Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The more I think about, the more I think the "Buy out 5 Milliion Isrealis" idea is incredibly insane that only the crazy and the absoutley over the top political fanatics would buy it.
 
And I am pretty sure I said rules and documents. There are a number of them - generally the newer take precedence over the older.

Also, so you know (point of logic.....) Iff any rules of war came to be used to protect actual troops from any assault due to the presence of civilians (what hamass and related try to push and imply) they would get thrown out so fast it would make the UN's head spin off (not a difficult task, I fear.) - I actually am curious if you know or at least can guess why...........
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, since there have been so many attempts to claim that "Israel is a horrible monster that should be destroyed," with rather questionable arguments, I think that it may be worth remembering that Hamas slaughters Palestinians freely. Frankly, whatever valid legal claims the Palestinians may or may not have, morally speaking, there's no equivalence between Hamas and Israel, and the "unity government" of the Palestinians is dramatically less credible and worth dealing with if it's willing to include Hamas.

Oh, and separately, here is a bit of a map to keep the damage in perspective a bit. It's really not pretty, but it doesn't look like it remotely qualifies as supporting evidence for a number of the accusations leveled at Israel by people like CE.

or the UN or most of Europe and Asia and goodly number in the US - and, you are quite correct, it does not - but, then, if the haters have to accept that but still want to blame Israel, they have tacitly admitted that they hate Jews rather than semites and support terrorists. Which they are trying to pretend is not the truth.
 
A Jew hating schlock website claims an unnamed, unidentified Jewish holocaust survivor wants Israel wiped off the map, and an anti-Semitic truther agrees.

Shocking.

At first, I though somebody was doing a sarcastic piece of satire, a la Jonathan Swift;s "A Modest Proposal" but then it dawned on me the writer was serious.

The comments after the article show me what kind of website that was. A good portion of the posts would have been out of place in the letters to the editor section of "Der Sturmer".
 
Another drive-by link posting from CE. Can't actually make an argument yourself, can you? And Marjorie Cohn seems to have made a career out of calling everyone she doesn't like a war criminal. It's almost comic in its quixoticness.

But I am curious: how can someone be guilty of genocide in a case where genocide doesn't actually occur?

And, last I checked, genocide is against a different race. Palestinians - even the hamass slime are semitic/Semites. Jews are semitic/Semites (unless they converted.
 
At first, I though somebody was doing a sarcastic piece of satire, a la Jonathan Swift;s "A Modest Proposal" but then it dawned on me the writer was serious.

The comments after the article show me what kind of website that was. A good portion of the posts would not have been out of place in the letters to the editor section of "Der Sturmer".

I am real certain you mean the FTFY
 
Another drive-by link posting from CE. Can't actually make an argument yourself, can you? And Marjorie Cohn seems to have made a career out of calling everyone she doesn't like a war criminal. It's almost comic in its quixoticness.

But I am curious: how can someone be guilty of genocide in a case where genocide doesn't actually occur?

Judging by Cohn's gleeful defense of Milošević's torture camps and Assad's scorched earth policy, I'd say her crocodile tears have more to do with political expediency than any actual concern for Palestinian suffering. She scores approximately zero on the credibility scale.
 
It is pretty annoying when people tell right actions from wrong ones by asking who commits them. "Let's see, 300 baby seals clubbed to death... by a group that hates Israelis. Hmm, guess that's fine, then".
 
And, last I checked, genocide is against a different race. Palestinians - even the hamass slime are semitic/Semites. Jews are semitic/Semites (unless they converted.

Genocide is not limited to race. Religion and ethnicity, for example, are some of the other qualifying categories. Nor is there any restriction or reasonable reason to add the restriction that it must be committed by "outsiders." For the record, there are a couple arguments that, if true, might potentially qualify Israel as committing genocide in a very weak way. If it is true that Israel was limiting the food supply into Gaza to close to the bare minimum for people to survive, for example, that might be able to qualify under "imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;" if the answers to multiple questions of intent were determined on investigation to be the ones needed for it to actually be genocide. With that said, the relevant point to Ziggurat's statement, however, is that while numerous Palestinians have died in the recent military conflict, that alone is not proper grounds for an accusation of genocide. For that matter, when the rest of the evidence is taken into account, the recent conflict shows no reasonable signs of genocide having actually occurred. Many unfortunate deaths, some of which may even qualify as resulting from war crimes, certainly, genocide, no.
 
Last edited:
For the record, there are a couple arguments that, if true, might potentially qualify Israel as committing genocide in a very weak way.
Translation: what's going on in Gaza is not a genocide. Glad we got that cleared up.
 
Translation: what's going on in Gaza is not a genocide. Glad we got that cleared up.

That was cleared up many, many pages of this thread ago. The main point of the post in question was to clarify what genocide actually is, again, and give relevant examples of what the term could validly be used for and where it still does not apply.
 
Meanwhile, in the Land of the Free:

Hollywood Studios Blacklist Penelope Cruz over Gaza Letter Accusing Israel of 'Genocide'


2638953eb2fc4127f2.jpg
 
Last edited:
If Israel were committing genocide, how come they've killed far less people than ISIS in a longer span of time?

Oh Wait, ISIS are global resistance against Capitalist Neoliberal Imperialism. :rolleyes:
 

Wow. You're really getting desperate. Not only do most people not care about the opinions of rich Hollywood celebrities detached from reality, but your own link undermines its own headline. In other words, they're making **** up as link bait. They've got ONE unnamed producer saying he will refuse to work with them. Wow, what a blacklist. And the only producer they got on record contradicts the entire notion:
"However, Kavanaugh doesn't believe the letter will harm either of the actors' careers as long as their films are box office hits."
Oh, the oppression! :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom