Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do a search on books.google.com on "vacuum reconnection" and you will find a paper by Priest, a paper by Priest and Schrijver (here section 5 even has software to do your own vacuum reconnection) and there is a paper by Pritchett, where he specifically lets the density go to zero in his modelling. I think that were the first three links (did this yesterday evening) and there I stopped.

The simple fact that Somov's currents are just two wires carrying an electric current (otherwise you cannot maintain a vacuum) seems to be lost on MM.

And no, vacuum reconnection does not mean that the vacuum itself is reconnecting!

Is there a PARTICULAR ONE that tickles your fancy that I can take a look at?
 
OK, I have reviewed part 3 of Clinger's demonstration. Just so we are clear on the nature of your objection, are you referring to the center of the colored illustration (the "neutral point") where all magnetic fields cancel?

Yes. It's a NULL. You can call it a "neutral point" if you like (it's technically correct), but without any plasma it's never going to form a fully developed "neutral" in the sense that Dungey is using the term. He's using the term 'neutral' more like an electrical term since he has current running up the Z axis.

Clinger has more of a NULL than a "neutral".
 
Last edited:
Just get yourself some refrigerator magnets.

I realize that you don't believe me, but I don't understand how (or if) you differentiate between *ORDINARY MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES* due to the movements of the magnets, and what you are calling 'magnetic reconnection'. The field topology changes alright, but it's just a "bending and twisting" of the lines that takes place. Nothing needs to 'reconnect' to explain the behaviors you're attempting to explain with two refrigerator magnets.

Surely if this "reconnection" process is so prevalent, so 'simple' to achieve in a freshman experiment, there MUST BE some published papers/books describing this process, just as there are MANY books describing the fact that magnetic lines do not begin or end, have a source or a sink. Can you find me a legitimate published reference to support your claim? I've provided a dozen or so that claim that magnetic lines form as a full, continuous circle/loop.
 
Last edited:
http://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/resources/the-electric-sky-preview/

Donald Scott earned his Bachelor’s and Master’s degrees in Electrical Engineering at the University of Connecticut in Storrs, CT. Following graduation he worked for General Electric in Schenectady, NY, and Pittsfield, MA. He earned a Doctorate in Electrical Engineering at the Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Massachusetts, and was a member of the faculty of the Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering at the University of Massachusetts/Amherst from 1959 until his retirement in 1998. During that time he was the recipient of several good-teaching awards. He was, at various times, Assistant Department Head, Director of the undergraduate program, Graduate admissions coordinator, and Director of the College of Engineering’s Video Instructional Program.

Hey Clinger...

Why don't you send your parts 1-5 to Dr. Scott for peer review and see what he has to say? :)
 
Last edited:
FYI, there was a really nice example of a dark filament eruption on the horizon/limb at the 9:00 position today. Fortunately that CME was not directed our way. :) There's a second mass flow moving toward the 3:00 position too. Interesting.

I'll post the LASCO images as the mass flows become visible in Lasco, but the CME is quite visible in the both iron line images (I just selected one) and the 304A images (HE).

http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0211.mpg
http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0304.mpg
 
Last edited:
FYI, the dual eruption is most visible in the 304A images. They both occur at approximately the same time, and move in relatively opposite directions. Fortunately both mass flows look to point away (flow away) from the direction of Earth.
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
OK, I have reviewed part 3 of Clinger's demonstration. Just so we are clear on the nature of your objection, are you referring to the center of the colored illustration (the "neutral point") where all magnetic fields cancel?


Yes. It's a NULL. You can call it a "neutral point" if you like (it's technically correct), but without any plasma it's never going to form a fully developed "neutral" in the sense that Dungey is using the term. He's using the term 'neutral' more like an electrical term since he has current running up the Z axis.

Clinger has more of a NULL than a "neutral".

OK, regardless of what we call it (I don't really care), do you agree that all magnetic lines cancel out along that axis? In other words, there is no magnetic energy that exists along that axis? I assume that would mean that if I placed an iron atom anywhere along that axis, it would not be moved by the four magnetic fields nearby since they cancel each other at the point of that atom.
 
Last edited:
I realize that you don't believe me, but I don't understand how (or if) you differentiate between *ORDINARY MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES* due to the movements of the magnets, and what you are calling 'magnetic reconnection'. The field topology changes alright, but it's just a "bending and twisting" of the lines that takes place. Nothing needs to 'reconnect' to explain the behaviors you're attempting to explain with two refrigerator magnets.

Perhaps you do not understand the meaning of topological equivalence. If two objects are topologically equal, all that can happen is "bending and twisting" to transform from one to the other. If two objects are topologically different, then for one to transform into the other, parts must break and/or connect.
Two bar magnets together have a topologically different magnetic field than the resulting fields when the two magnets are separated. That is why it is not possible for such a transformation without magnetic lines breaking and reconnecting. Most people here seem to think that constitutes magnetic reconnection.
 
OK, regardless of what we call it (I don't really care), do you agree that all magnetic lines cancel out along that axis?

Yes, it's a NULL.

In other words, there is no magnetic energy that exists along that axis? I assume that would mean that if I placed an iron atom anywhere along that axis, it would not be moved by the four magnetic fields nearby since they cancel each other at the point of that atom.

I'll buy that.
 
Perhaps you do not understand the meaning of topological equivalence. If two objects are topologically equal, all that can happen is "bending and twisting" to transform from one to the other. If two objects are topologically different, then for one to transform into the other, parts must break and/or connect.
Two bar magnets together have a topologically different magnetic field than the resulting fields when the two magnets are separated. That is why it is not possible for such a transformation without magnetic lines breaking and reconnecting. Most people here seem to think that constitutes magnetic reconnection.

The website where your previous magnet image came from was explicit about the fact that the magnets could 'reconnect', but it specifically talks about the lines "bending and twisting". The topology of the field lines can and do change over time *WITHOUT* any sort of 'reconnection' process. They just twist and bend as necessary.
 
Last edited:
OK, now as we follow the path of a magnetic line as it gets closer to that region, how does it become zero at that point if it does not end?

You could probably look at it TWO ways:

It's PROBABLY true that no field lines actually go directly through the NULL in the first place. They most likely interfere with each other and BEND around the NULL region, leaving no lines in the null.

It's probably "ok" to think of the lines as "fading to a ZERO strength" in the NULL, but NOT ENDING there. They didn't start there, they just faded to ZERO in that region, or all have a ZERO strength in that region.
 
Last edited:
The website where your previous magnet image came from was explicit about the fact that the magnets could 'reconnect', but it specifically talks about the lines "bending and twisting". The topology of the field lines can and do change over time *WITHOUT* any sort of 'reconnection' process. They just twist and bend as necessary.

Clearly, you do not understand the significance of topological homeomorphism. One doughnut cannot be bent and twisted to become two doughnuts. Breaking and reconnecting must occur. Basically that's what we have when the magnets are aligned as one and then split apart to become two distinct magnets. The resulting fields must break and reconnect just as with the doughnuts.
 
FYI, I think it's more "correct" to think of of the NULL region as an INTERFERENCE pattern that prevents lines from ENTERING the NULL to begin with. You can draw any number of ZERO strength lines from around the poles to ENTER that NULL with a zero strength, but they were all ZERO STRENGTH lines to begin with.
 
Clearly, you do not understand the significance of topological homeomorphism. One doughnut cannot be bent and twisted to become two doughnuts. Breaking and reconnecting must occur. Basically that's what we have when the magnets are aligned as one and then split apart to become two distinct magnets. The resulting fields must break and reconnect just as with the doughnuts.

I think if you thought of it as pushing 4 donuts together near a central point, in the middle a space forms where no donut material goes (the NULL). :) The rings/donuts bend and twist and avoid the NULL entirely, or at least all the ones with a non zero strength.
 
Clearly, you do not understand the significance of topological homeomorphism. One doughnut cannot be bent and twisted to become two doughnuts. Breaking and reconnecting must occur.

There's at least two basic problems with that logic. First of all the donuts *CANNOT* be broken without a monopole knife and none of us have one. The non zero strength donuts never actually CROSS in the NULL, they "interfere" with one another and AVOID that point entirely. The only LINES that might actually traverse that NULL would be lines that were ALWAYS ZERO, or simply didn't exist in the first place. :)

It's entirely possible NOTHING ever goes INTO the NULL in the first place!

Basically that's what we have when the magnets are aligned as one and then split apart to become two distinct magnets. The resulting fields must break and reconnect just as with the doughnuts.

I've already admitted that the H lines will in fact "reconnect' inside the magnet if and when you physically reconnect the magnets. B lines will not.
 
Last edited:
FYI, I think it's more "correct" to think of of the NULL region as an INTERFERENCE pattern that prevents lines from ENTERING the NULL to begin with. You can draw any number of ZERO strength lines from around the poles to ENTER that NULL with a zero strength, but they were all ZERO STRENGTH lines to begin with.

In the real world this does not make any sense at all.

There is no interference, there this just the summation of two vector fields, created by the two line currents.

Keep up the good work mikey.
 
Mozina, based on this recent exchange, I really believe you are not following the logic of these discussions. I suggest you go back to Clinger's part three with an open mind, and attempt to follow his argument. Your responses about interference patterns preventing lines from entering make no sense and have no scientific basis. What is the genesis of these interference patterns of yours? What is interfering with what? These are stationary magnetic fields generated by DC currents!
Clearly, magnetic lines end (or begin) at that axis. So, it appears to be conclusive that your objections to Clinger's part three scenario are baseless.

Regarding the discussion about bar magnets, bending and twisting without breaking and reconnection cannot lead to topological changes. For the topology of an object to change, breaking and reconnecting must occur -- for both doughnuts and magnetic fields. I suggest you try to comprehend ideas presented to you instead of reacting with mental knee-jerks.
The topology of the fields of two separate magnets is different from the topology of a single magnet (as when they are brought together); no bending and twisting (without breaking and reconnection) can account for that difference.
 
Oy Vey.

It doesn't matter HOW you look at it PS. Unless one of you has a monopole in your pocket, FOREGETABOUTIT! Magnetic lines do not have a source, a sink, a beginning or an end as those dozen or so references from various universities demonstrate. Clingers NULL is literally the beginning of NOTHING! It could never be the beginning or source of anything, because it's NOTHING! It's just a NULL.

Clinger's little handwave was doomed from the start. The moment he removed PLASMA from the PROCESS of reconnection, his experiment was doomed to failure.

Reconnection is a PROCESS of PLASMA physics.

He was wrong about anything BEGINNING at X. It doesn't. He was wrong to try to claim he could get 'reconnection' as Dungey described *WITHOUT* plasma.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom