Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Without seeing the Movie and without reviewing the code that appears to violate the laws of physic, I really have no idea how their "magic" works.
There are no laws of physics being broken (MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II , MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II ).

Aspects of Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection - (Invited Review);
A CD-ROM attached to this paper presents the results of a toy model of vacuum reconnection, which suggests that rapid flipping of field lines in fan and separator reconnection is an essential ingredient also in real non-vacuum conditions.
The CD-ROM contains the results of a "toy model of vacuum reconnection". This may just be the data. It may be the data + a code for the toy model. It may be the data, the math of the toy model + the code. The data is presented in at least 1 movie.
In the simple simulations shown in Movie I on the CD-ROM, vacuum reconnection occurs through null points as field lines move through separators (the intersections of separatrix surfaces) whenever two pairs of field-line segments exchange connectivity at the reconnection location.
(my emphasis of B lines breaking and reconnecting!)

What we do know is that it is a "toy model of vacuum reconnection".
What can we deduce from that phrase, MM?
For a start vacuums do not reconnect :eye-poppi! This is in a paper about magnetic reconnection. So the 'reconnection' part is magnetic reconnection. That leaves the vacuum part - this must where the MR happens so we have a toy model of MR in a vacuum.
 
Irony overload there from "Mr. electrical discharges cannot occur in plasmas". :)
How delusional - electric discharges cannot occur in plasma because by definition they require the breakdown of of a dielectric medium and plasmas conduct.

The really delusional thing to do is to think that an obsolete term used for high current density in a few (1 or 2?) papers by an author 60 years ago means that this term is being used today.

Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.
 
Without seeing the Movie and without reviewing the code that appears to violate the laws of physic, I really have no idea how their "magic" works.


To argue that it must be magic while admitting to not actually understanding it is an argument from ignorance. But it's not magic. Really. It's science.

I give up for now.


Excellent idea.
 
To argue that it must be magic while admitting to not actually understanding it is an argument from ignorance. But it's not magic. Really. It's science.

In this particular case it's probably neither. It's probably a SPECIFIC LINE OF BOGUS (toy) CODE that produces that "opening" of a "closed" magnetic line they talked about. :)

The way in which the field lines reconnect by changing from being open to closed and back to open can be seen clearly.

It sounds like an inappropriate *IF* statement to me. I wonder if the source code is commented? :) It shouldn't be hard to spot one way or the other. I wonder what language that program was written in, C++ I hope?
 
Last edited:
One other part of their presentation that is rather "telling" IMO is the fact that all their drawings show "sources and sinks" in terms of magnetic lines rather than showing the FULL LOOPS.
One other part of that post that is rather "telling" IMO is your inability to bother to read the papr.
The sources are sources of magnetic field.
We have been building up an understanding of complex topologies by considering the structure of the magnetic fields due to two, three, and four sources. For two unbalanced sources there is a null, a spine and a separatrix fan surface whicharches over to form a dome from the null point to the larger source (Figure 10). This may at first sight seem to be an uninteresting case, since as the sources move about the magnetic flux joining them remains constant. However, reconnection still takes place, since individual field lines will change their connectivity, by a process referred to as binary reconnection.
(more field lines breaking and reconnecting!)
In figure 12 the sources are magnetic dipoles and the field lines do form loops ecept where they pass through the null point(s).

There are no sinks.

First of all, we consider a simple model of binary reconnection due to the motion of two sources (Figure 14(a)). The right-hand source is the larger and it performs an orbit around the other source, during which we keep the directions constant of most of the field lines from the larger source. The way in which the field lines reconnect by changing from being open to closed and back to open can be seen clearly.
(more field lines breaking and reconnecting!)
 
The CD-ROM contains the results of a "toy model of vacuum reconnection". This may just be the data. It may be the data + a code for the toy model. It may be the data, the math of the toy model + the code. The data is presented in at least 1 movie.

In this case it better include source code and maths, or it's just a "toy picture" without any scientific value whatsoever.

What we do know is that it is a "toy model of vacuum reconnection". What can we deduce from that phrase, MM?

It's a "toy" (make believe) version with "open" lines, not a grown up SCIENTIFIC one where all B lines form CLOSED loops? :)

There's gotta be an IF statement that OPENS those lines (inappropriately).
 
Hey Clinger...

Why don't you send your parts 1-5 to Dr. Scott for peer review and see what he has to say? :)
We already know what Professor Donald E Scott has to say about magnetic reconnection, and Tim Thompson has already answered what Scott has to say.

Scott wrote a long rejoinder, of course. Its section on magnetic reconnection starts by attempting a proof by intimidation in which Scott asserts the superiority of engineering over physics, and goes on to say things like
Scott said:
...it is easy to see that magnetic field lines do not (cannot) do anything in the real world – because they do not exist in the real world.
That's downright silly. Magnetic field lines are every bit as real as magnetic fields. In fact, it's easy to prove that the complete set of magnetic field lines (as defined in the mathematically correct way) is equivalent to the magnetic field used to define them: You can derive either from the other. (That's not true of the informal notion of magnetic field lines that's taught in freshman physics or in graduate engineering courses by folk such as Donald E Scott, but I digress.)

Magnetic fields and magnetic field lines are both mathematical abstractions, but both field lines and fields are ultimately defined in terms of the Lorentz force, which is undeniably measurable. Scott can't dismiss magnetic fields or field lines without dismissing that undeniable force.

If Scott wants to defend his ideas here, he can register at the JREF Forum and join the conversation. Until then, he'll just have to depend on Michael Mozina to make his case for the Electric Universe.

You're right Tim, I could download the paper for free. Unfortunately, only the CD must contain the "toy reconnection" code that they are talking about.....

I guess I need to see the code and the CD.

As far as I can tell Priest's use of the term "vacuum" also includes PLASMAS, but I can't tell for SURE without looking at the source code.

I don't suppose you have a link to the CD with the "toy" code by any chance?

Um, it would appear (without having reviewed the actual software and code yet) that in the "toy model" that they are talking about, the "way it works" is by breaking the laws of physics. :)

I give up for now. Without seeing the Movie and without reviewing the code that appears to violate the laws of physic, I really have no idea how their "magic" works. All I can see so far is that they are INTENT on claiming that B field lines SWITCH from being closed, to "open". AFAIK, that's bogus nonsense. Unless they have a monopole up their sleeve, or some "magic monopole code" in that "toy" software, it's never going to happen. All magnetic lines form as closed directional loops.

In this particular case it's probably neither. It's probably a SPECIFIC LINE OF BOGUS (toy) CODE that produces that "opening" of a "closed" magnetic line they talked about. :)

In this case it better include source code and maths, or it's just a "toy picture" without any scientific value whatsoever.

It's a "toy" (make believe) version with "open" lines, not a grown up SCIENTIFIC one where all B lines form CLOSED loops? :)

There's gotta be an IF statement that OPENS those lines (inappropriately).


Michael Mozina's in luck. The computer code for my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is online, and it's perfectly clear from that code that there's no plasma and no cheating: The magnetic fields shown in my graphs and animations come entirely from currents running within the parallel conducting rods:
http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/dungey.sch
http://www.r6rs.org/final/html/r6rs/r6rs-Z-H-18.html#node_chap_D

I'll be happy to answer any honest questions that Michael Mozina or Donald E Scott may have about that computer code or the graphs and animations obtained from that code.
 
All I want to know from you is where you got the idea that field lines "begin" anywhere in the first place?
From mathematics:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7746071&postcount=4813

Most magnetic field lines don't have a beginning or end. According to Gauss's law for magnetism, B field lines can begin or end only at points where the magnetic field is zero.

Those neutral points are pretty unusual, hence interesting. Their rarity is the reason the popular myth about magnetic field lines neither beginning nor ending is a reasonable white lie for professors to tell freshmen.

It's been a while since I've taught any freshmen-level courses, but I'm fully aware of the need to simplify concepts, even to the point of telling white lies, for the benefit of freshmen. In recent years, I've been teaching a lot of sophomore-level courses, where it's part of my job to tell students the truth about some of the lies they were told in their freshman year. (I'm not teaching physics, but the pedagogical principles are the same.)
 
Well, I also want to know if you ever intend to get your work "peer reviewed" in a legitimate way? FYI, I'm sure Dr. Scott's comments about physical substance most like relates to the same problem you created by trying to get "reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma. That force won't accelerate anything PHYSICAL, or generate *DISCHARGES* until you add plasma. :)
 
From mathematics:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7746071&postcount=4813

Most magnetic field lines don't have a beginning or end. According to Gauss's law for magnetism, B field lines can begin or end only at points where the magnetic field is zero.

Those neutral points are pretty unusual, hence interesting. Their rarity is the reason the popular myth about magnetic field lines neither beginning nor ending is a reasonable white lie for professors to tell freshmen.

It's been a while since I've taught any freshmen-level courses, but I'm fully aware of the need to simplify concepts, even to the point of telling white lies, for the benefit of freshmen. In recent years, I've been teaching a lot of sophomore-level courses, where it's part of my job to tell students the truth about some of the lies they were told in their freshman year. (I'm not teaching physics, but the pedagogical principles are the same.)

But that's just it, they are NOT the same. You're looking at it ONLY from the standpoint of MATHEMATICS, but there is a PHYSICAL process going on *IN PLASMA* that you're *DESPERATELY* trying to sweep under the carpet (without plasma).

You're also *IGNORING* a "prime directive" of EM theory, rather BLATANTLY in fact. Worse yet, you're trying to claim a NULL (where NO FIELD energy exists) is a BEGINNING of something that HAS NO BEGINNING in the first place!

Every single one of the LINES you drew is CREATED BY the current running through one of the four/five poles you created. Not a SINGLE line in your graph BEGINS anywhere, certainly NOT in a NULL where the field strength is NOTHING!

You have the physics standing on it's head and claiming "oh, it doesn't matter". Baloney.

I showed you over a dozen printed references to support my claims. You've provided NONE (published references) to support yours. Why is that? Will you put your so called "work" out for actual "peer review"? Yes or no? If not SCOTT, then who?
 
According to Gauss's law for magnetism, B field lines can begin or end only at points where the magnetic field is zero.

That statement is a KLUDGE! Gauss's law says NOTHING of the sort! It doesn't INSIST or even ALLOW for a "beginning", an "ending", a source or a sink of a B line without a monopole Clinger. You're literally KLUDGING the LAW.
 
Well, I also want to know if you ever intend to get your work "peer reviewed" in a legitimate way?
I've known all along that my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is a trivial consequence of Maxwell's equations, using little more than freshman-level magnetostatics and vector calculus. It is not a research result and would not be accepted by a research journal.

I will, however, write up my derivation as a tutorial article that might be suitable for publication in a journal or presentation at a conference devoted to physics education. As a non-physicist, I don't know which journals or conferences might be appropriate. I have discussed this with a full professor at MIT who happens to be teaching a graduate physics course this semester, but I haven't yet discussed it with physics faculty who teach introductory electromagnetism. Now is not the right time to approach them, because it's the end of the semester and everyone's too busy. Have patience.

FYI, I'm sure Dr. Scott's comments about physical substance most like relates to the same problem you created by trying to get "reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma. That force won't accelerate anything PHYSICAL, or generate *DISCHARGES* until you add plasma. :)
Nonsense.

It's a good thing you added a smiley face, else someone might have thought you were serious.

But that's just it, they are NOT the same. You're looking at it ONLY from the standpoint of MATHEMATICS, but there is a PHYSICAL process going on *IN PLASMA* that you're *DESPERATELY* trying to sweep under the carpet (without plasma).

You're also *IGNORING* a "prime directive" of EM theory, rather BLATANTLY in fact. Worse yet, you're trying to claim a NULL (where NO FIELD energy exists) is a BEGINNING of something that HAS NO BEGINNING in the first place!

Every single one of the LINES you drew is CREATED BY the current running through one of the four/five poles you created. Not a SINGLE line in your graph BEGINS anywhere, certainly NOT in a NULL where the field strength is NOTHING!

You have the physics standing on it's head and claiming "oh, it doesn't matter". Baloney.
You forgot the smiley face.

That statement is a KLUDGE! Gauss's law says NOTHING of the sort! It doesn't INSIST or even ALLOW for a "beginning", an "ending", a source or a sink of a B line without a monopole Clinger. You're literally KLUDGING the LAW.
You forgot the smiley face again.

I said I would respond to honest questions. Ignorant shouting is not honest questioning.
 
I've known all along that my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is a trivial consequence of Maxwell's equations, using little more than freshman-level magnetostatics and vector calculus.

No, it's a trivial KLUDGE of Maxwell's equations and Guass's law of magnetism.

FYI, I've been patient for 11 months Clinger. In all that time you still have not accepted that:

A) Plasma and current is NOT optional in the "reconnection" process.
B) Electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares.

When did you intend to accept either A or B, or Both?

A ZERO point in spacetime in terms of magnetic field strength isn't the "beginning" of any B line in the universe Clinger. It's DEVOID OF THEM, or DEVOID OF ENERGY IN THEM at that location. Period. It's not a source. It's not a sink. It's not a beginning. It's not an "end". It's just a NULL, an empty vacuum.

As long as you keep trying to IGNORE the fact that B fields have no beginning or ending, no source or sink, you're pretty much running yourself in circles.
 
I said I would respond to honest questions. Ignorant shouting is not honest questioning.

I asked you a totally "honest" question about where you got the idea that any B line had a "beginning". You essentially told me "out of your own head" (in the form of mathematics). To you, in your mathematical world, an E field and a B field operate exactly the same. In the actual world of PHYSICS however, only the E field has monopole particles. The B field does NOT! It's a PRIME DIFFERENCE that you *PERSONALLY* keep ignoring. Why?
 
I asked you a totally "honest" question about where you got the idea that any B line had a "beginning". You essentially told me "out of your own head" (in the form of mathematics). To you, in your mathematical world, an E field and a B field operate exactly the same. In the actual world of PHYSICS however, only the E field has monopole particles. The B field does NOT! It's a PRIME DIFFERENCE that you *PERSONALLY* keep ignoring. Why?


I answered that question four days ago:

div B = 0 is not a handwave. I have presented at least three separate proofs of div B = 0 for the magnetic fields in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection:
It's a scientific fact that div B = 0 implies there are no monopoles, so I have proved there are no monopoles in any of the fields involved in my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Michael Mozina refers to those proofs as handwaves. It doesn't really matter whether his denials of scientific fact are dishonest or incompetent. He's in denial.
 
I answered that question four days ago:

No, you didn't answer it. You HANDWAVED a little *IMPROPER* vector calculus at me and claimed "it's all equal"! Baloney!

http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole

The fundamental laws governing electricity and magnetism become symmetric if particles exist that carry magnetic charge. Current understanding of electromagnetic physical phenomena is based on the existence of electric monopoles, which are sources or sinks of electric field lines (illus. a), and which when set into motion generate magnetic fields. The magnetic field lines produced by such a current have no beginning or end and form closed loops. All magnetic fields occurring in nature can be explained as arising from currents. However, theories of electromagnetism become symmetric if magnetic charges also exist. These would be sources or sinks of magnetic field and when set into motion would generate electric fields whose lines would be closed without ends (illus. b). See also Electric field.

CE397800FG0010.gif

You are essentially using the vector equations specified by B) rather than A) and *BLATANTLY IGNORING* the fact that monopoles do not exist! You have no business using vector calculus related to the B) orientation in the first place!
 
Last edited:
I answered that question four days ago:

No, you didn't answer it. You HANDWAVED a little *IMPROPER* vector calculus at me and claimed "it's all equal"! Baloney!
:p

Michael Mozina, who doesn't bark math and insists his inability to bark math has nothing to do with the credibility of his arguments, dismisses Maxwell's equations and related vector calculus as "HANDWAVED" and "*IMPROPER*".

I don't know about you guys, but I eagerly await Michael Mozina's erudite clarification of the distinction between proper and "*IMPROPER*" vector calculus.

You are essentially using the vector equations specified by B) rather than A) and *BLATANTLY IGNORING* the fact that monopoles do not exist!
Untrue. Michael Mozina is blatantly ignoring my multiple proofs of div B = 0.

You have no business using vector calculus related to the B) orientation in the first place!
Michael Mozina appears to be lying about the nature of his opponents' mathematical arguments.

It might be possible to argue that Michael Mozina is just making stuff up, but that more charitable interpretation would have us believe that Michael Mozina is determinedly clueless, aggressively ignorant, and one of the purest examples of Dunning-Kruger effect known to science.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom