MM explains his confusion, part 6
Since I don't have a clue how to proceed now, I'll make it simple. The instant you give up your PURE BLIND FAITH that Origin the great NULL is the "beginning" or the "ending" of any B line, you may proceed to part 5, and not one second before then. You WILL NOT violate the basic laws of physics in part 4.
To the best of my knowledge, I have never violated any fundamental laws of physics.
If I have violated any laws of physics, then they shouldn't be laws of physics. It should be impossible to violate a law of physics.
What
Michael Mozina means, of course, is that he thinks the
experiment I've been recommending to him since last December somehow violates the laws of physics, or that some part of my
simple derivation of magnetic reconnection involves calculations that are inconsistent with the laws of physics.
Note well, however, that
Michael Mozina has been unable to identify any law of physics that is inconsistent with my derivation. He has tried to suggest that my calculations are inconsistent with Gauss's law for magnetism, but it's absolutely trivial to prove that
all of the magnetic fields I have described satisfy Gauss's law for magnetism.
(Michael Mozina is unable to confirm that fact for himself, because he doesn't bark math.)
It is also easy to prove that
all magnetic field lines of B4 that run along the diagonals begin or end at a neutral point.
(Michael Mozina is unable to confirm that fact for himself, because he doesn't bark math.)
Since he doesn't bark math,
Michael Mozina can only argue from the authority of Wikipedia and other sources that have dumbed down the science for an audience that doesn't bark math:
No, you are wrong:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#B-field_lines_never_end
B-field lines never endMain article: Gauss's law for magnetism
Field lines are a useful way to represent any vector field and often reveal sophisticated properties of fields quite simply. One important property of the B-field revealed this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end (mathematically, B is a solenoidal vector field); a field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve.[nb 8] To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)
Unless you pull a magic monopole out of a hat during this conversation, you're wrong.
In this case, Wikipedia is wrong (but Wikipedia's more mathematical statement, in parentheses, is correct; there's an important lesson there). One of the good things that will come out of this discussion is that someone will eventually repair the multiple Wikipedia articles that repeat the almost-but-not-quite-true myth to which
Michael Mozina is so desperately clinging.
Another benefit of this discussion is that it has answered one of
Michael Mozina's perennial questions: Why is his inability/refusal to bark math relevant?
Answer: Because
Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, he can't discuss the actual science. When his authorities' mistakes are identified and refuted,
Michael Mozina can't answer (or even understand) the criticism.
Repeatedly shouting his dumbed-down "physics for poets" over-simplifications of Gauss's law for magnetism will not improve anyone's understanding of magnetic reconnection, including his.