Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
what logical fallacies ?

:confused:

Islam spread in the beginning through the sword. While christians in the first centuries where persecuted through the romans.

http://www.answering-islam.org/Terrorism/by_the_sword.html

Modernist interpretations notwithstanding, it is clear that military jihad—even in its expansionist form—is an authentic part of Islam.

No matter how you cut it, Muhammad was not only a religious leader, but a military leader who waged war against his enemies as soon as he had the means. Following his example, Muslims quickly carved out an enormous empire. And what ended Muslim expansion was not a change of heart or doctrine, but European military might.

Furthermore, the traditional doctrine of jihad remains alive to this day.

Why the hell would doc create a sock puppet when he's (as far as I know) still around posting on his thread-that-will-not-die? That sure is what this looks like, though.
 
:confused:



Why the hell would doc create a sock puppet when he's (as far as I know) still around posting on his thread-that-will-not-die? That sure is what this looks like, though.
Nah, Fundie apologists work from the same pile of apolegetics. They tend to not have any original ideas or their own thoughts. They just regurgitate the same old garbage.
 
Again : if you want to talk about proves, do it please at another thread. This one is about E V I D E N C E. Please understand the difference.

Since you're apparently not going to respond to my other post that actually addressed "your" arguments concerning cosmology, I might has well chime in here.

We understand the difference between evidence and proof -- and evidences and proofs as well! But clearly you do not. Evidence is that which leads to a conclusion. A proof is that which shows that a given conclusion is correct. Do you see the difference there? The thing about "evidence" is, it has to be interpreted and successfully recognized for what it is. An inept police force can convict the wrong man by reading the evidence wrong just as an inept philosopher can read the evidence wrong and come to an incorrect conclusion. In both cases, this usually happens when there is either insufficient evidence but the investigator just isn't satisfied with that or (more often) if the investigator starts with a conclusion in mind and works toward that. Good scientists gather the evidence and see what it tells them, not actively seek evidence to support a pet claim.

The other thing about evidence is, until a proof exists, it really shouldn't be called that (IMO). It's just data. If the wrong man is convicted, we can't really call the data that lead to his faulty conviction "evidence that he is guilty", now can we? If you come across an object buried in the sand, with a bit of it poking out that looks like a four-sided pyramid, can you say that's evidence of a buried cube? Not yet.

But what you're offering isn't even as good as that. Your evidence isn't consistent with itself or the science it claims to be based on. I expect you've stopped responding to me because I kept insisting that you argue your points with honesty. This is a skeptic board, GIBHOR. Dishonesty is worth less than nothing around here.
 
nothing has been debunked, nobody has come up with a better explanation for the origin and cause of the universe, than the one i have presented.

I do believe you don't understand how the burden of proof works. Just because in your own delusions, those delusions make perfect sense, doesn't really prove more than the Dunning-Kruger effect.

The fact is: you made a claim, you have to prove it. It doesn't matter if your own stupid theory makes more sense to you, but whether the chain of logic and evidence supports it. So far you have presented none.

Yes, in a sense nothing was debunked, because there wasn't anything to debunk: you still haven't presented any evidence at all. You've just done a bunch of cheap sophistry.

And let me educate you on what "evidence" means, since you still seem to just not get it: evidence in logic is that which you can support a conclusion with. This doesn't mean handwaving, fallacies and arguing whose suppositions sound better, it means the kind of X you can actually use in an "X => Y" proposition. I.e., you must start from something _true_, and a logic inference which is _valid_. "What else sounds better?" just isn't either.
 
at no moment at all i have said i would like to present proofs. Evidence is NO proof. Stop being boring, asking for proves.
So you admit that you have merely provided baseless assertions. Evidence must be proved valid. What you have offered as evidence in support of your position has not been proved valid because you have offered no reason to accept it as so. Playing semantic games in an attempt to distract from your inability to support the claims that you have presented isn't going to fool the majority of people on this forum. Would you care to address any of the rest of my comments from the post you quoted above?

My only statement is, that a creator seems to me to be the best explanation for the existence of our universe. And that by far. Any other explanation does not seem rational, and logical to me.
Obviously. The problem is that you have demonstrated that you do not understand the issues involved, therefor, I see no reason to accept your position as being based on anything more than your ignorance and desire.

Again : if you want to talk about proves, do it please at another thread. This one is about E V I D E N C E. Please understand the difference.
I know the difference. I also know that there is nothing wrong with my statement that you have not proved the assertions you initially offered as evidence. At any rate, you have yet to offer either evidence or proof in support of your claims.
 
Last edited:
Craig fails to impress me.

William Lane Craig said:
I don't know of any reputable philosopher who would say everything has a cause.
Of course not. That would negate the fundamental structure of the special pleading on which the Kalam argument depends because one would not be able to assert that everything but God has a cause.

And this is not special pleading in the case of God. After all, atheists have long maintained that the universe doesn't need a cause, because it's eternal. How can they possibly maintain that the universe can be eternal and uncaused, yet God cannot be timeless and uncaused?
The quote by Carl Sagan offered at the beginning of this thread sums up the real issue very elegantly: The objection is that a creator god becomes an unnecessary step in the model. In this case the argument is presented that the universe must have been generated by something and then the assertion that this generator is God is presented. But if the universe wasn't generated then what need of God? God has traditionally been offered as the terminus of an otherwise infinite regress based on human assumptions about the way the universe works. But modern cosmological science has strongly suggested that there may be no regression at all. There may be no need to explain the origin of the universe at all simply because the question is as meaningless as "what is north of the North Pole?". What Craig is really trying to do is avoid the really pressing question by turning it around. That question is, "If God can exist uncreated, then why can't the universe?". To quote Sagan once more, "...a universe with no edge in space, no beginning or end in time, and nothing for a Creator to do".
 
a case of a creator page 76

Craig's eyebrows shot up. "Well, that just misses the point!" he exclaimed. "Obviously, they're not dealing with the first premise of the kalam argument, which is not that everything has a cause, but that whatever begins to exist has a cause. I don't know of any reputable philosopher who would say everything has a cause. So they're simply not dealing with a correct formulation of the kalam argument.
"And this is not special pleading in the case of God. After all, atheists have long maintained that the universe doesn't need a cause, because it's eternal. How can they possibly maintain that the universe can be eternal and uncaused, yet God cannot be timeless and uncaused?"

Who the hell is Craig? Your brother-in-law? Posting these disembodied paragraphs from somewhere else is giving me the impression that you don't actually understand why you believe what you believe, but you just follow what you've heard someone else say. This discussion will work better if you post your own words.

I suspect this paragraph is William Lane Craig, because it sounds like what he'd say. That last couple of sentences of his really shows how he's not willing to be honest. He formulated a proof, a logical syllogism, and we atheists have pointed out that it's not valid because it's special pleading to say that everything needs a cause, but God doesn't. In the case of the Kalam form of the argument, the special pleading is built right in to the first premise, but that doesn't excuse it. Then Craig makes the dishonest assertion that the atheists are bound by the premises of his own argument, when we're just pointing out that his argument, if you turn it on itself, is self-defeating.

Craig is smart but slippery. He knows this. He just doesn't care whether it's true.
 
Just to hammer some more on the silliness of, basically, "well, then you come up with a better explanation", a contest of which BS sounds better is, in the absence of actual data and logic to support any of them, nevertheless just a BS contest.

Let's say one day I walk through the orchard and an apple falls on my head. I look around and up in the tree and see nobody else around. Which of the following explanations is the best?

1. The wind must have caused an apple to fall off a tree.

2. God wanted to give me a cryptic sign.

3. The Illuminati hired a secret Ninja clan from Japan to come drop an apple on my head as a warning.

4. My future self used a time machine to come back in time and drop an apple on my head, since he knew that would change my life in an indirect way. And he was gone back to his time before I could look upwards.

Which of them is the best explanation? I'm going with number 3. Can you come up with a better one.

And if you jumped on any of the 3 explanations at this point, congrats, you're wrong. Including number 1, yes. As long as you have no data, you can't make such a call. You don't know if it was an apple orchard or, say, a cherry orchard. You don't know if it was a season where there would actually be apples in the tree. Etc.

An explanation based on no actual data is just bullcrap.

Same with the "it must have been God" explanation waved around here. The question isn't whether I have a better piece of BS, or which sounds more believable, but whether there is any actual data to support that explanation. Otherwise, see the apples and ninjas above.
 
i dont agree.

http://contenderministries.org/prophecy/endtimes.php

10. TECHNOLOGY FOR THE MARK OF THE BEAST

Revelation 13:16-17 "And he causes all, the small and the great, and the rich and the poor, and the free men and the slaves to be given a mark on their right hand or on their forehead, and he provides that no one will be able to buy or to sell, except the one who has the mark, either the name of the beast or the number of his name."

On May 10, three members of a family in Florida became the first people to receive the biochip implant. Each device, made of silicon and called a VeriChip, is a small radio transmitter about the size of a piece of rice that is injected under a person's skin. It transmits a unique personal ID number whenever it is within a few feet of a special receiver unit. VeriChip's maker describes it as "a miniaturized, implantable, radio frequency identification device (RFID) that can be used in a variety of security, emergency and healthcare applications."

Is the biochip the mark of the beast to be used by the antichrist? We can't really know. What is significant is that people are being softened to the idea of a mark or an implant as a means of maintaining security, providing medical information, and regulating a more interdependent world. As attitudes change, fears subside, and people are convinced of the need for such a mark, the true mark of the beast will be easily introduced to the world by the antichrist.

Note highlighted.

The "right-hand marking" prophecy is one of very few specific prophecies to be made in the Bible. And so far it has entirely failed to come true.
The RFID chips are nonsense. Where on the body were they implanted? Are there any plans to make it so that these chips can perform banking actions, such as withdrawing cash for payment on groceries? Are there any plans to remove credit/debit cards from circulation? Are there any plans to make buying/selling without use of the chip illegal?
No? I thought not.

11. PLANS FOR THE ONE WORLD GOVERNMENT

The United Nations, World Trade Organization, International Criminal Court, UN peacekeeping/police force, numerous UN NGO's, and other agencies are preliminary steps to the formation of a one world government. We now have the communications technology, transportation, and the pro-globalization media necessary to usher in the one world government headed by the antichrist. The increasing terrorist threat and the middle east conflict will only speed up the formation of this governing body as fear and promises of better security make more people willing to give up their national sovereignty for global governance.

One giant bare assertion. Provide evidence if you want me to take it seriously.

3. RETURN OF THE ONE PURE LANGUAGE, HEBREW, TO ISRAEL

Zephaniah 3:9 "For then I will return to the people a pure language, that they may all call upon the name of the Lord, to serve him with one consent."

Prior to the restoration of Israel in 1948, Hebrew was a dead language. Now Hebrew is spoken throughout Israel.

Actually, the Hebrew language experienced a revival in the very early 1900s, prior to Israel's establishment.

1. EXISTENCE OF A 200,000,000 MAN ARMY IN THE EAST

Revelation 9:16 "And the number of the armies of the horsemen was two hundred million; I heard the number of them."

An army of that size had never existed until China's army reached that number in the 1960's.

http://www.endtimeprophecy.net/EPN-1/Articles/Articles-Mark/mndxmrk1.html#anchor1234567

Do the Chinese have a cavalry division?
 
The question isn't whether I have a better piece of BS, or which sounds more believable, but whether there is any actual data to support that explanation. Otherwise, see the apples and ninjas above.

Then of course there's the ever-popular tendency of people to generate explanations for event that haven't been shown to have happened at all. Much of GIBHOR's argument is based in coming up with explanations designed to account for misinterpreted science.
 
But what you're offering isn't even as good as that. Your evidence isn't consistent with itself or the science it claims to be based on. I expect you've stopped responding to me because I kept insisting that you argue your points with honesty. This is a skeptic board, GIBHOR. Dishonesty is worth less than nothing around here.

Please consider that i am alone, responding to a bunch of people. So one or the other post i might miss to respond.
you are free to think my conclusion has not enough base of scientific facts, to be taken that exact conclusion.
Based on the existing scientific discoveries, specially cosmologic ones, i would say, a case for a creator is pretty strong. Its up to you, to disagree with that. but then you remain with two choices : ignoring the data, and say " we dont know " what the origin of the universe is, or to say : Nothing is a better explanation as the cause of the existence of the universe. And then, you will have to explain, why you think, that is a better explanation. Up to that moment, nobody has brought ANY , me convincing argument to embrace a other explanation , than God, that looks more reasonable, and rational.
 
Last edited:
The quote by Carl Sagan offered at the beginning of this thread sums up the real issue very elegantly: The objection is that a creator god becomes an unnecessary step in the model.

If you take it granted, that uncaused things can appear and pop up into existence from absolutely nothing, then you might be right.
 
Are there any plans to remove credit/debit cards from circulation? Are there any plans to make buying/selling without use of the chip illegal?
No? I thought not.

In this direction everything will head. A society without cash money. Everything done through the rfid chip.
 
a case of a creator page 76

Craig's eyebrows shot up.

Craig's BS meter should have shot up rather than his eyebrows.

"Well, that just misses the point!" he exclaimed. "Obviously, they're not dealing with the first premise of the kalam argument, which is not that everything has a cause, but that whatever begins to exist has a cause. I don't know of any reputable philosopher who would say everything has a cause. So they're simply not dealing with a correct formulation of the kalam argument.
"And this is not special pleading in the case of God. After all, atheists have long maintained that the universe doesn't need a cause, because it's eternal. How can they possibly maintain that the universe can be eternal and uncaused, yet God cannot be timeless and uncaused?"

GIBHOR, do you have evidence that any particular god or gods were uncaused rather than the universe itself being uncaused?
 
GIBHOR, do you have evidence that any particular god or gods were uncaused rather than the universe itself being uncaused?

Sure. The universe is caused, since it had a beginning.
the cause had to be uncaused, otherwise there woule be eternal regress of causes, which is not plausible. And goes against Occams Razor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom