Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
No. There's no reason to assume that the resurrection ever occured, unless you believe the bible to be true and accurate, which it is demonstrably not the case. If you have some good reason and/or evidence of the resurrection, present it over on the thread "Evidence for why we know the New Testament writers told the truth", 200+ pages, 8500+ posts and still no evidence - surely you have some? (The other thread that was already mentioned - was jesus ressurected - is younger and may be more applicable, your choice).

there is so much evidence for the truth of the bible, that someone saying there is no evidence, is simply blind. If there would be no evidence, christianity as we know it today, and in history, would have never surged.
 
there is so much evidence for the truth of the bible, that someone saying there is no evidence, is simply blind. If there would be no evidence, christianity as we know it today, and in history, would have never surged.

Can you present this evidence?
 
I don't think so. Everything we know about life tells us it could not survive the core of the sun. One could imagine a potential life form that could exist there but we don't have any evidence to prove it is actually there. That's not incredulity, that's reasonable extroplation from currently available data.

I disagree. Malerin is not just saying that life does not exist in the center of the sun, but that it couldn't.
 
Without the resurrection of Christ, there would not be any Christianity, as we know it today.

<snip rehash of Geisler and Turek>


Without Muhammad's painful revelations visit to heaven on the winged horse Burak, there would not be any Islam as we know it today.

Without Joseph Smith's finding of the golden tablets and the translation stones, there would be no Mormonism as we know it today.


These arguments are the exact same as the one I quoted above.
Yet I highly doubt you find them convincing.

Why, then, should anyone find your version convincing? Especially anyone who is not Christian.







There is so much evidence for the truth of the bible, that someone saying there is no evidence, is simply blind. If there would be no evidence, Christianity as we know it today, and in history, would have never surged.


You want to go to the "Evidence for why we know the New Testament Writers told the truth" thread to discuss that.
I'd suggest you read the first few pages, too see what argument DOC has presented (some should be familiar to you, as you've presented them in this thread) and how easily they were shredded (N.B. You might need to step back and dissociate yourself from the argument to see the shredding.).

Note that fondly held belief does not carry any evidenciary weight.







P.S. I'm still eagerly awaiting an answer.
 
Last edited:
i will not answer posts anymore, where i am asked to show proves.

You used the word evidence in the title of this thread,now you refuse to provide proof of your irrational beliefs? Could it be that you have no proof,only the need for a security blanket?
 
Last edited:
My objection is actually there is no evidence life exists in the center of the sun and plenty of evidence that it doesn't.

Do you dispute this?
.
With our senses, we can't detect what we term "life".
Our definition may suck.
 
And this means...? That is what it seems like you are saying.

You can't produce a quote where I claim it is impossible that life exists in the sun. You imply I think that because I asked you if you thought it possible and to what degree.

I can imply you're an ******* for putting words in my mouth. Whatever. Welcome to ignore.
 
You can't produce a quote where I claim it is impossible that life exists in the sun. You imply I think that because I asked you if you thought it possible and to what degree.

No, I said that you implied that, which you seemed to. If I got it wrong, my bad.

I can imply you're an ******* for putting words in my mouth. Whatever. Welcome to ignore.

O_o

Overreaction much?

ETA: Could someone here explain Malerin's motivation here? I didn't think I was doing anything particularly ignore-worthy. I was just saying what I felt that he was saying.
 
Last edited:
I don't think so. Everything we know about life tells us it could not survive the core of the sun. One could imagine a potential life form that could exist there but we don't have any evidence to prove it is actually there. That's not incredulity, that's reasonable extroplation from currently available data.


The main problem is that Malerin has twice claimed that he/she has evidence that life cannot exist in places of which the sun's core is one example, but when challenged, has resorted to probability calculations, not evidence. I am still waiting for the evidence that life can only exist on Earth.
 
Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun? On the surface of Pluto? In the rings of Saturn? No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth? If Pluto-based life is very improbable (which it is), than non-molecular/non-stellar based life is extremely improbable. It's a fairy tale, in other words.

Found it, by the way.
 
i have not said that.
But you strongly imply it with your following statement.

exactly. thus the universe had a absolute beginning.
No. Trust me, you are not getting the concept that Hawking is describing. There is nothing "before" the Big Bang. You are stuck on a false dichotomy in which the only two alternatives are time tracing backward for eternity and the universe popping into existence from nothing. These are not the sole alternatives. You have the opportunity to educate yourself by reading the books I have suggested. If you choose not to understand these concepts because they do not conform with your desires regarding the mechanics of the universe then there really isn't much I can do about that.
 
But you strongly imply it with your following statement.


No. Trust me, you are not getting the concept that Hawking is describing. There is nothing "before" the Big Bang. You are stuck on a false dichotomy in which the only two alternatives are time tracing backward for eternity and the universe popping into existence from nothing. These are not the sole alternatives. You have the opportunity to educate yourself by reading the books I have suggested. If you choose not to understand these concepts because they do not conform with your desires regarding the mechanics of the universe then there really isn't much I can do about that.

Do the skeptics here ever actually quote people or is everything always implied?
 
ETA: Could someone here explain Malerin's motivation here? I didn't think I was doing anything particularly ignore-worthy. I was just saying what I felt that he was saying.

From the outside, it appeared you were telling him what he meant by what he said. That torques some people off (myself included). Given that the purported implication was weak (it only asked your opinion), his denial should have been sufficient, but you pressed him on it anyway.

Given Malerin's particular way of asking questions sometimes, maybe he should cut you some slack. I would. But maybe he's not aware of how his questions can sometimes be perceived. *shrug* You both seem like nice guys to me. I'm sure it'll sort itself out.
 
Found it, by the way.

I removed you from ignore for the moment to clear this up:

You claimed
I disagree. Malerin is not just saying that life does not exist in the center of the sun, but that it couldn't.

As proof, you give the following quote by me:

Originally Posted by Malerin
Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun? On the surface of Pluto? In the rings of Saturn? No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth? If Pluto-based life is very improbable (which it is), than non-molecular/non-stellar based life is extremely improbable. It's a fairy tale, in other words.

Where did I say there that life
couldn't exist
?

The kindest reading of that is me claiming that life does NOT exist on Pluto, or the core of the sun. Not that it COULDN'T exist, which is what you claim I said. If you look at the entire quote you can see that I don't come close to claiming that because I use the word IMPROBABLE twice, instead of impossible.

I didn't think I was doing anything particularly ignore-worthy. I was just saying what I felt that he was saying.

You don't seem all that bad, and maybe I was overreacting, but I don't like words put in my mouth that I didn't say. Never did I say life can't exist. Anywhere. You can maybe, by ignoring my use of "improbable", argue that I claimed life doesn't exist in the core of the sun, but that is a far different thing than saying it can't exist, which I never said.

Care to retract (or amend) your claim?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom