Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah...but the Japanese are not like the Jews. I mean, the Japanese don't go around feeling all sorry for themselves and constantly thinking themselves "Victims" while starting wars. On the other hand, an Israeli could strut around all day kicking Palestinians in the face while shouting "I'm a Victim"!

March of the wooden racists. :rolleyes:
 
Yeah...the Israelis are just a misunderstood people - and that's why the Anti-Semites hate them. I mean, doesn't the world understand that the Israelis have the right to Steal Land and Murder Arabs because Jews have been abused in the past - and because the living Almighty God has given them the RIGHT?

So, when you see some poor Arab Child die from Israeli bombs, don't feel bad - because that Arab Child was just dirt in the eyes of GOD - who really loves the Jews who are a very Special People. And, if you have any doubts, read the Bible where Jews rape, murder and kill children on a regular basis at the bequest of GOD, and be thankful that Israel doesn't (or can't) wage war like this anymore.

And is you don't agree that the Jews are a Special People with a Right to Murder and Steal Land, then you are an Anti-Semite: a really bad person who doesn't like Jews, Stealing and Murder.

Too bad Hamas doesn't care about that "poor Arab Child".

Keep spewing your bigotry though, it's amusing.
 
Too bad Hamas doesn't care about that "poor Arab Child".

Keep spewing your bigotry though, it's amusing.

Yeah...let's hear how Israel is a "Victim" of the Big, Bad Arabs they've been stomping on! Let's see some tears...some pleading for pity...some excuses for Israeli Land Stealing and Killing!
 
I could comment on Jules lack of knowledge of World War 2 in the Pacific, but that is another thread.....

It seems to be fairly incredible, given his choice of who to compare the Japanese to, there. At this point, though, I'd find it more incredible if he wasn't a troll, just given the nature, quality, and relevance of the arguments that he's employing.
 
Also throw in that Japan plays the victim card over Hiroshima while denying being an aggressor in ww2. (Strangely enough, socialists tend to agree)
 
Also throw in that Japan plays the victim card over Hiroshima while denying being an aggressor in ww2. (Strangely enough, socialists tend to agree)

Japan does not deny being an aggressor in World War Two. :rolleyes:

And which "socialists" tend to agree with this made-up thing of yours?

Oddly enough, that does not sell very well in China ......

Oddly enough, playing the victim sells very well. And they seem to have sold it to you too.
 
Japan does not deny being an aggressor in World War Two. :rolleyes:

I take it you haven't been looking at recent Japanese politics (since 2011) as well as the new Japanese textbooks whitewashing the Pacific war (all but calling it a defence against American imperialism while denying the Nanjing massacre happened)

And which "socialists" tend to agree with this made-up thing of yours?

Considering how the "AmeriKKKA bombed 50 countries since WW2" list gets passed around those circles as well as the "abolish nuclear weapons" campaign all but erasing the context behind Hiroshima.

Oddly enough, playing the victim sells very well. And they seem to have sold it to you too.

I take it you think the Nanjing Massacre and Unit 731 were exaggerated
 
Israel had worse relations (particularly during the Reagan years when he sold AWACs to Saudi Arabia over Israel's objections)
 
Japan != "some Japanese people"

It's beside the point anyways. Regardless of what Japan does or does not deny or accept responsibility for in terms of starting and prosecuting the war, the relevant fact for this discussion is that they surrendered and accepted defeat, and did not resort to terrorism. If they had not done so, they would not be a prosperous and wealthy nation today.
 
I've met a number of Japanese people who either denied or tried to explain away their aggression in WWII. It's not that unusual.

Great...send them an invitation to come live in Israel where they can complain about how the world denies the evil done against them in the 20th Century. They can all go around wailing about Hitler and Hiroshima while Stealing Arab Land and Creating a virtual Prison Camp out of the Palestinian Terrirtories.
 

Craig, I'm sure you think this is some sort of "gotcha", although it's hard to say for certain since you put almost nothing of your own commentary in, but to me it only makes you and Donna Nevel seem ignorant of history. Ignorant, or purposefully one-sided.

Prior to 1948 Zionist immigrants purchased land in Palestine. There was no "displacement", what happened is what always happens when immigrants come, the population density increased.

Yes, there were approximately 700 Arabs made refugees by the Israeli war of Independence, the "Nakba", if you prefer. What's said less often is there were also a comparable number of Jewish refugees from that conflict.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3743829,00.html

What's also not said very often is for the last 70 years, the Arab world, including Palestinian leadership, has resisted every effort to normalize or resettle these people. Everything from rejecting Israeli offers to build infrastructure in Palestinian villages (refugee camps), the PLO resisting West Bank land grants with low-cost building materials for Palestinian families, to Arab nations permanently denying citizenship to Palestinians, no matter how many generations they have been living there.

One could argue that Israel was wrong 70 years ago for not allowing those refugees to return, but what's happened to them since, being made to be pawns by people who only see them as a tool to deny Israel peace, that part is not on Israel.
 
The descendents of the Paliestinians who were removed in 1948 returning to pre 1967 Israel is about as practical as the desdendents of the Germans who were expelled from East Prussia in 1945-46 returning. Just ain't gonna happen.
And I continue to note the dodge of what the advocates of the return would do with the 5 million Jews living in Israel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom