Gumboot


Ok but I have been givin links to the 9/11 commission a number of times to answer my questions (not just here). If I dont have faith in that investigation (as many don't) than are our questions really getting answered?

There lies the majority of this battle. One persons evidence doesn't work for another person for different reasons. Not just because they are "crazy tofers".
 
Truthers vs. Debunkers for ever!!!!:)


That's fine by me.

'Truthers' are incapable of providing a convincing alternative narrative to the events of 911 and, as time goes by, their little movement will become even more insignificant...well, until the next major global event they can seize and spin as evidence of...... something.
 
You are not going to find people capable of doing a 9/11 investigation wandering around Ground Zero in black T-shirts.

Nope. Its only the people who have no money or power, that want to do something, that will resort to walking the streets pleading for somebody to listen.

Its up to somebody that has the power to compete with the government in creating a "official" investigation that won't get shot out of the sky because of politicial reasons.

Good luck to that person (it will never happen). Therefore you have to resort to the black shirts.
 
Nope. Its only the people who have no money or power, that want to do something, that will resort to walking the streets pleading for somebody to listen.

Its up to somebody that has the power to compete with the government in creating a "official" investigation that won't get shot out of the sky because of politicial reasons.

Good luck to that person (it will never happen). Therefore you have to resort to the black shirts.

Well I don't have any money or power, but I know a load of bollocks when I see it.
 
Nope. Its only the people who have no money or power, that want to do something, that will resort to walking the streets pleading for somebody to listen.

Its up to somebody that has the power to compete with the government in creating a "official" investigation that won't get shot out of the sky because of politicial reasons.

Good luck to that person (it will never happen). Therefore you have to resort to the black shirts.

Take it to the UN.... Amnesty International.... someone.

All 'truthers' have to do is pool their resources (ooops sorry guys, you gotta put your money where your mouth is) and commission reports by professional structural engineers and air crash investigators. If those reports then call into question the 'official account' (and that's a very big IF...which probably explains why 'truthers' won't go down this road) send them to every delegation at the UN imploring them to impose sanctions against the US until an 'independent' investigation is undertaken.

But 'truthers' won't do any of this because they don't really believe their own fantasies. It just gives them something to bitch about.
 
Take it to the UN.... Amnesty International.... someone.

All 'truthers' have to do is pool their resources (ooops sorry guys, you gotta put your money where your mouth is) and commission reports by professional structural engineers and air crash investigators. If those reports then call into question the 'official account' (and that's a very big IF...which probably explains why 'truthers' won't go down this road) send them to every delegation at the UN imploring them to impose sanctions against the US until an 'independent' investigation is undertaken.

But 'truthers' won't do any of this because they don't really believe their own fantasies. It just gives them something to bitch about.

I agree that somebody needs to step up and organize this mess if they have any hope. I am disapointed that so much focus is spent in the wrong direction. I started loosing respect for LC when they spent too much time on stupid battles on the internet and making a damn movie (that they charged for but didn't use the money to orgainize a comission).

But I can imagine its not easy to fund or organize something like that starting from nothing.

It would take somebody with allot of money and pull to be able to pull it off but honestly, what millionare gives a damn? They got money, they are not going to spend it on something that won't make them more money.

Its a loosing battle for the truthers. It doesn't mean that some questions are not valid questions though.
 
Its a loosing battle for the truthers. It doesn't mean that some questions are not valid questions though.

I disagree.

If one truly believed these theories there are any number of people you can approach, especially at a University.

The first thing you could do is simply run your concerns by qualified people to determine if there was enough reason to continue. These people are in the business of educating and most will answer your questions if you are polite, brief and to the point.

When these theories first began to surface I was working for the University of Texas and I did just that. Every time I heard a new one I’d walk over to the Engineering School and ask a few questions.

Now considering that Engineering is their life they already had a keen interest in what happened and I can assure you that they already knew the details of the buildings design and exactly what forces they were subjected to, a far deeper knowledge and understanding than some kid on the internet.

Needless to say every flawed logic or understanding of structural engineering proposed by the conspiracy camp was explained to me in great detail.

Now consider this. Suppose I had approached them with something that was not nonsense, something that they had simply not considered or had been unaware of.

Do you think that someone with no training would be able to understand the implications of such an anomaly but not someone with a lifetime of experience in the field? I think not.

Do you think that every professional approached and confronted with evidence that their own government cold-bloodily murdered thousands of its own citizens would just clam up and refuse to act? Again I think not.

All one would need to do is enlist the aid of someone with the proper credentials that people would listen to which would be easy enough to do if one truly had evidence or even legitimate questions that needed resolving.

Another approach I have used is email. I have looked up the names and emailed Egyptologists, Video Experts, you name it, at one time or another and have been pleasantly surprised at how willing most are to answer questions if you are brief and polite.

If you truly seek the truth, don’t question Loose Change. Don’t question the JREF forums. Ask an expert.

For example, If you’ve heard that the fires during 911 were not hot enough to cause the building to collapse then write that as a question, go online, google ‘Structural Engineer’, get some names and email 10 of them with that question

You’ll be separating the wheat from the chaff in no time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom