Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hot off the press, written with MM in mind (no doubt): "Theory of magnetic reconnection in solar and astrophysical plasmas", by D.I. Pontin (arXiv:1202.4013):
Magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in a plasma that facilitates the release of energy stored in the magnetic field by permitting a change in the magnetic topology. In this article we present a review of the current state of understanding of magnetic reconnection. We discuss theoretical results regarding the formation of current sheets in complex 3D magnetic fields, and describe the fundamental differences between reconnection in two and three dimensions. We go on to outline recent developments in modelling of reconnection with kinetic theory, as well as in the MHD framework where a number of new 3D reconnection regimes have been identified. We discuss evidence from observations and simulations of solar system plasmas that support this theory, and summarise some prominent locations in which this new reconnection theory is relevant in astrophysical plasmas.
 
You are relevant, Michael Mozina. No other contributor to this forum has done so much to discredit Electric Sun and Electric Universe pseudoscience. Keep up the good work.

Hear hear. Prior to Michael's contributions, I would have thought:

a) Birkeland was a pioneering scientist and the first to formulate good aurora hypotheses

b) Alfven got a Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, but was otherwise forgotten.

c) There was that one sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot at that one APS meeting

Thanks to Michael Mozina, I now know that

a) Birkeland was a dabbler-in-many-things rather than a careful space-plasma expert. He came up with a decent aurora hypothesis (by the standards of pre-space-age astronomy speculators), but his understanding was generally inferior to that of his countryman Carl Stormer. Plus he had a crazy steampunk plasma globe!

b) Alfven got the Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, then became both a plasma-physics curmudgeon and a full-blown cosmology crackpot, and was therefore forgotten.

c) The sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot was named Oliver Manuel.
 
Hear hear. Prior to Michael's contributions, I would have thought:

a) Birkeland was a pioneering scientist and the first to formulate good aurora hypotheses

b) Alfven got a Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, but was otherwise forgotten.

c) There was that one sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot at that one APS meeting

Thanks to Michael Mozina, I now know that

a) Birkeland was a dabbler-in-many-things rather than a careful space-plasma expert. He came up with a decent aurora hypothesis (by the standards of pre-space-age astronomy speculators), but his understanding was generally inferior to that of his countryman Carl Stormer. Plus he had a crazy steampunk plasma globe!

b) Alfven got the Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, then became both a plasma-physics curmudgeon and a full-blown cosmology crackpot, and was therefore forgotten.

c) The sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot was named Oliver Manuel.

Well, I have to disagree with both points b here. Alfvén was awarded the Nobel prize for:

Nobel Committee said:
for fundamental work and discoveries in magnetohydrodynamics with fruitful applications in different parts of plasma physics

And although he may have had some strange ideas (especially near the end of his life), he will never be forgotten in physics because of his development of MHD, and his insights in plasma physics for things like double layers and the critical ionization velocity as well as setting up a great experimental plasma laboratory at the Royal Institue of Technology in Stockholm, Sweden, which now carries his name.
 
Hot off the press, written with MM in mind (no doubt): "Theory of magnetic reconnection in solar and astrophysical plasmas", by D.I. Pontin (arXiv:1202.4013):

Well, it certainly can't be for Clinger's benefit since it relates to the KINETIC behaviors of plasma and Clinger doesn't have a plasma particle to his name. :(

Considering how busy it is at work at the moment, and how many folks I have to respond to in this thread, it will likely be awhile before I have a chance to get through the whole thing. At first glance it looks to be a good paper about the kinetic behaviors of *PLASMA*!
 
You underestimate both your relevance and the relevance of your inability to scratch chickens.

The problem has nothing to do with my ability to do chicken scratching, or follow along with them, it has to do with your inability to deal with the relevant scratchings directly based upon the *authors* that wrote them like Dungey and his explanation of ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES IN PLASMAS AND FLARES!

When I confronted you with that paper by Priest and I pointed out two EXACT *AND HIGHLY RELEVANT* CHICKEN SCRATCHINGS where particle kinetic energy (aka CURRENT) was being turned into magnetic monopole wine, you all IGNORED IT, particularly and most importantly YOU PERSONALLY!

Let's look at just one small example. With my highlighting:


You posted that on 2 December 2011. I believe that was the start of your "0+0=0" meme.

You may have forgotten what you meant by "0+0=0", so I'll remind you. Your "0+0=0" is not a quotation. It is your own personal shorthand for your own personal incredulity that direct currents at some distance from the (arbitrary) origin of a Cartesian coordinate system could generate magnetic fields within a vacuum in the neighborhood of that origin. You think plasma is required.

It is *REQUIRED*. You cannot and will not hide behind that equivocation fallacy forever and ever. You have NEVER and COULD NEVER produce particle acceleration or ANY release of energy in a VACUUM in a NULL!

Your math amounted to nothing more than another proof that the point in question is NOT SPECIAL OR UNIQUE in any way shape or form. All the laws of physics are satisfied at that point, just as they are satisfied *AT EVERY POINT IN THE EXPERIMENT*!

Your math is meaningless without plasma. It's not "reconnection" of any *THING* because you have no *THING* that could possibly produce particle kinetic energy. You left out the MOST IMPORTANT THING. You left out the PHYSICS!

The rest of your response isn't worth responding to because it is a personal attack against an individual because you cannot and never have produce a PUBLISHED WORK to support your nonsense.

You can't ride the coattails of Dungey because your in staunch denial of Dungey's world of conductors and PLASMAS, and ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in solar flares! All you can do is attack the messenger. How very sad for you that you cannot and will not embrace those holy "chicken scratchings" written by Dungey, written by Bruce, written by Birkeland, written by Birkeland himself. Bash him all you like, but always was, and always will be, 10 times the *SCIENTIST* that you or I will EVER be.

He didn't just sit around and do chicken scratchings, though he produced MANY Of them that you have personally never read. What a pity you would bash those scratchings without ever lifting a finger to educate yourself.

Whatever ego gratification you derive from attacking individuals, it will pale in comparison to the ultimately humiliation you will feel one day IMO. The rejection of that giant cathode in space is going to seem INCOMPREHENSIBLE to future generations IMO.
 
Last edited:
Maxwell's equations have been verified to explain how the electric and magnetic fields behave under non-quantum-scale conditions. Once the experiements verify that the fields behave according to what the equations say, they become more than just mathematical equations. They now are known to describe the physics. They, in effect, have become the physics.

No, they don't relate to the PHYSICS of plasma until you ADD PLASMA. You're essentially peddling an equivocation fallacy, and pulling a "bait and switch" routine. MHD theory, where "reconnection" occurs is a world related to PLASMAS and the BEHAVIORS OF PLASMAS in the presence of EM fields. You can't simply remove the PLASMA and claim the PHYSICS is identical! It's NOT!

I showed you all the EXACT TWO EQUATIONS where particle kinetic energy and CURRENT *DISCHARGE* (Dungey's words) themselves to the X,Y plane, causing RECONNECTION to occur. Tim tried to claim it not even relevant to the discussion! Holy cow. Talk about pure denial of those math formulas you claim are *oh so important*. I guess denial isn't logical. I shouldn't expect hater behaviors to be logical.

There is no need for any ions or anything for these equations to describe how the fields behave. You just don't understand physics. Many of us have grad degrees in physics or are even employed to do physics every day and do understand. That you are unwilling to learn from us is your problem, not ours.

I certainly know enough physics to know that PLASMA physics isn't exactly like VACUUM PHYSICS, no matter how many times you try to hide behind that equivocation fallacy. No amount of blaming the messenger is going to make up for the fact that "discharges happen" in reconnection events according to Dungey, and LEE made an EMPIRICAL connection that NONE OF YOU WILL EVER PRODUCE with MR theory. You could of course CRANK UP THE AMPERAGE AND VOLTAGE associated with those 'Bennett Pinches' in plasma, but then the ELECTRIC HORSE is still providing all the kinetic energy to the formulas I cited. Deal with it.
 
Hear hear. Prior to Michael's contributions, I would have thought:

a) Birkeland was a pioneering scientist and the first to formulate good aurora hypotheses

b) Alfven got a Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, but was otherwise forgotten.

c) There was that one sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot at that one APS meeting

Thanks to Michael Mozina, I now know that

a) Birkeland was a dabbler-in-many-things rather than a careful space-plasma expert. He came up with a decent aurora hypothesis (by the standards of pre-space-age astronomy speculators), but his understanding was generally inferior to that of his countryman Carl Stormer. Plus he had a crazy steampunk plasma globe!

FYI, his "aurora" theories were predicated upon a CATHODE bombarding his sphere with electrons. Once he saw how aurora worked, he naturally looked for the CATHODE that drove the process. You folks can bury your head in the sand till the end of time, but you'll never be half the "astrophysicist" that he was, nor will I. That is just "historical fact".

b) Alfven got the Nobel for the theory of Alfven waves, then became both a plasma-physics curmudgeon and a full-blown cosmology crackpot, and was therefore forgotten.

Oh no, haters still PILFER HIS WORK, and peddle what he called "pseudoscience" because haters are all incapable of seeing BOTH orientations to the same event.

If he was guilty of anything, he was guilty of being every bit as much of a bigot as the mainstream, just in the opposite direction.

c) The sun-is-metal-enriched crackpot was named Oliver Manuel.

Gee, you got in the world "crackpot" twice there, including Alfven himself. I don't suppose you own a Nobel Prize ben?

Whatever. I've been called "evil" by creationists for threatening their denial song and dance routine. I guess since you can't call your detractors "evil", you label them "crackpots" to protect yourselves emotionally. How very sad.
 
Well, I have to disagree with both points b here. Alfvén was awarded the Nobel prize for:



And although he may have had some strange ideas (especially near the end of his life), he will never be forgotten in physics because of his development of MHD, and his insights in plasma physics for things like double layers and the critical ionization velocity as well as setting up a great experimental plasma laboratory at the Royal Institue of Technology in Stockholm, Sweden, which now carries his name.

I do find it interesting that you honor his work in double layers and you fail to see how it's not related to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and "reconnection" events in general. :(
 
The above is an insightful observation. It is possible that some naive layman, exposed to some slick and facile introduction to EU theory, might be momentarily seduced by a more persuasive crackpot. Mozina has amply demonstrated the absurdity of EU theory by being a poster boy for its non-scientific bedlam. He indeed does not scratch chickens and bark math because of his profound ignorance, which he amply demonstrates for all laymen to see, thereby highlighting the comical madness of EU conjectures.

There you go, right back to attacking the individual and NOT DEALING with that actual math formulas I cited from Priest's work. You personally cannot and never will deal with those two formulas and their relevancy to this discussion. Therefore you will continue to attack *INDIVIDUALS* blindly, with hatred and malice, and you'll believe you're doing someone some good at the level of "science". You're only deluding yourself IMO. People can see for themselves how you have run from the two PRIEST equations by DISTRACTING the conversation. You can't handle the science. Therefore you attack the individual. If you want to discuss any math equations with me, start by addressing the two I cited from Priests Paper, and YOU TELL ME what they mean! I already cited the relevant work. If you're a "scientist", let's focus on the RELEVANT PHYSICS from Priest and get to it. Are you capable of actually discussing the PHYSICS, yes or no? If so, demonstrate it.
 
PURE *UNADULTERATED* DENIAL OF FACT! Dungey *PERSONALLY DID NOT* that himself!
The crank Bruce did it.
Birkeland did not do it too actually.

Yes RC, they did. You cannot change history. Their writings are all available on the internet for anyone to read. No amount of LYING TO YOURSELF is going to change history. Dungey associated "reconnection" with "electrical discharges" and flares. He did that himself. I've shown you a related paper where he did just that. Birkeland beat him to it by 50 years as it relates to flare events. Bruce CERTAINLY wrote about electrical discharges and solar flare. Lee showed an empirical connection to flares in the 70's. No amount of pure denial can ever change history RC.
 
FYI, DRD....

Someone just emailed me today, asking me to join the solid surface sun conversation he's engaged in over at Thunderbolts. I think I'll pop in and and see how the conversation is going. Evidently I'm not quite the pariah within the EU community that you would make me out to be. :)
 
FYI, his "aurora" theories were predicated upon a CATHODE bombarding his sphere with electrons. Once he saw how aurora worked, he naturally looked for the CATHODE that drove the process. You folks can bury your head in the sand till the end of time, but you'll never be half the "astrophysicist" that he was, nor will I. That is just "historical fact".

The sun is not a cathode. The solar wind is made up of charged particles, but there are an equal amount of positive and negative.
 
The sun is not a cathode. The solar wind is made up of charged particles, but there are an equal amount of positive and negative.

Well, put it this way: The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere, and current flows between them. The particle flow is composed of both types of charged particles AS PREDICTED by Birkeland's cathode solar model as listed in my sig line.
 
FYI DRD, in just 2 minutes I found 2 discussions of solid surface ideas, one going back to 2008 (Brant's thread). I posted on an EARLIER board that predated the new one as well, but I think many of those early posts were lost when their old board bit the dust. I'll post there now and again for your benefit, lest you label me outcast. ;)
 
Was going to write something else. But it's time to give up. It took over 6 years on this board to find someone worthy of the ignore list.
 
Last edited:
Well, put it this way: The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere, and current flows between them.

Hey circuit-man, why don't you write down a circuit for that? I'd like to see how Kirchhoff's Law can be obeyed by an isolated spherical cathode (without, pace Birkeland, a high-voltage wire soldered to it).
 
There you go, right back to attacking the individual and NOT DEALING with that actual math formulas I cited from Priest's work. You personally cannot and never will deal with those two formulas and their relevancy to this discussion. Therefore you will continue to attack *INDIVIDUALS* blindly, with hatred and malice, and you'll believe you're doing someone some good at the level of "science". You're only deluding yourself IMO. People can see for themselves how you have run from the two PRIEST equations by DISTRACTING the conversation. You can't handle the science. Therefore you attack the individual. If you want to discuss any math equations with me, start by addressing the two I cited from Priests Paper, and YOU TELL ME what they mean! I already cited the relevant work. If you're a "scientist", let's focus on the RELEVANT PHYSICS from Priest and get to it. Are you capable of actually discussing the PHYSICS, yes or no? If so, demonstrate it.

Excuse me? I have never claimed to be a scientist. I am not qualified to tell you anything about Priest's paper. I have steadfastly maintained that I am a layman, with a background in mathematics and some knowledge of electromagnetism. However, you profess to have expertise in solar and plasma physics and electromagnetism. So, once more, I ask you to describe for me the meaning of each of the symbols below and the significance of the equation:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

Otherwise, admit you are pretending to have knowledge that you do not actually have, which is the basis of your advocacy of crackpot physics.

Addendum: Sorry, I forgot: You don't scratch chickens or bark math!
 
Last edited:
FYI DRD, in just 2 minutes I found 2 discussions of solid surface ideas, one going back to 2008 (Brant's thread). I posted on an EARLIER board that predated the new one as well, but I think many of those early posts were lost when their old board bit the dust. I'll post there now and again for your benefit, lest you label me outcast. ;)


From what I see it looks like a bunch of crackpottery zealots patting each other on the back for having such unwavering faith in some ridiculous notions about the Sun. Clearly nobody in those conversations understands solar satellite imagery, how it's obtained, how it's analyzed, or what any of it means. Yet without so much as a clue they blabber on like a bunch of silly kids making unfounded assertions based on nothing more than other unfounded assertions... well that and incredulity, looks-like-a-bunny fantasies, and in some cases raw stupidity. Mathematical support? It doesn't look like any of the solid surface Sun kiddies know how to do math above a level of 0+0=0. And everyone knows understanding physics requires being able to count higher than zero. Okay, maybe not everyone knows that. :p
 
Michael Mozina said:
FYI DRD, in just 2 minutes I found 2 discussions of solid surface ideas, one going back to 2008 (Brant's thread). I posted on an EARLIER board that predated the new one as well, but I think many of those early posts were lost when their old board bit the dust. I'll post there now and again for your benefit, lest you label me outcast.
From what I see it looks like a bunch of crackpottery zealots patting each other on the back for having such unwavering faith in some ridiculous notions about the Sun. Clearly nobody in those conversations understands solar satellite imagery, how it's obtained, how it's analyzed, or what any of it means. Yet without so much as a clue they blabber on like a bunch of silly kids making unfounded assertions based on nothing more than other unfounded assertions... well that and incredulity, looks-like-a-bunny fantasies, and in some cases raw stupidity. Mathematical support? It doesn't look like any of the solid surface Sun kiddies know how to do math above a level of 0+0=0. And everyone knows understanding physics requires being able to count higher than zero. Okay, maybe not everyone knows that. :p

Thanks for quoting this GM; with MM on Ignore, I would not have seen it otherwise.

What forum (or fora) is MM referring to?

Here is a recent comment, by a mod on the Thunderdolts forum, on MM's website (the last four lines are links, in the original):
nick c said:
That is a pro "Iron Sun" site, a model that is quite different than the Electric Sun as formulated by Juergens/Scott/Thornhill etc.
Here are some TPOD's summarizing the differences between the EU position and the Iron Sun hypothesis.
The "Iron Sun" Debate (1)
The "Iron Sun" Debate (2)
The "Iron Sun" Debate (3)
The "Iron Sun" Debate (4)

There's some pretty damning words in those four Teapots; for example "It is a pity that the “Iron Sun” researchers [that means you, MM, among others] are not conversant with plasma cosmology and the Electric Sun model." Ouch! :p
 
From what I see it looks like a bunch of crackpottery zealots

The hallmark of any good cult is how well it villianizes the competition. Your little cult has taken the slander factor to new heights. Since you can't call anyone evil, it's 'crackpot', crank, whatever. Pitiful.

patting each other on the back for having such unwavering faith in some ridiculous notions about the Sun.

It looks like they discuss *SEVERAL* different options rather openly and fairly as far as I can tell.

Clearly nobody in those conversations understands solar satellite imagery, how it's obtained, how it's analyzed, or what any of it means.

Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?" Considering you STILL believe that the color of the horizon is somehow related to an alignment problem in an iron line composite image, and electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors, you have no right to complain about anyone and what they know or don't know about a solar satellite image.

Yet without so much as a clue

Wow. You already decided that ALL of them are clueless?

they blabber on like a bunch of silly kids making unfounded assertions

Blather? Unfounded assertions, like discharges cannot occur in conductors?

based on nothing more than other unfounded assertions... well that and incredulity, looks-like-a-bunny fantasies, and in some cases raw stupidity.

Oh, you must mean like that comment you made about discharges and conductors.

Mathematical support? It doesn't look like any of the solid surface Sun kiddies know how to do math above a level of 0+0=0. And everyone knows understanding physics requires being able to count higher than zero. Okay, maybe not everyone knows that. :p

This place is one giant, constant, relentless personal assault. That's all you folks understand. Science? What science do you understand? You don't know the very first thing about plasma or the manifestation of current inside of plasma. Dungey himself coined the term "reconnection' and purposefully associated the process with 'electrical discharges' in plasmas/conductors. Mann and Onel applies Alfven's circuit theory to actual satellite images. That demonstrates quite clearly that the real "crackpots" are. You and RC can't even embrace reality at it's most fundamental level. Personal attacks are therefore all you can do to protect those pitiful belief systems. Yawn.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom