Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's kinda amazing, shocking, saddening (and so on), all at the same time.

I mean, you'd think an inability to understand the relevant math would produce a little humility and a desire to learn. Yet here we have MM, in a really deep hole, continuing to dig with all his might. :jaw-dropp

The problem is that you're utterly ignoring the PHYSICS (what's new?)!

The math equates to 0+0=0 in a vacuum. I'm not impressed.

I've provided over a DOZEN published references from MANY colleges and universities around the world to support the fact that B lines have no beginning, no ending, no source and no sink.

When oh when did you folks intend to stop arguing like creationists (without published support for your claims) and when can I expect you to start arguing like SCIENTISTS with real published support for your claims?

Talk about digging deep holes! You folks are half way to China. :)
 
Zero/null/neutral points are special because they're the only points at which magnetic field lines can begin or end.

Zero/null/neutral points are so rare and so special that freshman are often told that magnetic field lines never begin or end, but that's an over-simplification. It's a white lie that professors have gotten into the habit of telling because it helps mathematically unsophisticated freshmen to understand an approximation to the truth.

*IF* that is true, then you personally should have no trouble finding OTHER PUBLICATIONS that make this claim. Where are they, or did you intend to handwave around that ridiculous claim forever, just like any good creationist?

When can I expect you to submit your *KLUDGED NONSENSE* for publication, and to which publication are you intending to submit it? Quit dodging this question!
 
Show of hands now.....

Who among you is willing to sign their names to Clinger's presentation, dress it up as necessary and submit it for publication with THEIR names on it?

Don't be bashful now....
 
http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0131.mpg

FYI, there were some pretty large and impressive reconnection/discharge events yesterday around the 2:00 position of the clock. It's amazing to me how large a distance the discharges can travel.


It is a magnetic reconnection event which resulted in the solar flare seen in the video. After analyzing the high resolution images and assembling a video showing the hour long event, I've come to the conclusion that nothing in the series of 131Å images objectively or quantitatively demonstrates anything like an electrical discharge akin to a lightning strike here on Earth.

Here's the HD video I made from 120 frames taken at less than one minute intervals and compressed into a video of about 22 seconds...

​
 
It's a busy day at work today, so let's cut to the chase:

[...]

*WHEN* can I expect you folks to provide REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES that claim that a NULL in a vacuum is a "beginning" of a B line?
This one's very easy.

"you folks" have provided a great many such references.

You, MM, will understand this when you take the time and trouble to learn the relevant math. With a sufficient grasp of said maths, a little light will go on inside your head, and your face will glow crimson with shame and embarrassment. :D

Until you do become au fait with the relevant math, you will continue to provide much amusement to readers of this thread (assuming that you continue to dig yourself ever deeper). :cool:
 
Nice video.

Oh look, the "reconnection" process, and those million degree LINES OF FORCE do include *PLASMA*.

Who would have guessed?
 
This one's very easy.

"you folks" have provided a great many such references.

You, MM, will understand this when you take the time and trouble to learn the relevant math. With a sufficient grasp of said maths, a little light will go on inside your head, and your face will glow crimson with shame and embarrassment. :D

Until you do become au fait with the relevant math, you will continue to provide much amusement to readers of this thread (assuming that you continue to dig yourself ever deeper). :cool:

I assume this means you intend to put your name on his paper and help him clean up it for publication? You do realize that all his math amounts to 0+0=0 in the absence of all plasma, right?
 
*WHEN* can I expect Clinger to submit his NONSENSE for publication and to which publication will he submit it to? *WHEN* can I expect you folks to provide REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES that claim that a NULL in a vacuum is a "beginning" of a B line?
*ONLY AN IGNORANT PERSON* would expect Clinger to submit his CLEAR and CORRECT derivation for publicationW.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is not new research and so will not be accepted for publication in a journal.
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is an undergraduate level derivation the MR does what science says it does - breaks and reconnects magnetic field lines.

You need to stop lying since a REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCE that claims that a NULL in a vacuum is a "beginning" of a B line has been cited:
Somov's book section: 4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum which you you are deluded about: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV ​
Also: MM: 1000's of references (many of which are REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES) for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting
 
*ONLY AN IGNORANT PERSON* would expect Clinger to submit his CLEAR and CORRECT derivation for publication

Only an ignorant person (and/or a creationist) would believe that his handwaves constitute "scientific evidence" as it stands. He's been slaving away on his freshman project for 11 months now. Isn't he the least bit proud of his work? Aren't you? Surely you want to "finish the job" and get it published, right?
 
Last edited:
The *WHOLE* field simply DOES NOT EXIST THERE at all. It's just a NULL. NOTHING begins there. NOTHING ends there. NOTHING physically exists there. It's simply a NULL.
Something real simple that you should be abile to understand:
Field lines only exists where there is a field.
​
You have just stated that "*WHOLE* field simply DOES NOT EXIST THERE at all".
Can you understand that means that "*FIELD LINES* simply DO NOT EXIST THERE at all".
​
 
Somov's "vacuum" has currents, AKA non-neutral plasmas that "reconnect". Clinger doesn't have a plasma particle to his name.
 
I must say......

I really had no idea that arguing with EU haters would be *SO* much like discussing the topic of evolutionary theory with creationists. The parallels are ASTOUNDING.

It's amazing how many of you have NOT read a book on plasma physics yet. It's amazing how you all keep handwaving in claims, yet refusing to provide any *PUBLISHED* materials to support those claims. All I've seen thus far is some ridiculously simplistic mathematical equations that amount to 0+0=0 in a vacuum. Nothing begins in a NULL. NOTHING ends there. It's just a stinking NULL for crying out loud!

Your argument is like claiming that a parched desert on Mercury must be the "beginning and ending of all human beings" because no human begins live there or typically go there! OMG.

605px-Mercury_in_color_-_Prockter07_centered.jpg


Look! It's the beginning and the "source" of all the humans in the universe!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom