Fight for your right to bare arms!!

So under the equal protection clause, should I have the right to bear the same type of arms that the Indians have? I mean, protection from the wild savages is exactly what the second amendment was all about, isn't it? ;)
 
No to all.

The correct answer is......Convicted Felons!

DD (didn’t see that one coming did you!) WW
 
OK, so there are people that would like to repeal the Second Amendment. Is there any evidence that Obama wants to do such a thing?

Repeal it? No. But his understanding of it appears to be at odds with the Supreme Court's understanding of it. There is evidence that Obama favors legislation which would violate the 2nd amendment as understood by the Supreme Court. The distinction does matter, but gun rights advocates are not wrong to view Obama as hostile to their interests.
 

It is illegal for a convicted felon to own a firearm. If they did have one illegally they are not compelled to register the firearm, as registration would be self incriminating, and therefore not required under the 5th Amendment. (As a Federal Court ruled many years ago).

DD(But as G. Gordon Liddy says, "As a convicted felon I cannot legally own a gun, but Mrs. Liddy owns a bunch of them!)WW
 
For the last ten years we have averaged about 41,000 deaths each year in the US due to automobile accidents. Automobiles are doing a better job at controlling our population than guns.
And yet to have an automobile you need to register it, and have a licence to use it....
 
And yet to have an automobile you need to register it, and have a licence to use it....

You don't need to register a car to own it, only to drive it on public roads. You don't need a license to own a car either, but (again) only to drive it on public roads. Legally speaking, driving is a privilege, not a right, and so the state has quite a bit of authority to regulate driving on public roads. Because of the ubiquity of driving, it may seem strange that it can be more restricted than gun ownership, but constitutionally speaking, that just isn't so.
 
The "and yet" seems out of place. Cars are more deadly than guns; cars are more tightly regulated than guns. This fits.

Are cars more deadly, or is it just that more people use them and use them more often? Which is higher, the deaths per use of firearms, or the deaths per use of cars?
 
You don't need to register a car to own it, only to drive it on public roads. You don't need a license to own a car either, but (again) only to drive it on public roads. Legally speaking, driving is a privilege, not a right, and so the state has quite a bit of authority to regulate driving on public roads. Because of the ubiquity of driving, it may seem strange that it can be more restricted than gun ownership, but constitutionally speaking, that just isn't so.
However as I previously noted, it is already regulated as to who can and can't have a gun. Convicted Felons cannot own guns for instance. This is a form of regulation right there. The debate isn't "should there regulation?" but rather, "how much regulation should there be?"
 
However as I previously noted, it is already regulated as to who can and can't have a gun. Convicted Felons cannot own guns for instance.

Oh, but that's not the same at all. Convicted felons can't own guns because they've forfeited a right to own guns by committing a felony. And it's not the only right they forfeit.

The debate isn't "should there regulation?" but rather, "how much regulation should there be?"

I'm not suggesting that we can't or shouldn't have any regulations. But those regulations are constrained by the constitution, because gun ownership IS a right. There is no similar constitutional restraint on regulations regarding driving on public roads, because driving is not a right.
 
Quiz question #1:


What is the only class of United States citizen who is exempt from gun registration laws?


DD (not me) WW

Trick question. No one is required to register their firearms in my State.
 
Trick question. No one is required to register their firearms in my State.

But everyone in your state (except convicted felons) is still subject to gun registration requirements if they go elsewhere, so you aren't actually exempted, there just aren't any that apply to you within your own state.
 
The "and yet" seems out of place. Cars are more deadly than guns; cars are more tightly regulated than guns. This fits.

The ownership of cars is actually not regulated at all. Driving a car is not regulated either. You can own and drive whatever car you want, without any license, without any vehicle registration, and without any insurance...until you want to drive that vehicle on public roads.

That's why there is the term Street Legal, as opposed to the simple binary of legal and illegal.
In the United States, the individual states have the authority to determine, by means of statutes and regulations, which types of vehicles are permitted on public streets, as a function of the police power.

You do not have a right to drive a vehicle on public roads.
 
Oh, but that's not the same at all. Convicted felons can't own guns because they've forfeited a right to own guns by committing a felony. And it's not the only right they forfeit.
Only because the Government has placed it in Law that they lose that right, this the Government has introduced regulations on who has the right and who doesn't. The 2nd Amendment doesn't say "everyone but convicted felons have the right to bear arms" the Government does. Further the Government often regulates what right can be exercised, where and when. Take free speech... You can't yell "Fire" in a crowded theatre, nor can you use Free Speech to incite violence. If you went into the Capital Building and tried to shout down Obama's SOTU address no right to free speech would have saved you being tossed out on your ear, if not tossed in a cell too.

I'm not suggesting that we can't or shouldn't have any regulations. But those regulations are constrained by the constitution, because gun ownership IS a right. There is no similar constitutional restraint on regulations regarding driving on public roads, because driving is not a right.

As I pointed out in other posts, our gun regulation here is tough, but not overly so. People that shouldn't own guns legally can be excluded, while those that need to have them legitimately can get them easily, yet many in the US would call our gun laws highly restrictive because you have to hold a licence to own one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom