Empirical Evidence vs Reason

While it's funny how nobody seems to wish address the materialist notion that when we're dead and gone, it will be as if we (to those who are dead and gone anyway) were never here. Doesn't this suggest that life is merely nothing more than a dream?

If you're being allegorical by equating life and dreams, then yes, I'll agree with you. If you are being literal, then I have to disagree.

You're correct that, to the dead, life will have no meaning. To the living, however, we still remember those who've left us, they've left legacies of one sort or another, they aren't totally forgotten.
 
If you're being allegorical by equating life and dreams, then yes, I'll agree with you. If you are being literal, then I have to disagree.
All except for one thing, why should our dreams be considered any less real, if we are unable to maintain them either when we die? And, since these are something which occur within us, how do we know that this isn't actually where "we" begin?

You're correct that, to the dead, life will have no meaning. To the living, however, we still remember those who've left us, they've left legacies of one sort or another, they aren't totally forgotten.
While I would venture to say that the vast majority people who have ever lived on this planet have been forgotten, at least on a "personal" level.
 
Last edited:
All except for one thing, why should our dreams be considered any less real, if we are unable to maintain them either when we die?

We aren't able to maintain dreams very well after we awaken either. Also, dreams can change from night to night, moment to moment. REM lasts for very short periods of time, and the dream you had in one REM period won't necessarily carry on to another. Dreams are less real than reality, as any form of random neuron firings should be.

While I would venture to say that the vast majority people who have ever lived on this planet have been forgotten, at least on a "personal" level.
Yeah, so what? For a while they were remembered, then those that remembered them died themselves and so on and so on. So it goes.
 
We aren't able to maintain dreams very well after we awaken either. Also, dreams can change from night to night, moment to moment. REM lasts for very short periods of time, and the dream you had in one REM period won't necessarily carry on to another. Dreams are less real than reality, as any form of random neuron firings should be.
In and of themselves dreams are very real. Or for that matter, how do we know that external reality isn't merely a consolidation of what goes on in this other worldly state of our dreams? Isn't this in fact the only thing that makes it real for us, how we experience it on the inside?


Yeah, so what? For a while they were remembered, then those that remembered them died themselves and so on and so on. So it goes.
And there will no doubt come a point when "all" is forgotten.
 
Last edited:
And do you realize there is no such thing as external reality? Because all is maintained from within.
 
Reality is nothing more than one big interaction. An interaction that occurs between things on an interior level. So, the only thing about reality that is external, is how it appears on the surface.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom