For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Oh, there's "coming cooling?" Do you have perchance a crystal ball or something similar? Maybe some kind of model?

Tsonis does say a cooling of about 0.2C from now to 2035. I'm disinclined to call this a prediction, since it is simply the alignment of several natural phenomena causing a slight temperature change. But it might be more accurate as a predictor than the supposed predictors...

AUP mentions the drought down under: Australia does have correlated droughts with El Nino, and wet weather with La Nina. It appears that we are moving into the La Nina phase. Maybe things will change down there?
 
It's the same big orange ball that Met O is relying on.

Capeldodger has a lot of faith in their 'new and improved' model, even though they give no details; there never are. All they say is starting some time after 2009, global warming will return in earnest and temperatures will higher than 1998.

That's what they predict. It's a detailed prediction, quite daring really. You'll soon be able to see how it actually works out.

It's the same thing they said in January 2007.

There's no connection at all between the two.

In January the Met Office predicted that if El Nino conditions continued as they were, '07 would set a record for warmth. The El Nino turned out to be short-lived, and '07 was slightly cooler than '05. Nothing there to do with models or what was going to happen beyond 2007. Just something they said about 2007.

The model predictions that were released later in the year are about the future (and I intend to be here to watch how they turn out).

So not the same thing.

There is going to be cooling regardless of what happens after 2009.

So even if it just keeps getting warmer after 2009 there'll be a cooling regardless? How does that work?

Wanna bet? It's happening now.

In your dreams.

Met O is counting on a strong solar cycle 24 despite Capeldodger's claims to the contrary.

They're not depending on it all, despite your claims that they are. They're using a physical climate model, and one that makes projections way beyond cycle 24, which is what you appear to be depending on.

Thus far, there are more indicators for a weak SC24 than strong, but we'll just have to wait and see. There are other signs as well, but who cares right? In 3-8 years we're all doomed.....

In three-to-eight years I - along with some others - will still be as comfortably smug. You, on the other hand, are doomed to the fate of Sisyphus. Unless you choose to give up seeking ever new reasons for a cooling being always just around the corner.
 
Tsonis does say a cooling of about 0.2C from now to 2035. I'm disinclined to call this a prediction, since it is simply the alignment of several natural phenomena causing a slight temperature change. But it might be more accurate as a predictor than the supposed predictors...

Alignment of what natural phaenomena?

AUP mentions the drought down under: Australia does have correlated droughts with El Nino, and wet weather with La Nina. It appears that we are moving into the La Nina phase. Maybe things will change down there?

La Nina conditions have prevailed through late '07, without the usual impacts on Australian rainfall. That's got some people worried down there, and it's not as if they're new to the subject. Not, for instance, as new as you obviously are.

Have you abandoned the 60-80 year cycle for the flighty charms of La Nina? Signs of a mid-life crisis there.
 
That's what they predict. It's a detailed prediction, quite daring really. You'll soon be able to see how it actually works out.



There's no connection at all between the two.

In January the Met Office predicted that if El Nino conditions continued as they were, '07 would set a record for warmth. The El Nino turned out to be short-lived, and '07 was slightly cooler than '05. Nothing there to do with models or what was going to happen beyond 2007. Just something they said about 2007.

The model predictions that were released later in the year are about the future (and I intend to be here to watch how they turn out).

So not the same thing.



So even if it just keeps getting warmer after 2009 there'll be a cooling regardless? How does that work?



In your dreams.



They're not depending on it all, despite your claims that they are. They're using a physical climate model, and one that makes projections way beyond cycle 24, which is what you appear to be depending on.



In three-to-eight years I - along with some others - will still be as comfortably smug. You, on the other hand, are doomed to the fate of Sisyphus. Unless you choose to give up seeking ever new reasons for a cooling being always just around the corner.

2007 was only slightly cooler than 2005? Based on whose data? That's not what satellite data shows. It disagrees with your source (UHI infested obsolete surface stations), so it must be wrong?

The models are always about the future. We keep hearing how the models from the past accurately predicted today. Where are they? What did they predict? You've already been presented with several studies about climate models. Who has their head in the sand?

There is no if anywhere to be found in the Met O forecast release. Please point it out. They said there was a 60% probability (how did they arrive at that, throwing bones on the ground?) in January 2007. Met O couldn't have been more wrong:
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/2007/pr20070104.htm
The forecast takes into account known contributing factors, such as solar effects, El Niño, greenhouse gases concentrations and other multi-decadal influences.


and

The potential for a record 2007 arises partly from a moderate-strength El Niño already established in the Pacific, which is expected to persist through the first few months of 2007. The lag between El Niño and the full global surface temperature response means that the warming effect of El Niño is extended and therefore has a greater influence the global temperatures during the year.
and of course, always the dire consequences:

Katie Hopkins from Met Office Consulting said: "This new information represents another warning that climate change is happening around the world.
So it appears you are making things up again. Is it spontaneous or do you have to think about it?

The latest RSS data is out. There is still one month to go in 2007.
 
Last edited:
It's the same big orange ball that Met O is relying on.

Capeldodger has a lot of faith in their 'new and improved' model, even though they give no details; there never are. All they say is starting some time after 2009, global warming will return in earnest and temperatures will higher than 1998.

It's the same thing they said in January 2007.

There is going to be cooling regardless of what happens after 2009. Wanna bet? It's happening now. Met O is counting on a strong solar cycle 24 despite Capeldodger's claims to the contrary.

Thus far, there are more indicators for a weak SC24 than strong, but we'll just have to wait and see. There are other signs as well, but who cares right? In 3-8 years we're all doomed.....


This just amuses me now. The met office "is counting on a strong cycle 24." Well, David Rodale is counting on a weak cycle 24.
 
Tsonis does say a cooling of about 0.2C from now to 2035. I'm disinclined to call this a prediction, since it is simply the alignment of several natural phenomena causing a slight temperature change. But it might be more accurate as a predictor than the supposed predictors...

This is comedy gold also. I'm disinclined to call this prediction a prediction because then it would mean it was a prediction just like those other predictions that I don't like the sound of. I do like the sound of this one, so I'll just call it something else and wave my hands about and hope no one notices.
 
Bali is just Monsters in the Closet.

Originally Posted by mhaze It wasn't a point. It was a claim there were monsters in his closet.

And only in the closet. By the way. We're not screwed, unless and until people fall prey to such a climate of fear.
the real world is already providing proof enough.
​
Ridiculous assertions. Next it will be Chicken Little, and the sky is falling
​
"monsters in the closet"? Can you try to keep this debate rooted in reality?

CD said the world is already showing signs of warming. The 4AR provides plenty of information on why scientists are concerned about the environment being disrupted by global warming, it's not a fairy tale.

Quantifying the Influence of Surface Processes and Inhomogeneities On Global Climate Data By Ross McKitrick and Pat Michaels
article just published in the Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres,

Full JGR pdf!
"Our results suggest that as much as half of post 1980 land based "global warming" may be attributable to contamination of the basic data."
​
Not a fairytale? I never said it was. It's....
monsters in the closet!
​
And only in the closet. By the way. We're not screwed.
Unless and until people fall prey to such a climate of fear.
 
Last edited:
Why don't you just go to AIT to find out more about the big wall of water? Your friends at Environmental Defense League? Greenpeace? Hansen? We've discussed this matter here several times, actually I've gotten pretty bored of it. Or if you have a specific point, what is it?
Huh?? I don't even know what AIT is. And I've never cited (nor so much as read!) anything from the other organizations you mention.

Meaning, all you're doing here is changing the subject away from the fact that you've been exposed propagandizing. Again.
 
Huh?? I don't even know what AIT is. And I've never cited (nor so much as read!) anything from the other organizations you mention.

Meaning, all you're doing here is changing the subject away from the fact that you've been exposed propagandizing. Again.

To your credit, you do not in your GW Evidence link to these ridiculous theories of " walls of water".

Exposing propagandizing. Here it is some from an AGW leader.
The Tipping Point?By Jim Hansen

The Earth's climate is nearing, but has not passed, a tipping point beyond which it will be impossible to avoid climate change with far-ranging undesirable consequences. These include not only the loss of the Arctic as we know it, with all that implies for wildlife and indigenous peoples, but losses on a much vaster scale due to rising seas.

Ocean levels will increase slowly at first, as losses at the fringes of Greenland and Antarctica due to accelerating ice streams are nearly balanced by increased snowfall and ice sheet thickening in the ice sheet interiors.

But as Greenland and West Antarctic ice is softened and lubricated by meltwater, and as buttressing ice shelves disappear because of a warming ocean, the balance will tip toward the rapid disintegration of ice sheets.
The Earth's history suggests that with warming of two to three degrees, the new sea level will include not only most of the ice from Greenland and West Antarctica, but a portion of East Antarctica, raising the sea level by twenty-five meters, or eighty feet. Within a century, coastal dwellers will be faced with irregular flooding associated with storms. They will have to continually rebuild above a transient water level.

This grim scenario can be halted if the growth of greenhouse gas emissions is slowed in the first quarter of this century.—From a presentation to the American Geophysical Union, December 6, 2005
​
We were only talking about a 20' wall of waters. Hansen says 80!
​
 
This is comedy gold also. I'm disinclined to call this prediction a prediction because then it would mean it was a prediction just like those other predictions that I don't like the sound of. I do like the sound of this one, so I'll just call it something else and wave my hands about and hope no one notices.

Call it a prediction then.
 
mhaze, I'd like to explain how quotation marks work. You know, those things that look like so:

"<text goes here>"

The text that's inside of the quotation marks is supposed to be something that someone actually said. Because when you use quotation marks, and inside you place something that someone didn't actually say, that's called lying.
 
mhaze, I'd like to explain how quotation marks work. You know, those things that look like so:

"<text goes here>"

The text that's inside of the quotation marks is supposed to be something that someone actually said. Because when you use quotation marks, and inside you place something that someone didn't actually say, that's called lying.

Normally it's not worth replying to such trivial nonsense, but since you brought it up, quotation marks can be used to simply draw attention to or highlight something, a word or a phrase. It does not need to be a direct quote from an individual. It's only in your mind he was attributing "walls of water" as a direct quote.

Hope that helps.

Below may be what you're expecting?
http://www.nationalpost.com/opinion/story.html?id=145245
“manipulations”
“false claims”
“ignored”
“contradicts”
“concealed”
“exaggerated”
“suppress”
“large warming bias”

No comment on the paper MHaze linked to?
http://icecap.us/images/uploads/MM.JGRDec07.pdf
 
Last edited:
mhaze, I'd like to explain how quotation marks work. You know, those things that look like so:

"<text goes here>"

The text that's inside of the quotation marks is supposed to be something that someone actually said. Because when you use quotation marks, and inside you place something that someone didn't actually say, that's called lying.

Your avatar has a nice magnifying glass.

Please use it.

Look for "reality".

You wanted wall of waters, you got it.

You have the link to the source.

Want more?
 
in January 2007. Met O couldn't have been more wrong:
[/SIZE]http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/2007/pr20070104.htm




i'd like to read the press release, but the link you posted does not get me there; couldyou post another please?

thx
 
Capeldodger has a lot of faith in their 'new and improved' model, even though they give no details; there never are.

so i have rather limited "faith" in the current model, but it is silly to say there are no details. details are widely discussed, good things and bad things.

All they say is starting some time after 2009, global warming will return in earnest and temperatures will higher than 1998.

It's the same thing they said in January 2007.

can you provide specific quotes please?

Met O is counting on a strong solar cycle 24
again, this is something of a silly claim. there are people in the met office who honestly believe, who have faith their models can do things which i find astounding. i think they are incorrect, but i know they are not thinking about solar cycles.

you asked some really good questions on this thread; why dilute them by saying things that make you appear clueless to everyone with even a remote connection to the scientists?

or was all the solar stuff a joke?
 
Last edited:
there are people in the met office who honestly believe, who have faith their models can do things which i find astounding. i think they are incorrect, but i know they are not thinking about solar cycles.

you asked some really good questions on this thread; why dilute them by saying things that make you appear clueless to everyone with even a remote connection to the scientists?

or was all the solar stuff a joke?

But what other than Solar 11 year cycle might cause a 2008 decrease, then a 2009 onward increase? No volcanoes, PDO shift yes, but longer term effect, more la Nina, again a general longer term effect.

Maybe the answer is just that they programmed their model to reflect recent cooling, that had some latency, then the tuned C02/AGW parameters overrode that. Giving some cooler, then some hotter.

No actual cause and effect needs to exist with the model...
 
2007 was only slightly cooler than 2005? Based on whose data? That's not what satellite data shows. It disagrees with your source (UHI infested obsolete surface stations), so it must be wrong?

From GISS figures. Which, as you'll be aware, aren't restricted to US surface stations. There are, for instance, UK stations as well. Brits have been at it for a long time, weather observation was invented over here, after all. If your guys are crap at it it's not my problem, or the world's really. The US doesn't account for much of it.

The models are always about the future. We keep hearing how the models from the past accurately predicted today. Where are they? What did they predict? You've already been presented with several studies about climate models. Who has their head in the sand?

Hansen et al 1988 predicted 0.2C per decade over the last two decades, which is pretty much what happened (the model was slightly low, but who's counting?).

When it comes to the 2007 temperature, that's not a product of digital models. It's gone. Past. Nothing to be done about it now.


There is no if anywhere to be found in the Met O forecast release. Please point it out. They said there was a 60% probability (how did they arrive at that, throwing bones on the ground?) in January 2007. Met O couldn't have been more wrong:

They arrived at it because the combined December and January anomoly was at record levels, and there was an El Nino in progress. Comparing this to similar events in the past - such as '98 - and not to models they came to the conclusion they did - a hich probability of a record warm year.

Notice how that has nothing to do with models?


"The potential for a record 2007 arises partly from a moderate-strength El Niño already established in the Pacific, which is expected to persist through the first few months of 2007. The lag between El Niño and the full global surface temperature response means that the warming effect of El Niño is extended and therefore has a greater influence the global temperatures during the year."

Notice the scary alarmist "potential " that you inexplicably failed to bold? You should have been right on that one.

Again, notice the absence of models in your quote.

and of course, always the dire consequences:

Well, let's revisit them in all their direness :

"Katie Hopkins from Met Office Consulting said: "This new information represents another warning that climate change is happening around the world. "

You bold "warning" but where's the dire to follow? Where the doom? Nary a wall of water in sight.

So it appears you are making things up again. Is it spontaneous or do you have to think about it?

I guess the stuff you appear to make up just boils out from a maelstrom of misconnected thought. Models and annual predictions are all mixed up together, then blended with conspiracies and politics and untrustworthy observations into something curiously amorphous.


The latest RSS data is out. There is still one month to go in 2007.
[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_103234757694b1aefd.jpg[/URL]

The meteorological year, by historical accident, runs from December to November. We're in meteorological year 2008 now. (Meteorologists get two New Year's parties, and these are deep-down party people, believe me.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom