Fight for your right to bare arms!!

As I pointed out in other posts, our gun regulation here is tough, but not overly so. People that shouldn't own guns legally can be excluded, while those that need to have them legitimately can get them easily, yet many in the US would call our gun laws highly restrictive because you have to hold a licence to own one.

Actually, you are wrong. "People that shouldn't own guns legally can [NOT] be excluded" for the simple reason that only those who are legally allowed to own guns can be compelled to register them. A felon who has lost the right to own a gun can not be convicted of failing to register a gun due to 5th Amendment rights against self incrimination.

Haynes v United States
The National Firearms Act of 1934 required the registration of certain types of firearms.

Miles Edward Haynes was a convicted felon who was charged with failing to register a firearm under the above mentioned act. Haynes, however, argued that because he was a convicted felon, and thus prohibited from owning a firearm, requiring him to register was essentially requiring him to make an open admission to the government that he was in violation of the law, which was thus a violation of his right not to incriminate himself.

The Court's decision
In an 7-1 decision, the Court ruled in favor of Haynes.
 
BTW, I'm pretty sure that the initial assertion that "the sentiment to protect Second Amendment rights [is] a straw man to divert attention away from more important issues" like health care "reform" has been shown to be in error.
 
Actually, you are wrong. "People that shouldn't own guns legally can [NOT] be excluded" for the simple reason that only those who are legally allowed to own guns can be compelled to register them. A felon who has lost the right to own a gun can not be convicted of failing to register a gun due to 5th Amendment rights against self incrimination.

Haynes v United States

You are conflicting registering, and owning. Depending on the state he was in, he could have been charged with "Criminal possession of a firearm" at which point it wouldn't have mattered if it was registered or not.
 
Last edited:
But everyone in your state (except convicted felons) is still subject to gun registration requirements if they go elsewhere, so you aren't actually exempted, there just aren't any that apply to you within your own state.

What? If I move from Tennessee to Iowa, I'm not required to register my legally owned firearms in Iowa simply because I relocated.


What are you saying?
 
You are conflicting registering, and owning. Depending on the state he was in, he could have been charged with "Criminal possession of a firearm" at which point it wouldn't have mattered if it was registered or not.

No, I am not conflating registering with owning. In states where registration is required to own a gun, only people who are NOT felons can be prosecuted for failing to register their gun, as required by law. Yes, the felon can indeed be charged with a possession related offense, but ONLY non felons can be charged with a failure to register a gun.

Or do you think that the Supreme Court somehow incorrectly conflated registering and owning firearms?
 
BTW, I'm pretty sure that the initial assertion that "the sentiment to protect Second Amendment rights [is] a straw man to divert attention away from more important issues" like health care "reform" has been shown to be in error.

I disagree. Yes, Obama is for gun regulation. No, I have not yet seen evidence that he wants to repeal the Second Amendment. I'd be willing to bet that the majority of Americans favor regulating gun sales, like Obama. Where is the evidence that Obama wants to take away the right to keep and bear arms?
 
Trick question. No one is required to register their firearms in my State.
The state I moved from 4 years ago requires handguns to be registered.

Don't think it has changed.

BTW: I help write this states' shall Issue law in 2000.

DDWW
 
No, I am not conflating registering with owning. In states where registration is required to own a gun, only people who are NOT felons can be prosecuted for failing to register their gun, as required by law. Yes, the felon can indeed be charged with a possession related offense, but ONLY non felons can be charged with a failure to register a gun.

Or do you think that the Supreme Court somehow incorrectly conflated registering and owning firearms?

I don't really care what the SCOUS said about registering a firearm, I was talking about legally owning a firearm. You brought up the red herring of registration.
 
Would it be fair to say that the 2nd Amendment is specifically related to the possible rapid formation of a militia, and has nothing whatsoever to do with the keeping of firearms for shooting rats, burglars and the like?
That the 2nd Amendment is in fact archaic, given that the likelihood of a need for a militia is so close to zero that invasion by giant radioactive Martian ants is a bigger worry?
 
Would it be fair to say that the 2nd Amendment is specifically related to the possible rapid formation of a militia, and has nothing whatsoever to do with the keeping of firearms for shooting rats, burglars and the like?

No, it would not be. Regardless of the justification for granting the right to bear arms, that right is given. If people want to exercise that right for shooting rats, burglars and the like, they are entitled to do so.

That the 2nd Amendment is in fact archaic,

That statement has no legal meaning. The 2nd amendment, along with every other line of the constitution and its other amendment, has the full force of law until it is repealed. If you do not accept that, then there's no point in holding to the constitution at all, so you might as well throw it away.
 
Can you define what a 'right' is then?

Something granted to people of a country by their Government's formative (or later) legislation, in the case of the US, the Constitution, in New Zealand, The Bill of Rights. Things identified globally as a Right are Human Rights, others are only rights in a country, state, or smaller jurisdiction.

In this case I believe he was using the word "right" as in "moral" or "correct" though.
 
Haynes v United States

Quote:
The National Firearms Act of 1934 required the registration of certain types of firearms.

Miles Edward Haynes was a convicted felon who was charged with failing to register a firearm under the above mentioned act. Haynes, however, argued that because he was a convicted felon, and thus prohibited from owning a firearm, requiring him to register was essentially requiring him to make an open admission to the government that he was in violation of the law, which was thus a violation of his right not to incriminate himself.

The Court's decision
In an 7-1 decision, the Court ruled in favor of Haynes.

I love this ruling and will proceed apace to spread it to FOTL variants wherever I find them. They're so obsessed, I can see a movement starting... "Commit a Felony To Assure Your Unfettered Freedom to Lock and Load". (Hey, it'll work as well as their Admiralty Courts and Upper Case Letter ploys!)
 
No, it would not be. Regardless of the justification for granting the right to bear arms, that right is given.

Actually, no. That's why I posted the text of the Second Amendment earlier in this thread. Taken literally, the amendment stipulates that the federal government would not interfere with armament as long as such was connected to a well-regulated militia. The courts have ruled that this could not have been the intent of the amendment as this would deprive many citizens of a necessary tool for their pursuit of life, liberty, and so on.

The Second Amendment is vague enough that courts have had a difficult time interpreting it. The current interpretation allows for most citizens to own guns but it's not etched in stone.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom