Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
The funny thing i find is, Islam surged alot faster than christianity after "founding". According to GIBHOR's argument, does this mean there is more evidence for Islam than for christianity? :P

Islam spread in the beginning through the sword. While christians in the first centuries where persecuted through the romans.

http://www.answering-islam.org/Terrorism/by_the_sword.html

Modernist interpretations notwithstanding, it is clear that military jihad—even in its expansionist form—is an authentic part of Islam.

No matter how you cut it, Muhammad was not only a religious leader, but a military leader who waged war against his enemies as soon as he had the means. Following his example, Muslims quickly carved out an enormous empire. And what ended Muslim expansion was not a change of heart or doctrine, but European military might.

Furthermore, the traditional doctrine of jihad remains alive to this day.
 
what logical fallacies ?

Take your very first post: you present a flawed argument based on unproved assertions that draws an unjustified conclusion that the universe had a creator. Tacked on to this conclusion is another baseless assertion that the creator is the Christian god. You have yet to respond to challenges to to prove that this alleged creator must be the Christian god rather than, say, the Hindu god or the Muslim god. Hence my comment about my lost sock being the result of its being taken by a dragon. Even if you did have evidence that the universe was generated ex nihilo, you offer no reason to conclude that it was generated by any one god over any other god, just as the evidence in the form of my missing sock does not justify my claim that it was stolen by a dragon.
 
that is why we are still here.
Sure.
But if the energy would be eternal, we would not exist anymore.
No. This only follows from there being enough time in the past for heat death to occur.

And since there simply isn't that much past to this moment, it does not follow.

Let me explain to you what reification of zero means, and why you're doing it. Consider the following joke proof:
1. A dime is better than nothing.
2. Nothing is better than heaven.
3. Therefore, a dime is better than heaven.​
1 is certainly true. It's better to have a dime than it is to have nothing. And if heaven exists, and is anything like they say, 2's in fairly good standing. Logically, then, dime > nothing and nothing > heaven should imply that dime > heaven. Presumably you don't buy that. So where's the flaw?

Well, the flaw is that two completely different kinds of things are being claimed in 1 and 2. In 1, the state of having no dime, which is called "nothing", is being declared as worse than the state of having a dime. In essence, this is comparing a dime to nothingness itself.

But 2 is not declaring that nothingness in itself is better than heaven. Quite the opposite. It is declaring that there is no thing that is better than heaven. Or rephrased, no thing, including nothingness in itself, is better than heaven.

Now, if time had a beginning, then it's false to say that nothingness existed before time. This would be impossible, because what it means for time to have a beginning is that there is a point in time relative to which no thing, including nothingness, is before that point.

But you're trying to establish that energy had to have been created simply because it had a beginning--that nothingness doesn't spawn into things. In relation to time, you're assuming that no thing existing before time means that nothingness existed before time.

Reification of zero occurs when you treat no thing as if it is nothingness.

Or more simply... if time having a beginning implies that energy must have been created, then a dime is better than heaven.
 
Last edited:
Islam spread in the beginning through the sword. While christians in the first centuries where persecuted through the romans.
And we all know that there have never, ever been any Christian armies in human history.

And what ended Muslim expansion was not a change of heart or doctrine, but European military might.
Then how do you explain Muslim expansion since the end of this period of military expansion.

Furthermore, the traditional doctrine of jihad remains alive to this day.
Quite right. Why, the Muslim father-in-law of my wife's brother is currently engaged in a jihad against poverty in his own community.

You do realize that the word "jihad" simply means "struggle", yes, and that for most of the world's Muslims it is a positive word that refers to efforts to better one's self and the community as a whole? Before you try to paint Islam as inferior to Christianity by painting all Muslims as militant extremists, keep in mind that in the United States we have examples of Christian extremism as well. Among the worst examples is the Christian Identity Movement which is basically waiting for Jesus to come back and lead the "racial holy war" in which white people will rise up and slaughter all the non-white people on Earth. Attempting to identify all of Islam with Islamic extremists is no more justified than attempting to identify all Christians with racist Christian xenophobes.
 
Take your very first post: you present a flawed argument based on unproved assertions

at no moment at all i have said i would like to present proofs. Evidence is NO proof. Stop being boring, asking for proves.


that draws an unjustified conclusion that the universe had a creator.

My only statement is, that a creator seems to me to be the best explanation for the existence of our universe. And that by far. Any other explanation does not seem rational, and logical to me.

Again : if you want to talk about proves, do it please at another thread. This one is about E V I D E N C E. Please understand the difference.
 
And we all know that there have never, ever been any Christian armies in human history.


Then how do you explain Muslim expansion since the end of this period of military expansion.


Quite right. Why, the Muslim father-in-law of my wife's brother is currently engaged in a jihad against poverty in his own community.

You do realize that the word "jihad" simply means "struggle", yes, and that for most of the world's Muslims it is a positive word that refers to efforts to better one's self and the community as a whole? Before you try to paint Islam as inferior to Christianity by painting all Muslims as militant extremists, keep in mind that in the United States we have examples of Christian extremism as well. Among the worst examples is the Christian Identity Movement which is basically waiting for Jesus to come back and lead the "racial holy war" in which white people will rise up and slaughter all the non-white people on Earth. Attempting to identify all of Islam with Islamic extremists is no more justified than attempting to identify all Christians with racist Christian xenophobes.

IMO and personal experiences I have found that the "Muslims" I have met or are friends with to be much nicer people on average than the "Christians" i have met, however I'm sure the majority in this thread - deny if you wish, this is purely assumption and I may be hopelessly wrong - will agree with me that it could both, be argued the other way as I obviously have not met EVERY Muslim/Christian nor even a majority; but also that people's belief systems actually tend to have little to do with their personal qualities and even their morality provided they are open-minded.
 
at no moment at all i have said i would like to present proofs. Evidence is NO proof. Stop being boring, asking for proves.




My only statement is, that a creator seems to me to be the best explanation for the existence of our universe. And that by far. Any other explanation does not seem rational, and logical to me.

Again : if you want to talk about proves, do it please at another thread. This one is about E V I D E N C E. Please understand the difference.
The problem is, you keep stating that every piece of "evidence" you present leads to the conclusion that WAS a creator AS OPPOSED TO to stating there MIGHT have been a creator as one of many possibilities. You then go on to state that this creator was your personal god AS OPPOSED TO to stating that your personal creator is one of the many possibilities, and that those possibilities could include FSM.

Because Foster's sock was missing this morning, and because, I believe in dragons; you can't prove they don't exist; I have a book that I consider holy that states they are real and like munching on socks; do you agree that is as logical a conclusion as the one you have for your god's existence?
 
Is GIBHOR a DOC-puppet? The MO seems to be the same

No, Doc endlessly repeats debunked arguments but he was at least coherent. We have here a whole new level of special pleading. My troll-dar is pinging but I'm sticking it out for now to see where this goes.

Gibhor, there is so much wrong with the bible that it's contradictions and the sheer vileness of it's main characters has inspired entire threads.
 
Sure.

No. This only follows from there being enough time in the past for heat death to occur.

And since there simply isn't that much past to this moment, it does not follow.

It seems you do not grasp what eternal means. If there is not that much past time to this moment, time had a absolute beginning. Isn't it what you try to avoid ?
 
No, Doc endlessly repeats debunked arguments

nothing has been debunked, nobody has come up with a better explanation for the origin and cause of the universe, than the one i have presented.

We have here a whole new level of special pleading.

The special pleading argument

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/doe...ty-f10/the-special-pleading-argument-t226.htm

a case of a creator page 76

Craig's eyebrows shot up. "Well, that just misses the point!" he exclaimed. "Obviously, they're not dealing with the first premise of the kalam argument, which is not that everything has a cause, but that whatever begins to exist has a cause. I don't know of any reputable philosopher who would say everything has a cause. So they're simply not dealing with a correct formulation of the kalam argument.
"And this is not special pleading in the case of God. After all, atheists have long maintained that the universe doesn't need a cause, because it's eternal. How can they possibly maintain that the universe can be eternal and uncaused, yet God cannot be timeless and uncaused?"
 
nothing has been debunked, nobody has come up with a better explanation for the origin and cause of the universe, than the one i have presented.
Zebob the Celestial Troll who farts on YHWH and impregnated Mary with magic semen as a joke.
 
there is so much evidence for the truth of the bible, that someone saying there is no evidence, is simply blind. If there would be no evidence, christianity as we know it today, and in history, would have never surged.

No, I don't think so. Plenty of people do things based on beliefs not supported by evidence. Your ad hoc reasoning is false.
 
i dont agree.

http://contenderministries.org/prophecy/endtimes.php

10. TECHNOLOGY FOR THE MARK OF THE BEAST

Revelation 13:16-17 "And he causes all, the small and the great, and the rich and the poor, and the free men and the slaves to be given a mark on their right hand or on their forehead, and he provides that no one will be able to buy or to sell, except the one who has the mark, either the name of the beast or the number of his name."

On May 10, three members of a family in Florida became the first people to receive the biochip implant. Each device, made of silicon and called a VeriChip, is a small radio transmitter about the size of a piece of rice that is injected under a person's skin. It transmits a unique personal ID number whenever it is within a few feet of a special receiver unit. VeriChip's maker describes it as "a miniaturized, implantable, radio frequency identification device (RFID) that can be used in a variety of security, emergency and healthcare applications."

Is the biochip the mark of the beast to be used by the antichrist? We can't really know. What is significant is that people are being softened to the idea of a mark or an implant as a means of maintaining security, providing medical information, and regulating a more interdependent world. As attitudes change, fears subside, and people are convinced of the need for such a mark, the true mark of the beast will be easily introduced to the world by the antichrist.

11. PLANS FOR THE ONE WORLD GOVERNMENT

The United Nations, World Trade Organization, International Criminal Court, UN peacekeeping/police force, numerous UN NGO's, and other agencies are preliminary steps to the formation of a one world government. We now have the communications technology, transportation, and the pro-globalization media necessary to usher in the one world government headed by the antichrist. The increasing terrorist threat and the middle east conflict will only speed up the formation of this governing body as fear and promises of better security make more people willing to give up their national sovereignty for global governance.

3. RETURN OF THE ONE PURE LANGUAGE, HEBREW, TO ISRAEL

Zephaniah 3:9 "For then I will return to the people a pure language, that they may all call upon the name of the Lord, to serve him with one consent."

Prior to the restoration of Israel in 1948, Hebrew was a dead language. Now Hebrew is spoken throughout Israel.

1. EXISTENCE OF A 200,000,000 MAN ARMY IN THE EAST

Revelation 9:16 "And the number of the armies of the horsemen was two hundred million; I heard the number of them."

An army of that size had never existed until China's army reached that number in the 1960's.

http://www.endtimeprophecy.net/EPN-1/Articles/Articles-Mark/mndxmrk1.html#anchor1234567

You're not the first person in history to link contemporary events with prophecy. So far, no apocalypse, though. I wonder why.
 
My only statement is, that a creator seems to me to be the best explanation for the existence of our universe.

And why do you then jump to the conclusion that it's the christian God ?

Any other explanation does not seem rational, and logical to me.

Then I suggest you spend more time educating yourself on these matters.

Again : if you want to talk about proves, do it please at another thread. This one is about E V I D E N C E. Please understand the difference.

Your evidence fails.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom