MM explains his confusion, part 5
To this very day and moment, you are *STILL* confusing *MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES* in a vacuum, which take place over the *ENTIRE* field, not a single line, or just in the middle region, with mythical monopoles.
Nope. So far as we know, magnetic monopoles don't exist. In fact, their nonexistence is implied by Gauss's law for magnetism.
Since all of the magnetic fields I have posted satisfy Gauss's law for magnetism, and I have actually presented several simple proofs of that fact, including the
obvious proof from linear superposition,
Michael Mozina's accusation above was extremely foolish.
(I started to write "extraordinarily foolish", but finding extreme foolishness in
Michael Mozina's posts is of course ordinary.)
The ENTIRE FIELD will experience "flux changes" that would (not in your experiment in a vacuum) induce E fields in a plasma, not JUST at the X. Grrr.
From the start, I have acknowledged that changes in the magnetic field would induce
E fields. I have also pointed out that the resulting
E fields can be made arbitrarily small, hence negligible, by changing the magnetic field slowly:
By conducting the experiment in a vacuum and changing the magnetic field slowly, we can make Maxwell's correction as small as desired. (Changing the magnetic field more slowly makes magnetic reconnection happen more slowly, so you might be afraid this demonstration will be like watching grass grow. Never fear: We can compensate by using time-lapse animation to view the reconnection.) We can simplify our math by making Maxwell's correction negligible and dropping it from the equation to obtain Ampère's original law:
That simplification allowed me to stay within the domain of freshman-level magnetostatics, which made my
simple derivation of magnetic reconnection accessible to a wider audience.
Even with that and other simplifications,
Michael Mozina has apparently been unable to understand the derivation. Why am I not surprised?
When oh WHEN will you understand that B field lines have no beginning and no ending? The only way that could EVER occur is if someone pulls a monopole out of their hat!
False.
The magnetic field
B4 satisfies Gauss's law for magnetism, so there are no magnetic monopoles within that field. Nonetheless, as I
have proved several times (most recently just a few posts above), the xy plane at z=0 contains two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point.
Magnetic flux CHANGES are NOT "magnetic reconnection"
Most changes in magnetic flux do not result in magnetic reconnection, but some changes in magnetic flux do result in magnetic reconnection. It all depends on details of the specific magnetic field and the specific changes.
To tell whether magnetic reconnection happens, you have to do the math or look at the results of physical observations or experiments.
Michael Mozina has refused to do the math, has ignored the many published papers that report on observations of magnetic reconnection in space or in experimental laboratories, and has refused to perform the
simple experiment I've been recommending to him since last December.
"Magnetic reconnection" is an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PROCESS IN PLASMA, not a magnetic flux CHANGE in a VACUUM.
Shouting doesn't make it so.
Michael Mozina has neither the right nor the power to force real scientists to adopt his crackpot definitions.
All competent authorities agree that magnetic reconnection consists of changes in magnetic field line topology as magnetic lines merge or separate at neutral points. As my
simple derivation of magnetic reconnection has demonstrated, magnetic reconnection is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations and can occur in a vacuum, with no nearby currents or electrical discharges, and with arbitrarily small (hence negligible) electric field.
Tell you what Clinger:
How about running your graph routine for us, AFTER you CHANGE the current in one of those poles for us and post what you come up with? I guarantee you that you won't see changes *ONLY* at the X.
I have already done that. As can be seen in this animation of what happens when the current running through the north and south rods is reduced to zero and then increased back to its original 1000 amperes,
Michael Mozina is right about changes occurring throughout the field:
[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/mr00.gif[/qimg]
(You'll have to click on that link, because the animated GIF is almost 750 kilobytes, and I don't want this JREF Forum web page to load slower just because
Michael Mozina hasn't been paying attention.)
I also guarantee you it won't look like your animation image of a 'reconnection' process.
Hilarious.
Not only does
that animation look like my "animation image of a 'reconnection' process", it
is one of my animated images of a reconnection process.
That animation is only possible *IF* monopoles did exist and B field lines did have beginning and endings. The EXCEPTION would be a monopole, not a NULL POINT!
The highlighted statements are false.
As
I have proved several times, most recently just a few posts above, the magnetic field
B4 contains magnetic field lines that begin or end at neutral points, but I have also proved that
B4 satisfies Gauss's law for magnetism, so there are no monopoles.
All of my images and animations of magnetic fields and magnetic field lines show numbers calculated using formulas that are straightforward consequences of Maxwell's equations.
I have published those formulas at my web site as well as
within my previous posts here at the JREF Forum.
If
Michael Mozina believes any of those formulas to be incorrect, then it is his responsibility to identify the formulas and to explain why he believes those formulas are incorrect. Repeatedly shouting his dumbed-down "physics for poets" over-simplifications of Gauss's law for magnetism will not improve anyone's understanding of magnetic reconnection, including his.