Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Depends on the beer. Prohibition seems to have done great damage to the American taste for good beer, but the discriminating palate can still find the gems among the rabbit poo.

I live in the St. Loser (the "Gateway City") area. Budweiser nearly turned this place into a beer desert. There are a few micros that are worth drinking, but only if the supply from Europe is cut off somehow.
 
As compared to the skunk piss in Heineken,...
At this point I'd like to inject that Heineken is just about Holland's blandest beer, it's a Pilsener, and the export version is extra tasteless to minimize the number of people who think it tastes bad. You're not exactly comparing apples here.
 
I believe there was no cause of God.


elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/who-created-god-t77.htm


How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence. But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence. That ever-existing thing is what we call God. God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence. God is the uncreated Creator who created the universe and everything in it.



everystudent.com/wires/created.html


If something comes into being, it must have been prompted by something else. A book has an author. Music has a music artist. A party has a party-thrower! All things that begin, that have a start, have a cause to their beginning.

Consider the universe. Scientists once held to the "steady-state" theory, that the universe has always existed without beginning.

Cosmological evidence now refers to the "Big bang" as the point in time that the universe came into being. Our space-time-matter-energy universe had a distinct and singular beginning.

Since it did not always exist, but came into existence (had a singular beginning), then some other reality must have caused or created it.1

Everything we observe in nature has a beginning. God however is in a different category, and must be so. God is different from all nature and humanity and everything that exists, in that he has always existed, independent from anything he created. God is not a dependent being, but self-sufficient, self-existent. And this is exactly how the Bible describes God, and how God has revealed himself to be. Why must God be this way?

Our universe cannot be explained any other way. It could not have created itself. It has not always existed. And it could not be created by something that itself is created. Why not?

It isn't coherent to argue that the universe was created by God, but God was in turn created by God to the second power, who was in turn created by God to the third power, and so on. As Aristotle cogently argued, there must be a reality that causes but is itself uncaused (or, a being that moves but is itself unmoved). Why? Because if there is an infinite regression of causes, then by definition the whole process could never begin.

I am assuming you expect intelligent rational arguments here. Dont you want to join in?
 
Last edited:
The only "saving grace" with flag-wavers is that they or someone else might actually start thinking about their babble after coming here. Or is that too much to hope for?

Considering that the goofy wave flaggers can't even grasp the concept of search for previous threads I wouldn't hold much hope.

I mean REALLY what do these morons think "gee's there have been umpteen dozen threads just like the one I am about to post by a bunch of hit and run magic skydaddy worshippers that got shot down and went no where. But MY brilliant post will surely persuade them"

By the way the ONLY beer worth drinking is Guinness
guinness_mind.jpg
 
How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence. But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence. That ever-existing thing is what we call God. God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence. God is the uncreated Creator who created the universe and everything in it.

You know, now we only have to find Aquinas's tomb, wrap him in copper wire, and put a big-ass magnet around his tomb. *WHAM* Instant free electricity ;)

More seriously, it's ironic that the fundies who try to use Aquinas's arguments actually seem to understand Aquinas the least, and I suspect some haven't even read more than a few quotes from him.

Those rationales aren't some kind of Redundant Array of Independent Drivel. They're not X independent proofs of god, but a small part of the bigger whole of Aquinas's work on the topic. That's what allows Aquinas to make the leap from such generic stuff as "something must have always existed" to specifically the Christian God. They're not even his main proofs of God, but each deal with just one aspect of a God which Aquinas had already proven (or so he believed.)

E.g., even if you bridge from "something which always existed" to divinity, why the Christian _one_ God, and not, say, to the 8 Gods of the Ogdoad?

Aquinas could do that because he had already devoted a freaking chapter on that one point, based on the philosophical principle that the one must come before the multitude. There must be _one_ human before there are two humans. There must be _one_ God before there are two Gods. And if we extrapolate that principle: there must be one quark before there are two or three quarks in the universe, and there must be one kind of particle (either quark or gluon) before there are two kinds of particles (quarks _and_ gluons.)

That extrapolation, btw, is the counter-example: a single quark can't actually exist, nor quarks without gluons, nor gluons without quarks. Hence that principle applied by Aquinas is false, and so is any conclusion based on it.

But at any rate, that's why Aquinas could do the leap to one God.

E.g., if something existed, why specifically a God and not, say, an amorphous bit of energy?

Aquinas could bridge that gap better, because he also goes through a whole list of what other attributes get ascribed to his God. E.g., the unmoved mover part.

Ironically, that's also false and based on a falsehood. The pre-Galilei physics they had postulated that anything only moves if it's pushed, and stops when you stop pushing it. What they had instead of Newton's a = F / m was basically v = F / m. No force applied, no velocity. Hence they needed someone who moves the planets around.

Again, nowadays we know that to be false, so Aquinas's whole "unmoved mover" argument falls flat on its face.

But, again, that bit is one of the many which allow Aquinas to (brokenly) support such a leap between notions.

But, of course, that all goes right over the head of the average fundie who quotes a bit of Aquinas as definitive proof of God. He'll pick such a bit and think it's a full independent proof.
 
I had beers in 72 countries to date. I loves me some imports. Sam Adams is on the gunnels of the canoe.
.
Back in the olden days, I kinda liked some Japanese beers over anything domestic.. and those mega-beers from Oz.
Wow!
 
But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence.

Why not just the universe then?

That ever-existing thing is what we call God.

I'm glad you have a name for it if it makes you feel better. But you know what they about assumptions, right?


God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence. God is the uncreated Creator who created the universe and everything in it.

Pick the god you are referring to, then show evidence that it exists.

Monster
[/quote]
 
From my personal virtual library :

Arguments for the Existence of God

elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/arguments-for-the-existence-of-god-t5.htm

five good reasons to think that God exists:

1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

5. God can be immediately known and experienced.

Maibe we start with nr.1

The Kalam Cosmological Argument

elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/the-kalam-cosmological-argument-t132.htm

leaderu.com/truth/3truth11.html

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.

I'm presuming that you know nothing about the history of your religion, but can you answer these questions, if God has been here since he created the earth, why is it no one knew his name til Abraham, why is it that all his special creation stories (earth man etc) were copied from the creation stories of other Gods who were worshipped for far longer by pagans before anyone knew your Gods name and why is it that your God has no supporting evidence for his existence whereas the Gods whos stories were plagiarised for your God did (at least according to their followers) ?

seems to me that until you answer these questions, you don't know much about your God so are in no position to ask questions when you havent answered any for yourself

in your own time
;)
 
I believe there was no cause of God.
I believe your methods of arguing about God are not capable of discerning truth--they're only capable of reflecting your imagination to yourself, giving you the illusion that you're supporting beliefs you already want to have.
How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence.
Now you just need to establish that there was ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence. Big Bang doesn't quite do it. Here's why.

Per special relativity, we know that time is relative to velocity. Someone who is traveling near the speed of light would experience time very slowly with respect to you, and vice versa. Heck, not only time itself, but even simultaneity is affected. Distance is at well.

At t=0 in the big bang, all of observable space was collapsed to a single point.

Per general relativity, we know that time is also relative to the curvature of space--in particular, affected by gravity. Someone who is deeper in a gravitational well will appear to have time move more slowly relative to you.

At t=0 in the big bang, space curvature approaches infinite. The mass is also collapsed to a single point.

So you have work to do just to establish that there was a t<0 in the first place.
But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence. That ever-existing thing is what we call God.
This is the second major issue you run into. You can slap the label "God" onto something, but if you do so, you should take your definitions quite a bit more seriously than you're doing. You're not doing this. It is, in fact, possible that perchance we can define t<0, according to grander laws, or at least refer to things outside of the universe, and that we could identify something there that always existed, so you can have your God. But what if this God is inanimate? What if it's just a property of nature? You don't get that this entity has a mind from your reasoning--all you get is that it exists. You don't get that it's omnipotent and omniscient--merely that it has some sort of nature. Calling it God isn't that big of a deal, but make sure you attribute to it only what you have demonstrated of it. To do otherwise is to commit an error.
God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence.
...for example, this. Your arguments that God--i.e., whatever caused everything in our universe--was not itself uncaused, doesn't necessarily hold true. It's perfectly plausible that the thing that caused Big Bang was also in itself caused. Beyond that you're working blind, because all of our intuitions apply only to our universe's laws, and we don't have any idea of how the metalaws work yet. LHC may give major clues... so maybe in 10 to 15 years...
If something comes into being, it must have been prompted by something else. A book has an author. Music has a music artist. A party has a party-thrower! All things that begin, that have a start, have a cause to their beginning.
Here you're equivocating. Books have authors, but they are made from trees--ink comes from various places, etc. Music is performed from instruments, which are themselves made out of things we find on the earth. Parties are held at pre-existing locations, and use materials for party favors or games or whatever. What all of these have in common is that only transformations of existing things apply.

Absolutely none of these examples has creation of matter ex nihilo. In fact, if we apply parallel reasoning, we never see things causing things to come into being ex nihilo (even virtual particles aren't properly caused to come into being by something else--they just occur).

Furthermore, diamonds come from natural processes. Snow is formed by natural processes. The elements are formed in stars--some from supernovae. Can you say that there's a creator for diamonds, snow, and potassium without begging the question?
Consider the universe. Scientists once held to the "steady-state" theory, that the universe has always existed without beginning.

Cosmological evidence now refers to the "Big bang" as the point in time that the universe came into being. Our space-time-matter-energy universe had a distinct and singular beginning.
Sort of. The observable universe had a beginning.
Since it did not always exist, but came into existence (had a singular beginning), then some other reality must have caused or created it.
Probably. But the "or created" doesn't match what we observe.

Again, with parallel reasoning--every entity we observe to create things (not ex nihilo) has a functional brain. Artists have functional brains. Musicians have functional brains. Party throwers have functional brains! So if the universe was created, it should stand to reason that whoever created the universe has a brain. But that leads to the question of how God's brain got there. Certainly something as complex as a God that can create a universe must have an enormously complicated brain.
Everything we observe in nature has a beginning. God however is in a different category, and must be so.
But see? Now you're violating your own rules. You're showing us that things are generally true by showing us that they're always true within our scope. Artists create paintings, Musicians create musical works, party throwers create parties, so everything must have something analogous to an artist! (And yet they don't--diamonds, snow, potassium). Yet when you get your God there by these rules, suddenly you change it. Now God is different because he must be different.

You're really playing a game with yourself to put God there. You're squeezing him in.
Our universe cannot be explained any other way. It could not have created itself. It has not always existed. And it could not be created by something that itself is created. Why not?
You're pretending that you've established that the thing that made the universe was sentient, all powerful, and all knowing. But you haven't established that at all. You just assumed it in.
It isn't coherent to argue that the universe was created by God, but God was in turn created by God to the second power, who was in turn created by God to the third power, and so on.
Sure it's coherent. And should we ever find that the universe was in fact the result of a brane collision, you yourself would be moving along this chain. You already defined the thing that made the universe to be God, so if we find it was the result of colliding branes, then that's God, by definition. But you're then going to ask, well, who created this God? And you're going to squeeze your God in--eternal, etc.

But in doing so, hopefully you will realize the game you're playing with yourself.
 
What's a god?

elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/who-is-god-essence-of-god-t79.htm

The phrase "Essence of God" is a theological term used to refer to God's personal characteristics, or to the facets of His personality. Sometimes the term "Attributes of God" is used to refer to God's essence. The "attributes", or the "essence", of God are His primary characteristics, so they cannot be completely communicated to man. They can be described to a degree, but they cannot be fully defined.

Finite man cannot define the infinite. The Bible is the Word of God, and as such it reveals those facts about the Creator that He has seen fit to reveal about Himself.

Man suppose that God thinks like a man. We think God wants revenge, because when we're insulted, we want revenge. When we are cheated, we want immediate justice and retribution. We are indignant and shocked at the behavior of others, so we expect God to be shocked.

But God does not feel insulted. He does not feel cheated - He owns everything. He is not indignant, temperamental, or emotional. He does not throw tantrums (or lightning bolts). He is not surprised or shocked by anything. He is never depressed or moody.

God is not arrogant or egotistical. He knows Himself, is self-assured, and is humble.

God is a rational, logical, stable-minded, patient; and all of His thinking is backed up by His omniscience. And He approaches every issue from the basis of His perfect character, the subject of this study.

God approaches every issue regarding human beings out of His love for all men. His thinking toward man takes all of His attributes into consideration - but Love is always present. It is God's thinking about us, in love, that is His perfect Grace thinking. He is always gracious, always thinks Grace.

Spirituality is one of God's primary attributes. God is immaterial, in a universe that is made up of both material and immaterial. God has revealed something of what He is in the Word, but only He knows Himself fully. We must rely on what is written in the Bible for any understanding of what God is like.

The fact that God is a spiritual being means that He lives. Spirituality implies life. Jer. 10:10 and 1 Th. 1:9 tell us that God is alive and well. The life of God has no beginning and no ending. God is eternal. The Christian shares God's eternal life, but since his eternal life has a beginning at the time he accepted Jesus Christ as Saviour, his eternal life is properly called "everlasting life".

All of the characteristics of the divine essence are present in God at all times, but not all are manifest at the same time, just as while all colors are present in a ray of white light, the individual colors can be seen only under certain conditions of reflection or refraction. Various attributes of God can be seen in certain situations. For example:

* In salvation, God's love and eternal life are apparent.

* In judgment, His righteousness and justice are manifested.

* In God's faithfulness, His immutability and veracity are shown.

* In God's Plan, His omniscience and sovereignty are seen.

* In God's will, sovereignty is paramount.

* In God's revelation, veracity, love, and omniscience are obvious.

The rest of this paper is devoted to a description of the ten characteristics of the Essence of God as seen in the various Bible passages that describe them.
 
If this so-called god always was, why is the universe only 13.7 billion years old, what the hell did he do for all that time before.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I'm presuming that you know nothing about the history of your religion, but can you answer these questions, if God has been here since he created the earth, why is it no one knew his name til Abraham, why is it that all his special creation stories (earth man etc) were copied from the creation stories of other Gods who were worshipped for far longer by pagans before anyone knew your Gods name and why is it that your God has no supporting evidence for his existence whereas the Gods whos stories were plagiarised for your God did (at least according to their followers) ?

It was the Goa'uld, right? :p Those other religions may have seemed to have real tangible Gods, but they were all humans implanted with a symbiont :p
 
...

You're pretending that you've established that the thing that made the universe was sentient, all powerful, and all knowing. But you haven't established that at all. You just assumed it in.

...
.
These guy's god fails to survive "all knowing" in the 1st Chapter of Genesis, and yet they can't see that.
And it's in the very book they use!
 
No cause, gee, everything else needs a cause, but not your magical god, how convenient.

Yes things can come from nothing, it happens all the time, they are called "Virgil Particles":

Also the universe has zero energy, when one adds up the energy, matter and gravity, the net energy is zero.


Just saying something with words doesn’t make it so.

Paul

:) :) :)

elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/quantum-fluctuations-t65.htm

Even if the total energy is not zero, matter could still be created spontaneously - but only for a very short time. According to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, we cannot determine energy and time precisely. Therefore, it is possible for a group of particles with non-zero total energy appear spontaneously and then disappear within a short time. The more the total energy is created, the shorter the lifetime. This process is known as the quantum fluctuation, which has been well confirmed by experiments.

In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested that our universe might originate from the quantum fluctuation. This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom