Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Without source code, and based on the fact the source points MOVE, I'd have to assume it's based on MHD theory, leaving Clinger stuck in a vacuum without a plasma particle to his name. :)
Without source code and pased on the facts that the authors
  1. State that this is 'vacuum reconnection'
  2. State that the points move which they would in a vacuum (or a plasma)
anyone with a basic knowledge of English would assume that it is MR ain a vacuum (EM theory, not MHD theory)., leaving your delusions about W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection stuck in an Internet forum for the world to be appalled at for the foreseeable future.
 
*IF* that were true (and it's not), then you should be able to show me some PUBLISHED references that explain the fact it's a 'little white lie'.
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III
Could it be that anyone who has ever completed a course in plasma physics knows that B lines can end and start?

Of course we do not have to trust people who actually work in magnetic reconnection to know what they are talking about just because they have spent years or decades studying their subject :jaw-dropp!

All we need to do is look up the definition of a field line, MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II
or read
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
how much dishonesty can MM cram into a single day?

All of the dishonesty quoted below comes from yesterday's posts by Michael Mozina.

IMO it's "dishonest" of you to turn a scientific discussion into a PERSONAL attack. I've been VERY upfront about the fact that I personally believe that *CLINGER'S* (not my) claim that all lines CROSS in the middle is BS.
It was Michael Mozina who claimed (on 14 November 2011) that magnetic field lines cross at the X.

Magnetic field lines cannot cross. I have corrected Michael Mozina on this point several times. When Michael Mozina pretends his mistake was mine, he is being dishonest.

You folks are the ones *INSISTING* that every freshman physics textbook on the planet is *WRONG*, not me. How HONEST is that behavior...?
Michael Mozina is the one who's been insisting that every freshman-level textbook states a certain popular myth. The better textbooks, such as Purcell's Electricity and Magnetism, do not repeat that myth.

From a *PURELY MATHEMATICAL* perspective, yes, you might *THINK* of a bunch of lines crossing at ZERO, but even in basic EM theory, they make it clear the NO B LINES CROSS! Clinger has made ONE FRESHMAN MISTAKE AFTER ANOTHER AFTER ANOTHER.
From a purely mathematical perspective, it is obvious that magnetic field lines cannot cross. Once again, Michael Mozina is accusing me of making mistakes only he has made.

Clinger has been handwaving nothing but mathematical NONSENSE at me based on a SERIES of freshman *THEORETICAL* mistakes about BASIC EM theory.
Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, and has never taken a course in electromagnetism, so he cannot distinguish the correct mathematics I have posted from the hand-waving and mathematical nonsense he has been shouting.

None of your arguments have been "peer reviewed". None of them have ever been "published' anywhere before *THIS* conversation. The whole conversation is surreal. I hand you more than a dozen published papers that all claim that B lines do not begin, end, have sources or sinks.
B fields do not have sources or sinks, but B field lines can begin or end.

Michael Mozina has not found any published papers that contradict what I just said. He has found several Wikipedia articles, and he has found some online course notes. When he claims to have handed us "more than a dozen published papers that all claim that B lines do not begin", he is lying.

You have provided NOTHING to demonstrate otherwise,
I have provided a rigorous mathematical proof that B field lines can begin or end at the neutral point of magnetic fields such as B4. When Michael Mozina denies that I have provided that proof, he is lying.

So what? Gauss's law is satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, not ONLY in NULLS! What a LAME argument!
I have supplied several different proofs that Gauss's law for magnetism is satisfied everywhere in the magnetic fields that contradict Michael Mozina's claims. When Michael Mozina pretends those proofs applied only to the null/neutral points, he is lying.

Excuse me? It's *DISHONEST AS HELL* of you to try to claim that B lines can "begin" in the absence of a monopole. It is dishonest to argue with nothing more than HANDWAVES rather than published works. It's DISHONEST to claim that it's "super-significant' that Gauss's laws are satisfied in ONE point when they are in fact satisfied *EVERYWHERE*! This whole conversation is dishonest because your side has presented no science. It simply attacks the individual repetitiously and loudly and tosses in PERSONAL HANDWAVES by the bucket load. Those are purely dishonest debate tactics from start to end. Do not even *THINK* about lecturing me about "honesty".
I have given a mathematical proof that some magnetic field lines of B4 begin at the neutral point. I have also given several different mathematical proofs that B4 has no monopoles.

When Michael Mozina refers to those mathematical proofs as "HANDWAVES", he is being dishonest.

When Michael Mozina pretends my proofs that B4 satisfies Gauss's law for magnetism apply only to one point, he is lying.

When Michael Mozina pretends we have presented no science, he is lying.

When Michael Mozina pretends our debating tactics have been dishonest, he is lying.

I already gave you a "science" based response. You FALLACIOUSLY believe that all errors/truths are MATHEMATICAL in nature. That's ridiculous. In this case his error isn't MATHEMATICAL at all. It's CONCEPTUAL in nature. CONCEPTUALLY, B lines *DO NOT* begin, end, have a source or a sink. That is a CONCEPTUAL understanding of how our universe functions that *MUST* be applied to all discussions related to particle and plasma physics.
Michael Mozina appears to be admitting there's nothing wrong with our mathematics, but he's trying to impose his own conceptual errors on everyone else. That isn't dishonest, but it's ridiculous.

So long as you VIOLATE that basic CONCEPTUAL understanding of the PHYSICAL NATURE of B lines, what else can I say? You're in pure denial of how THIS PHYSICAL UNIVERSE OPERATES at a FUNDAMENTAL level, rather than the function of some mythical monopole universe. At a fundamental level, B lines *DO NOT* begin, end, have a source or a sink. Only E fields can do that. All B lines are a result of the MOVEMENT OF CURRENT, and they from as continuous loops as that A diagram I posted earlier demonstrates.
When Michael Mozina pretends we're the ones who are denying the physics, he's being dishonest.

When Michael Mozina pretends we are assuming monopoles, he is lying.

When, within a single phrase, Michael Mozina repeats his false claim that magnetic field lines cannot begin or end alongside the true fact that magnetic fields have no sources or sinks, he is being disingenuous.

When Michael Mozina claims that all magnetic field lines form continuous loops, he is mistaken.

Gauss's laws isn't *ONLY* preserved in Origin the Dud, it's preserved *EVERYWHERE IN THE EXPERIMENT* PS! Origin isn't unique. Get off your knees already.
I have given several different proofs that Gauss's law for magnetism holds for all of the magnetic fields involved in the experiment. When Michael Mozina pretends those proofs apply only at the origin, he's being dishonest.

Without the source code, there's no way to see how the magic was done.
When Michael Mozina complains about not having access to source code after I have given him the source code for an even simpler demonstration of magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, he is being dishonest.

What LINES OF FORCE? You don't even have any evidence that any actual *LINES OF FORCE* go through X in the first place!
We have stated, correctly, that no lines of force go through the neutral point at the X. That's part of the proof that magnetic field lines can begin or end at the neutral point.

When Michael Mozina pretends we have been saying there are lines of force that go through the neutral point (X), he is being dishonest.

No, the saddest part is that you still think Clinger made some fantastic discovery about some UNIQUE point. :( Every point MUST AND DOES satisfy Gauss's law of magnetism, but NO POINT is the "beginning" of any line.
When Michael Mozina pretends my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is anything more than a straightforward consequence of Maxwell's equations, he is being dishonest.

Woah! Hold your horses. Round up the SOURCE CODE that was used for us *BEFORE* you make any claims about this "vacuum" they discuss. They switch back and forth between the terms "corona" and 'toy' reconnection. I want to see how this "toy" process works at the level of source code. If the source code is based on MHD theory, Clinger is SOL! He left out the HYDRO.
The source code I provided is based on Maxwell's equations as taught in a decent freshman-level course in electromagnetism. It is not based on MHD theory. When Michael Mozina pretends there is any question about that, he is being dishonest.

Mathematically speaking, Clinger's example only applies in monopolism. Only if monopoles exist can B lines have "beginnings" and "endings". In our "real" universe, all the loops simply AVOID the actual X point. Nothing "begins" there, and nothing ends there. It's just another ordinary point in spacetime that conforms with Gauss's laws.
I have given several different proofs that Gauss's law for magnetism holds for every magnetic field of my examples. Since Gauss's law for magnetism holds, there are no monopoles. When Michael Mozina says there are monopoles in my examples, he is lying.

The two of you need to stop erroneously using appeals to authority fallacies rather than real scientific arguments.
My simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is an original proof from Maxwell's equations. Unless Michael Mozina is disputing Maxwell's equations, my derivation is as far from being an appeal to authority as one can get. When Michael Mozina pretends it was an appeal to authority, he is being dishonest.

I already provided you with a published work from MIT that REFUTES your claims! Since Tim's last paper is based on MHD theory, you're still stuck in a vacuum without a plasma particle to your name. If you don't have a published reference that claims reconnection occurs in the absence of plasma, when can I expect you to submit your UTTER NONSENSE for peer review?
Michael Mozina provided us with online course notes, which were not peer-reviewed.

We have cited several books that say magnetic reconnection can occur in a vacuum, without plasma. When Michael Mozina pretends we haven't, he is being dishonest.

In reality I have gone though each of those references and noted where they either USE CURRENT, or MHD theory, leaving you utterly stranded in a vacuum without a single reference, or legitimate scientific support for *YOUR PERSONAL* claims. Stop trying to ride everyone ELSE's PLASMA PHYSICS coattails. You specifically claimed you could create reconnection *WITHOUT* plasma.
I have done so.

When Michael Mozina pretends that his incompetent analysis of the books and papers we've cited is in any way authoritative, he is being dishonest.

The *MODEL* that Clinger describes is a MONOPOLE UNIVERSE MODEL, not the universe we live in.
My model is that of James Clerk Maxwell, so there are no monopoles in my mode. When Michael Mozina says there are monopoles in my model, he is lying.

His mathematical model is fine in monopoleverse. In this universe however, B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning and no end.
When Michael Mozina pretends that monopoles have anything to do with my model, he is lying.

When Michael Mozina says B field lines have no source and no sink, he is telling the truth. When Michael Mozina pretends I disagree with that, he is lying.

When Michael Mozina says B field lines cannot have a beginning or an end, he is mistaken.
 
Last edited:
Scientific debate: 101

Dear Clinger,

In a "scientific debate", one is *EXPECTED AND REQUIRED* to provide *EXTERNAL* and preferably PUBLISHED works to support their case. Ideally such references should come from *OUTSIDE* of self. If one's own works HAVE in fact been published, well then, that's a different story. Even still, something 'outside of self' is really the "best" type of reference. Then nobody has to rely upon a SINGLE INDIVIDUAL for "truth", and nobody has to "guess" what you mean, they can read the whole thing as a complete presentation. You also don't end up being your own source of "truth" using that technique.

Here's an "example" of using an *EXTERNAL* resource to make your case:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line

For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field

One important property of the B-field produced this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end (mathematically, B is a solenoidal vector field); a field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve.[nb 9] To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)

Now I grant you that these are simply "wiki" references, not actually "PUBLISHED" works, but they are "external" references outside of "self". Do you understand the concept of providing REFERENCES OUTSIDE OF SELF? If so, please reciprocate now, and provide me with a *EXTERNAL* reference, that is OUTSIDE of yourself, that claims that B lines begin or end in the absence of all plasma.
 
Last edited:
Scientific debate: 301

Dear Michael Mozina,

In a scientific debate, it is really stupid to cite sources that anyone can edit. It is even more stupid to cite a source that contradicts itself
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line states that B filed lines do not end thus contradicting the defintion of a field line :jaw-dropp! They end anywhere that B=0.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

In a scientific debate, you do not go write gibberish and expect this to enhance your credibility: MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement

In a scientific debate, you try to understand the textbooks and that when they have an example about reconnection in vacuum then it is an example of MR in a vacuum :jaw-dropp:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI

In a scientific debate about an advanced topic like magnetic reconnection you cite the scientific literature: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

In a scientific debate about an advanced topic like magnetic reconnection, you try to understand W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection rather then relying on screaming about the lies to children that professors tell undergraduates.
If you cannot understand it enough to coherently debunk it then you are left with trusting more knowledgeable people, such as other posters in this thread. None of us with university level education has found any errors in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
 
No, you have not! You have NOT provided a single *EXTERNAL* reference yet that supports the concept of "B LINE reconnection" in the absence of plasma!
Wrong:
Reality Check beat me to it, but it's worth repeating: On that very page, Somov writes:

As Somov says, it is the magnetic field lines that reconnect in that vacuum.
 
Somov's "vacuum" includes *CURRENT*, AKA NON-NEUTRAL PLASMA!

This is double idiotic:

1. The currents in Somov's example of vacuum reconnection can just be electrical wires carrying the current, and hence there is vacuum and no plasma.
2. A current carrying plasma is NOT per definition a non-neutral plasma.
 
This is double idiotic:

1. The currents in Somov's example of vacuum reconnection can just be electrical wires carrying the current, and hence there is vacuum and no plasma.
2. A current carrying plasma is NOT per definition a non-neutral plasma.

It doesn't say ANYTHING ABOUT WIRES! You're just ADDING STUFF IN now.
 
It doesn't say ANYTHING ABOUT WIRES! You're just ADDING STUFF IN now.

It also does not say anything about plasmas, YOU are adding stuff in.
It says there is a current in vacuum. The only way to have a current in vacuum is when you put wires in there that carry the current. Simple comme bonjour.

I notice that you back out of the non-neutral plasma silliness.
 
It also does not say anything about plasmas, YOU are adding stuff in.

No, I'm not. The current Somov added *IS* a non-neutral plasma!

Try again.

How desperate are you folks anyway? Assuming Clinger was actually right, *HE* should be able to round up DOZENS of links that demonstrate his claim! I had no trouble at all finding him a dozen external references that said he's wrong, and B lines are continuous, without beginning or end.

Every reference on 'reconnection' that has been provided thus far *REQUIRES* plasma, including Somov's "vacuum" with two "currents". When did you folks intend to accept the fact that plasma and current are NOT OPTIONAL in order to get a 'reconnection/discharge' process to occur in plasma? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Dear Michael Mozina,

In a scientific debate, it is really stupid to cite sources that anyone can edit. It is even more stupid to cite a source that contradicts itself
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line states that B filed lines do not end thus contradicting the defintion of a field line :jaw-dropp! They end anywhere that B=0.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

In a scientific debate, you do not go write gibberish and expect this to enhance your credibility: MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement

In a scientific debate, you try to understand the textbooks and that when they have an example about reconnection in vacuum then it is an example of MR in a vacuum :jaw-dropp:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI

In a scientific debate about an advanced topic like magnetic reconnection you cite the scientific literature: MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

In a scientific debate about an advanced topic like magnetic reconnection, you try to understand W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection rather then relying on screaming about the lies to children that professors tell undergraduates.
If you cannot understand it enough to coherently debunk it then you are left with trusting more knowledgeable people, such as other posters in this thread. None of us with university level education has found any errors in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3

Scientific debate? One cannot have a scientific debate with someone who does not understand science any more than one can have a French debate with someone that does not speak French.
 
Scientific debate? One cannot have a scientific debate with someone who does not understand science any more than one can have a French debate with someone that does not speak French.

Exactly. Rather than Clinger providing an *EXTERNAL* scientific reference to support his claims a year ago, like any NORMAL person, he spent 11 months BADMOUTHING THE INDIVIDUAL and failed to produce ANYTHING to read or look at. *FINALLY*, some 11 months later, he produced something that *HE PERSONALLY* created, but it's UTTERLY KLUDGED and IT'S WRONG at the level of EM *THEORY*.

I've provided more than dozen external references from EM classes at over a dozen colleges and universities to demonstrate that magnetic B lines do not begin, end, have a source or a sink. Clinger has produced NOTHING that is external to himself to verify or validate any of his *RIDICULOUS* claims about B lines 'beginning' anywhere, let alone in the absence of plasma no less.

He's been speaking something *OTHER THAN* science for more than a year now. I'm done listening to his nonsense. If he can't provide EXTERNAL REFERENCES, then his claims are MEANINGLESS!
 
Last edited:
Look....

I didn't twist Clinger's arm into making any claims. I didn't FORCE him to claim he could get "reconnection" to occur *WITHOUT* plasma. He did that to himself.

*IF* he can back up his claim with *EXTERNAL* sources of support, then it's worth considering his argument. *IF* he can't do that, then those dozen or so college curriculum textbooks spell it out quite clearly. B lines do not begin. They do not end. They do not have a source without monopoles. They do not have a sink either.

Clinger painted himself into a corner. Period. It's not my fault. It's not anyone's fault but his! No amount of denial will save him from his inevitable retreat from a position that is SCIENTIFICALLY WRONG and therefore untenable. Wake up and smell the coffee already.
 
FYI, a *BILLION* references on "reconnection" based on MHD theory and PLASMA doesn't help Clinger *ONE IOTA* in terms of supporting *HIS PERSONAL* claims about "B *LINE* reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma.
 
Last edited:
No, I'm not. The current Somov added *IS* a non-neutral plasma!
Try again.

How can there be plasma when it is reconnection in VACUUM!!!

So, you try again, and then please also clear up why you think a current is a "non-neutral" plasma, whatever that may mean in the Moziverse.

How desperate are you folks anyway? Assuming Clinger was actually right, *HE* should be able to round up DOZENS of links that demonstrate his claim! I had no trouble at all finding him a dozen external references that said he's wrong, and B lines are continuous, without beginning or end.

Every reference on 'reconnection' that has been provided thus far *REQUIRES* plasma, including Somov's "vacuum" with two "currents". When did you folks intend to accept the fact that plasma and current are NOT OPTIONAL in order to get a 'reconnection/discharge' process to occur in plasma? :confused:

So, whenever you turn on the light in your room, there is a "non-neutral plasma" turned on I guess. That would be interesting to see, all those lamps without any cables but just plasma flowing from the socket in the wall to the bulb, mmmm talking about ectoplasma!!

Plasma is optional, current probably not if you want to create a magnetic field. However, current in a wire (withoug any plasma at all) creates a magnetic field quite easily. I see it daily in our magnetometer laboratory, lots of magnetic fields but not a plasma around!

Also, the fact that vacuum reconnection is a student text book excersize should be enough to explain why there are no published papers on this topic, mainly because it is boring and trivial. You probably will also not find a paper where it is proven that an apple falling increases in speed as a*t and in place as 0.5 a * t^2, however, every student in physics has probably done this experiment.

So section 3 of this Priest and Forbes paper basically discussed vacuum reconnection as stated in Section 4.1: GENERAL THEORY
The analysis of Section 3 refers to vacuum reconnection when there is no feedback of the plasma on the magnetic behaviour.

I also think that in Priest & Birn "Reconnection of magnetic fields - magnetohydrodynamics and collisionless theory" has stuff about vacuum superposition models etc.
 
Sometimes plain old logic suffices and links and references are a waste of time. It is well known that magnetic fields can be configured to cancel themselves to zero magnetic energy in specific areas. In fact, there exists an industry using that fact to "shield" magnetic fields by canceling technology in order to conserve energy in power lines. It is so simple to visualize a magnetic line entering an area of cancellation and ceasing to exist. It's that simple; the magnetic line can be seen to end or begin at the point it enters a place of zero magnetic energy. It is not a "sink" or "source." It is simply a place where the lines ceases to exist. Use you brain, Mozina!
 
Sometimes plain old logic suffices and links and references are a waste of time. It is well known that magnetic fields can be configured to cancel themselves to zero magnetic energy in specific areas. In fact, there exists an industry using that fact to "shield" magnetic fields by canceling technology in order to conserve energy in power lines. It is so simple to visualize a magnetic line entering an area of cancellation and ceasing to exist. It's that simple; the magnetic line can be seen to end or begin at the point it enters a place of zero magnetic energy. It is not a "sink" or "source." It is simply a place where the lines ceases to exist. Use you brain, Mozina!

My brain can clearly see the differences between a plasma physical process called 'reconnection' and a B *LINE* reconnection in the *ABSENCE* of all plasma. How your brain does NOT see that distinction is beyond me.

I realize that you personally don't think it's a 'big deal' in terms of the physics, but there is in fact a very important physical difference between the process that CLINGER is claiming occurs in the absence of plasma (B *LINE* reconnection), and the "reconnection' process that occurs *EXCLUSIVELY IN* plasma. There is a clear difference.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom