General questions from a new member...

Wait a sec...you don't want anyone here to put you in a catagory by generalizing you so you find it ok to generalize the people here. You don't see that as a bit ironic?

Your right! I am sorry.
 
Zero points for creativity, zero points for believability, zero points for ingenuity.

Try being less obvious next time, Lee5.


I don't get it. Who am I trying to be creative for? My questions may not be creative but I am not trying to come up with things out of thin air. :boggled:
 
9/11 was commited by Al Qeida. It is a fact. This has nothing to do with the blind faith in any organization government or otherwise. This had to do with the facts.
 
Last edited:
You mean mark of insanity ala 8bitmoron at LCF.

Are you thinking I am 8bit?

I am not.

I think my questions would be more interesting if I was.

Im just a nobody in northern california thats stuck at work for 12 hours with nothing to do tonight.
 
Thanks Gumboot those were great answers.

So, pretty much, at best we are guilty of just creating "monsters"?

Blowback if you will?


I think the United States is primarily guilty of underestimating the threat of Radical Islam, specifically:

1. Underestimating the intensity and depth of animosity towards the USA for supporting Israel and any involvement whatsoever in the Middle East

2. Underestimating the conviction of those willing to support their ideology with action.

3. Underestimating the skill and capability of these people to penetrate the US system, exploit it, and defeat it (laws, US customs, military defense, intelligence, law enforcement, etc)

4. Underestimate the depth of understanding and expanse of "vision" these people have in their assault against the West.

I believe with the exception of 1) the American people, collectively, are still guilty of the above. I also believe the same is true of virtually all westerners, with very few exceptions.

-Gumboot
 
Are you thinking I am 8bit?

I am not.

I think my questions would be more interesting if I was.

Im just a nobody in northern california thats stuck at work for 12 hours with nothing to do tonight.
Nope...don't think your that idiot. He wouldn't dare show his face with his moronic PTECH theories but then again, that is the first theory you mentioned. 8bit is a fairly smart guy and he knows his bs has no chance outside of his targeted audience.
 
9/11 was commited by Al Qeida. It is a fact. This has nothing to do with the blind faith in any organization government or otherwise. This had to do with the facts.

You may be right. But I am not just talking about 9/11.

I am talking about all tragic events that have taken place that people have said the government was behind.

*JFK
*CIA involvment in almost everything bad (so its claimed)

I said a few things that got avioded but Ill ask properly...

1. Was the gulf of tonkin really a lie?
2. Was this the reason we went to the vietnam war? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin_Incident)
3. If yes, then wouldnt this be considered a "false flag"?
4. If yes, then do you believe "false flags" are real terms for real operations?
 
The history of covert operations and how wars have been started, fought, or won by false pretenses makes for fascinating reading.

However, most of history, including the cause of wars, happens in plain view. Really. Politics exists, both in the US and other countries, without shadowy forces creating it. Sometimes people just don't get along.
 
Nope...don't think your that idiot. He wouldn't dare show his face with his moronic PTECH theories but then again, that is the first theory you mentioned. 8bit is a fairly smart guy and he knows his bs has no chance outside of his targeted audience.

ok:boggled:

At first I thought your insulting me but I guess you did no such thing. :D
 
The history of covert operations and how wars have been started, fought, or won by false pretenses makes for fascinating reading.

However, most of history, including the cause of wars, happens in plain view. Really. Politics exists, both in the US and other countries, without shadowy forces creating it. Sometimes people just don't get along.

Ok, that makes sense but, it still doesn't justify a lie that ends up killing thousands of people does it?

And if its known to be a lie, then where is the line drawn on what is ok to lie about and what is not?
 
I think the United States is primarily guilty of underestimating the threat of Radical Islam, specifically:

1. Underestimating the intensity and depth of animosity towards the USA for supporting Israel and any involvement whatsoever in the Middle East

2. Underestimating the conviction of those willing to support their ideology with action.

3. Underestimating the skill and capability of these people to penetrate the US system, exploit it, and defeat it (laws, US customs, military defense, intelligence, law enforcement, etc)

4. Underestimate the depth of understanding and expanse of "vision" these people have in their assault against the West.

I believe with the exception of 1) the American people, collectively, are still guilty of the above. I also believe the same is true of virtually all westerners, with very few exceptions.

-Gumboot

Ok. Good points!!

So, you think our forign policy is wrong then?

Do you believe in ANY malicious operations by our government or do you think they are all in good intentions?
 
1. Was the gulf of tonkin really a lie?

Which version of it?


2. Was this the reason we went to the vietnam war? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin_Incident)

No.



3. If yes, then wouldnt this be considered a "false flag"?

No, the Gulf of Tonkin Incident was not a "false flag".


4. If yes, then do you believe "false flags" are real terms for real operations?

Yes I believe "false flag" is a real term, I believe they have been used in the past, and will be in future. I'm not aware of the USA ever undertaking one to justify entry into a major conflict, although I am aware that various military brainstormings have proposed this.

-Gumboot
 
...I don't have blind faith in my government as most of you do (it seems).

If I may offer one last piece of advice -- one that may help ensure mutual respect for all in this discussion -- avoid saying stuff like this. Because frankly, it's both insulting and demonstrably untrue. I think you'd be very hard pressed to find a single poster in any of these forums that can be accurately described as having "blind faith" in the government. That's an accusation many CTers make, and it's ridiculous. With even a modicum of effort, you'll quickly discover that forum members come in nearly all possible political persuasions, none of which I'd describe as blind faith.

I personally have voted against George Bush twice, and would have done it more if they let me. I think he's almost certainly the worst president of my lifetime. Yet that doesn't blind me to the fact that 9/11 CTers are full of bull.
 
Ok. Good points!!

So, you think our forign policy is wrong then?


I think your foreign policy is seriously flawed, but I think it's in more of the right direction than the foreign policy of many other western nations, including my own.



Do you believe in ANY malicious operations by our government or do you think they are all in good intentions?

I think by and large your government has always acted in what it felt were the best interests of the nation. However I think many times their actions were actually not in the interests of the nation, and I think in some cases they should have known this.

I would probably say the same about my own government, although more relating to policy and less to actual operations (I have no real issue with any of the military operations that my government has been involved in).

-Gumboot
 
Which version of it?

The one at the time it took place.


No.


Then what was the reason?


No, the Gulf of Tonkin Incident was not a "false flag".

Then why did they lie? What was the benefit?


Yes I believe "false flag" is a real term, I believe they have been used in the past, and will be in future. I'm not aware of the USA ever undertaking one to justify entry into a major conflict, although I am aware that various military brainstormings have proposed this.

So what events do you think were "real" "false flags"?

-Gumboot

Do you think that if a real large scale "false flag" occured that you would really be able to know?
 
If I may offer one last piece of advice -- one that may help ensure mutual respect for all in this discussion -- avoid saying stuff like this. Because frankly, it's both insulting and demonstrably untrue. I think you'd be very hard pressed to find a single poster in any of these forums that can be accurately described as having "blind faith" in the government. That's an accusation many CTers make, and it's ridiculous. With even a modicum of effort, you'll quickly discover that forum members come in nearly all possible political persuasions, none of which I'd describe as blind faith.

I personally have voted against George Bush twice, and would have done it more if they let me. I think he's almost certainly the worst president of my lifetime. Yet that doesn't blind me to the fact that 9/11 CTers are full of bull.


I know, I said sorry. I should have kept that idea to myself. It just seems as though nobody here can say the government does no wrong and every event that occured that appears that way, people are telling me there is no way it could have happened.

It just seems like allot of faith in something that nobody can be 100% sure of.

Thats just my opinion though and I don't mean any harm.
 
1. Was the gulf of tonkin really a lie?
No, it wasn't a lie, but the incident didn't happen either. It was an operator error. (Another point about history: Sometimes small screwups have big effects.)

2. Was this the reason we went to the vietnam war?
The US moved into Vietnam immediately after the French lost in 1954. Escalation began under Kennedy, before the second Tonkin incident, in response to ongoing incursions from the north, to signal to the Soviets that the US would not back down on containment.

It's a very bad idea to trust Wikipedia on anything with political implications.

3. If yes, then wouldnt this be considered a "false flag"?
It wasn't a false flag op because the US ship wasn't flying another country's flag. And it wasn't a covert op either, because it wasn't intentional.

4. If yes, then do you believe "false flags" are real terms for real operations?
Yes, it's a real term. It's in the dictionary. And covert operations are also real, but they're not the driving force of history.
 
Doble seat Double seat gotta get a double seat

Which "real flags" would you accept/allow to happen?

Cuban missile crisis perhaps? ooh. how about sept 11 attacks? hmm let's take it out of the American theatre. Falklands was a false flag to re-elect teh thatch maybe. :popcorn1
 
ok, then I may go upon my life feeling good about my country and not worry about any lies being told or any wars being started for the wrong reasons or any of my right being taken away?

WOOOOHOOOO!!!! :):D:D:D

Honestly, I am not being sarcastic! Thats what I want! It just sounds too good to be true. Hope Im wrong and you guys are right. I really do. I am having a daughter soon and I think that has been the driving reason I have been scared and trying to learn if any of these "rumors" are true. I would have to move to Canada or something until the NAU!! ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom