Friction heat and compression heat

OK, I see where I went wrong. While it may be true that the energy per unit volume of a gas is increased when the volume is reduced (not taking the work into account), that's not what temperature measures. Temperature measures the average kinetic energy of the particles, and that doesn't change in the description I offered up. What I was describing is closer to heat capacity - as mentioned by other posters.

When compressed a gas loses energy do to the molecules being restrained that energy transfers to the environmental surrounding as heat.

To expand a gas has to absorb energy, from it's surrounding environment.

Molecular motion is what we refer to as heat energy so when restrained a gas has to release that energy to occupy the smaller space.

You don't need to ask a scientist or engineer, just a diesel mechanic, the 17/1 compression ratio of a diesel engine releases enough heat to ignite the diesel fuel, without a spark plug.

The same phenomenon applies to the Capsule, compressing restraining the air heated by the solar winds.
 
Last edited:
You don't need to ask a scientist or engineer, just a diesel mechanic, the 17/1 compression ratio of a diesel engine releases enough heat to ignite the diesel fuel, without a spark plug.

As aptly demonstrated by the fire piston, a device I didn't know existed until reading about it in this thread:

 
Another thing is to consider the free-expansion of an ideal gas. The gas expands from a small volume to a large one, but there is no energy transfer and there is no change in temperature. The energy in the gas is more spread out than it was, but the temperature doesn't go down.

If this were the case your refrigerator wouldn't work.
 
As aptly demonstrated by the fire piston, a device I didn't know existed until reading about it in this thread:


Yes decreasing the space restraining the gas causes particle collisions with the walls of the container, releasing heat to the container. Causing it's molecules to heat up and vibrate rapidly.
It is the transfer of photons, do to increased particle collisions within the gas and it's surrounding that causes the increase or decrease in temperature.
The fire piston was actually designed before the diesel engine, as a way to relight steam boilers at sea in a predictable way. It will even work in wet environmental conditions.
Where matches, and friction might not.
The fires Compression ignition fueled diesel ran on peanut oil, the first attempt at a Internal combustion engine was with black gun powder, fortunately some one figured out gasoline would work better.
Can't wait for a fusion drive car, though one drop of water travel the world, what's taking you scientific minded people so long to come up with this, they predicted fusion powered cars in the 1950 that would fly and take you anywhere. Why can't I trade the Chevy for one now?:D
Could you at least have it done by next Apr, in time for my birthday?;)
 
That's not what I'm referring to. Joule expansion is not Joule-Thompson. Enthalphy is constant in Joule-Thompson. Temperature is constant in ideal gas (but not real gas) Joule expansion.


I’m not sure a Joule expansion is the right model. I guess that depends on how you interpret the OP though. The system boundary in Joule expansion isn’t just the compressed gas it, also includes the space the gas is expanding into. So neither the volume nor amount of gas nor the energy in the system in the system is actually changing, which is why temperature doesn’t change.

You could still get changes in the distribution of heat within the room if it were not a vacuum. Eg the expanding gas in the canister would cool while the gas outside the canister would warm.
 
I’m not sure a Joule expansion is the right model. I guess that depends on how you interpret the OP though. The system boundary in Joule expansion isn’t just the compressed gas it, also includes the space the gas is expanding into. So neither the volume nor amount of gas nor the energy in the system in the system is actually changing, which is why temperature doesn’t change.

You could still get changes in the distribution of heat within the room if it were not a vacuum. Eg the expanding gas in the canister would cool while the gas outside the canister would warm.

Post #3 gives the specific system in question. The compression zone below a blunt nosed orbital re-entry vehicle such as the Apollo craft.

As I see(and I am no engineer of physicist) it air enters the system ie. it hits the compression zone, and is incorporated into it, compresses, heats up. There is movement of this hot gas though (there is no 'container') so some of that hot gas exits off the edges. If air entering equals air exiting then temperatures and volume of the compressed zone stays the same.

Gases exiting the system are carrying away heat. That heat was created courtesy of the kinetic energy of the craft and therefore the craft must slow down (in addition to other forces contributing to slowing the craft such as 'lift').

There is another issue though. We know that the heat shield also heats up. It then sends heat away from the craft by ablation, outgassing as it heats up and vapourizes.
 
Post #3 gives the specific system in question. The compression zone below a blunt nosed orbital re-entry vehicle such as the Apollo craft.

As I see(and I am no engineer of physicist) it air enters the system ie. it hits the compression zone, and is incorporated into it, compresses, heats up. There is movement of this hot gas though (there is no 'container') so some of that hot gas exits off the edges. If air entering equals air exiting then temperatures and volume of the compressed zone stays the same.

Gases exiting the system are carrying away heat. That heat was created courtesy of the kinetic energy of the craft and therefore the craft must slow down (in addition to other forces contributing to slowing the craft such as 'lift').

There is another issue though. We know that the heat shield also heats up. It then sends heat away from the craft by ablation, outgassing as it heats up and vapourizes.

Ah, somehow I missed that. Ok my first approximation (which could be wildly wrong because something I’m discounting is much more important than I know) would be:

Compressing the air in front of the capsule will heat it but not change the energy it contains. (its effectively adiabatic). The re-entry energy of the capsule therefore needs to be turned into heat primarily via friction. The conduction between the capsule and the gas is pretty small so most of the heat is radiated away as light and IR, not carries away by the atmosphere. Some will go into phase state changes from vaporizing the surface of the capsule, but I’m assuming (perhaps falsely) that this is small compared to re-entry energy.
 
Compressing the air in front of the capsule will heat it but not change the energy it contains. (its effectively adiabatic).
First law of thermodynamics: The change in energy = Heat + Work. Adiabatic compression does work on the substance without allowing heat to flow, therefore it certainly changes the energy (and temperature) of the substance. This is an elementary feature of PV-diagrams - adiabats intersect multiple isotherms, as you note, thus they correspond to different states of internal energy.

Anyway, we run into trouble depending on the speeds considered. Most of basic thermodynamics assumes processes (adiabatic ones, in particular) are quasistatic, that is, that the compression is slow compared to the speed of sound in the working medium, so that the compression is uniform and not "wave-like". This does is not true w.r.t the question considered, so I'm not sure if it can be easily analyzed. The compression of air that occurs at re-entry speeds will be a whole lot more complicated than anything I could easily work with for sure.
 
First law of thermodynamics: The change in energy = Heat + Work. Adiabatic compression does work on the substance without allowing heat to flow, therefore it certainly changes the energy (and temperature) of the substance. This is an elementary feature of PV-diagrams - adiabats intersect multiple isotherms, as you note, thus they correspond to different states of internal energy.

Anyway, we run into trouble depending on the speeds considered. Most of basic thermodynamics assumes processes (adiabatic ones, in particular) are quasistatic, that is, that the compression is slow compared to the speed of sound in the working medium, so that the compression is uniform and not "wave-like". This does is not true w.r.t the question considered, so I'm not sure if it can be easily analyzed. The compression of air that occurs at re-entry speeds will be a whole lot more complicated than anything I could easily work with for sure.

oh yeah,, double digit mach numbers and a mach velocity that changes as altitude drops would make this very complicated to calculate through the whole reentry. Basically though, we are talking about the very high altitude region of greatest reentry heating.
 
I’m not sure a Joule expansion is the right model. I guess that depends on how you interpret the OP though.

I mentioned Joule expansion as a counterexample to the suggestion that enlarging the volume of a gas lowered the temperature specifically because the energy is more spread out. It wasn't in reference to the OP or an attempt to model anything.
 
This came up in another forum area but my query is more apropos here.



Yeah, I am trying to get a handle on why (not "if", that is very well established ) compression raises temperature. Obviously it has to do with the energy input required to push molecules of a gas closer together, increasing the density of the gas.
I am simply putting out a few thoughts on this and absolutely welcome informed explanation and corrections. It's een decades since I took physics classes.
In the bow shock wave of an object falling very fast there is no physical wall. Instead it is the gas itself that "can't get out of the way fast enough".
Why can it not get out of the way fast enough? Does it have to do with the inertia of the gas molecules? Does it have to do with bonds between molecules?


Then there is friction. Why does friction cause an increase in temperature of the surfaces involved? Again obviously there is the input of energy due to the relative velocities of the objects. One explanation I see on the internet is that molecules on each surface form a bond that gets broken as they move apart thus increasing the velocity or vibration of those molecules.

Friction is usually demonstrated with two solids in contact moving by each other. It could just as well be two fluids, or a fluid and a solid. The biggest difference I can see is that the fluid will form layers moving at different speeds. When the fluid is moving slowly there may be fewer, thinner layers meaning most of the friction is between solid and fluid. If the fluid is much faster the layer nearest the solid does not have the same freedom of movement and cannot form another layer. It must deal with the solid/fluid interface, ie friction, therefore it cannot move as fast as layers further from the solid. Essentially a limit on the friction between a solid and fluid. Layers further from the solid surface then are compressed against the contact layer. Most of the heat generated then is in this compression compared to the friction layer in contact with the solid.

The transition from coherent compression waves to internal energy is mediated by a combination of vortex shedding and Brownian motion. The fluid friction initially causes large eddies to form in the fluid. Friction breaks the eddies down into smaller and smaller eddies. At some point, Brownian motion breaks up the very smallest eddies into completely randomized molecular motion.

The generation of internal energy (i.e., heat) is not just a case of kinetic energy being converted to heat energy. Heat energy is a form of kinetic energy, after all. What happens is that the frictional force create entropy. The motion has to be come disordered.

The creation of entropy is dominated by vortex shedding. The breakdown of vortices increases the disorder of the molecules. This disorder is called entropy. The word heat often designates entropy rather than any form of energy. The more vortices, the more entropy and therefore the more 'heat'.


One simple way to look at compression heating is that when the piston moves down, it collides with air molecules increasing their kinetic energy. Because air molecules are hit at different times, the motion of the air molecules becomes random. The reverse applies when the piston moves out,. The molecules collide with the piston, moving the piston out. The molecules lose energy to the piston.

A more complete way to look at it is in terms of fluid dynamics. The piston hits the air, creating compressional waves. The molecules are in phase for a few nanoseconds, so the energy goes into a sound wave. However, frictional forces in the air cause vortex shedding. In other words, collisions between clusters of molecules creates vortices that rub against each other, creating smaller vortices. Eventually, the vortices become comparable to the mean spacing between molecules. At this point, the sound wave has become heat energy.

I did a fast search on recent fluid dynamic studies. There may not be the simplest references, but they are a start. Here are some links and relevant quotes.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vortex_shedding
n fluid dynamics, vortex shedding is an oscillating flow that takes place when a fluid such as air or water flows past a bluff (as opposed to streamlined) body at certain velocities, depending on the size and shape of the body. In this flow, vortices are created at the back of the body and detach periodically from either side of the body. See Von Kármán vortex street. The fluid flow past the object creates alternating low-pressure vortices on the downstream side of the object. The object will tend to move toward the low-pressure zone.’

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.307.4121&rep=rep1&type=pdf
‘Periodic vortex shedding in pulsating flow inside wavy channel and the effect it has on heat transfer are studied using the finite volume method.’

entropy-18-00134.pdf
‘Heat Transfer Enhancement and Entropy Generation of Nanofluids Laminar Convection in Microchannels with Flow Control Devices’
 
oh yeah,, double digit mach numbers and a mach velocity that changes as altitude drops would make this very complicated to calculate through the whole reentry. Basically though, we are talking about the very high altitude region of greatest reentry heating.

Well, I think I can answer one concern in your OP - no significant change in temperature on compression of gasses is attributable to forces between the particles under normal conditions - that is only the case in a liquid. It is because compression involves doing work on individual particles, giving them momentum. In the case of expansion, it is important to remember that the gas always does work on the piston, even if you're the one moving it.

But for the kind of heating you describe, I believe that is irrelevant because the momentum does not have time to travel through the gas. Instead it is simply many, many particles colliding with the surface of the spacecraft and deforming it; the deformation results in sound waves through the surface, which dissipates as heat. Essentially, it's the craft being heated by compression, not the gas it moves through.
 
Are you disputing that the refrigerator cools food by first compressing gas and then allowing it to expand?

The gas, on expansion, does work on its surroundings (either by piston movenent, a throttling valve...) In free expansion this is not the case.
 
The gas, on expansion, does work on its surroundings (either by piston movenent, a throttling valve...) In free expansion this is not the case.

The gas has to absorb heat to do work, it is the gas absorbing heat that induces work.
Without heat the gas will not expand at all.
 
Well, I think I can answer one concern in your OP - no significant change in temperature on compression of gasses is attributable to forces between the particles under normal conditions - that is only the case in a liquid. It is because compression involves doing work on individual particles, giving them momentum. In the case of expansion, it is important to remember that the gas always does work on the piston, even if you're the one moving it.

But for the kind of heating you describe, I believe that is irrelevant because the momentum does not have time to travel through the gas. Instead it is simply many, many particles colliding with the surface of the spacecraft and deforming it; the deformation results in sound waves through the surface, which dissipates as heat. Essentially, it's the craft being heated by compression, not the gas it moves through.

That is part of it, however the gas does have to move out of the way and is compressed below the craft on a shock wave effect. It is more complicated than just one simple effect.
 
The gas has to absorb heat to do work, it is the gas absorbing heat that induces work.
Without heat the gas will not expand at all.

This is wrong. If you expand a cylinder mechanically, the gas particles do work on the piston. They collide with the piston, briefly interacting with it while it moves, thus transferring some momentum to it.

Think of it as the difference in work you have to do between expanding a gas and expanding a vacuum - the gas does some of the work against the atmosphere for you.
 
This is wrong. If you expand a cylinder mechanically, the gas particles do work on the piston. They collide with the piston, briefly interacting with it while it moves, thus transferring some momentum to it.

Think of it as the difference in work you have to do between expanding a gas and expanding a vacuum - the gas does some of the work against the atmosphere for you.

Obviously you are wrong, temperature effects the pressure exerted by a gas on a flexible membrane. Thats why I have to add air in the winter to truck and equipment tires.
An expanding gas absorbs energy, a compressed gas releases energy.

A Compressed gas transits to a lower energy state, an expanding gas has a higher energy state. It has nothing to do with the work the gas does but solely the energy state of the gas.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom