Foster, what a Catholic Christian could do about the lobster is have it now and again, but get to confession immediately thereafter to get cleaned up.
Looks like the Muslims may not have that feature. Too bad. Or, if they do, I am simply ignorant of it.
DR
I know a few Catholics who just use "confession" to excuse themselves when they sin, according to the Bible. I don't like it, but I guess it's a good way to get people to prefer Catholicism over other denominations who don't work the same way.
"I just beat my wife because she gave me cheek.... Forgiveness now please, I have other things to do!"
"Of course, my son, Jesus forgives anyone. As long as you're
really sorry.

"
And then the person can go on feeling like the morally pure Catholic, and not worry if he/she sins again because, according to them, it doesn't matter.
Back to the thread. No matter what people say about Christians not being allowed to eat shellfish and disobeying other ridiculous (now) laws from the Bible, it doesn't matter. IMO, these people don't use the Bible as the initial reason to hate gays, instead they use it as the justification. Either way, take away their faith and the Bible and then all they can be is what they are - not God loving zealots, but ignorant, aggressive and hate-filled bigots.
Edit: Though, my grandmother is a very devout Christian (follows the Bible to the word, almost... - believes in the creation myth and flatly refuses to learn anything about evolution, though still breaks rules like the shellfish one). She also believes that homosexuality is wrong, not because she is hate-filled and bitter (she's actually a happy woman) but instead because the Bible tells her so. She differs from Fred Phelps and his gang though - she doesn't take her idiotic belief out into the world and starts protesting at funerals. So bigotry and homophobia can be the result of following the Bible. But to do what Phelps does he still needs to be the hate-filled and aggressive person he is.
I know another person who is atheist, has not grown up in a Christian or religious family, who is also bigoted towards homosexuality (strangely enough, that's only homosexuality in men). I asked him a few days ago, after reading about Phelps, why he hates gay men so much, and guess what? He didn't have a reason. He just hates gay men. He can't use the Bible as justification though, so people can't see him as someone carrying out the word of God. He's just a ignorant, bigoted, hate-filled homophobe.
People like the second gay-hater scare me more than my grandmother, because they base their hatred on nothing, they are wild. People like Fred Phelps scare me more than both of the two combined. Not only is he hate-filled, he also thinks that what he is doing is righteous, and that he will be rewarded for his hard work.