Getting back to the topic at hand:
Phelps is little more than a theological bully, a punk thug with nothing more than a big stick and low self-esteem. He's a coward, who won't debate the issue with anyone in an intelligent or even honest way. When he picketed Randy Shilts' funeral, he and his crew of bigoted miscreants ran when they were confronted, rather than face up to their despicable act and the harm it was causing. It revealed who he truly was, and showed the world that he should have been ignored years ago.
Phelps was the slimeball that was going to put up a monument in Wyoming, declaring that Matthew Shepherd was in Hell, and that God was happy about it. He deliberately seeks to cause pain and harm, all in the name of his "god," who seems to be pretty easy with thieves, bigots, sadists, and other such neanderthals, but just can't get over two people of the same sex together for anything more intimate than a game of Gin Rummy. It's hard to believe that Christians aren't willing to stand up to this brute as he drags his knuckles up to the churches where funerals for servicemembers are being held, claiming that Phelps has a First Amendment right to be a god damned jackoff, but then, I don't expect the Churches to show any backbone any more.
Those who cite the First Amendment seem to be willing to ignore the responsibility that goes with such a right, that you may not use it to cause deliberate harm to another. That's why there's laws against libel and slander, and why Phelps wound up being nailed for a million dollar settlement. That he's now willing to travel to a foreign country to spew his venomous sludge is more than enough reason to revoke his passport, simply on the basis of simple decency. (Seems to me it won't take long before his and Westboro's collective mouth cause an international incident.)
These people, spiritually -- and possibly physically -- inbred, with little rational thought behind their hateful actions, will continue with their hateful verbal vomit, committed in the name of their "god," more vengeful punk than Holy Deity, until someone shuts them down hard. They need to be sued, and they need to lose big time. They need to lose their church building, their church's charter, and Phelps needs to be bankrupted. Churches themselves need to stand up to this kind of barbaric hate. Frankly, I'm surprised more cities don't prevent the Westboro cult from picketing, primarily because they're out there disturbing the peace. I would think if there were some way to lock them up once they hit town for a "protest," it would be a wise move on the part of most communities, since Phelps' Philthy Phew aren't really showing up to protest as much as they're there to disrupt communities.
It's time to start saying "No" to this kind of cruelty. Life may not be fair, but that doesn't mean we have to be unfair. Enough is enough.