Empirical Evidence vs Reason

Hey! That's good. You've found a way for Iacchus to combat his problem with reality.

Because the axioms and evidence that Iacchus presents are only in imaginary states, such as dreams, they can only be considered operative in those states.

So is the stuff you spout true, Iacchus? In your dreams.
And, when I'm dead and gone, so what huh? Maybe it was just a dream?

:dl:
 
That would be great if you were capable of jumping out of your skin. :D Indeed, how is it possible to know something exists on the outside, unless "you" were looking at it from the inside? There has to be some form of mediator between you and the outside doesn't there? And, what do you think that mediator might be, if not reason?

The absence of the mediator does not mean that the outside and the inside don't exist.
 
Nonetheless, it's still wholly reliant upon reason to explain to us what it means.

Not really. To really show our idea of what it might mean is correct, we have to perform experiments to eliminate contradicting explanations. And the results of the experiments don't change over time, so the "meaning" of evidence is persistent, whether or not anyone is there to reason over it.
 
Not really. To really show our idea of what it might mean is correct, we have to perform experiments to eliminate contradicting explanations. And the results of the experiments don't change over time, so the "meaning" of evidence is persistent, whether or not anyone is there to reason over it.
Yet I bet if you tried to explain those results to a chimpanzee it would mean something entirely different if, anything at all. In which case we have to ask, who's doing the interpreting and, who wants to know?
 
If you died this instant, there would still be evidence that you had existed. Iacchus fossils, if you will.
So what, what would it mean to "me" if I were dead? If you folks are right, and there is no afterlife, then the life I "thought" I knew was nothing more than just a dream. So, dream on dude! :D
 
Last edited:
So what, what would it mean to "me" if I were dead? If you folks are right, and there is no afterlife, then the life I "thought" I knew was nothing more than just a dream. So, dream on dude! :D
Your posts would still be here. People would remember you. The parts of your body would be tranformed into other things, perhaps fossilized if the conditions were right (like if you were dropped into wet concrete)

True, you wouldn't be generating any more of your brilliant insights, but the ones you had would still be around, like your book. Of course, if you had said truly brilliant things, like Shakespeare or Einstein, you'd be remembered a lot longer.

But we have evidence of people who lived many thousands of years before us. They weren't a dream.
 
Your posts would still be here. People would remember you. The parts of your body would be tranformed into other things, perhaps fossilized if the conditions were right (like if you were dropped into wet concrete)

True, you wouldn't be generating any more of your brilliant insights, but the ones you had would still be around, like your book. Of course, if you had said truly brilliant things, like Shakespeare or Einstein, you'd be remembered a lot longer.

But we have evidence of people who lived many thousands of years before us. They weren't a dream.
Yes, and when I'm dead and gone, you might as well try explaining this to a brick wall. ;)
 
Well, anyone who has dealt with your threads clearly has practise in that area.
 
Yes, and when I'm dead and gone, you might as well try explaining this to a brick wall. ;)
Your meaningless non-sequitur in no way addresses the point that I have made. Evidence of you will exist after you are dead. Do you deny this, or are you just running away again?
 
Your meaningless non-sequitur in no way addresses the point that I have made. Evidence of you will exist after you are dead. Do you deny this, or are you just running away again?
And my answer to you is, so what? Why should I care when I'm dead and gone?
 
And my answer to you is, so what? Why should I care when I'm dead and gone?


HOLY CHICKEN!!! Do you realize that you and I agree 100% on that statement? It's a bloody manifestation-of-a-nigh-impossible-occurance....hrm, that doesn't have that "roll off the tounge" quality I'm looking for; I'm gonna try it again.

It's a bloody miracle!!!!

That's better.
 
And, if our assessment of materialism is correct, would you agree, that life is nothing but a dream?
 
And, if our assessment of materialism is correct, would you agree, that life is nothing but a dream?

Nope. I'm not Brahma. ;)

I have, at times, been convinced that I was living a nightmare, but then I took some asprin, drank a lot of water and the hangover went away.

We could lapse into sophistry by discussing how to differentiate between wakefullness and dreaming, but I'm too tired, I haven't had enough coffee, and it's too pretty out. I'll just state that dreaming is something that you do while sleeping (ok, maybe some while daydreaming too, but it's not quite as good). I don't know if it has any real purpose, but I've heard that it's a side-effect of the brain "settling" after a dayfull of events.

Life, on the other hand, seems to be that which you do when you AIN'T sleeping.
 
While it's funny how nobody seems to wish address the materialist notion that when we're dead and gone, it will be as if we (to those who are dead and gone anyway) were never here. Doesn't this suggest that life is merely nothing more than a dream?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom