Fight for your right to bare arms!!

Again no, a red hering is an attempt to distract or derail, much like you are doing now. The post above mine referenced the SCOUS denying cities the ability to introduce gun control, my post responded to that, thus was on topic.

If you want to argue the whole bringing up of the gun issue is a red herring to throw light off the health bill, well you may have a case, but my post wasn't responsible for that.

Fair enough. I was actually implying the latter.
 
Is sentiment to protect the environment a straw man to divert attention away from X?

It is possible for people to be concerned about more than one issue at a time.

I don't think it's a straw man to be very concerned about environmental issues, and yes, of course people can be concerned about more than one issue at a time. But I wasn't aware of any initiative by the Obama Administration or anyone else to repeal the Second Amendment.

So what? It's Facebook.

Yes, but 199,000 real human beings signed up, that appear (from their posts) to be very angry about Obama trying to take their guns away.

Regarding the issue of this being a straw man argument or not. From the Wikipedia article on the topic:

A straw man argument is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man_argument#cite_note-book-0

The idea that liberals and/or Obama are trying to repeal the Second Amendment, or otherwise take guns away from Americans, is a misrepresentation. I remember seeing a Tea Party sign that said "Obama give me back my gun" (or something to that effect).
 
No it wasn't, because it doesn't in any way, shape, or form display any threat to the Second Amendment as a precedence for all-of-the-sudden trying to make it a more up-front or important issue. Considering healthcare is on the table in Congress currently and the right to bear arms is not, I would say that his post displayed quite clearly that it is a strawman.

Who is "all-of-the-sudden trying to make it a more up-front or important issue"? Firstly, the people for whom the Second Amendment is a big deal are ALWAYS talking about the Second Amendment; you can't get them to shut up about it, myself included. Secondly, the Second Amendment isn't a one time issue, like a big push to get health care passed in Congress; it is similar to the First Amendment in that it is a constant, lower level issue. Protecting a specific right is something that requires constant battles...that's why we have persistant groups like the ACLU or NRA with substantial longevity but not analagous groups for specific policy implementations. Secondly, there is an extremely important case coming up before the Supreme Court regarding the Second Amendment. It was, in fact, the case discussed in my link.


Your claim is that 1) some people are now making a fuss about about the Second Amendment, 2) these same people are making a bigger issue of the Second Amendment than they usually do, 3) that they don't really need to concern themselves with worrying about their Second Amendment rights, and 4) that the entire argument is simply sturm und drang to distract attention from policy proposal X.

Horse feathers.

There are significant and ongoing attempts to curtail Second Amendment rights (as evidenced in this very thread - your strawman suddenly came to life) and some people are particularly focused and vocal about those specific rights (and have been on a consistent basis) and (oh by the way) there happens to be the single biggest Second Amendment case to be heard soon by the Supreme Court.

People who are opposed to the current health care "reform" don't need to use any distraction techniques; just the opposite. The more people learn about the bill, the less support there is for it.
 
Is it just me, or is the sentiment to protect Second Amendment rights a straw man to divert attention away from more important issues (like health care reform)?

You mean, just like the civil rights movement was really a cover for forcing a communist revolution?
 
OK, so there are people that would like to repeal the Second Amendment. Is there any evidence that Obama wants to do such a thing?

You mean, just like the civil rights movement was really a cover for forcing a communist revolution?

No. There are folks that believe Obama has an agenda to stop Americans from bearing arms. AFAIK, there is zero evidence for this. The civil rights movement was a very real fight that had very tangible results. I'm missing the analogy.
 
Last edited:
OK, so there are people that would like to repeal the Second Amendment. Is there any evidence that Obama wants to do such a thing?



No. There are folks that believe Obama has an agenda to stop Americans from bearing arms. AFAIK, there is zero evidence for this. The civil rights movement was a very real fight that had very tangible results. I'm missing the analogy.

You mean aside from the words that came out of his mouth and his votes in the Illinois Congress? He spent all of his political career advocating for very strong gun control (and in some cases, outright bans) but then veered towards the conter when he started running for President.

http://www.ontheissues.org/domestic/Barack_Obama_Gun_Control.htm]voting record
 
You mean aside from the words that came out of his mouth and his votes in the Illinois Congress? He spent all of his political career advocating for very strong gun control (and in some cases, outright bans) but then veered towards the conter when he started running for President.

http://www.ontheissues.org/domestic/Barack_Obama_Gun_Control.htm]voting record

I looked at the link, but I'm missing the part where he's for repealing the Second Amendment. I understand that Obama and many other liberals are for gun control. That's not the same as repealing the 2nd Amendment though, and that's not the same thing as depriving American their right to bear arms. Many of us feel that banks and corporations should be regulated; that doesn't mean we're against Capitalism.

FactCheck.org on Obama and guns:

http://www.factcheck.org/elections-2008/nra_targets_obama.html
http://www.factcheck.org/2008/12/obamas-gun-ban/
 
Last edited:
I looked at the link, but I'm missing the part where he's for repealing the Second Amendment.

Well, negative fecal matter, investigator. No politician is EVER going to come right out and say that they want to repeal one of the Amendments that make up the Bill of Rights. They will simply propose (or not even propose, just implement) policies that violate that specific clause of the Constitution.

Did George W. Bush ever advocate Amending the Constitution to remove habeus corpus protections? Newp. He simply denied habeus protections to certain individuals. Is your argument that because Bush never openly advocated for removing the clause regarding habeus corpus from the Constitution, that there was no merit at all in arguments against Bush's actions wrt habeus rights of terror detainees?

That's got to be the one of the most amazing arguments I've ever read.

Obama has (in the past, not currently) taken stands that are clearly at odds with the Second Amendment; complete bans on all firearms of any type in Chicago, for instance. Enumerated rights of the Constitution do not need to be regulated. Do you need a license to engage in free speech, or freedom of religion? Do you need to register with the police before you are granted freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures? Do you need to pay a fee to the government before you are granted protection against double jeopardy? Do you have to pass a government mandated class before you gain the right to not self incriminate? Which of the other enumerated rights are subject to regulation?
 
What about the right to bear alms?

You may not think Yogi and Boo-boo are entitled to raid pic-a-nic baskets, but can we not find some form of charitable donation for our ursine friends?
 
Excellent.... 25-30,000 people die every year in the US by gunshots and 70-80,000 are shot and wounded, but hey, most of them are suicides or criminals shooting each other so who cares right? Why bother making sure that those with and carrying guns are sensible and stable enough to do so when you can give everyone them and kill off the population of a small town every year. Helps keep the population down.

For the last ten years we have averaged about 41,000 deaths each year in the US due to automobile accidents. Automobiles are doing a better job at controlling our population than guns.

ETA: my bare arms.
1116848fbd035a1b37.jpg

1116848fbd035da179.jpg
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=14097
 
Last edited:
Quiz question #1:


What is the only class of United States citizen who is exempt from gun registration laws?


DD (not me) WW
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom