Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Try this animation on REPULSION PS:
http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp
No B lines "reconnect". They simply "spread out" or "bend and twist".
No one expects B lines to break and reconnect in these animations. They just demonstrate attraction and repulsion between 2 magnets.

The magnetic fields from 4 current bearing rods (W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection) have a null point.

At a null point, field lines do not exist for really simple reasons:
  • no field = no field lines :jaw-dropp,
  • zero strength field = zero field line density
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II
 
Last edited:
Scientific debate: 101 (replicability of results)

Michael Mozina has given us a nice explanation of how one particular advocate of the Electric Sun pseudoscience misconceives of scientific debate.

That gives me an excuse
  • to explain what real scientific debate is like,
  • to explain how most of the participants in this thread have been engaging in a real scientific debate,
  • to explain why the most prolific contributor to this thread is not engaging in a scientific debate,
  • and to point out yet another example of that contributor's hypocrisy.
In a "scientific debate", one is *EXPECTED AND REQUIRED* to provide *EXTERNAL* and preferably PUBLISHED works to support their case. Ideally such references should come from *OUTSIDE* of self. If one's own works HAVE in fact been published, well then, that's a different story. Even still, something 'outside of self' is really the "best" type of reference. Then nobody has to rely upon a SINGLE INDIVIDUAL for "truth", and nobody has to "guess" what you mean, they can read the whole thing as a complete presentation. You also don't end up being your own source of "truth" using that technique.
Michael Mozina thinks scientists debate by quoting holy texts.

When real scientists debate, reproducibility matters more than publication.


[size=+1]What real scientific debate is like[/size]

If a scientist can check my calculations for herself, then she doesn't much care whether those calculations have been published. Her own calculations are more convincing to her than the calculations in some paper---because she'd have to check the calculations in that paper anyway before she'd be fully convinced.

If a scientist can easily perform the experiment I've been suggesting in his own lab, then he doesn't much care whether someone else has performed that experiment and published her results. His own measurements are more convincing to him than someone else's reported measurements---because he'd have to perform those measurements himself or wait for them to be confirmed by others before he'd be fully convinced.

In real scientific discussions, all participants have mastered the basic math and science of their discipline.

For our discussion here, which involves a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection from Maxwell's equations, in a vacuum, without plasma, the only prerequisites are vector calculus and electromagnetism as taught to physics majors during their first year at a good university.

Anyone who possesses those basic skills is qualified to participate in this discussion. Those who do not possess those basic skills are not qualified to participate in this scientific discussion, but the rules of this forum do permit them to kibbitz or to flame.


[size=+1]Most of us have been participating in a real scientific debate[/size]

The qualified participants all know that div B=0 for the magnetic field B around a current-carrying rod, from which div B4=0 follows immediately by linearity. (Those who want more practice with freshman calculus may also calculate the divergence explicitly.) The qualified participants all know that div B4=0 is the mathematically correct way to say Gauss's law for magnetism holds for B4, which means there are no monopoles, sources, or sinks anywhere in B4.

Some qualified participants might not know that four of the magnetic field lines within each xy plane begin or end at the neutral point of B4, but they will learn that fact by reading and checking my proof of that fact. After all, that's just a matter of understanding the mathematical definition of magnetic field lines and applying some high school algebra to the equation for B4. All qualified participants can and will check that math for themselves.

All qualified participants in this scientific discussion are capable of checking my graph of B4:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoomout.png[/qimg]

They're unlikely to reproduce that graph for themselves (because producing such graphs and animations is tedious for those of us who don't work with computer graphics on a regular basis), but they will hold their right hand in an appropriate orientation for each of the four current-carrying rods before concluding that my graph is qualitatively correct. If they have any lingering doubts about my graph, they can spot-check it using the equation for B4 or they can download my source code and the Runge-Kutta library and calculate any field line that interests them.

That's why all qualified participants in this discussion are aware that B4 is the magnetic field generated by currents running through the four parallel rods of the experiment I suggested to Michael Mozina almost a year ago. They're also aware that B4 is the magnetic field in a vacuum, that the only currents are those that run through the four rods, and that there is no plasma in that experiment or in the vacuum that surrounds the rods.

All qualified participants are capable of checking my animations of the magnetic reconnections that occur when the currents that generate B4 are changed slowly:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr100.gif[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr00.gif[/qimg]

They're unlikely to reproduce those animations themselves, again because it's tedious, but they can use the right-hand rule to confirm that what they're seeing in the animations is qualitatively correct, and they can spot-check the animations using my source code or by performing the calculations themselves.

The qualified participants in this scientific discussion agree with my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection from Maxwell's equations because they are able to check my work for themselves, and they have done so.

To those who are qualified to discuss science, their own examination and checking of my derivation is more convincing than anything Wikipedia or some professor's course notes might say.

That's not to say scientists ignore the published literature. In this case, there are literally hundreds of research papers and several books on magnetic reconnection. Most of those involve plasma, of course, but tusenfem, Tim Thompson, and Reality Check have cited at least five publications that discuss magnetic reconnection in a vacuum:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7815340#post7815340

I have not yet read all of those publications, but I understand that most or all of them discuss a two-rod variation of the experiment I've been suggesting, and achieve reconnection by changing the distance between the rods instead of varying the current through them. That's conceptually simpler than my experiment, but the math is a little simpler with my experiment.


[size=+1]Why Michael Mozina is not engaging in real scientific debate[/size]

The threshold for participation in this particular scientific debate is fairly low. Participants must understand basic vector calculus and electromagnetism.

Michael Mozina does not understand basic vector calculus, and he does not understand basic electromagnetism.

That's why Michael Mozina is still blabbering about Gauss's law for magnetism, monopoles, sources, and sinks. If he actually understood div B=0, he'd have dropped that line of argument about ten seconds after I described the experimental setup that generates B4.

That's why Michael Mozina is still blabbering about how the magnetic field lines simply "flux" or "bend and twist" or "spread out" instead of reconnecting. If he actually understood magnetic flux and field lines, he'd have dropped that line of argument long before I ever got around to producing my animations of magnetic reconnection.

That's why Michael Mozina is still blabbering about "magnetic repulsion/attraction" or "solid magnet reconnection". He doesn't know what the magnetic field looks like in the vacuum around a current-carrying rod, so he has absolutely no idea of what the magnetic field generated by four such rods might look like.


[size=+1]Michael Mozina's hypocrisy[/size]

Michael Mozina is no more ignorant of vector calculus and electromagnetism than a typical panhandler in the vicinity of Harvard Square, but the typical panhandler knows he doesn't understand vector calculus and electromagnetism.

Michael Mozina doesn't seem to know his limitations.

Or maybe Michael Mozina is aware of his limitations, but doesn't think his near-total ignorance of vector calculus and electromagnetism disqualifies him from participating in a real scientific discussion of magnetic reconnection. After all, he's read actual books on plasma physics, including one or two by the great Hannes Alfvén.

Michael Mozina relies on authority figures because he is unable to evaluate scientific arguments on their own merits.

That's not a bad idea, really. If you aren't qualified to evaluate a scientific argument, you could do worse than to trust the experts.

Michael Mozina trusts experts only when they agree with him. If some expert disagrees with him, Michael Mozina will either deny the expert's expertise or find a way to misinterpret what the expert is saying. For example:

Hannes Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
That's the great Hannes Alfvén acknowledging that magnetic reconnection is a straightforward consequence of Maxwell's equations. Michael Mozina misinterprets that as the great Hannes Alfvén condemning magnetic reconnection as pseudoscience.

A sensible man would at least consider the possibility that those of us who studied vector calculus and electromagnetism as undergraduates before going on to complete graduate degrees in mathematics, physics, or engineering could be right about magnetic reconnection being a straightforward consequence of Maxwell's equations. A sensible man would at least consider the possibility that not all of the hundreds of research papers and several books devoted to magnetic reconnection are wrong about the nature of magnetic reconnection.

Not Michael Mozina. Michael Mozina is in full denial. Michael Mozina insists we show him a published reference before he'll believe anything we say.

We've been showing him hundreds of published references. He denies them.

When Michael Mozina feigns respect for the authority of scientific publications, he's being hypocritical.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo VI: Mozina's links

Try this animation on REPULSION PS:

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/images/MagneticFieldRepulsion.gif

No B lines "reconnect". They simply "spread out" or "bend and twist".


What, are you blind? Look at the animation entitled "A pair of D42 magnets attracting, animated" (second from bottom) on your first link ...

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

Look at the magnetic field lines that connect the poles of the attracting magnets. Those B-field lines, in that animation, clearly break and reconnect as the poles pull apart. I can see it and I know you can see it too.
 
Michael Mozina has given us a nice explanation of how one particular advocate of the Electric Sun pseudoscience misconceives of scientific debate.

Er, the process of providing *EXTERNAL VALIDATION* isn't just for a SINGLE TOPIC Clinger!

Michael Mozina thinks scientists debate by quoting holy texts.

As always, you begin with a lie. I asked you for an EXTERNAL REFERENCE. I didn't say squat about "Holy Texts". A scientific reference *OUTSIDE OF SELF* ensures that one is not just "making it up" in their head like you're doing with the notion of B lines "beginning" somewhere.

When real scientists debate, reproducibility matters more than publication.


[size=+1]What real scientific debate is like[/size]

If a scientist can check my calculations for herself, then she doesn't much care whether those calculations have been published.

Epic Kludge number one: Not all errors are *MATHEMATICAL* in nature. While there is nothing wrong with your PITIFUL math, that pitifully simple math was NEVER the problem. The problem is that you believe you can take *ANY* point and turn it into a "beginning" of B lines. You ABUSE of vector calculus in that manner **IS** the problem.

A real scientist *WILL CARE* if similar work has been published and properly cited. In your case a "proper" citation is one that does NOT involve plasmas since you claimed that "
reconnection" is a plasma optional process.

Her own calculations are more convincing to her than the calculations in some paper---because she'd have to check the calculations in that paper anyway before she'd be fully convinced.

However, she won't ASSUME like you do that your error is mathematical in nature.

[size=+1]Most of us have been participating in a real scientific debate[/size]

No. Most of the "haters" don't even provide external citations. They argue like you.

The qualified participants all know that div B=0 for the magnetic field B around a current-carrying rod, from which div B4=0 follows immediately by linearity. (Those who want more practice with freshman calculus may also calculate the divergence explicitly.) The qualified participants all know that div B4=0 is the mathematically correct way to say Gauss's law for magnetism holds for B4, which means there are no monopoles, sources, or sinks anywhere in B4.

Yes, but those same qualified participants know that Gauss's laws are satisified EVERYWHERE, meaning no point is the "beginning" of any B lines.

Some qualified participants might not know that four of the magnetic field lines within each xy plane begin or end at the neutral point of B4,

The "qualified" participants know that isn't true! NONE of the B lines begin or end there.

but they will learn that fact by reading and checking my proof of that fact. After all, that's just a matter of understanding the mathematical definition of magnetic field lines and applying some high school algebra to the equation for B4. All qualified participants can and will check that math for themselves.

All they will find there is KLUDGED NONSENSE and vector equations that amount to 0+0=0, proving conclusively that NOTHING could "begin" there or anywhere else.

We've been showing him hundreds of published references. He denies them.

I deny they relate to YOUR SPECIFIC claims because they all involved MHD theory and plasma physics, whereas you claim plasma is OPTIONAL in the "reconnection" process.

You've essentially SKEWERED yourself in this thread for all the world to see. You refuse to provide *EXTERNAL* published references about "reconnection" in the absence of plasma, because there ARE NONE! You refuse to provide any references that claim B lines "begin" anywhere, because there ARE NONE! You make false claims by the bucket load, and like any good creationist, you refuse to provide any "evidence" outside of yourself to demonstrate your claims. You've been hiding behind equivocation fallacies since day one. You can't ride Dungey's coattails because his process is PLASMA related and he explains it in terms of PLASMA PROCESSES that result in *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in plasma. You can't ride anyone's coattails in fact because nobody else claims in published works that B lines "begin" anywhere, particularly WITHOUT plasma.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina does not understand basic vector calculus, and he does not understand basic electromagnetism.

Pure lies and pure personal attacks in absence of an external reference as requested. Your simplistic vector calculus amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum, and you've KLUDGED EM theory since the moment you claimed B lines "begin" somewhere. I provided you with more than a dozen EM class links that all demonstrate *YOUR* error, including one from MIT. You've provide ZERO references outside of yourself to support your absurd and ridiculous claim about B lines "beginning" somewhere.
 
Last edited:
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.

Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, but nowhere is the "beginning" of a B line.
 
Last edited:
Hannes Alfven on the topic of magnetic reconnection/merging:

B. Magnetic Merging — A Pseudo-Science

Since then I have stressed in a large number of papers the danger of using the frozen-in concept. For example, in a paper "Electric Current Structure of the Magnetosphere" (Alfvén, 1975), I made a table showing the difference between the real plasma and "a fictitious medium" called "the pseudo-plasma," the latter having frozenin magnetic field lines moving with the plasma. The most important criticism of the "merging" mechanism of energy transfer is due to Heikkila (1973) who with increasing strength has demonstrated that it is wrong. In spite of all this, we have witnessed at the same time an enormously voluminous formalism building up based on this obviously erroneous concept. Indeed, we have been burdened with a gigantic pseudo-science which penetrates large parts of cosmic plasma physics. The monograph CP treats the field-line reconnection (merging) concept in 1.3, 11.3, and 11.5. We may conclude that anyone who uses the merging concepts states by implication that no double layers exist.

A new epoch in magnetospheric physics was inaugurated by L. Lyons and D. Williams' monograph (1985). They treat magnetospheric phenomena systematically by the particle approach and demonstrate that the fluid dynamic approach gives erroneous results. The error of the latter approach is of a basic character. Of course there can be no magnetic merging energy transfer.

I was naive enough to believe that such a pseudo-science would die by itself in the scientific community, and I concentrated my work on more pleasant problems. To my great surprise the opposite has occurred; the "merging" pseudo-science seems to be increasingly powerful. Magnetospheric physics and solar wind physics today are no doubt in a chaotic state, and a major reason for this is that some of the published papers are science and part pseudoscience, perhaps even with a majority for the latter group.

In those parts of solar physics which do not deal with the interior of the Sun and the dense photospheric region (fields where the frozen-in concept may be valid), the state is even worse. It is difficult to find theoretical papers on the low density regions which are correct. The present state of plasma astrophysics seems to be almost completely isolated from the new concepts of plasma which the in situ measurements on space plasma have made necessary (see Section VIII).

I sincerely hope that the increased interest in the study of double layers — which is fatal to this pseudoscience — will change the situation. Whenever we find a double layer (or any other E ll # 0) we hammer a nail into the coffin of the "merging" pseudo-science.
 
Last edited:
I've seen handwaves used in arguments before, but EU haters take it to a new level. It's physics be damned with this crew. Just handwave a little math at them and they all swoon and kneel in reverence to Origin the great NULL, the false B line beginnor god of the vacuum.
 
Just handwave a little math at them and they all swoon and kneel in reverence to Origin the great NULL, the false B line beginnor god of the vacuum.

Show the mistakes in Clinger's math, and then someone will listen. His math, BTW, starts with Maxwell's equations, which have been borne out by experiment to be valid descriptions of the EM field.

So to refute Clinger's derivation, you have to do one of these things:

1) Show Maxwell's equations are in error
2) Show Clinger's math is in error.

Just saying Clinger's math is wrong is not enough. You have to show specific steps. It's like I said in the example of the 1 = 0 proof. You have to show where the math went wrong before anyone will believe you that the result is incorrect.

This is how science works. If you want to argue in the manner you have been in this thread, I suggest you try literary criticism instead, where things are more subjective.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo VI: Mozina's links (2)

Try this animation on REPULSION PS:

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/images/MagneticFieldRepulsion.gif

No B lines "reconnect". They simply "spread out" or "bend and twist".


What, are you blind? Look at the animation entitled "A pair of D42 magnets attracting, animated" (second from bottom) on your first link ...

http://www.kjmagnetics.com/magneticfield.asp

Look at the magnetic field lines that connect the poles of the attracting magnets. Those B-field lines, in that animation, clearly break and reconnect as the poles pull apart. I can see it and I know you can see it too.


They are magnets in an attracting process. Where do you see the word "reconnection" on that page?


OK, you're blind and illiterate! What part of this is too complicated for you: Those B-field lines, in that animation, clearly break and reconnect as the poles pull apart.. Well, do they or don't they? Don't give me any crap about "the word reconnection" this time and look at the animation you posted. The animation not the words. What do you see?
 
Show the mistakes in Clinger's math, and then someone will listen. His math, BTW, starts with Maxwell's equations, which have been borne out by experiment to be valid descriptions of the EM field.

It's not his "math" that's the problem, it's his "interpretation" of that math that stinks, not to mention the fact it makes no logical sense!

His math amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum. Miraculously this revelation somehow in his mind translates to: "Look, it's the "beginning" of a B line." It's a non-sequitur fallacy. He might as well be claiming that same 0+0=0 math proves that the moon is made of green cheese! No point in the experiment is in any way "unique" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law, so I have no idea why he even thinks that *ONE LOCATION* (in this case a NULL) is "special" in terms of B line "beginnings". :confused: :boggled:
 
Last edited:
OK, you're blind and illiterate!

I love how you folks are allowed to get away with the personal attacks on a daily basis, but if I put a toe over the line, 10 of my posts disappear. :(

What part of this is too complicated for you: Those B-field lines, in that animation, clearly break and reconnect as the poles pull apart.

The fields pull apart and their topology changes over time, but unlike you, I do care about the *PROPER USE* of "scientific terminology". In terms of PHYSICS, "magnetic attraction" isn't "reconnection".
 
Last edited:
It's not his "math" that's the problem, it's his "interpretation" of that math that stinks, not to mention the fact it makes no logical sense!

His math amounts to 0+0=0 in a vacuum. Miraculously this revelation somehow in his mind translates to: "Look, it's the "beginning" of a B line." It's a non-sequitur fallacy. He might as well be claiming that same 0+0=0 math proves that the moon is made of green cheese! No point in the experiment is in any way "unique" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law, so I have no idea why he even thinks that *ONE LOCATION* (in this case a NULL) is "special" in terms of B line "beginnings". :confused: :boggled:

You're wrong.
 
You're wrong.

Then provide a PUBLISHED reference, EXTERNAL TO CLINGER, that demonstrates this statement is false:

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.

Gauss's law is satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, not just at a SINGLE point!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom