For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

But what other than Solar 11 year cycle might cause a 2008 decrease, then a 2009 onward increase? No volcanoes, PDO shift yes, but longer term effect, more la Nina, again a general longer term effect.

La Nina has an immediate effect on global surface temperatures - it directly affects a pretty big swathe of surface, after all. El Nino the same, of course, which is why '98 has become such a refuge.

Maybe the answer is just that they programmed their model to reflect recent cooling, that had some latency, then the tuned C02/AGW parameters overrode that. Giving some cooler, then some hotter.

Schneibster went to a lot of trouble to explain how physical climate models work (on another thread - they do proliferate) and it all just ambled past you.

There has not been a recent cooling, models are not tuned for "desired" CO2 parameters they incorporate a database of tens of thousands of infrared spectra at varying temperature, pressure and humidity, and - last but not least - climate modellers do not make guesses and build a machine to produce that answer. That is no way to build a scientific reputation.

No actual cause and effect needs to exist with the model...

Climate models incorporate physical laws to reproduce sequences of causes and effects. They're a mass of differential equations representing known science. Not data-mined statistical models like the current Solar Cycle obsession - which is a pretty new subject. Not the old unsophisticated Sunspot Cycle, that goes way back (without much luck), but the more involved sciency things about lengths and intensities and shapes of Solar Cycles.

Only a damn' fool or an idiot would nail his flag to Solar Cycle 24, and the Hadley Centre people that have done this work take a longer-term career view than that. And over here they're out of the clutches of Hansen.
 
Some interesting reading for anyone who's interested.

http://www.amsi.org.au/twisted

Enting’s analysis exposes the numerous contradictions in the arguments of the ‘greenhouse sceptics’ and suggests they are far from constituting an alternative to mainstream climate science.
Simple graphical illustrations are used to show that some representations of the data are misleading. In other cases quotes from the sceptics are lined up side by side to show that what passes, in public debate, for an alternative view of science is an inconsistent set of fragments.
"....importantly this book shows, in a non-technical way, how these scams are being foisted into public discussion."
Finally the author presents calculations of the actual emission levels that would be required to stabilise CO2 concentrations. This is an update of calculations that he contributed to the pre-Kyoto IPCC report on Radiative Forcing of Climate. The new calculations demonstrate the extent to which delays in mitigation have increased the difficulty in stabilising greenhouse gases. This defines the real cost of greenhouse denial.

By a former research climate scientist. I'll be buying a copy.


Some chapter headings.
8 Beyond the pretend science
Some aspects of the ‘pretend debate’ that go beyond the
science.
8.1 Alleged motivations Ranging from half-truths to
downright weird.
8.2 Gagging Comparing claims that sceptics are being
gagged, to the reality of political pressure particularly in
Australia and the USA and the so-called ‘culture of fear’
at CSIRO.
8.3 Left-vs-right Proposing that characterising climate
change as a left-vs-right issue is misdirection.
9 The cost of denial
Why it matters.
9.1 Progress of climate science Much of the
increasing certainty about climate change comes from
watching it happen.
9.2 Beyond the great victory The Kyoto Protocol,
discussing various commentaries on Australia’s position.
9.3 Achieving targets Some new calculations showing
the emissions that would be required to stabilise the
amount of CO2 in the atmosphere.
10 Take home messages
Quoting Richard Feynmann: “. . . reality must take
precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be
fooled”
 
They were in fact correct, since they put an error factor on their projection.

Almost every statement should contain a degree of equivocation :).

La Nina conditions are established; how's the summer rainfall turning out? The question may seem premature but Solstice is just around the corner and that's the Solar mid-season. It may not feel that way, but that's inertia for you :).

We celebrate mid-winter Solstice in these parts, and stay smashed for a week so as not to confuse Christians. It's been very mild so far, even by recent comparison. Stormy, though. No shortage of bloody rain (or wind).
 
so i have rather limited "faith" in the current model, but it is silly to say there are no details. details are widely discussed, good things and bad things.



can you provide specific quotes please?

again, this is something of a silly claim. there are people in the met office who honestly believe, who have faith their models can do things which i find astounding. i think they are incorrect, but i know they are not thinking about solar cycles.

you asked some really good questions on this thread; why dilute them by saying things that make you appear clueless to everyone with even a remote connection to the scientists?

or was all the solar stuff a joke?

2002:
Met Office "new" weather prediction model.
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/nwp/numerical/unified_model/new_dynamics.html

Science Daily May 2003:
"New" climate model.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2003/05/030521092312.htm

August 2007:
Another "new" model.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/conte...el&searchid=1&FIRSTINDEX=0&resourcetype=HWCIT
Previous climate model projections of climate change accounted for external forcing from natural and anthropogenic sources but did not attempt to predict internally generated natural variability. We present a new modeling system that predicts both internal variability and externally forced changes and hence forecasts surface temperature with substantially improved skill throughout a decade, both globally and in many regions. Our system predicts that internal variability will partially offset the anthropogenic global warming signal for the next few years. However, climate will continue to warm, with at least half of the years after 2009 predicted to exceed the warmest year currently on record.
Natural? Offset? What is offsetting the anthropogenic signal?


http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/2007/pr20070810.html
The forecast for 2014... Climate scientists at the Met Office Hadley Centre will unveil the first decadal climate prediction model in a paper published on 10 August 2007 in the journal Science. The paper includes the Met Office's prediction for annual global temperature to 2014.
Over the 10-year period as a whole, climate continues to warm and 2014 is likely to be 0.3 °C warmer than 2004. At least half of the years after 2009 are predicted to exceed the warmest year currently on record
These predictions are very relevant to businesses and policy-makers who will be able to respond to short-term climate change when making decisions today. The next decade is within many people's understanding and brings home the reality of a changing climate.
The new model incorporates the effects of sea surface temperatures as well as other factors such as man-made emissions of greenhouse gases, projected changes in the sun's output and the effects of previous volcanic eruptions — the first time internal and external variability have both been predicted.
Team leader, Dr Doug Smith said: "Occurrences of El Nino, for example, have a significant effect on shorter-term predictions. By including such internal variability, we have shown a substantial improvement in predictions of surface temperature." Dr Smith continues: "Observed relative cooling in the Southern Ocean and tropical Pacific over the last couple of years was correctly predicted by the new system, giving us greater confidence in the model’s performance".
Is the "new" model in 2007 the same "new" model from 2003?

Now, what do you suppose "projected changes in the sun's output" means? Weren't we told back in July (Lockwood et al) the sun isn't a factor in warming anymore? Didn't natural variation in climate go away 20 years ago? Or could it be that Met O is relying on an off-the-chart SC24 predicted by Dikpati et al ?

If their model includes solar output, what if SC24 is very weak as predicted by Schatten et al?

Then the question is, why hasn't the earth warmed for the last several years? What possible internal variability could have caused it? There has been no volcanoes since 1992 and yet it is cooling. Why?

If Met O is going to publish in Science in August 2007, and they claim their model predicted (I'm assuming it was hindcast as well) up to August 2007, surely they should have been able to predict the current cold snap and give the reasons why. Where are they now that it's four months after the big announcement, hurriedly tuning perhaps for the next news release claiming their models are "spot on"?

Maybe Met O wasn't thinking about solar cycles in January or April 2007, but they are now.
 
La Nina has an immediate effect on global surface temperatures - it directly affects a pretty big swathe of surface, after all. El Nino the same, of course, which is why '98 has become such a refuge.



Schneibster went to a lot of trouble to explain how physical climate models work (on another thread - they do proliferate) and it all just ambled past you.

There has not been a recent cooling, models are not tuned for "desired" CO2 parameters they incorporate a database of tens of thousands of infrared spectra at varying temperature, pressure and humidity, and - last but not least - climate modellers do not make guesses and build a machine to produce that answer. That is no way to build a scientific reputation.



Climate models incorporate physical laws to reproduce sequences of causes and effects. They're a mass of differential equations representing known science. Not data-mined statistical models like the current Solar Cycle obsession - which is a pretty new subject. Not the old unsophisticated Sunspot Cycle, that goes way back (without much luck), but the more involved sciency things about lengths and intensities and shapes of Solar Cycles.

Only a damn' fool or an idiot would nail his flag to Solar Cycle 24, and the Hadley Centre people that have done this work take a longer-term career view than that. And over here they're out of the clutches of Hansen.

More dopey unsupported statements; another speech.

Now, since there's been no recent cooling, please explain to us what the squiggly blue means when it appears to be pointing downward at the right side of the graph. The relatively straight red line is CO2. Note the r squared number of .42. That means the correlation is quite low. If calculating r squared beginning in 1996, it's almost zero.



The only thing you have right in the above, possibly without even realizing it, is during warm periods it's mostly La Ninas and during cooling periods it's mostly El Ninos as shown below. Since there has been no volcanoes since 1992, something else must be responsible for the blue squiggly line moving downward. What do you suppose that is?


Could it be:
 
Last edited:
Some interesting reading for anyone who's interested.
http://www.amsi.org.au/twisted
By a former research climate scientist. I'll be buying a copy.
Some chapter headings.


I checked amazon. They had three pages of books "Twisted" including one by Jeffrey Dearer (good), kellerman (good) but.... No Twisted by Enter.

So.... how about Lomborg? Yes, 3 1/2 stars for his ratings.


Cool It: The Skeptical Environmentalist's Guide to Global Warming
by Bjørn Lomborg (Author)
See all 47 customer reviews...
orange-arrow._V42752349_.gif
See all 2 discussions...

(47 customer reviews)
The most helpful favorable review 151 of 196 people found the following review helpful:
He makes sense
In COOL IT; Dr Lomborg, again, hits the nail on the head. One of the few scientists in the world who is willing to buck the popular and political trend, Dr Lomborg looks at a lot of data and then draws a scientific conclusion. It is amazing how many of those who disagree with Dr Lomborg are trying to stifle his and other's similar comments. Where is the debate? His...

Read the full review ›

what else might be on Amazon?


Unstoppable Global Warming: Every 1,500 Years,Updated and Expanded Edition (Paperback)
by S. Fred Singer (Author)
See all 135 customer reviews...
(135 customer reviews)

Hey, this is fun!! What else could there be?


Shattered Consensus: The True State of Global Warming (Paperback)
by Patrick J. Michaels (Author)
See all 13 customer reviews...

(13 customer reviews)



I'll be buying these. They seem to be highly rated, don't they?
 
Last edited:
Lomborg has no idea what he is talking about, I wouldn't waste your time. His shallow analyses is exemplified by his rating of Australia as having plenty of water. This is done by taking the average rainfall for the country, which is huge, and dividing it by the population, which is small. He completely ignores the fact that most of it is desert. :rolleyes:
 
Lomborg has no idea what he is talking about, I wouldn't waste your time. His shallow analyses is exemplified by his rating of Australia as having plenty of water. This is done by taking the average rainfall for the country, which is huge, and dividing it by the population, which is small. He completely ignores the fact that most of it is desert. :rolleyes:
where does he say that?
 
again, this is something of a silly claim. there are people in the met office who honestly believe, who have faith their models can do things which i find astounding. i think they are incorrect, but i know they are not thinking about solar cycles.
or was all the solar stuff a joke?

But what other than Solar 11 year cycle might cause a 2008 decrease, then a 2009 onward increase?

lots and lots and lots of things, that is why they call it "natural variability".

both the real world and the models wiggle up and down a lot; one of the poor presentation issues of the IPCC report is that they tend to show only ensemble means (which tend to rise pretty smoothly) and "bands" in the SPMs.

the ensemble mean can increase quite smoothly over 30 years, even if every model that went into that mean has three years of cooling off every now and then. i expect the presentation of information in this way will come back to haunt us.

Maybe the answer is just that they programmed their model to reflect recent cooling,

do you mean intentionally? as in taking a dive in a boxing match?

No actual cause and effect needs to exist with the model...

this was a problem Newton recognised, there is no cause and effect in Newton's Laws, save LaPlace's ~the current state of the universe is the cause of its subsequent state~; not sure about the universe but this is certainly true regarding computer models and Newton's Laws.
 
[/quote]
Is the "new" model in 2007 the same "new" model from 2003?

Weren't we told back in July (Lockwood et al) the sun isn't a factor in warming anymore? Didn't natural variation in climate go away 20 years ago? Or could it be that Met O is relying on an off-the-chart SC24 predicted by Dikpati et al ?

in order: i think not (year to year). no. no.

Maybe Met O wasn't thinking about solar cycles in January or April 2007, but they are now.

i think you are mistaken, the solar impact in the models is fairly well understood (much better than on the Earth, anyway).

but i concede your quotes are (again) rather interesting, and certainly ambiguous. i'll try and find out what solar forcing was used...

i assume you do not have a citation on that too?
 
More dopey unsupported statements; another speech.

Now, since there's been no recent cooling, please explain to us what the squiggly blue means when it appears to be pointing downward at the right side of the graph.

Perhaps because NH winter's coming on, but it's impossible to tell since there's no caption, references, or explanation of either scale. As it stands it's just a picture. One can certainly surmise that the right-hand scale is CO2-load, but what does the left-hand scale relate to?

The relatively straight red line is CO2. Note the r squared number of .42. That means the correlation is quite low. If calculating r squared beginning in 1996, it's almost zero.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_103234758aa81c043f.jpg

Is it your contention that the world is not warmer now than in 1996? If not that, what is your contention?

You seem to have fallen into the same error as mhaze - that climate will correlate directly with CO2-load. That will happen given enough time at equilibrium, because CO2-load changes the global energy-budget, it doesn't create energy itself. However there has been neither time nor a stable CO2-load to equilabrate with (check out the red not-so-squiggly line). You're r-squared of whatever is apparently worth squat because it's addressing a meaningless question.


The only thing you have right in the above, possibly without even realizing it, is during warm periods it's mostly La Ninas and during cooling periods it's mostly El Ninos as shown below.

What length periods are you referring to? '98 was a pretty warm period, with very strong El Nino conditions.

Since there has been no volcanoes since 1992, something else must be responsible for the blue squiggly line moving downward. What do you suppose that is?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_103234703ba621b1ee.jpg

I'm left to surmise what the blue squiggly line represents. Can you not provide direct links to sources as well as pictures extracted from them?


Could it be what? Another picture?

Yet more "What about this?". Well, what about it? Give us some speech.
 
Lomborg has no idea what he is talking about, I wouldn't waste your time. His shallow analyses is exemplified by his rating of Australia as having plenty of water. This is done by taking the average rainfall for the country, which is huge, and dividing it by the population, which is small. He completely ignores the fact that most of it is desert. :rolleyes:

And he completely ignores watersheds, which are what define fundamental human divisions. To Lomborg and his ilk Australia is just another nation on the list, near Austria and not that far from Denmark (alphabetically, and why not? A nation is a nation, after all).

Austrians ship excess precipitation across country, from West to East. Why shouldn't Australians?
 
More "where to get Ur Climate Info" (Amazon)

P152 of TSE. Australians are third best off in the world of water/capita, didn't you know, way ahead of the English.

I'll have to check that table in context when the book comes in.

In the meantime, more Amazon goodies -

The Chilling Stars: The New Theory of Climate Change(Paperback)
by Henrik Svensmark (Author)
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
The authors explain their theory that sub-atomic particles from exploded stars have more effect on the climate than manmade CO2. Their conclusion stems from Svensmark's research which has shown the previously unsuspected role that cosmic rays play in creating clouds. During the last 100 years cosmic rays became scarcer because unusually vigorous action by the Sun batted away many of them. Fewer cosmic rays meant fewer clouds--and a warmer world. The theory, simply put here but explained in fascinating detail, emerges at a time of intense public and political concern about climate change. Motivated only by their concern that science must be trustworthy, Svensmark and Calder invite their readers to put aside their preconceptions about manmade global warming and look afresh at the role of Nature in this hottest of world issues.
(20 customer reviews)

Meltdown: The Predictable Distortion of Global Warming by Scientists, Politicians, and the Media (Paperback)
by Patrick J. Michaels (Author)
(47 customer reviews

The Satanic Gases: Clearing the Air about Global Warming (Paperback)
by Patrick J. Michaels (Author)
(33 customer reviews)

Editorial Reviews
From Library Journal
Michaels (climatology, Univ. of Virginia) and Balling (director, Laboratory of Climatology, Arizona State Univ., Tempe) Their main thesis is that politicians and the media have blown this issue out of proportion, manipulating currently known information in order to fulfill their own objectives. The authors also assert that the current scientific paradigm accepts as fact both global warming and humankind's contributions to its acceleration. Scientists therefore tend to ignore contradictory data. Michaels and Balling present a good discussion of the climatological factors and theories of climate change and of the human activities that could be influencing climate.....conservative political agenda is also very apparent......book is recommended for public, academic, and high school environmental collections as a good balance to alarmist materials that present global warming as an imminent catastrophe.

An Inconvenient Truth: The Crisis of Global Warming (Hardcover)
by Al Gore (Author)

Nonsense
Al Gore has a miserable academic record. For all those still swooning from his "masterful" presentation, I suggest that anyone who flunks divinity school (all 'F''s) is hardly a guy whose opinion I would want on a topic as incredibly complicated as climate theory. Earth's climate is an infinitely complex nonlinear system that some human beings (in their pomposity)...
Read the full review ›
Published 2 months ago by PhD

A must read!, August 21, 2007
By Sahra Badou "Bibliophile" My first impression upon reading this book was utter amazement and fear. In fact, "An Inconvenient Truth" is billed as the scariest book you'll ever see. Could it be that life on Earth as we know it will end within the next 50 years? ....Gore blames CO2 for the temperature hikes we are experiencing worldwide....left me no room for doubt regarding the reality of global warming as Earth's ultimate environmental crisis and eventual doom.
 
Is the "new" model in 2007 the same "new" model from 2003?

no, of course not.

while one can complain that models are "updated" too often, to ignore changes in computer resources since 2003 would be suicidal in any scientifically competative field. (of course they could have used the extra cpu power for ensembles of model runs...).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom