For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

How do you define uncertainty? When I see the word it can have one of two definitions depending on the context.

good question.

standard usage is pretty clear in each of the technical literatures of physical science, statistics and economics, but it is also different in each. especially the words uncertainty, risk and hazard.

for me, something is uncertain if it is not certain, so if models or experts disagree then that thing they disagree on is uncertain. (agreement does NOT imply certainty, of course.)

so the IPCC makes it clear in the SPM that precip projections are highly uncertain, they do not hide this. that was my point.

    • The condition of being uncertain; doubt, vagueness, ambiguity etc.
    • The estimated amount or percentage by which an observed or calculated value may differ from the true value.
Definition #2 can be quite complex, however is necessary to achieve any degree of confidence in the measurement reported or predicted. In a nutshell, if the relevant errors are not accounted for and included in the uncertainty calculation, the result is still ambiguous and not to be trusted. Uncertainty is a well established statistical methodology in science as I’d assume you know.

handling uncertainty in observations is well-defined and widely taught (in physics as well as stats)

handling uncertainty in statistics, almost always involves selecting a model class, and then assuming it is perfect and dealing with uncertainty within that class of models.

there is no clear methodology for handling uncertainty when you know your model class is inadequate (even if you have a large historical forecast-verification archive, as in weather forecasting)

there are not even good candidates for a clear methodology when extrapolating into new parameter regimes (as in climate science).

so if we require a "well established statistical methodology", then you (inadvertently) rule out any application of current climate science. methodology is often created as we go in science, that is a good reason to be skeptical but nothing more.


Until such time as those factors can be accurately and precisely determined, no amount of parameterizations (fudging) will improve the skillfulness of climate models at predicting future climate.

this argument leads to the conclusion that applied science is impossible. not just climate science, but weather forecasting, circuit design and celestial dynamics.

to confuse "parameterizations" with "fudging" is to confuse having an car accident when your brakes go out with driving into a brickwall on purpose.



Are climate model outputs then the result of well understood climate forcings, feedbacks, established physics etc., or more or less the numerical expression of the programmer’s assumptions?
How might we tell the difference?
 
Nonsense
Al Gore has a miserable academic record. For all those still swooning from his "masterful" presentation, I suggest that anyone who flunks divinity school (all 'F''s) is hardly a guy whose opinion I would want on a topic as incredibly complicated as climate theory. Earth's climate is an infinitely complex nonlinear system that some human beings (in their pomposity)...
Read the full review ›
Published 2 months ago by PhD

Al Gore flunked divinity school? Give that man a cigar!
 
Al Gore flunked divinity school? Give that man a cigar!

It is the core of the AGW belief set, so I have no problem listing it as one that should be read.

The mis statements of the leading propagandist for AGW, aptly dubbed "climate porn". As with Earth is the Balance the book is is replete with interesting anecdotes and laughable bad "science".

But draw your own conclusions.

Next. A list of books on Amazon we should not get our information on climate science from.
 
good question.

standard usage is pretty clear in each of the technical literatures of physical science, statistics and economics, but it is also different in each. especially the words uncertainty, risk and hazard.

for me, something is uncertain if it is not certain, so if models or experts disagree then that thing they disagree on is uncertain. (agreement does NOT imply certainty, of course.)

so the IPCC makes it clear in the SPM that precip projections are highly uncertain, they do not hide this. that was my point.



handling uncertainty in observations is well-defined and widely taught (in physics as well as stats)

handling uncertainty in statistics, almost always involves selecting a model class, and then assuming it is perfect and dealing with uncertainty within that class of models.

there is no clear methodology for handling uncertainty when you know your model class is inadequate (even if you have a large historical forecast-verification archive, as in weather forecasting)

there are not even good candidates for a clear methodology when extrapolating into new parameter regimes (as in climate science).

so if we require a "well established statistical methodology", then you (inadvertently) rule out any application of current climate science. methodology is often created as we go in science, that is a good reason to be skeptical but nothing more.




this argument leads to the conclusion that applied science is impossible. not just climate science, but weather forecasting, circuit design and celestial dynamics.

to confuse "parameterizations" with "fudging" is to confuse having an car accident when your brakes go out with driving into a brickwall on purpose.



How might we tell the difference?

to confuse "parameterizations" with "fudging" is to confuse having an car accident when your brakes go out with driving into a brickwall on purpose.
Confuse? Please clarify the connection in your analogy. If the brakes go out that can be found through investigation. As to whether it was done on purpose who's to say the driver didn't fall asleep? What if another component failed such as the accelerator sticking, suspension breaking? All those questions need answering before a conclusion can be drawn. Imagine piecing the puzzle of an aircraft crash back together, for which part of my job in earlier years was engine failure analysis for intermediate stage compressor sections in gas turbine engines.

this argument leads to the conclusion that applied science is impossible. not just climate science, but weather forecasting, circuit design and celestial dynamics.
Why should climate "science" be immune from the same rigorous standards applied to other fields? Why wouldn't a climate modeler want their models independently verified? Are you suggesting they shouldn't be? It is a closed network protected from outside analysis.

so if we require a "well established statistical methodology", then you (inadvertently) rule out any application of current climate science. methodology is often created as we go in science, that is a good reason to be skeptical but nothing more.
It's not just "well established statistical methodology", it is well established 'best practice' methodology outside of statistics. For instance the surface station network. Common sense alone dictates that placing thermometers at or near parking lots, buildings, air conditioners etc. cannot possibly result in accurate or precise readings. One not need be a climate "scientist" to understand this. The IPCC ignores all criticism of the published temperatures. Ironically, the gatekeepers of the data are the same lead authors in the IPCC chapters on surface temperatures who are rejecting the criticism. Such practices are not tolerated in any industry, but we're dealing with climate "science".

As noted, studies using empirical measurements demonstrating the effects of UHI and land use change have been linked to, however as of yet your only discussion has been to critique what I say. rather than the evidence provided to support it.

so the IPCC makes it clear in the SPM that precip projections are highly uncertain, they do not hide this. that was my point.
Then why is it used as evidence for AGW?


handling uncertainty in statistics, almost always involves selecting a model class, and then assuming it is perfect and dealing with uncertainty within that class of models.
In statistics, it is observed rather than theoretical values considered for empirical measurements. In order to attain statistical confidence in a model output, it first must be tested. The uncertainty is calculated based on quantifiable (qualitatively derived) errors which must be known prior to publishing the results. Again, several articles on climate model uncertainties have been linked to. Please comment on those.

Capeldodger continues to claim climate models are skillful, yet cannot provide one example to support it. Using AGW talking points does not qualify as evidence. We keep hearing how they are "spot on", but which ones, specifically?

Thus when I see statements like "climate models match the surface temperatures", it means nothing if the surface measurements are of spurious origins. In my view they are based on the evidence available, several of which are very recent. This goes back to the core of the discussion; how do climate models come to match observations, if they do?

How might we tell the difference?
I've already suggested how, but one way is through 'Independent Verification and Validation' (look it up). However climate modelers are not eager to allow outsiders audit their work. Do you think they should be required to?

I would appreciate more discussion on the articles posted rather than a nonproductive ping pong game.
 
Why should climate "science" be immune from the same rigorous standards applied to other fields? Why wouldn't a climate modeler want their models independently verified? Are you suggesting they shouldn't be? It is a closed network protected from outside analysis.

That's the thing, it's the only field of science that comes under such scrutiny, except for perhaps evolution. And it's not just scrutiny, it's relentless personal attacks, accusations of fraud, and, god help us, communism.
 
Last edited:
That's the thing, it's the only field of science that comes under such scrutiny

Perhaps because its one of the only fields of science that doesnt have any rigourous standards in place.

Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Mann?
Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Jones?
Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Hansen?

Perhaps a former "oil executive" is the one "officialy" responsible, since he is the one that finds the errors in their work.

And it's not just scrutiny, it's relentless personal attacks, accusations of fraud

Personal attacks? That fits you to a tee. Want me to link to the thread I started that you derailed with them?

Fraud? There is evidence. You derailed a thread that contained some of it. Its the same link. Want to me to link to it?
 
to confuse "parameterizations" with "fudging" is to confuse having an car accident when your brakes go out with driving into a brickwall on purpose.

Confuse? Please clarify the connection in your analogy.

sure. you seemed to imply "parameterizations" were "fudging".

they might be used to cheat, but they are required elements of any computer simulation.

so they can go wrong due to something beyond the programmers control/knowledge (brakes go out) or the programmer can intentionally wreck the scientific value of the simulation by (intentionally driving into a brick wall). or they can provide a simulation that is fit for purpose.

i'd only call the second of those three "fudging".

if we agree on that, then perhaps we can step through some of the other points posted, which i am also happy to clarify. (if not, then i am happy for more on parameterizations. your call).
 
That's the thing, it's the only field of science that comes under such scrutiny, except for perhaps evolution. And it's not just scrutiny, it's relentless personal attacks, accusations of fraud, and, god help us, communism.

I only wish to point out that people who choose to disrespect websites and persons who advocate free market principles, principles of individual liberty, and private property rights, have oriented themselves against such principles.

Seems like a fair assessment.

Modify or correct my assertion in line with your personal beliefs if you like.
 
sure. you seemed to imply "parameterizations" were "fudging".

they might be used to cheat, but they are required elements of any computer simulation.

so they can go wrong due to something beyond the programmers control/knowledge (brakes go out) or the programmer can intentionally wreck the scientific value of the simulation by (intentionally driving into a brick wall). or they can provide a simulation that is fit for purpose.

i'd only call the second of those three "fudging".

if we agree on that, then perhaps we can step through some of the other points posted, which i am also happy to clarify. (if not, then i am happy for more on parameterizations. your call).

A statement that "Global Climate Model XYZ yielded this or that result" might be credible on its merits if it was accompanied with a printout or a link to the full list of parameter and values used to generate those results, along with the code and database versions. Assume that was all archived, and you are given a link to it. The claim can be evaluated.

Now take that converse. You are given a claim that Global Climate Model XYZ produced such and such results, with none of the above supporting documentation and data.

The second scenario is not even wrong, just unquantified and unverifiable.

It should be completely disregarded, of course.
 
Perhaps because its one of the only fields of science that doesnt have any rigourous standards in place.

Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Mann?
Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Jones?
Who is officialy responsible for checking up on the work of Hansen?

Perhaps a former "oil executive" is the one "officialy" responsible, since he is the one that finds the errors in their work.



Personal attacks? That fits you to a tee. Want me to link to the thread I started that you derailed with them?

Fraud? There is evidence. You derailed a thread that contained some of it. Its the same link. Want to me to link to it?

No one is 'officially' in charge of checking anything, there is an ongoing process of research, review, and advancement. That is the history of science. It is always 'wrong', in the sense that it is never really 'right'. Whatever research is done now, is always just an incremental step along the road to knowledge and understanding. This process has proven itself to be robust and successful, and the proof of that is all around you. Despite the frauds, flaws and mistakes, science has triumphed.

The original Mann work was flawed but also pioneering. The vitriol and lies targetted at Mann are unbelievable. If I was him, I wouldn't give any of those people the time of day either, because they are not interested in advancing science, but in destroying it.
 
No one is 'officially' in charge of checking anything, there is an ongoing process of research, review, and advancement. That is the history of science. It is always 'wrong', in the sense that it is never really 'right'. Whatever research is done now, is always just an incremental step along the road to knowledge and understanding. This process has proven itself to be robust and successful, and the proof of that is all around you. Despite the frauds, flaws and mistakes, science has triumphed.

The original Mann work was flawed but also pioneering. The vitriol and lies targetted at Mann are unbelievable. If I was him, I wouldn't give any of those people the time of day either, because they are not interested in advancing science, but in destroying it.

Vicious, indeed ....

http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2007/12/ushcn-crn-qualityplot2.png

Science has triumphed?

The plot is Anthony Watts audit of surface temperature stations.

What are the red and orange dots?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
​
http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpre...alityplot2.png
The plot is Anthony Watts audit of surface temperature stations. What are the red and orange dots?
​
Areas on my screen where photons of a certain range of frequencies are emitted?

You said -
Whatever research is done now, is always just an incremental step along the road to knowledge and understanding. This process has proven itself to be robust and successful, and the proof of that is all around you. Despite the frauds, flaws and mistakes, science has triumphed.
So what are the orange and red dots?
 
Last edited:
La Nina has an immediate effect on global surface temperatures - it directly affects a pretty big swathe of surface, after all. El Nino the same, of course, which is why '98 has become such a refuge.

Not to get to far off subject but isn't it also the prevailing theory that global warming has increased the occurrence of el nino events and we expect more of them with increased warming? I understand your point that an el Nino event like '98 would effect global surface temps to go up (and if I understand correctly, this would be offset by the fact that there would be more cold water "trapped" below the surface).
 
No one is 'officially' in charge of checking anything, there is an ongoing process of research, review, and advancement.

Who is reviewing Mann, Jones, and Hansen please. Surely you arent suggesting that it is the journals they are publishing in.. right?

That is the history of science.

One of the central tenets of Science is independent verification. Who has independently verified the works of Mann, Jones, and Hansen?

(you of course realize that independent verification would require that these bums disclose their methodology and data.. which only court orders seem to get them to do.. sometimes decades after the published research)

The original Mann work was flawed but also pioneering.

Who caught the flaw (hint: "former oil executive"), and what reason did he give for checking? (hint: Mann used presentation techniques that would be illegal in the business world because they mislead)

The vitriol

Indeed. Yours.
 
Last edited:
Who is reviewing Mann, Jones, and Hansen please. Surely you arent suggesting that it is the journals they are publishing in.. right?

One of the central tenets of Science is independent verification. Who has independently verified the works of Mann, Jones, and Hansen?

(you of course realize that independent verification would require that these bums disclose their methodology and data.. which only court orders seem to get them to do..

As you note, skeptics in climate science are commonly vilified and smeared, but are there any published studies by skeptics for which methodology and data are not released and publicly available?

Any?

Any at all?

Somewhere?
 
Update

Exercising my M.O. degree (Master of the Obvious), clearly we should assign a lot more weight to peer-reviewed science than to opinion pieces from free marketeers and other non-expert blow hards.

Yet even here on a skeptical forum, the dubious citations constantly posted by a/gw pseudo-skeptics -- accepted uncritically as fact while the peer-reviewed science is considered suspect at every turn -- never ceases to astound me. Dubious sources such as...

A bumbling associate economics professor. A construction worker (foisted as an oceanographer). A marketing professor. Lyndon Larouche. Malloy / junkscience. CO2 "Science". Heartland Institute ("our mission is to discover, develop, and promote free-market solutions to social and economic problems") and countless other bags of free market hot air. The Marshall Institute. Michael Crichton ad nauseum. An oil industry businessman. A coal mining engineer. An economist. Right-wing lobbyist DCI (and their TechCentral arm). Anonymous bloggers and even anonymous blog commenters. "Here". Paid Exxon shills. Some guy who conducted a study concerning professional basketball. A small businessman from Arizona with a blog. The Czech president who freely admits to ignoring scientific evidence. Countless cherry-pickers who play the 1998-present game (a twisting of reality that borders on the surreal). Last and arguably least, Senator James Inhofe.

And it doesn't even make a dent when a lying propagandist is proven to be a lying propagandist -- the citations just keep on coming. And coming.

(Sorry to flog but I couldn't let my omission of Inhofe go uncorrected.)
 
Updates in blue

Exercising my M.O. degree Master of the Obvious, clearly we should assign a lot more weight to peer-reviewed science than to opinion pieces from free marketeers and other non-expert blow hards.

Yet even here on a skeptical forum, the dubious citations constantly posted by a/gw pseudo skeptics -- accepted uncritically as fact while the peer-reviewed science is considered suspect at every turn -- never ceases to astound me. Dubious sources such as...

A bumbling associate economics professor. A construction worker (foisted as an oceanographer). A marketing professor. Lyndon Larouche. Malloy/junkscience. CO2 "Science". Heartland Institute ("our mission is to discover, develop, and promote free-market solutions to social and economic problems") and countless other bags of free market hot air. The Marshall Institute. Michael Crichton ad nauseum. An oil industry businessman. A coal mining engineer. An economist. Right-wing lobbyist DCI (and their TechCentral arm). Anonymous bloggers and even anonymous blog commenters. "Here". Paid Exxon shills. Some guy who conducted a study concerning professional basketball. A small businessman from Arizona with a blog. The Czech president who freely admits to ignoring scientific evidence. The Viscount Monckton of Brenchley, politician/business consultant. Last and arguably least, Senator James Inhofe, nutjob extraordinaire.

And it doesn't even make a dent when a lying propagandist is proven to be a lying propagandist -- the citations just keep on coming. And coming.

(Nope, this isn't exaggerated.)
 
It reminds me of the HIV stuff that people pass around, and very strangely the 'satanic' study by the Xian right. They use a limited number of suspect sources and then self reference each other shamelessly. You also see this in the anti-psychiatry community and the autism woo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom