I was complaining because you said it's LARGER than the system. The "system" is a circuit, or a series of circuits in the case of the Onel and Mann paper. As they demonstrated, the circuit arrangement can be made more complex as needed.
It does tell you what's taking place at the level of current and the flow of current. It does not adequately describe all the physical properties of the plasma however. That much I agree with. That's why I do not reject the B.
No, I said
larger than the largest spatial scale of the system which does not mean larger than the system, although I guess you can interprete it that way. But all processes of the system have a certain scale, and only things larger than the largest scale can be described by circuit theory.
And it does not matter if you can make it as complex as a Japanese locked box, you still will not get to the basic plasma physics. You think that one can describe everything with a circuit, but that is not the case, because as a certain small scale the circuit model breaks down.
A circuit will tell you what takes place on
a current scale, again
large scale. And indeed it does not describe microphysical properties of the plasma.
True. I agree that there are LIMITS with only looking at it from ONE perspective rather than both.
So that's why you just keep on claiming that e.g. Önel & Mann totally explain solar flares etc. with their circuit model, and from what you keep on writing one really gets the impression that circuits are the alpha and omega of plasma physics. You do not look at both perspectives, you keep on hammering on circuits.
When did I suggest otherwise? I'm confused.
You said that "
Ya, and the B field is an average of the current flow through the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch too. So?" as a reply to my comment that in circuit theory "
All quantities are put together in averaged/integrated large scale properties." Now I see here magnetic field of the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch, apart from the fact that these two things are not the same, and that the latter (BP) can happen in the former (CL), which leads me to conclude that you think that the currents through the coronal loop are generating the magnetic field of the coronal loop. You have claimed that before in some of the other threads, maybe even in this one.
My point is that what you're calling a "coronal loop" is nothing more than a Bennett pinch that is part of a "circuit" of current. That's why I have no problem calling it "current reconnection" or "circuit reconnection" when the topology changes over time.
No a coronal loop is a coronal loop, if the current happens to become strong enough through e.g. footpoint shearing then a Bennett Pinch may happen. A coronal loop is a structure which is in balance with its surroundings and itself and there is no reason for it to form a Bennett Pinch unless the current gets cranked up through external processes.
So, it would be interesting to see how you are going to model a Bennett Pinch with a circuit. Please show us how to do this.
No, but it's important to know that the filament is acting as part of a circuit.
Yeah, the filament can be described as a circuit, but now show me how you model a Bennett Pinch with a circuit. (I won't hold my breath tho until you do) For someone claiming that "there are limits looking only at one perspective" you definitely seem to be hung up on circuits.
I'm really having a hard time finding our EXACTLY where we disagree and there's not point in responding to your inane insults, so I'll just stop here.
My whole intent is to demonstrate that *BOTH* orientation are related and relevant. It's SILLY to claim only ONE ORIENTATION IS RIGHT, just at it was SILLY for Alfven to reject the B orientation of these same events JUST because he didn't like the name.
But you
don't use *BOTH* orientations, from all the comments you given above you claim you do, but in the end you want everything in a circuit and you cannot have it. And Alfvén never rejected the B orientation, but claimed, as some other well respected plasma physicist do, that the currents and electric fields should be looked at too.
Tim Thompson already discussed this whole stuff with respect to the wonderful book of Eugene Parker, and there are various other peer-reviewed papers where a close look is made to what is driving what exactly in magnetospheric plasma physics (because in the Earth's magnetosphere we at least have bezillion observations for this kind of stuff). Are the currents driving the magnetic field or is the magnetic field driving the currents (Vitenis Vasiliunas comes to mind, one of the great space plasma physcis thinkers, and an excellent church organ player, the problem is can one understand his papers).