Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Define "started". There where hostilies from both sides, a tit for tat. But from an objective viewpoint the conflict started 1897 in Basel when the first Zionist Congress decided,"...to establish a home for the Jewish people in Palestine…", without asking the indigenous population, one might ad.
You seem to be forgetting that they were the indigenous population. Jewish history in Palestine stretches back thousands of years, in case you did not know.

Here, you are inserting a new factor in the discussion, military logic. Well, all kinds of violations can be made by refering to "defense capabilities", "security" and the like. If you start down that path...
Yes, all kinds of violations can be justified by this reasoning, but we're not talking about "all kinds of violations", we're talking about a specific instance. Got anything to say regarding that?

I'm not sure what you mean here. Of course they had every right to dispute it. Why should the indigenous Palestinian population feel that they had a moral obligation to sacrifice their land to compensate for the crimes commited against jews by the Europeans?
...what:confused:?

I'm not complaining. The Jews won. There won't be a Palestine.
You keep saying this, but repeating a statement over and over does not make it true.

I think that in 20 years, there will be a one-state solution. Israel isn't capable of leaving the WB.
Likewise.
 
Third, likewise, it isn't hard to see why the Palestinians didn't accept the plan. They considered Palestine their homeland, and were expecting the british to fullfill their promises. Why would they accept it? If someone were to take over your home, then offering you a few rooms in a "fair compromise" you might not be overwhelmed by his generosity, even if he were homeless, destitute, and persecuted.
You mean if they used to live in my house, but had since been forcibly driven out, basically thrown on the street to live at the mercy of all kinds of abuse and even murder attempts? What if it was a family and they had just had several of their family members killed?

Damned right I would let them stay. Heck, I would be tempted to give the them whole house. Also remember, the Arabs in Palestine were exactly that -- Arabs. The idea of "Palestinians" as anything more than the residents of the geographical area Palestine is a fairly new one, fuelled in part by organized propaganda efforts.

If you look at a map with this in mind, it becomes clear that the Arabs haven't exactly sacrificed that much land to give the Jews a safe haven ;) .
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_the_Arab-Israeli_conflict-blank.svg
 
If you look at a map with this in mind, it becomes clear that the Arabs haven't exactly sacrificed that much land to give the Jews a safe haven ;) .
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_the_Arab-Israeli_conflict-blank.svg

So...you don't deny that the Arabs have had their land stolen, you just argue that the Arabs "...haven't exactly sacrificed much"?

How much more sacrifice....how much more stolen land....do you think is right?

And all this happens while Israel is sucking on the American teat to the tune of Billions per year with the largest Washington lobbying effort in history.

Tell us...when will Israel stop stealing?
 
Not that I accept the land stealing bit, it's more complicated than that, but let's pretend...

Tell us...when will Israel stop stealing?

When the Palestinians acknowledge Israel's right to exist and engage in serious peace talks. Could have happened anytime in the last 50 years or so. Maybe you could let them know.

But without the hate and the conflict the leaders lose most of their power over the people and the leaders have usually done pretty well for themselves.
Wikipedia said:
Arafat remains a highly controversial figure whose legacy has been widely disputed. The majority of the Palestinian people—regardless of political ideology or faction—viewed him as a heroic freedom fighter and martyr who symbolized the national aspirations of his people, while many Israelis have described him as an unrepentant terrorist.[4][5] Critics have accused Arafat of mass corruption, secretly amassing a personal wealth estimated to be USD $1.3 billion by 2002 despite the degrading economic conditions of the Palestinians.[6]


I know anything but Israel has been declared irrelevant but I find it so ironic how concerned you are with the effect on America of Israel's land stealing, when if ever there was a country that was stolen from it's indigenous people it is the good old USA. And it's not like it is ancient history, it only happened a few hundred years before Israel was established. Would you be OK with native Americans vowing to kill every white man and lobbing rockets into your neighborhood? Or maybe Israel should allow the Palestinians to open a few casinos.
 
So...you don't deny that the Arabs have had their land stolen, you just argue that the Arabs "...haven't exactly sacrificed much"?

How much more sacrifice....how much more stolen land....do you think is right?

And all this happens while Israel is sucking on the American teat to the tune of Billions per year with the largest Washington lobbying effort in history.

Tell us...when will Israel stop stealing?

When you stop beating your wife.
 
During the 1967 War, Israel gained land from Egypt, Jordan, and
Syria. Israel maintained that Jerusalem would remain a unified city,
with all religions having access to their holy sites. But Israel stated it
was open to returning other territories in exchange for peace and
recognition of its right to exist. Arab nations met in Khartoum, Sudan
in 1967, and declared their unwillingness to make peace, recognize,
or even negotiate with Israel. Egypt began small-scale attacks
against Israeli positions which continued until Anwar Sadat came to
power in 1970. During this same period, the PLO attacked Israeli
military personnel and civilians from bases in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria
and Egypt. It also carried out airplane hijackings and terrorist attacks
outside of Israel.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-VnMxWp2ChGk/US4HUzKB86I/AAAAAAAAABY/f4TW1sRWRTM/s1600/expanding_israel.jpg

But they just keep stealing land!!!!11111 :jumps up and down:
 
I know anything but Israel has been declared irrelevant but I find it so ironic how concerned you are with the effect on America of Israel's land stealing, when if ever there was a country that was stolen from it's indigenous people it is the good old USA. And it's not like it is ancient history, it only happened a few hundred years before Israel was established. Would you be OK with native Americans vowing to kill every white man and lobbing rockets into your neighborhood? Or maybe Israel should allow the Palestinians to open a few casinos.
Already pointed this out to him by reminding him that there are no Finnish suicide bombers against Russia, not Tibetan rockets against Chinese schools and houses. Predictably enough, since this didn't fit into the "but, but terrorism is a result of occupation" worldview, they ignored me.
 
Of course. But it also conveys that Israel, far from "continuously stealing land", has in reality made several major concessions that it would never have made had it really been the imperialist state its opponents try to make it out to be. But thanks for the feedback:).
 
Of course. But it also conveys that Israel, far from "continuously stealing land", has in reality made several major concessions that it would never have made had it really been the imperialist state its opponents try to make it out to be. But thanks for the feedback:).

It is absolutely true that Israel is not anywhere close to being the imperialist state its opponents try to make it out to be. On the other hand, it's also true that the land it's given back in the concessions depicted in that graph isn't exactly land that it started out with.
 
It is absolutely true that Israel is not anywhere close to being the imperialist state its opponents try to make it out to be. On the other hand, it's also true that the land it's given back in the concessions depicted in that graph isn't exactly land that it started out with.

Who ever claimed it was?
 
Who ever claimed it was?

The image linked by Safe-Keeper heavily implies it, by going right from a map of all of Mandatory Palestine at the time of the Balfour Declaration (which, despite what was suggested by the caption, was not and was never intended to be the basis for the borders of the future State of Israel), to a map of Israeli territory fifty years later and showing all the subsequent land concessions and withdrawals.

It's the inclusion of the map of the Mandate and the half-century gap between it and the next map which makes the image slighly misleading, giving the impression that Israel started with a huge chunk of land that has gradually been surrendered to its neighbors leaving a only rump state, rather than an initially small state which expanded its borders after a series of wars over several decades but has partially drawn back from the land it occupied.
 
Last edited:
A'isha: I think we all know enough about the conflict to know the map doesn't tell the full story, so I don't judge it "misleading" to post it here. It shows Israeli concessions, nothing more, but then again, that's what I posted it to illustrate.

Childlike Empress: for once I appreciate something you have given us in your hit-and-run postings. Interesting read, thank you very much:).
Now compare Israel's level of security with that in other areas of the world with the same threat level towards its civilian population. Is Israel more heavy-handed, or less?
 
Checkpoints AKA a legitimate response to campaigns of terror. They've saved countless lives.
 
Fascinating interview:

Joshua Frank said:
Journalist Max Blumenthal’s latest book Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel has been one of the most controversial and enlightening books of 2013. It’s a fearless, no holds barred take on life in Israel and the brutal occupation of Palestine. Needless to say, not all have been happy with Blumenthal’s take on Israeli culture and politics. I recently caught up with Max to discuss his new book and the backlash he’s received from the pro-Israel coterie.
 
How is it "fearless"? What is he afraid of, angry Israeli editorials?

Edit: oh. He is.


MB: Once the Zionist freakout began, the sub-mental smears were predictable. As I said, if they could make a positive case for the Jewish state, they would do so. But they can’t. And so they are left with nothing but risible propaganda and McCarthyite tactics. I suppose it was an honor that John Podhoretz, the son of the man who smeared Hannah Arendt for writing Eichmann in Jerusalem, wound up labeling Goliath, “the year’s most disgusting book.”
The horror.
 
Last edited:
Max Blumenthal's book makes top ten list of anti-semitic/anti-Israel slurs:

Blumenthal uses chapter titles in his book Goliath like “Summer Camp of Destruction, ‘Date with the Devil,” “There Is No Dream,” “The Concentration Camp,” and “The Night of Broken Glass, and “How to Kill Goyim and Influence People” to equate Israelis with Nazis. He mentions the Holocaust only to ask: [Is it right] to have the Jewish victims of the Nazis impose their independence day on another people’s tragedy?”

He quotes approvingly characterizations of Israelis soldiers as “Judeo-nazis.” His explanation for the Arab-Israel conflict is “Israeli society’s nationalistic impulses” and Israeli politicians who “outdo one another in a competition for the most convincing exaltation of violence against the Arab evildoers” and who incite “unprovoked violence against the Arab outclass” as well as “indoctrinate Jewish children into the culture of militarism.


Standard "Israelis are Nazis" diatribe that appeals to the hardcore fundamentalist left.


How is it "fearless"? What is he afraid of, angry Israeli editorials?

He's being persecuted for speaking truth to power by doing book tours at multi-million dollar corporate and taxpayer-funded liberal institutions.

I see this a lot on the left. It's not enough to regurgitate trite banalities all day, they have to consider themselves brave and "anti-establishment" for doing it. As though there is some sort of price to be paid for mediocrity.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom