Friction heat and compression heat

The transition from coherent compression waves to internal energy is mediated by a combination of vortex shedding and Brownian motion. The fluid friction initially causes large eddies to form in the fluid. Friction breaks the eddies down into smaller and smaller eddies. At some point, Brownian motion breaks up the very smallest eddies into completely randomized molecular motion.

The generation of internal energy (i.e., heat) is not just a case of kinetic energy being converted to heat energy. Heat energy is a form of kinetic energy, after all. What happens is that the frictional force create entropy. The motion has to be come disordered.

The creation of entropy is dominated by vortex shedding. The breakdown of vortices increases the disorder of the molecules. This disorder is called entropy. The word heat often designates entropy rather than any form of energy. The more vortices, the more entropy and therefore the more 'heat'.


One simple way to look at compression heating is that when the piston moves down, it collides with air molecules increasing their kinetic energy. Because air molecules are hit at different times, the motion of the air molecules becomes random. The reverse applies when the piston moves out,. The molecules collide with the piston, moving the piston out. The molecules lose energy to the piston.

A more complete way to look at it is in terms of fluid dynamics. The piston hits the air, creating compressional waves. The molecules are in phase for a few nanoseconds, so the energy goes into a sound wave. However, frictional forces in the air cause vortex shedding. In other words, collisions between clusters of molecules creates vortices that rub against each other, creating smaller vortices. Eventually, the vortices become comparable to the mean spacing between molecules. At this point, the sound wave has become heat energy.

I did a fast search on recent fluid dynamic studies. There may not be the simplest references, but they are a start. Here are some links and relevant quotes.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vortex_shedding
n fluid dynamics, vortex shedding is an oscillating flow that takes place when a fluid such as air or water flows past a bluff (as opposed to streamlined) body at certain velocities, depending on the size and shape of the body. In this flow, vortices are created at the back of the body and detach periodically from either side of the body. See Von Kármán vortex street. The fluid flow past the object creates alternating low-pressure vortices on the downstream side of the object. The object will tend to move toward the low-pressure zone.’

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.307.4121&rep=rep1&type=pdf
‘Periodic vortex shedding in pulsating flow inside wavy channel and the effect it has on heat transfer are studied using the finite volume method.’

entropy-18-00134.pdf
‘Heat Transfer Enhancement and Entropy Generation of Nanofluids Laminar Convection in Microchannels with Flow Control Devices’
Fantastic, Darwin. Thank you. I will have to read it a few more times and check the links but it does answer my inquiry.

So many times I seem to run across questions I should have asked my profs in university. This is one of them.
 
Obviously you are wrong, temperature effects the pressure exerted by a gas on a flexible membrane. Thats why I have to add air in the winter to truck and equipment tires.
An expanding gas absorbs energy, a compressed gas releases energy.

A Compressed gas transits to a lower energy state, an expanding gas has a higher energy state. It has nothing to do with the work the gas does but solely the energy state of the gas.

Sigh. Any gas exerts pressure, that is force per area, on the interior of its container. At constant-volume equilibrium, this is balanced by the atmosphere, mechanical properties of container, etc. If you by whatever means change the volume of the container the gas does work PdV. This is FORCE × DISPLACEMENT, literally the definition of work in Newtonian dynamics. This is why an expanding gas cools under normal conditions.

The reason your tires flatten in the winter is because they exchange HEAT with the environment. I explicitly referred to ADIABATIC (with no exchange of heat) expansion/compression.

If you are going to argue with me again, please do the following homeqork: Consider a small cylinder, area, say, 100 cm^2. Atmospheric pressure is 100 kPa (100 000 N/m^2). Or a force of 1000 N (~lifting 100 kg) on the cylinder). You'll be able to displace the cylinder a bit by doing work on the piston by pulling it apart with your hands, depending on the volume. You are working against the atmosphere, which also does work, but you are unlikely to be exerting a force of 1000 N. What supplies the difference in force? What is the work done by this difference? Why is your ability to displace the piston volume-dependent?
 
Last edited:
Sigh. Any gas exerts pressure, that is force per area, on the interior of its container. At constant-volume equilibrium, this is balanced by the atmosphere, mechanical properties of container, etc. If you by whatever means change the volume of the container the gas does work PdV. This is FORCE × DISPLACEMENT, literally the definition of work in Newtonian dynamics. This is why an expanding gas cools under normal conditions.

The reason your tires flatten in the winter is because they exchange HEAT with the environment. I explicitly referred to ADIABATIC (with no exchange of heat) expansion/compression.

If you are going to argue with me again, please do the following homeqork: Consider a small cylinder, area, say, 100 cm^2. Atmospheric pressure is 100 kPa (100 000 N/m^2). Or a force of 1000 N (~lifting 100 kg) on the cylinder). You'll be able to displace the cylinder a bit by doing work on the piston by pulling it apart with your hands, depending on the volume. You are working against the atmosphere, which also does work, but you are unlikely to be exerting a force of 1000 N. What supplies the difference in force? What is the work done by this difference? Why is your ability to displace the piston volume-dependent?

Yes you are correct with no exchange of heat, adiabatic but that would hardly be the environment that Jay was referring too.
 
Yes you are correct with no exchange of heat, adiabatic but that would hardly be the environment that Jay was referring too.

FYI, the gas does work with exchange of heat as well. It's just that the PV^g = constant relationship does not hold. While you take heat from tires for example the atmosphere ALSO does work on your tires. These kinds of interactions are why Classcal Thermodynamics is a nontrivial discipline easy to make wrong assumptions in. I say that having minutes ago written a 3rd-year undergrad exam in StatPhys/Thermo that had as first problem finding the temperature in a freaking hot air balloon at equilibrium.
 
It's easy to look at the laws of thermodynamics and make the mistake without realizing it, as early physicists did based on chemical reactions, that heat is conserved or some similar folly. But despite the deceptive simplicity of dU = Q + W or especially PV = NkT, the relationships between individual quantities are unknowable unless some special condition holds. So while f(P,V) = T is a very simple function, f(P) = V is not nevessarily so unless T is known at every point. Similar for differential equations e.g. dp/dT = f(T) can only be expressed at phase boundaries (Classius-Clapeyron), and only has a solution of the form F(T) = P with some very rough assumptions.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom