MikeMangum
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2008
- Messages
- 1,856
As I pointed out in other posts, our gun regulation here is tough, but not overly so. People that shouldn't own guns legally can be excluded, while those that need to have them legitimately can get them easily, yet many in the US would call our gun laws highly restrictive because you have to hold a licence to own one.
Actually, you are wrong. "People that shouldn't own guns legally can [NOT] be excluded" for the simple reason that only those who are legally allowed to own guns can be compelled to register them. A felon who has lost the right to own a gun can not be convicted of failing to register a gun due to 5th Amendment rights against self incrimination.
Haynes v United States
The National Firearms Act of 1934 required the registration of certain types of firearms.
Miles Edward Haynes was a convicted felon who was charged with failing to register a firearm under the above mentioned act. Haynes, however, argued that because he was a convicted felon, and thus prohibited from owning a firearm, requiring him to register was essentially requiring him to make an open admission to the government that he was in violation of the law, which was thus a violation of his right not to incriminate himself.
The Court's decision
In an 7-1 decision, the Court ruled in favor of Haynes.