Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope. Israel attacked first. Israel used some kidnappings as an excuse to wrongfully crack-down on Hamas and it backfired. The whole world saw it. Israel started the war. Israel killed 2000+ people. Israel was wrong.

Where have YOUR morals gone?

You do realize that your "butbutISRAEL!" fails in light of the fact that Hamas specifically targetted civilians and noncombatants unrelated to Operation Brother's Keeper and nowhere near military targets while pointedly putting their military assets in the middle of what would otherwise be noncombatants?
 
You do realize that your "butbutISRAEL!" fails in light of the fact that Hamas specifically targetted civilians and noncombatants unrelated to Operation Brother's Keeper and nowhere near military targets while pointedly putting their military assets in the middle of what would otherwise be noncombatants?

Maybe if the Pals got $3 Billion/Year in US Military Aid (like Israel does) so they could stop Israel from bombing them, then they could build some nice Military Bases away from civilian areas.

That would be fair, wouldn't it?

Silly questions. Silly answers.
 
Maybe if the Pals got $3 Billion/Year in US Military Aid (like Israel does) so they could stop Israel from bombing them, then they could build some nice Military Bases away from civilian areas.

That would be fair, wouldn't it?

Silly questions. Silly answers.

Riiight. As if "fair" had any meaning when used like that. As it is, the US has given and been giving the Palestinians quite a bit of financial aid, in addition to numerous other things. Far more than any other single country, at last check. Why would the US officials directly give military aid, though, when chances are extremely high that it would end up in the hands of those who are officially terrorists who want to destroy one of the US' allies? Furthermore, why would Hamas build military bases away from civilian areas when using civilian and noncombatant involvement as a deterrent is one of their main defensive strategies, if not the only main defensive strategy?

Regardless, your poor attempt to dodge is noted. Operation Brother's Keeper could be used to justify a number of responses, potentially including military force, sure. However, it does not, in any way, justify actions which are indisputably war crimes and Hamas' declarations have made it quite clear that quite a few of their actions are exactly that. Perhaps you might recall where and what, exactly, those rockets are intended to hit?
 
Last edited:
Maybe if the Pals got $3 Billion/Year in US Military Aid (like Israel does) so they could stop Israel from bombing them, then they could build some nice Military Bases away from civilian areas.

That would be fair, wouldn't it?

Silly questions. Silly answers.

Say, where does that $3 B / year rank amid all USG aid, and what is it composed of? What is the historical trend in the amount per year? Do you have some context for that number?
 
So, it looks like even Israel has abandoned the two-state solution? So what's the solution then? I guess nothing? If the West Bank doesn't have a future of independence to look towards, they may likely be radicalized again.

Where do you get that from?
 
Zionists have NEVER taken a two state solution seriously. It was always their aim to take the entirety of Palestine if not more.

See, the thing about "Zionists" is that they're people, just like you and I. There is no Zionist hive-mind so that you can point to something one person said and use it as evidence of someone else's intentions 50 years later. It just doesn't work that way, even with Jews.

"Zionism" was a political movement to establish a Jewish homeland on/around Jerusalem, and among the zionists of that time there were wildly differing opinions on the best methods to accomplish that and what it should look like when completed. Modern Zionism would basically be anything and anyone who supported the continued existence of Israel. This is a very large umbrella that covers a huge variety of thought and action, with much disagreement among the participants.

I think a huge problem with "anti-Zionists" is they seem to want to present Zionism as this huge monolithic entity, with all the individual Zionists psychically linked somehow, so that something Ben-Gurion said back in 1937 is somehow proof of what millions of people today think. It's nonsense, of course, but I guess to some people it seems a little more plausible if you say it about "Zionists" and not people.
 
Operation Brother's Keeper could be used to justify a number of responses, potentially including military force, sure. However, it does not, in any way, justify actions which are indisputably war crimes...

Blah, blah, blah. Yeah...the world has seen some War Crimes alright - a lot of cold-blooded Israeli Murder. But...that's what the Israelis wanted. The Israelis were spoiling for war and doing everything they could to obstruct peace. Netenyahu and the Israeli Government politicized a kidnapping by a couple of Palestinian idiots and used it as an excuse for a war.

Well...Israel got its war alright, and they kicked arse. But...they lost BIG TIME on the World Stage of Public Opinion and they know it. They know that people all over the world saw the carnage they were committing for no damned reason other than to Obstruct Peace and Steal Land - and they are beginning to talk about it and keep talking about it. And no matter how many times Israel and its toadies scream "Anti-Semite" and "Jew Hater", people aren't going to quit talking...not this time. Get used to it.
 
Blah, blah, blah. Yeah...the world has seen some War Crimes alright - a lot of cold-blooded Israeli Murder. But...that's what the Israelis wanted.

Cold blooded murderers rarely set up hospitals to treat those they're trying to murder.

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/183104#.U--NqvldXIV

The Israelis were spoiling for war and doing everything they could to obstruct peace. Netenyahu and the Israeli Government politicized a kidnapping by a couple of Palestinian idiots and used it as an excuse for a war.

And what were those tunnels and 30,000 stockpiled rockets for?

Well...Israel got its war alright, and they kicked arse. But...they lost BIG TIME on the World Stage of Public Opinion and they know it. They know that people all over the world saw the carnage they were committing for no damned reason other than to Obstruct Peace and Steal Land -

Oh yeah? How much land did Israel get this time?


...and they are beginning to talk about it and keep talking about it. And no matter how many times Israel and its toadies scream "Anti-Semite" and "Jew Hater", people aren't going to quit talking...not this time. Get used to it.

I'm gonna step out on a limb here and suggest you might have problems in that area even if there were no Israeli/Arab conflict.
 
Blah, blah, blah. Yeah...the world has seen some War Crimes alright - a lot of cold-blooded Israeli Murder. But...that's what the Israelis wanted. The Israelis were spoiling for war and doing everything they could to obstruct peace. Netenyahu and the Israeli Government politicized a kidnapping by a couple of Palestinian idiots and used it as an excuse for a war.

Well...Israel got its war alright, and they kicked arse. But...they lost BIG TIME on the World Stage of Public Opinion and they know it. They know that people all over the world saw the carnage they were committing for no damned reason other than to Obstruct Peace and Steal Land - and they are beginning to talk about it and keep talking about it. And no matter how many times Israel and its toadies scream "Anti-Semite" and "Jew Hater", people aren't going to quit talking...not this time. Get used to it.

So, in short, you're quite unable to defend your claims or dispute the counterarguments, again, and try to dance to yet another set of claims that frankly, don't hold anywhere close to as much water as you seem to wish they did. As it happens, just about all your "facts" don't even remotely match reality, yet again. I'm tired, though, so I'm not going to dissect your post right now.
 
Cold blooded murderers rarely set up hospitals to treat those they're trying to murder.

Yeah...blow them in half and then give them a Band-aide.


And what were those tunnels and 30,000 stockpiled rockets for?

I don't know. Maybe to defend themselves against all those Israeli Tanks, Fighter Jets and Killer Helicopters that kill thousands of Palestinians?
 
Yeah... Israel is carrying out a "genocide" in Gaza, which is why they've got field hospitals to treat wounded Palestinians.

They've got an "Apartheid" regime, except there are lots of Arabs living in Israel.

They're "starving" Gaza, except from the fact that Gaza receives more aid per capita than possibly anyone else in the world; much of it from Israel.

They want to take Palestine's land, except they aren't, and just gave Gaza back to the Palestinians.

The devil is in the details...
 
Yeah and rockets too! Because everyone knows launching missiles at innocent civilians is a good defense against "Tanks, Fighter Jets and Killer Helicopters".

Next, Jules will be defending Osama Bin Laden.
Missiles which also frequently malfunction and kill Palestinian civilians. But hey, don't condemn them, they're Just Defending Themselves:rolleyes:.
 
Cold blooded murderers rarely set up hospitals to treat those they're trying to murder.


Yes, they do. It's called PR, aka cold-blooded propaganda.

Similarly, warning civilians that you about to bomb their homes doesn't make bombing their homes any less of a war crime.
 
Last edited:
Well...it appears that Israel has lost another war: the second in 10 years. The first loss against Hezbollah shattered the Arab Myth of the Israeli Military Bogeyman and the second war against Hamas put Israel's naked aggression on stage for the world to see. As a result, Israel has lost credibility - a lot of credibility.

Of course, I do not expect that Israel will stop seeking to Militarily destroy the Palestinians...no, they will keep attacking Palestine until the thought of killing more Arabs becomes futile even to Israel's Hard-Zionist Right - and they are forced to seek a path of peace. Of course, this is going to take a long time and a lot of Israeli Murder, but it will happen. And, by the time it does, support for Israel's War Machine will have all but dried up.

Sooner or later, the US and Europe are going to become tired of supporting Israel's War Machine and they are going to start pulling the plug. But Israel need not worry for now - they got a lot of killing still left to do before that happens. But it is inevitable.

If you ever wanted to look at a time in History and say, "Look...there's a Milestone of Note", then this time is it. It is the first time when Israeli Military defeats have become a rule and not an exception. It is the time where the more Israel murders the Palestinians, the worst things get for Israel.

Militarily, Israel is in a "No Win" scenario. It is time for Israel to grow up and recognize that they are not going to accomplish anything more through dealing-out death. It is time for them to truly seek peace. Actions speak louder than words.
 
Last edited:
Yeah... Israel is carrying out a "genocide" in Gaza, which is why they've got field hospitals to treat wounded Palestinians.

They've got an "Apartheid" regime, except there are lots of Arabs living in Israel.

They're "starving" Gaza, except from the fact that Gaza receives more aid per capita than possibly anyone else in the world; much of it from Israel.

They want to take Palestine's land, except they aren't, and just gave Gaza back to the Palestinians.

The devil is in the details...

Incidentally, each of the points raised here, except perhaps the land one, is quite insufficient on its own to counter the accusation in question.
 
Similarly, warning civilians that you about to bomb their homes doesn't make bombing their homes any less of a war crime.

True, if it actually qualifies as a war crime in the first place under the circumstances in question. If there's acceptable reason to believe that the civilian's home contains a military target, for example, bombing the civilian's home does not qualify as a war crime. Given Hamas' tactic of putting and using military targets in and around civilian structures, you really should be going much harder on them for giving the Israeli forces easy justification to do so. If they did not do so, Israel would either 1) not hit civilian structures or 2) be without defense for their actions. It'd be a win-win scenario for everyone, frankly, except for the terrorists and the people who want Palestinian civilians to suffer and die.

Well...it appears that Israel has lost another war: the second in 10 years.

Ignoring the rest of the foolishness, what's your evidence for this claim?
 
Last edited:
I don't know. Maybe to defend themselves against all those Israeli Tanks, Fighter Jets and Killer Helicopters that kill thousands of Palestinians?

The rockets cannot hit tanks, fighter jets, or "killer helicopters". And while the tunnels could indeed protect Palestinian civilians from all those things, Palestinian civilians are not allowed to use the tunnels, because that's not their intended purpose (killing Jews). If Hamas let Palestinians use the tunnels as bomb shelters, that would get in the way of using them to kill Jews, which is why Hamas doesn't let them.

tl;dr version: you're using your own willful ignorance to excuse terrorism. Pathetic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom