Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's his actual quote:



Aside from the usual opportunistic piling on, what exactly is wrong with that statement?

Le Fraude has already backtracked:

“I will not allow my commitment to Israel to be questioned by anyone, particularly for partisan, political purposes,” Kerry said in a release put out by the State Department. “… If I could rewind the tape, I would have chosen a different word to describe my firm belief that the only way in the long term to have a Jewish state and two nations and two peoples living side by side in peace and security is through a two state solution.”

But of course nobody really questions whether there will be a two-state solution, because it would be absurd to posit a single state. And by the way, can you name the only nation in the Middle East that allows Muslims to vote?
 
I'd agree with John Kerry up to a point. Isreal being a specifically Jewish state is the alpha and the omega of the problem, actually. That in itself is a politically disgusting idea in the modern world. Politics and religion (or ethnic background, if that's your take on it) quite simply don't mix when you have a non-homogeneous population (which means pretty much everywhere). Governance should be above such questions.

Of course, Mr. Kerry didn't dare tell the whole truth... and may not have seen it in precisely that way. I'd say his comment was quite mild.

I don't hate Israel... I just don't think they're doing it right.
 
Last edited:
I'd agree with John Kerry up to a point. Isreal being a specifically Jewish state is the alpha and the omega of the problem, actually. That in itself is a politically disgusting idea in the modern world. Politics and religion (or ethnic preference, if that's your take on it) quite simply don't mix when you have a non-homogeneous population (which means pretty much everywhere).

Of course, Mr. Kerry didn't dare tell the whole truth... and may not have seen it in precisely that way. I'd say his comment was quite mild.

Well, what you say may be totally true, but I have it on good authority that Saudi Arabia and Qatar are worse, so don't criticize.

Daredelvis.
 
And by the way, can you name the only nation in the Middle East that allows Muslims to vote?

Depends on how you draw the Middle East but....

Turkey ?
Syria ?
Lebanon ?
Jordan ?
Iraq ?
Iran ?
Israel ?
Egypt ?

Or are you referring to voting for a specific role ? As a constitutional monarchy, Jordanians cannot vote for their head of state but they can vote for their government.
 
I'd agree with John Kerry up to a point. Isreal being a specifically Jewish state is the alpha and the omega of the problem, actually. That in itself is a politically disgusting idea in the modern world. Politics and religion (or ethnic background, if that's your take on it) quite simply don't mix when you have a non-homogeneous population (which means pretty much everywhere). Governance should be above such questions.

Of course, Mr. Kerry didn't dare tell the whole truth... and may not have seen it in precisely that way. I'd say his comment was quite mild.

I don't hate Israel... I just don't think they're doing it right.

I agree, to some degree. The unmitigated ethno-religious jingoism of Israel is a bit disturbing for a modern "Western" state; on the other hand, given how they are targeted and portrayed by many their adversaries, it isn't that strange either.
 
Le Fraude has already backtracked:



But of course nobody really questions whether there will be a two-state solution, because it would be absurd to posit a single state.

I don't know if "nobody" is correct. From what I understand, Hamas, Hizbullah and Likud at least characterize their positions as if to make a two-state outcome untenable. From what I understand, the two-state solution is the argument that was made by the Brookings Institute. Yet while most people agree in public, almost anyone who genuinely tries to make it work will be in trouble.

And by the way, can you name the only nation in the Middle East that allows Muslims to vote?

There's not "only" one. There are a number of nations that allow voting in the Middle East.
 
http://www.jewishpress.com/news/bre...-blast-kerry-for-apartheid-remark/2014/04/29/

"Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.), who is Jewish and who has strongly defended the Obama administration’s Israel record, also slammed the remarks on Twitter. “Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East and any linkage between Israel and apartheid is nonsensical and ridiculous,” she said."


Silly Democrat, doesn't she know it was all made up? (By me apparently).
 
http://www.jewishpress.com/news/bre...-blast-kerry-for-apartheid-remark/2014/04/29/

"Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.), who is Jewish and who has strongly defended the Obama administration’s Israel record, also slammed the remarks on Twitter. “Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East and any linkage between Israel and apartheid is nonsensical and ridiculous,” she said."


Silly Democrat, doesn't she know it was all made up? (By me apparently).

She did the same thing you did, and completely ignored what he actually said, rather than responding to what he did say.
 
This does look like a very cheap shot at Kerry (he deserves better criticism).

“A two-state solution will be clearly underscored as the only real alternative. Because a unitary state winds up either being an apartheid state with second-class citizens — or it ends up being a state that destroys the capacity of Israel to be a Jewish state,”

I disagree with his position, but it's no more stupid than other US policy.

Why can't Israel push religion to the back-burner like other advance nations and integrate their population ? The church of England and church of Sweden are official state religions, but largely ignorable.

Jefferson saw first hand now non-Anglicans were excluded from power in Virginia and invented the areligious state to cure this problem. Why are we now trying to help enforce a religious state or else separation on others ? It defies our principles as a nation. Would the US send arms if half the Vatican population decided to turn pagan ? What exactly is the US national interest here ?


Depends on how you draw the Middle East but....

Turkey ?
Syria ?
Lebanon ?
Jordan ?
Iraq ?
Iran ?
Israel ?
Egypt ?

Or are you referring to voting for a specific role ? As a constitutional monarchy, Jordanians cannot vote for their head of state but they can vote for their government.

Lebanon, Syria, Yemen (at least for the moment), Iraq, Iran seem to make the cut. Most of the others are constitutional monarchies w/ varying amount of monarchic power; they can vote but can't be considered democracies since the ppl don't choose that branch of government - directly or indirectly.

Egypt isn't considered ME, and it's currently in chaos. Turkey is certainly a fairly stable and fairly liberal democracy, but not ME either.

I don't understand stand where this "Israel ... only democracy in the M.E." thing comes from.
 
Egypt isn't considered ME, and it's currently in chaos. Turkey is certainly a fairly stable and fairly liberal democracy, but not ME either.

I don't understand stand where this "Israel ... only democracy in the M.E." thing comes from.

According to Wiki, both Turkey and Egypt are considered part of the Middle East and one or both feature on most of the maps of the region I have seen.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East

Wikipedia said:
Traditional definition of the Middle East

The following countries are included within the Middle East, which is corresponding to Western Asia, excluding the Caucasus:

Bahrain
Cyprus
Egypt
Iran
Iraq
Israel
Jordan
Kuwait
Lebanon
Northern Cyprus
Oman
Palestine
Qatar
Saudi Arabia
Syria
Turkey
United Arab Emirates
Yemen

Whether or not Egypt is stable, Muslims are still allowed to vote there :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom