Friction heat and compression heat

jaydeehess

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Messages
20,849
Location
40 miles north of the border
This came up in another forum area but my query is more apropos here.

I have never seen an explanation of the pressure/temperature relationship in a gas that attributed it to friction.

Yeah, I am trying to get a handle on why (not "if", that is very well established ) compression raises temperature. Obviously it has to do with the energy input required to push molecules of a gas closer together, increasing the density of the gas.
I am simply putting out a few thoughts on this and absolutely welcome informed explanation and corrections. It's een decades since I took physics classes.
In the bow shock wave of an object falling very fast there is no physical wall. Instead it is the gas itself that "can't get out of the way fast enough".
Why can it not get out of the way fast enough? Does it have to do with the inertia of the gas molecules? Does it have to do with bonds between molecules?


Then there is friction. Why does friction cause an increase in temperature of the surfaces involved? Again obviously there is the input of energy due to the relative velocities of the objects. One explanation I see on the internet is that molecules on each surface form a bond that gets broken as they move apart thus increasing the velocity or vibration of those molecules.

Friction is usually demonstrated with two solids in contact moving by each other. It could just as well be two fluids, or a fluid and a solid. The biggest difference I can see is that the fluid will form layers moving at different speeds. When the fluid is moving slowly there may be fewer, thinner layers meaning most of the friction is between solid and fluid. If the fluid is much faster the layer nearest the solid does not have the same freedom of movement and cannot form another layer. It must deal with the solid/fluid interface, ie friction, therefore it cannot move as fast as layers further from the solid. Essentially a limit on the friction between a solid and fluid. Layers further from the solid surface then are compressed against the contact layer. Most of the heat generated then is in this compression compared to the friction layer in contact with the solid.
 
Last edited:
This came up in another forum area but my query is more apropos here.



Yeah, I am trying to get a handle on why (not "if", that is very well established ) compression raises temperature. Obviously it has to do with the energy input required to push molecules of a gas closer together, increasing the density of the gas.
I am simply putting out a few thoughts on this and absolutely welcome informed explanation and corrections. It's een decades since I took physics classes.
In the bow shock wave of an object falling very fast there is no physical wall. Instead it is the gas itself that "can't get out of the way fast enough".
Why can it not get out of the way fast enough? Does it have to do with the inertia of the gas molecules? Does it have to do with bonds between molecules?


Then there is friction. Why does friction cause an increase in temperature of the surfaces involved? Again obviously there is the input of energy due to the relative velocities of the objects. One explanation I see on the internet is that molecules on each surface form a bond that gets broken as they move apart thus increasing the velocity or vibration of those molecules.

Friction is usually demonstrated with two solids in contact moving by each other. It could just as well be two fluids, or a fluid and a solid. The biggest difference I can see is that the fluid will form layers moving at different speeds. When the fluid is moving slowly there may be fewer, thinner layers meaning most of the friction is between solid and fluid. If the fluid is much faster the layer nearest the solid does not have the same freedom of movement and cannot form another layer. It must deal with the solid/fluid interface, ie friction, therefore it cannot move as fast as layers further from the solid. Essentially a limit on the friction between a solid and fluid. Layers further from the solid surface then are compressed against the contact layer. Most of the heat generated then is in this compression compared to the friction layer in contact with the solid.

I studied the kinetic molecular theory of gasses 35 years ago, but my recollection is that you are correct. It's more about compression than friction.
 
Thanks John.

This came up in a discussion about spacecraft reentry. Basically a blunt object moving through a fluid.

So we have most of the heat being generated in the compression layers which are not in contact with the spacecraft. Fluid moving into and out of the compression zone reaches an equilibrium that sees the heat generated moving out to the sides in a plasma that does not touch the craft.
However, we also know that there is a "heat shield" at the bottom of the craft that is carrying heat away via ablation, vapourization of the shield. Most of the heat again is not in the layer against the shield but it is reaching a temp high enough to vaporize it. That must be due to friction.
 
Thanks John.

This came up in a discussion about spacecraft reentry. Basically a blunt object moving through a fluid.

So we have most of the heat being generated in the compression layers which are not in contact with the spacecraft. Fluid moving into and out of the compression zone reaches an equilibrium that sees the heat generated moving out to the sides in a plasma that does not touch the craft.
However, we also know that there is a "heat shield" at the bottom of the craft that is carrying heat away via ablation, vapourization of the shield. Most of the heat again is not in the layer against the shield but it is reaching a temp high enough to vaporize it. That must be due to friction.

When you're inches from a sheet of plasma, I'd bet that radiation was a large component of your thermal load.
 
The way I've always thought about temperature rise under compression is that you have Vol1 with energy X and then Vol2 (which is smaller) with the same energy. This means the average energy per unit volume has to go up - there's less volume overall.

Not sure how that mental picture applies to the rest of the OP though.
 
Yeah, I am trying to get a handle on why (not "if", that is very well established ) compression raises temperature.

In a thermal distribution, the individual objects will all have different speeds. But for the moment, imagine a room with some tennis balls that are all bouncing at exactly the same speed. They bounce off the walls with the same speed that they strike.

Now move one of the walls into the room. This makes the collision speed with that wall greater, so the objects will bounce off faster. Faster bounce, greater energy content, higher temperature.

Another way to think about it is that the wall and the gas push on each other. That's a force. To compress the gas, then the wall has to move. Force times distance equals work, so again, you're supplying energy to the gas.
In the bow shock wave of an object falling very fast there is no physical wall. Instead it is the gas itself that "can't get out of the way fast enough".
Why can it not get out of the way fast enough? Does it have to do with the inertia of the gas molecules? Does it have to do with bonds between molecules?
Any push against a gas is going to increase the temperature. It's just that at low speeds, the force required to do so is so small that the energy delivered is tiny as well. You're not going to be able to measure the increase because you wave your hand around. At higher speeds you are supplying more force across a longer distance. That equals more energy delivered into the gas.
Friction is usually demonstrated with two solids in contact moving by each other. It could just as well be two fluids, or a fluid and a solid.

It would be unusual (I won't say "wrong") to describe fluid drag as "friction". That's normally reserved for solid interaction. Drag, yes. Friction, no.
 
The way I've always thought about temperature rise under compression is that you have Vol1 with energy X and then Vol2 (which is smaller) with the same energy. This means the average energy per unit volume has to go up - there's less volume overall.

The container has to do work on the gas to compress it. So it is incorrect to think of it as the same energy in a smaller space. Energy has been delivered into the container.

Another thing is to consider the free-expansion of an ideal gas. The gas expands from a small volume to a large one, but there is no energy transfer and there is no change in temperature. The energy in the gas is more spread out than it was, but the temperature doesn't go down.
 
The container has to do work on the gas to compress it. So it is incorrect to think of it as the same energy in a smaller space. Energy has been delivered into the container.

Another thing is to consider the free-expansion of an ideal gas. The gas expands from a small volume to a large one, but there is no energy transfer and there is no change in temperature. The energy in the gas is more spread out than it was, but the temperature doesn't go down.

I don't think this is correct but I think there are people who are going to be able to explain this much better than myself.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adiabatic_process#Adiabatic_heating_and_cooling

Adiabatic cooling occurs when the pressure on an adiabatically isolated system is decreased, allowing it to expand, thus causing it to do work on its surroundings. When the pressure applied on a parcel of air is reduced, the air in the parcel is allowed to expand; as the volume increases, the temperature falls as its internal energy decreases. Adiabatic cooling occurs in the Earth's atmosphere with orographic lifting and lee waves, and this can form pileus or lenticular clouds.
From what I understand, if you take a gas and increase its volume without adding or removing any energy from the system, the temperature decreases. I'm mostly familiar with this concept from this weather concept:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lapse_rate
Basically, if you take a warm rising parcel of air and take it to altitude, you can predict it's temperature due to adiabatic cooling. If the actual temperature aloft is substantially different from the Dry Adiabatic Lapse Rate, you can predict the stability of the atmosphere (lots of convection or very little convection)
 
Another thing is to consider the free-expansion of an ideal gas. The gas expands from a small volume to a large one, but there is no energy transfer and there is no change in temperature. The energy in the gas is more spread out than it was, but the temperature doesn't go down.


I thought the temperature does go down, as when I puncture a pressurized container.

On a side note, is temperature a measure of energy per unit volume or something else?
 
The way I've always thought about temperature rise under compression is that you have Vol1 with energy X and then Vol2 (which is smaller) with the same energy. This means the average energy per unit volume has to go up - there's less volume overall.

Not sure how that mental picture applies to the rest of the OP though.
That's a decent word story version of the ideal gas equation PV=NrT , or, pressure x volume equals amount of stuff times temperature.

There was an early experiment in science in which a tank of air was stirred with something like an ice cream churn paddle until the temperature went up. In that experiment energy was added to the container as direct mechanical kinetic agitation of the air, and was crucial to discovering the nature of "heat" as, in part, the kinetic energy of molecules. But that would be heating by friction.
 
Last edited:
Conversely to the stirring experiment, a fire piston uses rapid compression of gas to start fire. No friction, just increasing pressure by reducing volume.
 
I thought the temperature does go down, as when I puncture a pressurized container.

On a side note, is temperature a measure of energy per unit volume or something else?

Something else I think.. specific heat takes into consideration the amount of mass (so volume isn't relevant) whereas temperature changes with volume but my physics is very rusty
 
Another thing is to consider the free-expansion of an ideal gas. The gas expands from a small volume to a large one, but there is no energy transfer and there is no change in temperature. The energy in the gas is more spread out than it was, but the temperature doesn't go down.

ETA: Never mind
 
Last edited:
The container has to do work on the gas to compress it. So it is incorrect to think of it as the same energy in a smaller space. Energy has been delivered into the container.

Adiabatic compression, as it is called, conserves the quantity PVg where g = (f + 2)/f, again, f is degree of freedom.
 
This is wrong. This is known as a Joule-Thompson process; the quantity conserved is the Enthalpy H = U + PV. U is proportional to fT/2 (where f is the degrees of freedom of the gas, 3 for monatomic, 5 or 7 for diatomic); PV is proportional to T. As PV generally increases for free expansion the temperature tends to drop as U decreases in equal amount.

That's not what I'm referring to. Joule expansion is not Joule-Thompson. Enthalphy is constant in Joule-Thompson. Temperature is constant in ideal gas (but not real gas) Joule expansion.
 
I thought the temperature does go down, as when I puncture a pressurized container.

On a side note, is temperature a measure of energy per unit volume or something else?

The temperature is constant during free expansion only for ideal gases. Real gases almost always cool during expansion, but above certain temperatures, hydrogen and helium can warm.

Absolute temperature is proportional to the average kinetic energy of the particles in the gas as long as things don't get too cold and you have to worry about quantum effects.
 
The temperature is constant during free expansion only for ideal gases. Real gases almost always cool during expansion, but above certain temperatures, hydrogen and helium can warm.

Absolute temperature is proportional to the average kinetic energy of the particles in the gas as long as things don't get too cold and you have to worry about quantum effects.

Plus, puncturing a pressurized contained is actually a (cardinal example of a) Joule-Thompson process unless done in a vacuum, since the gas is doing work dW = PdV with P being 1 atmosphere in room conditions.
 
The temperature is constant during free expansion only for ideal gases. Real gases almost always cool during expansion, but above certain temperatures, hydrogen and helium can warm.

Absolute temperature is proportional to the average kinetic energy of the particles in the gas as long as things don't get too cold and you have to worry about quantum effects.

OK, I see where I went wrong. While it may be true that the energy per unit volume of a gas is increased when the volume is reduced (not taking the work into account), that's not what temperature measures. Temperature measures the average kinetic energy of the particles, and that doesn't change in the description I offered up. What I was describing is closer to heat capacity - as mentioned by other posters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom