General questions from a new member...

All I can say to that is: Some people like making up stuff to fool other people and/or make themselves look important. Take it all with a mountain of salt.

I agree! And I do try to take everything with a grain of salt.

But, what would Howard Hunt have to gain by leaving audio tapes of confessions to his son to only be heard after his death?

Also, why would Tony Gambino care about more attention? He also said Hoffa's body is in the George washington bridge and gave pretty chilling details. I think he knows more than your average cookie.

So, is there no "conspiracy" that you guys believe in?!? :boggled:
 
Thanks for the links. I WILL read them. Maybe just not this minute. Im having fun talking.
 
Hi Lee5. Welcome to the forum!

If I may offer a bit of introductory advice, it's this: don't base any of your conclusions about 9/11 on anything written by someone who has gone on record as saying 9/11 was an inside job. Because it's all utter crap, every last word of it. And no, that's not a generalization. All such materials are full of mistakes, unsupported conjectures, bad science, wild accusations, and similar nonsense. Not one contains even a single claim that hasn't been shot to pieces by people who actually know what they're talking about. So if you do come across such content, you would be well served to find out whether or not it has been debunked (which is usually the case) and by whom.

I think a lot of people who become interested in the 9/11 movement do so because they come across something written by a troofer. And because the author writes with such seeming confidence, they mistakenly believe the writer must be informed on the subject. I hope you don't make the same mistake, because at best you'll be highly embarassed when you realize your error in a few months, and at worst you'll waste a significant chunk of your life fighting imaginary enemies.
 
That the wealthy have more pull with government due to their ability to contribute to elections is not all that shocking; what many forget is that much of what the wealthy want is to be left alone. That is, they are not so concerned with having the government help them with X as they are trying to prevent the government from screwing them over with Y.

The movie's thoroughly nutter; the notion that the Rothschilds have anything like 500 trillion in "wealth" is absurd; that's something like 1000 times Bill Gates' net worth. This is typical conspiracy theory stuff; none of the CTs seem to have any conception of what the numbers they throw around really mean.

Big family fortunes typically dwindle as they are distributed to many heirs; David Rockefeller, grandson of John D. is only #149 on the Forbes 400 list; no other Rockefeller is on the list. Fortunes also rise and fall; in the past 25 years only 23 people have managed to be listed in the top 400 every single year.

Good points.

So, how far has the government gone to "help" these people in your opinion? How far is the government willing to go for these Bankers?

Also, do you believe the federal reserve being owned by bankers is a good thing?

Do you think they are responsible for the depression by sending out false stock claims to only then buy up the market?
 
I agree! And I do try to take everything with a grain of salt.

But, what would Howard Hunt have to gain by leaving audio tapes of confessions to his son to only be heard after his death?

Also, why would Tony Gambino care about more attention? He also said Hoffa's body is in the George washington bridge and gave pretty chilling details. I think he knows more than your average cookie.

So, is there no "conspiracy" that you guys believe in?!? :boggled:

Of course I can't speak for everyone here, but there seems to be a fair consensus that Nixon conspired to cover up his involvement in the Watergate break-in.

Also I think most will concede that hotdog manufacturers are in cahoots with the bread companies to make people buy more than they need.

I also happen to believe that the Howard Government here in Australia conspired with a shipping company to sack hundreds of dock workers. Oh and the AWB paid bribes to Saddam Hussein.

Apart from that, not too much.

Got any evidence? Let's take a look...
 
Hi Lee5, what are these questions re 9/11 that you have? Could you perhaps list some, numbered, in question format so we can easily provide answers (where applicable).

For example, instead of saying "like the whole funding thing"

Something like "Is there any credibility to the claim that the Pakistani ISI paid $100,000 to Mohammed Atta?"

It would really avoid us all wasting each other's time.

-Gumboot
 
It's been six years since 9/11 and you're still JAQing off? Pick a side, already.

Steve, the guy seems pretty honest and sincere here.

In fact, he mentioned that one of the reasons he was a little apprehensive was because of exactly that kind of reply you posted.

lee5, read the Bugliosi book as far as JFK is concerned. It is the definitive, slam dunk debunking of any conspiracy. The evidence is irrefutable.

And, welcome to the board. Keep reading and researching. Some of us can be pretty sarcastic and rude but mostly that's because it's a "been there, done that" kind of mentality.
 
Hi Lee5. Welcome to the forum!

If I may offer a bit of introductory advice, it's this: don't base any of your conclusions about 9/11 on anything written by someone who has gone on record as saying 9/11 was an inside job. Because it's all utter crap, every last word of it. And no, that's not a generalization. All such materials are full of mistakes, unsupported conjectures, bad science, wild accusations, and similar nonsense. Not one contains even a single claim that hasn't been shot to pieces by people who actually know what they're talking about. So if you do come across such content, you would be well served to find out whether or not it has been debunked (which is usually the case) and by whom.

I think a lot of people who become interested in the 9/11 movement do so because they come across something written by a troofer. And because the author writes with such seeming confidence, they mistakenly believe the writer must be informed on the subject. I hope you don't make the same mistake, because at best you'll be highly embarassed when you realize your error in a few months, and at worst you'll waste a significant chunk of your life fighting imaginary enemies.


Thanks for your advice. And, that is my fear, that I will have gonnen sucked into something stupid and have wasted time to only come to the conclusion that our government is good.

But, I am not a sucker. I never have been before at least so I am going to trust my gut on this one and say the government is not great and they have done some bad things. I have a hard time believing that wars happen because we did nothing wrong and it is the rest of the world that is evil.

I have a feeling that things happen for money and power instead for the good of mankind.

I don't have blind faith in my government as most of you do (it seems).

But thanks for being repectfull. I hope I am doing ok and respecting you guys.
 
You are trying really hard to put me into some kind of catagory.

No. You put yourself into that category by your own words. Reread my above post.



This is what I mean about generalizing people.


*ding*ding*ding* I win Randi's million! Woohoo!

Im not trying to be rude but I don't want to you generalize me with anybody else.

Then stop adopting the same rhetorical devices that the troofers use.

Like I said in my first post, it's reality vs. fantasy. If you're still fence sitting after six years it's time to take a long look in the mirror.

Steve S.
 
Last edited:
Hi Lee5, what are these questions re 9/11 that you have? Could you perhaps list some, numbered, in question format so we can easily provide answers (where applicable).

For example, instead of saying "like the whole funding thing"

Something like "Is there any credibility to the claim that the Pakistani ISI paid $100,000 to Mohammed Atta?"

It would really avoid us all wasting each other's time.

-Gumboot

Hey Gumboot!

your are one of the members here that I respect the most! I definetly don't want to waste your time with stupid questions.

I am fairly new to this stuff. The other guy said I need to pick a side because its been 6 years but it has only been one year for me because I never paid attention until then.

I will just start off with a couple questions.... (I am at work and might disapear from time to time)

1. Do you think Ptec had any involvment with the organisation of 9/11 in any way?
2. If so, do you think there are any American ties with Ptec that are "shady"?
3. Do you think the ISI had anything to do with aiding the "terrorist" in 9/11?
4. Do you think there is any relation between the ISI and the CIA? If not, was there ever?

ok, I have to work for a bit guys. I will be back!
 
Zero points for creativity, zero points for believability, zero points for ingenuity.

Try being less obvious next time, Lee5.
 
I don't have blind faith in my government as most of you do (it seems).
Wait a sec...you don't want anyone here to put you in a catagory by generalizing you so you find it ok to generalize the people here. You don't see that as a bit ironic?
 
1. Do you think Ptec had any involvment with the organisation of 9/11 in any way?

No. The US Government has investigated Ptech and found that they had not incorporated any malicious software into US computer systems. In addition I cannot see any way in which Ptech would have helped, even if the software had been suspect. There's no indication that any of the US Government's computer systems operated abnormally in any way relating to 9/11.


2. If so, do you think there are any American ties with Ptec that are "shady"?

I don't think American ties with Ptech are shady, but I find Ptech's ties with Islamic Terrorists to be extremely "shady". So too did the US Government, hence their investigation.


3. Do you think the ISI had anything to do with aiding the "terrorist" in 9/11?

Regarding the attacks specifically, no. However I think it's more than likely the ISI has had involvement in supporting Al Qaeda training camps prior to 9/11, and in supporting Al Qaeda members after the invasion of Afghanistan. To what extent this support was "official" as opposed to individual members of the ISI with divided loyalties, I have no idea.


4. Do you think there is any relation between the ISI and the CIA? If not, was there ever?

Certainly there's a relationship. The CIA and ISI are both intelligence agencies, and the USA and Pakistan are allies, if sometimes reluctant ones. The intelligence agencies of allied nations routinely share intelligence, training and so forth. Additional the CIA and ISI were jointly involved in operations together regarding the Soviet-Afghanistan War. However I don't believe for a second that the CIA has any sort of control or even significant influence over the CIA, or vice-versa, and I do not for a second believe that either agency is fully aware of the activities of the other.

I hope that helps.

-Gumboot
 
No. You put yourself into that category by your own words. Reread my above post.






*ding*ding*ding* I win Randi's million! Woohoo!



Then stop adopting the same rhetorical devices that the troofers use.

Like I said in my first post, it's reality vs. fantasy. If you're still fence sitting after six years it's time to take a long look in the mirror.

Steve S.


I am sorry sir. We don't agree on the idea that somebody can be "undecided" or believe in some things but not others.

You want me to pick a side but by doing so, that would mean I automaticly agree with all the views of the one side. I don't, so it wouldn't make sense for me to cliam so. It also wouldn't be very smart considering how quick you guys are to label somebody a "truther" and completly discredit them.

I hope we can skip this subject because it won't go anywhere. :)
 
You mean mark of insanity ala 8bitmoron at LCF.

Well, I suppose. I mean whoever it was that coined the term "mark of woo" to mean someone who comes here claiming to be "new" and "skeptical" only to start viciously arguing for conspiracies against the evil "debunkers" after a few posts.

ETA: I believe it was T.A.M. that coined it.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by lee5 View Post
I don't have blind faith in my government as most of you do (it seems).

Wait a sec...you don't want anyone here to put you in a catagory by generalizing you so you find it ok to generalize the people here. You don't see that as a bit ironic?


Ditto and amen.

Steve S.
 
No. The US Government has investigated Ptech and found that they had not incorporated any malicious software into US computer systems. In addition I cannot see any way in which Ptech would have helped, even if the software had been suspect. There's no indication that any of the US Government's computer systems operated abnormally in any way relating to 9/11.




I don't think American ties with Ptech are shady, but I find Ptech's ties with Islamic Terrorists to be extremely "shady". So too did the US Government, hence their investigation.




Regarding the attacks specifically, no. However I think it's more than likely the ISI has had involvement in supporting Al Qaeda training camps prior to 9/11, and in supporting Al Qaeda members after the invasion of Afghanistan. To what extent this support was "official" as opposed to individual members of the ISI with divided loyalties, I have no idea.




Certainly there's a relationship. The CIA and ISI are both intelligence agencies, and the USA and Pakistan are allies, if sometimes reluctant ones. The intelligence agencies of allied nations routinely share intelligence, training and so forth. Additional the CIA and ISI were jointly involved in operations together regarding the Soviet-Afghanistan War. However I don't believe for a second that the CIA has any sort of control or even significant influence over the CIA, or vice-versa, and I do not for a second believe that either agency is fully aware of the activities of the other.

I hope that helps.

-Gumboot


Thanks Gumboot those were great answers.

So, pretty much, at best we are guilty of just creating "monsters"?

Blowback if you will?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom