Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
A PUBLISHED reference (without currents/plasma) is idiotc.

Yep, it sure is. Unfortunately Clinger claimed he could demonstrate Dungey's "reconnection" process *WITHOUT* plasmas.

You have to get the magnetic field from somewhere,. That is why Somov postulates 2 parallel electric currents in if example of MR in vacuum.

The moment you introduce currents into that vacuum you introduce PLASMA into that vacuum. Do you understand that? Yes or no?
 
If he's so "proud" of his work, then he should be EAGER to publish it.
He is *proud* and EAGER to publish it. It is just that he cannot because it is not new research.

You need to stop displaying your ignorance about scientific literature and read what I wrote:
W.D. Clinger should be proud of his simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
I am proud of W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

*ONLY AN IGNORANT PERSON* would want W.D. Clinger to "finish the job" and get it published.

Scientific journals publish new research. W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is not new research. It is an undergraduate level derivation the MR does what science says it does - breaks and reconnects magnetic field lines.

Thus W.D. Clinger has "published" this simple stuff where is should reside - on the Internet.

Actually there may be an educational journal out there that might be interested in publishing a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
He is *proud* and EAGER to publish it. It is just that he cannot because it is not new research.

Oh, it's new "research" (gag) alright. Not one of you can cite a legitimate publication that claims what Clinger claims. Somov ran open currents through his vacuum. Clinger promised to do his 'reconnection' magic entirely *without* plasma.

More importantly none of you can provide references countering the dozen or so references I provided about B lines having no beginning, ending, source or sink. None of you could provide ANYTHING in fact that is REMOTELY like Clingers claims because all other "reconnection" papers you've cited *REQUIRE AND USE* plasma. He's been in UNCHARTED TERRITORY since he first claimed that he could replicate Dungey's version of 'reconnection' *WITHOUT* a plasma.
 
Last edited:
I want a show of hands of who among you is willing to lend your name to Clinger's claims (and help him clean it up) and put it through an actual peer review process? Anyone? Will Clinger himself even do it?
You are the only one here that seems to be that *ONLY AN IGNORANT PERSON* in my previous posts so you will not get any hands.

If W.D. Clinger did decide to publish his simple derivation of magnetic reconnection in a journal about physics education then he will not need our help. He has what looks like a mostly complete article.

W.D. Clinger is unlikely to do this for the simple reason that it does not matter. You are already ignoring the published science so why should he write something else for you to ignore or be deluded about?

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
MM: 1000's of references (many of which are REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES) for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting
 
You are the only one here that seems to be that *ONLY AN IGNORANT PERSON* in my previous posts so you will not get any hands.

I won't get any hands because none you actually believes this nonsense enough to put it through a peer review process with your actual name attached to it. It's garbage and deep down inside somewhere you know that to be true. I've provided around a dozen published references from EM classes at various colleges and universities and scientific websites (like Wiki) around the country/planet that refute your claims that B lines have "beginnings" without monopoles.

His epic kludge of basic EM theory would NEVER pass a peer review process. As long as none of you have to face that process, you can keep handwaving away like any good creationist.
 
Last edited:
Yep, it sure is. Unfortunately Clinger claimed he could demonstrate Dungey's "reconnection" process *WITHOUT* plasmas.
And he did: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
MM: W.D. Clinger did demonstrate his claim

P.S. MM: Show the mistakes in a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 3
This is basically either put up or shut up. If you cannot show that you understand his derivation and thus show where he made his errors, then you are just arguing from a stance of ignorance.


The moment you introduce currents into that vacuum you introduce PLASMA into that vacuum. Do you understand that? Yes or no?
The moment you introduce currents into that vacuum you introduce WIRES into that vacuum. Do you understand that? Yes or no? :rolleyes:

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
 
Last edited:

Been there, done that a dozen times now, 15 or more if count WIKI pages. Each of them claims that only a monopole is an exception to any rule, and they all claim that B lines do not begin, end, have a source or a sink. So far your side has produced NOTHING but PLASMA processes which Clinger claimed were NOT REQUIRED in his contraption.
 
Last edited:
Nobody, not even Clinger himself is willing to put his presentation through an actual peer review process? Do you REALLY expect to me accept this nonsense? How exactly is your handwave any different than a creationist handwave? Talk about pathetic arguments.
 
It is new. Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing PLASMA to the PROCESS.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V

Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing WIRES to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing ELECTRON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducing PROTON BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.
Somov ran open CURRENTS through the vacuum, introducingIONIZED SILVER BEAMS to the PROCESS :rolleyes:.

Can you see that my satirical comments is as stupid as your serious assertion about PLASMA?

Somov has no plasma.
Somov has no wires.
Somov has no beams of any kind of charged particle.

He has 2 parallel electrical currents that just exist.
 
Last edited:
Nobody, not even Clinger himself is willing to put his presentation through an actual peer review process? Do you REALLY expect to me accept this nonsense? How
He is willing. But he knows that this material is probably covered in plasma physics courses (it is a reasonable first step as in Somov's book). It probably takes the lecturer about 20 minutes to go through it. Or less - this is so basic that he may just say "read pages X to Y in your textbooks", e.g. Somov.

I know that your ignorance of science will not allow you to accept the fact that peer-reviewed journals publish new research.
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is an interesting exercise in undergraduate physics. It is not new scientific research. MR in vaccum is a trival exercise, e.g.

Magnetic reconnection on the sun, Priest 1990
In an vacuum, magnetic reconnection is trivial process...


Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
"Section 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum" covers this topic in a page and a half !
 
Last edited:
You and PS have both made this claim. Can either of you present a PUBLISHED, preferably "peer reviewed" paper that I can read?

Just get yourself some refrigerator magnets.

I HONESTY (I don't care what you think) do not understand what PHYSICAL thing you believe "reconnects".

The magnetic fields reconnect (that’s why it’s called magnetic reconnection), acting like you don’t already know that is just you being dishonest.

The term "reconnection" could be replaced in your description with "reconfiguration", or "realignment" and I'd be fine. Care to meet in that middle ground before we go in endless circles?

The term “reconnection” could be replaced with just about anything other than “reconnection” and you’d “be fine”. Pretending that giving you exactly what you want simply because of your own personal distain is somehow a “middle ground” is again just you being dishonest. Again reconnection is a specific type of "reconfiguration", or "realignment", that you’re not “fine” with that is simply your problem. You simply do not like the word reconnection and would prefer that it were anything else, unfortunately for you that word is accurately descriptive of the type of "reconfiguration", or "realignment" it pertains to.


Monopoles are not optional as it relates to B *LINE* beginnings, endings, sources and sinks. Without them, magnetic lines cannot have beginning or endings. The EM universe can have a TRILLION different NULLS (where nothing happens), but not one of those NULLS is the "beginning or ending", the "source or sink" of any of the B lines in the universe.

Again get yourself some refrigerator magnets and let us know when you have found any monopoles.

It is not so much that “nothing happens” at the null point as it is that two different field configuration are exactly (topologically) the same because of that null point.

I’ll try to make this easy for you.

Let’s consider a traffic circle, two roads lead into the circle and two lead away. One road approaches going South East and another leaves going North East. The third road approaches going North West and the fourth leaves South West.

So we’ll label the roads

1 SE IN
2 NE OUT
3 NW IN
4 SW OUT

From this configuration we can have two different combinations of opposing routes. 1 to 2 and 3 to 4 as opposing East and West routes respectively. We also have 1 to 4 and 3 to 2 as opposing South and North routes respectively. It is basically the same with the null point (and generally in this application the null only refers to the magnetic field vector at that point) without any field vector itself, opposing field lines that approach and leave can sometimes do so in a way where the topology represent more than one configuration, generally tending for a configuration with lower energy, which is why energy previously stored in the magnetic fields can be released through reconnection.


Do any of you have published works to support these claims? Clinger seems to believe that Origin the NULL is a "necessary" "beginnor and endor", and he believes plasma and current is optional for "reconnection". You've taken it one step further (actually Clinger said it too once) and you are now claiming that even the NULL is optional. Care to provide any of the Pig-Latin math you claim is OH SO IMPORTANT to explain YOUR position *WITHOUT A NULL*?

Holy cow. Now I'm *UTTERLY* confused as to WHAT relevant maths ANY of you might provide.

“you are now claiming that even the NULL is optional”? Don’t know where the heck you think I claimed such a thing, but if you would quote where you think that was I could probably clarify that misinterpretation.
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Exactly where is the flaw in Clingers demonstration?
It started in part three (the epic disaster installment) where Clinger claimed that Origin the NULL was a "beginning" of B lines. It went downhill from there.
OK, I have reviewed part 3 of Clinger's demonstration. Just so we are clear on the nature of your objection, are you referring to the center of the colored illustration (the "neutral point") where all magnetic fields cancel?
 
Do a search on books.google.com on "vacuum reconnection" and you will find a paper by Priest, a paper by Priest and Schrijver (here section 5 even has software to do your own vacuum reconnection) and there is a paper by Pritchett, where he specifically lets the density go to zero in his modelling. I think that were the first three links (did this yesterday evening) and there I stopped.

The simple fact that Somov's currents are just two wires carrying an electric current (otherwise you cannot maintain a vacuum) seems to be lost on MM.

And no, vacuum reconnection does not mean that the vacuum itself is reconnecting!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom