Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sometimes plain old logic suffices and links and references are a waste of time. ..... Use you brain, Mozina!

Let's do a little role reversal here. Let's pretend this conversation was related to the topic of evolutionary theory. Let's say that I *PERSONALLY* was in STANCH DENIAL of some process related to evolutionary theory, say micro-evolutionary processes, and I said something like that to you? Suppose I told you to "Use your brain, sometimes plain old logic suffices and "scientific references are a waste of time"? What would you say to that statement PS?
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual StudentSometimes plain old logic suffices and links and references are a waste of time. It is well known that magnetic fields can be configured to cancel themselves to zero magnetic energy in specific areas. In fact, there exists an industry using that fact to "shield" magnetic fields by canceling technology in order to conserve energy in power lines. It is so simple to visualize a magnetic line entering an area of cancellation and ceasing to exist. It's that simple; the magnetic line can be seen to end or begin at the point it enters a place of zero magnetic energy. It is not a "sink" or "source." It is simply a place where the lines ceases to exist. Use you brain, Mozina!


Let's do a little role reversal here. Let's pretend this conversation was related to the topic of evolutionary theory. Let's say that I *PERSONALLY* was in STANCH DENIAL of some process related to evolutionary theory, say micro-evolutionary processes, and I said something like that to you? Suppose I told you to "Use your brain, sometimes plain old logic suffices and "scientific references are a waste of time"? What would you say to that statement PS?
I would not waste my time citing references, authorities and papers. I might use such sources to enhance my own knowledge but then I would use a well though out argument, using my knowledge of the fossil record, genetics, mutation rates, lab experiments, embryology, etc. to make my case.
The logic of my argument would be effective only if my subject did not have a closed mind on the subject. Sound familiar?
Nice diversion! I notice that, as usual, you avoided my point above about magnetic lines ceasing to exist as they enter an area of cancellation.
 
I would not waste my time citing references, authorities and papers. I might use such sources to enhance my own knowledge but then I would use a well though out argument, using my knowledge of the fossil record, genetics, mutation rates, lab experiments, embryology, etc. to make my case.
The logic of my argument would be effective only if my subject did not have a closed mind on the subject. Sound familiar?

Yes, it does, including that disclaimer at the end about having an "open mind". Even when I pointed out that Clinger's Origin was not *UNIQUE* in any way in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws, you pretty much outright ignored every logical argument I could think of.

Nice diversion! I notice that, as usual, you avoided my point above about magnetic lines ceasing to exist as they enter an area of cancellation.

So what? They don't BEGIN there, or ANYWHERE. Magnetic field lines DO NOT GO into (or "cease to exist" as you put it) MANY regions of spacetime. Big deal. That doesn't make any of those EMPTY regions a "beginning' of any B lines that exist in other regions.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it does, including that disclaimer at the end about having an "open mind". Even when I pointed out that Clinger's Origin was not *UNIQUE* in any way in terms of satisfying Gauss's laws, you pretty much outright ignored every logical argument I could think of.
You have never presented a logical argument. All you have ever done is provide links to sources you do not understand.



So what? They don't BEGIN there, or ANYWHERE. Magnetic field lines DO NOT GO into (or "cease to exist" as you put it) MANY regions of spacetime. Big deal. That doesn't make any of those EMPTY regions a "beginning' of any B lines that exist in other regions.
I have no idea what the above is supposed to mean. So, what happens to a B line when it enters an area of cancellation?
 
You have never presented a logical argument.

Boloney. You don't like those dozen references is all. You don't like the fact that Origin isn't "special" either.

All you have ever done is provide links to sources you do not understand.

Oh I understand them JUST FINE! It's you that refuses to embrace reality! As long as you continue to claim B lines "begin", you're in pure denial of BASIC EM THEORY!

I have no idea what the above is supposed to mean.

Sure you do. Again, you just don't want to admit that B lines DO NOT ENTER many regions of spactime. That doesn't make any of those regions where no lines exist, the 'beginning" of any B line.

So, what happens to a B line when it enters an area of cancellation?

NOTHING!
 
Last edited:
Somov's "vacuum" includes *CURRENT*, AKA NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA!.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI are persisting :jaw-dropp!
Wow - you are really making yourself seem deluded with this continued instance that a section about reconnection in vacuum has plasma in it.

As I pointed out before this is stupid:

Originally Posted by Reality Check
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V

Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing WIRES to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing ELECTRON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing PROTON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducingIONIZED SILVER BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.

Can you see that my satirical comments is as stupid as your serious assertion about PLASMA?

Somov has no plasma.
Somov has no wires.
Somov has no beams of any kind of charged particle.

He has 2 parallel electrical currents that just exist.

and:
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing CHARGED PINK UNICORNS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
Assuming Clinger was actually right, *HE* should be able to round up DOZENS of links that demonstrate his claim!
That is where you display your ignorance yet again.
Magnetic reconnection in vacuum is a trivial process. It is probably covered in a few minutes in a plasma physics class.
No one would expect DOZENS of sources for MR in a vacuum.
A few textbooks may cover it.
Even fewer scientific papers would mention it.

And we do have these sources: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III that include MR in vacuum.

We also have a clear description of MR in a vacuum: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
I didn't FORCE him to claim he could get "reconnection" to occur *WITHOUT* plasma. He did that to himself.
And he did get "reconnection" to occur *WITHOUT* plasma: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
Your ignorance though brevents you from understanding this simple derivation.

He has external *EXTERNAL* sources of support: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

B lines do not begin. They do not end. They do not have a source without monopoles. They do not have a sink either.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

It's not my fault.
It is your fault that you cannot understand the definition of field lines that makes the Wikipedia atrial contradict itself:
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

It is your fault that you are obsessing about the lies to children that professors tell undergraduates (B lines never end) rather than leaning the actual physics:
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

It is your fault that you keep whining about W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection being wrong without being able to understand it enough to show that is wrong.
MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3

It is your fault that you are persisting with the delusion that there are monopoles in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection:
Michael Mozina delusion that there are monopoles needed for MR

There are no monopoles in the derivation (or MR).
There are no sinks in the derivation (or MR).
There are no sources in the derivation (or MR).
 
Tell it to Dungey. He's delusional too evidently. :)
No - it is you who are deluded (Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma).
60 years ago, in a few papers, Dungey decided to label a high current density (and made it explicitly clear that he was using this label only in this context) as a discharge or 'electrical discharge'.
This practice did not continue probably since scientists quickly realized the confusion this caused since actual electrical discharges can never happen in plasma.

What we are left with is your fantasy that you can use an obsolete term for high current density and not be thought of as ignorant..
 
FYI, Clinger, I'm still waiting for a reference of "B *LINE* reconnection*, OUTSIDE of yourself, that doesn't involve plasma or MHD theory.
 
"Origin the unimportant" is the antithesis of "special". Nothing about that specific point in spacetime is "unique" in terms of "Gauss's laws". Gauss's laws are not *ONLY* satisfied at ONE point, they are satisfied EVERYWHERE!

The basic argument that you're trying to make is that an area *WITHOUT* any B lines is the "beginning" of B lines! That's just a ridiculous argument. :eek:
 
Oy Vey. It was a DIRECT ANSWER. NOTHING HAPPENS!

Lots of areas of spacetime do NOT contain B fields. That does not make ANY of those areas the 'beginning' of any B line in the universe! Your argument is invalid!

Still evasive. I am quite clearly talking about magnetic lines that exist until they enter an area where they are cancelled out by equal and opposite lines. What happens to them when they are cancelled? On what scientific basis do you insist (a little mathematical demonstration would do) that they do not cease to exist and hence, do not stop, end or begin?
 
Last edited:
Still evasive. I am quite clearly talking about magnetic lines that exist until they enter an area where they are cancelled out by equal and opposite lines.

What do you mean "cancelled out"? Do you mean magnetic repulsion/attraction that diverts the lines away from the NULL?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom