Ed Forum birdwatching 2008

Sorry, I missed this.

To me, based on Sibley's "Field Guide to Birds of Eastern North America", this is a Red-shouldered Hawk Buteo lineatus. I base this identification mainly on the evenly streaked belly, and the light crescent of the upper wing tip. It appears to be a juvenile bird, and that's often tricky no matter what raptor you're looking at, but the Broad-winged would be either much lighter, almost Osprey-white, on the undersides, or much darker, with white primaries and secondaries (if juvenile). In all adult plumages in the book, the Broad-winged has a distinct white tail band, which I cannot find on the bird in your picture.

The alternative would, of course, be the Red-tailed hawk, but while this species has a white "window" on the primaries, the bird in your picture seems to me to have rather the crescent-shaped patch of the Red-shouldered. However, I would appreciate if someone with more experience of American hawks would chime in...

Thanks for your input! I suspect you're correct as that would be the most likely and least sexy possibility. I'm very familiar with Red Shouldereds which I've photographed many times, and a juvy would fit the bill. The Broad Wing is a much more rare occurance.

I participated in the 2008 Audubon Christmas Bird Count this past Sunday. I have a few good pics that I'll share soon. We ID'd over 100 species and counted thousands of birds.
 
Wonderful picture. I have some photos somewhere of an old nest hill from the place I visited this summer.

Incidentally, it seems the thread has succumbed to the winter.

EHocking: if you could send me the list and note up to which post you have added, I could do the rest and we'll do at least one more update before the year's over...
OK. Well I missed that didn't I. I've got a little spare time over here in Oz at the moment, so I've really only got your lists to download and update. I'm about to fire up the laptop and get back to the Excel file and see what's what. I only have 2 more from my last Ghana trip (not noted on thread yet) and probably have nothing to add to the Oz list that Kotatsu has pretty much demolished[1].

I'll get back to you later this weekend.

In the meantime, I hope everyone had a good 2008 and have started their 2009 lists!

No one vied for the first of 2009?
Or are we waiting for Kotatsu to start a new thread.

[1]Ironically I've just started reading a book by Sean Dooley called, The Big Twitch. A book about his attempt to set the record for the number of birds spotted in Australia in one calendar year (721).
 
Can I start out 2009 with a Bald Eagle Haliaeetus leucocephalus, photographed on January 1, 2009 near Boulder, Colorado, USA?

Eagle.jpg


I am not sure what he is having for lunch.

Spotted several other birds today, but will wait for a 2009 thread before posting a list.
 
Last edited:
Nice to find a twitcher community here.

Gorgeous eagle photo.

Have not done any watching seriously in decades but still keep binoc and guides handy. Biggest regret was not taking time in South Africa to up the life list significantly- the western Cape is glorious.

Dove took up residence outside my window this summer and I swear she posed for this:D

Picture19-2.jpg
 
OK. Well I missed that didn't I. I've got a little spare time over here in Oz at the moment, so I've really only got your lists to download and update. I'm about to fire up the laptop and get back to the Excel file and see what's what. I only have 2 more from my last Ghana trip (not noted on thread yet) and probably have nothing to add to the Oz list that Kotatsu has pretty much demolished[1].

I'll get back to you later this weekend.

In the meantime, I hope everyone had a good 2008 and have started their 2009 lists!

No one vied for the first of 2009?
Or are we waiting for Kotatsu to start a new thread.

[1]Ironically I've just started reading a book by Sean Dooley called, The Big Twitch. A book about his attempt to set the record for the number of birds spotted in Australia in one calendar year (721).

Sorry, I was away in Austria for New Years, and have been a bit sick since then (I actually collapsed on the airport on my way home!), so I haven't had time to open a new thread yet. However, I will do so now, and report my first bird from Austria for 2009 there (I have some for 2008 as well).

Still, we'll have to finish the old list somehow. I could do if it you're travelling, but I need to know how far you've got. For the new list, I will simply erase the text in the old one and write in the new records for now.
 
Apologies for lateness of records. Still, if you're not feeling well you'll have time to enter these? :)

Happy New Year!

Portugal List
19-23/11/08
Azure-winged Magpie
Gadwall
Mallard
Pochard
Coot
Little Grebe
Black-winged Stilt
Shoveler
Black-headed Gull
Little Egret
Cormorant
Moorhen
Stonechat
Blackbird
Booted Eagle
Sardinian Warbler
Redshank
Snipe
House Sparrow
Robin
Collared Dove
Waxbill
Hoopoe
Greenfinch
Goldfinch
Chiffchaff
Thekla Lark
Fan-tailed Warbler
Ringed Plover
Dunlin
Sanderling
Grey Plover
Greenshank
White Wagtail
Bar-tailed Godwit
Common Sandpiper
Wigeon
Purple Gallinule
Tufted Duck
Grey Wagtail
Cetti's Warbler
Teal
Turnstone
White Stork
Grey Heron
Black Stork
Cattle Egret
Lesser Black-backed Gull
Kingfisher
Black Redstart
Kestrel
Greater Flamingo
Coot
Little Grebe
Caspian Tern
Lapwing
Crag Martin
Crested Lark
Stonechat
Linnet
Water Pipit
Buzzard
Rock Bunting
Red-legged Partridge
Sparrowhawk
Yellow-legged Gull
Southern Grey Shrike
Little Bustard
Raven
Spotless starling
Corn bunting
Chaffinch
Serin
Jay
Meadow pipit
Song Thrush
Blackcap
Great Bustard
Black-shouldered Kite
Red Kite
Black-bellied Sandgrouse
Skylark
Purple Heron
Black Kite
Common Magpie
Green Sandpiper

Spain 23/11/08
Red Kite
Griffon Vulture
Black Vulture
Buzzard
Stonechat
Spotlaess Starling
Common Egret
House Sparrow
Common Magpie
Southern Grey Shrike
Lapwing
Great Crested Grebe
Yellow-legged Gull
Grey Heron
Common Sandpiper
Little Egret
Crested Lark
White Stork

Portugal 24-25/11/08
Great Spotted Woodpecker
Marsh Harrier
Greenshank
Black-tailed Godwit
Snipe
Spoonbill
Little Stint
Kentish Plover
Ruff
Swallow
Whimbrel
Grey Plover
Mediterranean Gull
Teal
Red-crested Pochard
Tufted Duck
Grey Wagtail
Great Crested Grebe
Glossy Ibis
Little Bittern
Gannet
 
I hadn't even sorted all of Kotatsu's so you're OK with the late list.
(hope you've recovered, K)

Kotatsu, I'll try to finalise my spreadsheet and get it to you tonight, in the meantime....

Anyone want to start a sweep on the total number of species for 2008?
Tomorrow PM I'll get the preliminary numbers posted here.

Kotatsu and I will need to have a bit of to-and-fro on sorting clashes with English/Latin names as well as some of the subspecies before the number is finalised - so, have at it.

Did we get the 1000?
If not, how close did we get?

I'll have to see if I can get some Australian "firsts" from my trip over the NY and hope to add 2 new countries (and their endemics) to the 2009 list.
 
Last edited:
Here are some birds I shot during the Christmas holidays.
There are no new ones except perhaps for the unidentified (by me) one at the end.

10e10jn.jpg



hrk1uo.jpg



295r15l.jpg





2ise41y.jpg


Cheeky little fella isn't he?


(If you have seen these before it's because they accidentally ended up on the "Picture Thread" :o).

BJ
 
Last edited:
A new one to me, and I couldn't find it on your list. But that's probably because searching it is difficult for me.
Anhigina anhigina.
Viewed at the Audubon Society's Corkscrew Preserve east of Fort Meyers, Fla.
Picture to follow, when I get back.
 
[qimg]http://i40.tinypic.com/2ise41y.jpg[/qimg]

Cheeky little fella isn't he?

I am thinking that this might be a Fairy tern Sternula nereis, but I would like to have more input. It depends, of course, on where you were for Christmas, but anyway:

- Black does not connect eye to bill, as it does in Little Tern Sternula albifrons sinensis, the only other alternative in Australia, but stops shortly before the eye.
- Wing seems totally light, without a darker forward edge on the outer primaries as on S. albifrons.
- Bill lacks black tip, and is more orange than on S. albifrons.

However, this was one of many species I missed when I was down there, so...

As to EHocking's sweep:

An excellent idea! I actually have a kind of prize that I think would fit if we'd want to have a prize for that sort of thing. It still hasn't arrived in Sweden, though, as I sent it from Japan by surface mail, but I think it will arrive within a month, and could then be sent on to whoever gets closest. I will not tell you what it is (at least not until it arrives), but it is something that can not be bought for money, and thus was not bought for money. It is a produced thing, though, so not just feathers or something.

That would require a deadline, though. Perhaps if you delay the revelation a week, and I go and make a new thread in Community and try to get people who have been participating, but not recently, to come and guess? I am not sure if such threads are allowed, but I'll ask a mod first and see.
 
I am thinking that this might be a Fairy tern Sternula nereis, but I would like to have more input. It depends, of course, on where you were for Christmas, but anyway:

- Black does not connect eye to bill, as it does in Little Tern Sternula albifrons sinensis, the only other alternative in Australia, but stops shortly before the eye.
- Wing seems totally light, without a darker forward edge on the outer primaries as on S. albifrons.
- Bill lacks black tip, and is more orange than on S. albifrons.

However, this was one of many species I missed when I was down there, so...

I agree it's Fairy Tern - (never having seen one), but I think you've made the ID harder than necessary. Any Little Tern in Australia at Christmas will be in winter plumage (they're entirely N. hemisphere breeders AFAIK), so it would look something like this:

http://orientalbirdimages.org/searc...=978&Bird_Image_ID=20341&Bird_Family_ID=&p=18

This is bird is clearly in breeding plumage, so it's pretty straightforward.
 
Ah, yes. Having handled several of the Little ones (but got no lice from them, sadly) in November, I should have remembered^^. Still, a detailing of the characteristics could be useful for the future, so its not all a loss.
 
As to EHocking's sweep:

An excellent idea! I actually have a kind of prize that I think would fit if we'd want to have a prize for that sort of thing...

That would require a deadline, though. Perhaps if you delay the revelation a week, and I go and make a new thread in Community and try to get people who have been participating, but not recently, to come and guess? I am not sure if such threads are allowed, but I'll ask a mod first and see.
OK. All will be revealed on Friday 16th Jan 2009.

To make it interesting you'll need to state a figure for:
1. Total number of distinct species
2. Total number of species and subspecies.

  • Winner will be the person who gets the total species correct.
  • Tiebreaker will be decided by the subspecies guess.
For the more anal scientific, have a bash at Order and Family counts as well.

Of course some people might download the last species list and review the subsequent posts on the forum to arrive at a figure. I don't believe anyone here would attempt such a thing. Besides, Kotatsu and I have a bit of wrangling to do over English/Latin names in the meantime, but to counter such an attempt, I will PM Kotatsu with my Australia list for December. My list is from Qld and Vic and he was predominantly in WA so there's a fair chance that there is some new species for the list in there.

Hint. Without my Dec Oz list, the sightings count for the year is 2610.
 
Last edited:
...I can add the following (all in Perth):

Rainbow lorikeet Trichoglossus haematodus (2)
(2) Way outside its range according to Simpson and Day. Nevertheless, everything fits: Blue head with yellow band in the upper neck, green back and tail, "flamy" red and yellow chest, blue belly, under tail coverts "flamy" in red, yellow and black, sound describable as "chre'et" (my description) or "screet" (S&D). I have contacted Birds Australia to see if they know of any escapee populations here that are not on the maps of S&D. This bird should thus not be added until I have heard from them. Photos exist, but are not very good. Three individuals were seen, but two flew away almost immediately, while the third stayed and could be observed for about 15 minutes before my neck started hurting.
Just trying to tie up loose ends:
The Rainbow Lorikeet occurs in coastal regions across northern and eastern Australia, with a local population in Perth (Western Australia), initiated from aviary releases.
http://www.birdsinbackyards.net/finder/display.cfm?id=97

So. Are we allowing "escapes"? Or does the "initiated" in "initiated from aviary releases" indicate an introduction ala Red Kites in the UK?

Also, did you sort out the Japanese swan?
ETA: Got a Latin name for the Asian Grey Flycatcher?
 
Last edited:
6/11 Perth, Western Australia:
White-cheeked Honey-eater Phylidonyris nigra (1)
---
(1) I am not 100% sure about this, as the habitat doesn't seem to fit, but there's certainly nothing else in Simpson and Day that fits the look of this bird. Maybe the New Holland Honey-eater P. novaehollandiae but that seem to fit even worse with the habitat... Any help would be appreciated.
The White-cheeked Honeyeater is endemic to eastern and south-western Australia, ranging from east of the Great Divide in Queensland through coastal New South Wales, becoming scattered south to Jervis Bay. Also in south-western Western Australia and from Perth northwards to Murchison River.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-cheeked_Honeyeater
 
Hint. Without my Dec Oz list, the sightings count for the year is 2610.

So, except for our last things, everything's accounted for and added? Great!

So. Are we allowing "escapes"? Or does the "initiated" in "initiated from aviary releases" indicate an introduction ala Red Kites in the UK?[/quopte]

My understanding is that they have a quite steady and solid population there now. I certainly saw heaps after those first, especially when I came back at the end of the month. I would suggest we keep it in, as we'd otherwise have to remove things like all Swedish and Danish Canadian Geese.

Also, did you sort out the Japanese swan?
ETA: Got a Latin name for the Asian Grey Flycatcher?

I have to look these up when I get home. I can't even remember what the issue with the swan is, but I have the name for the flycatcher at home.

EDIT: The Japanese swan should be Cygnus columbianus bewickii.

The White-cheeked Honeyeater is endemic to eastern and south-western Australia, ranging from east of the Great Divide in Queensland through coastal New South Wales, becoming scattered south to Jervis Bay. Also in south-western Western Australia and from Perth northwards to Murchison River.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-cheeked_Honeyeater

As I recall, it looked just like one (and I saw the New Holland one later), but I think the field guide stated they lived in mangroves or something, and this was in the bushes lining a carpark.

Did we get a decision on the ID of this?
I'll have a look tonight at my US field guides and see if I can help.

Isn't that an Eastern Bluebird Sialia sialis?
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom