Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since the burden of proof in this thread is the responsibility of the......

Clinger has been *HANDWAVING AWAY* for over a FULL YEAR now about his "vacuum" contraption that would demonstrate "magnetic reconnection". This is HIS CLAIM, not mine, and HIS BURDEN of proof, not mine.

He's also the one claiming that B lines have a beginning and ending. His burden of proof, not mine. No monopoles, no beginnings or endings of B lines. Has he got a monopole up his sleeve or what?
 
Last edited:
Clinger has been *HANDWAVING AWAY* for over a FULL YEAR now about his "vacuum" contraption that would demonstrate "magnetic reconnection". This is HIS CLAIM, not mine, and HIS BURDEN of proof, not mine.


W.D.Clinger has done a pretty good job so far of making his explanation simple and clear to those who have the ability to understand it. Complaining about not understanding it does not make the explanations any less correct or valid.

He's also the one claiming that B lines have a beginning and ending. His burden of proof, not mine. No monopoles, no beginnings or endings of B lines. Has he got a monopole up his sleeve or what?


Since this is the electric Sun thread, the burden of proof in this thread is the responsibility of the electric Sun proponents. The correct and honest way to proceed is to support that conjecture rather than demanding that other people explain the physics supporting the contemporary consensus position.
 
W.D.Clinger has done a pretty good job so far of making his explanation simple and clear to those who have the ability to understand it.

Sure, and as long as you don't mind the fact that he's GROSSLY violating the laws of physics, praying to Origin the NULL, the beginning and ending of B lines, it's fine! When he, you, RC, and PS are ready to admit that a NULL point is *NOT* the beginning or the ending of any B line or collection of B lines, and B lines are continuous, without a beginning or an end, please let me know. Until then, IMO you're all clueless.
 
Last edited:
Sure, and as long as you don't mind the fact that he's GROSSLY violating the laws of physics, it's fine! When he, you, RC, and PS are ready to admit that a NULL point is *NOT* the beginning or the ending of any B line or collection of B lines, and B lines are continuous, without a beginning or an end, please let me know. Until then, IMO you're all clueless.


Not understanding W.D.Clinger's explanation is not a valid criticism of it. That would be an argument from ignorance.

This is the electric Sun thread. The burden of proof here is the responsibility of the electric Sun proponents. The honest way to proceed is to support that conjecture rather than demanding that other people explain the physics of the contemporary consensus position.
 
Not understanding W.D.Clinger's explanation is not a valid criticism of it.

Oh, I understand (and have explained) the fact that his belief in Origin the beginor and endor of B lines violates the laws of physics, because a NULL is not a beginning or an ending of a B line. Any FRESHMAN can understand a FRESHMAN mistake. Not one of you four even UNDERSTANDS his mistake. How pitiful.
 
I have HONESTLY seen high school students *CORRECTLY* verbally explain this experiment in a vacuum WITHOUT claiming that any B lines "begin" or "end" in the NULL. HOLY MOTHER OF PHYSICS!
HONESTLY - given your ignorance of physics you have no way to tell if these mythical high school students *CORRECTLY* verbally explained this experiment.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point
Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule)
Michael Mozina's delusion that permeability is inductance!
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length").

HONESTLY any high school students that verbally explain this freshman-level experiment in a vacuum withut mentioning that the B field lines cannot exists at the neutral point are *INCORRECTLY* verbally explaining this experiment in a vacuum. This would not be surprising because they would not have the knowledge needed for this. They will have the intelligence to understand the explanation:
  1. The neutral point has B=0.
  2. Magnetic field lines have a density that is proportional to the magnetic field strength.
  3. If B=0 then the density of magnetic field lines is zero.
  4. Thus there are no magnetic field lines at the neutral point.
  5. Therefore any magnetic field line that crosses a neutral point must break, i.e. end before it and start after it.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point

HOLY MOTHER OF PHYSICS!
 
OMG.
I cannot believe that you are writing inane rants!
And lying about me still: I am not an "EU hater". I am a pitier of the ignorance, inability/unwillingness to learn and delusions displayed by you.

As for the electric universe - I also pity anyone ignorant enough to think that it is a valid scientific theory.

:id:

It's absolutely amazing to me what you've learned about EU theory *WITHOUT* ever picking up, let alone reading a single book on the subject. :)

(Sorry Belz, I just couldn't resist. :) )
 
Last edited:
This is the electric Sun thread. The burden of proof here is the responsibility of the electric Sun proponents. The honest way to proceed is to support that conjecture rather than demanding that other people explain the physics of the contemporary consensus position.


And the follow-up...

Oh, I [...]


Nope. Empty.

It's [...]


Nope, nothing here. Lots of words keep appearing but they barely even relate to an electric Sun conjecture much less actually provide any support for it. Apparently I was correct many, many pages ago when I noted that it's unsupportable.
 
It's absolutely amazing to me what you've learned about EU theory *WITHOUT* ever picking up, let alone reading a single book on the subject. :)
It's absolutely not amazing to me given your displayed ignorance of physics that you have not learned that EU theory does not have any validity :eye-poppi!

It is off topic because your electric sun fantasy has little to do with EU theory but there are plenty of problems with the EU solar fantasy, e.g. that the currents they demand to happen
  • are not detected and
  • would make the Sun explode!
 
MM explains his confusion, part 6

Since I don't have a clue how to proceed now, I'll make it simple. The instant you give up your PURE BLIND FAITH that Origin the great NULL is the "beginning" or the "ending" of any B line, you may proceed to part 5, and not one second before then. You WILL NOT violate the basic laws of physics in part 4.
To the best of my knowledge, I have never violated any fundamental laws of physics.

If I have violated any laws of physics, then they shouldn't be laws of physics. It should be impossible to violate a law of physics.

What Michael Mozina means, of course, is that he thinks the experiment I've been recommending to him since last December somehow violates the laws of physics, or that some part of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection involves calculations that are inconsistent with the laws of physics.

Note well, however, that Michael Mozina has been unable to identify any law of physics that is inconsistent with my derivation. He has tried to suggest that my calculations are inconsistent with Gauss's law for magnetism, but it's absolutely trivial to prove that all of the magnetic fields I have described satisfy Gauss's law for magnetism. (Michael Mozina is unable to confirm that fact for himself, because he doesn't bark math.)

It is also easy to prove that all magnetic field lines of B4 that run along the diagonals begin or end at a neutral point. (Michael Mozina is unable to confirm that fact for himself, because he doesn't bark math.)

Since he doesn't bark math, Michael Mozina can only argue from the authority of Wikipedia and other sources that have dumbed down the science for an audience that doesn't bark math:

MM, you are wrong.

No, you are wrong:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#B-field_lines_never_end

B-field lines never endMain article: Gauss's law for magnetism

Field lines are a useful way to represent any vector field and often reveal sophisticated properties of fields quite simply. One important property of the B-field revealed this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end (mathematically, B is a solenoidal vector field); a field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve.[nb 8] To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)

Unless you pull a magic monopole out of a hat during this conversation, you're wrong.
In this case, Wikipedia is wrong (but Wikipedia's more mathematical statement, in parentheses, is correct; there's an important lesson there). One of the good things that will come out of this discussion is that someone will eventually repair the multiple Wikipedia articles that repeat the almost-but-not-quite-true myth to which Michael Mozina is so desperately clinging.

Another benefit of this discussion is that it has answered one of Michael Mozina's perennial questions: Why is his inability/refusal to bark math relevant?

Answer: Because Michael Mozina doesn't bark math, he can't discuss the actual science. When his authorities' mistakes are identified and refuted, Michael Mozina can't answer (or even understand) the criticism.

Repeatedly shouting his dumbed-down "physics for poets" over-simplifications of Gauss's law for magnetism will not improve anyone's understanding of magnetic reconnection, including his.
 
This is the electric Sun thread. The burden of proof here is the responsibility of the electric Sun proponents. The honest way to proceed is to support that conjecture rather than demanding that other people explain the physics of the contemporary consensus position.
Not quite right, GeeMack :).
When I see "electric Sun", I think about the electric universe fantasies about the Sun (e.g. the Sun is a giant lightbulb powered by interstellar electric currents). Those are obvious fantasies because the evidence is that the Sun is powered by internal fusion.

This thread is about Michael Mozina's solar fantasy, that electrical discharges cause solar flares. This is a fantasy because he has never been able to find any scientific literature on electrical discharges within plasma. He has been relying on Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma .

MM lately seems to have softened that assertion to electrical discharges happen in solar flares. We know that by definition this is wrong (no dielectric medium to breakdown as in Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge). If MM was honest about this then all we would have is his insistence on using an obsolete term for large current density in magnetic reconnection (e.g. Dungey's 'electric discharge' = high current density in magnetic reconnection).

The strange thing is now MM wants to make his 'electric sun theory' even more of a fantasy by denying that magnetic reconnection exists (and so the obsolete usage of 'electrical discharge' is about something that does not exist!) despite the fact that the scientific literature states that he is wrong :jaw-dropp!
Or maybe he is sticking to his other delusion that he can dictate scientific terminology to the world by arbitrarily renaming magnetic reconnection to something that has little to do with the major process that is happening (his 'current reconnection') or to a complete fantasy ('his 'circuit reconnection').
 
Mr. Mozina,
Thank you for the link to H. Önel and G. J. Mann paper. I had already downloaded it some time ago but had yet to thoroughly examine it. I am currently assimilating the paper but I am also reading several other books so it may take me some time. However, from my brief sampling, I can say that this is the type of work I was encouraging you to undertake or at least investigate.

Be it known though, that Önel and Mann are proposing an energy release mechanism that relegates reconnection as a ancillary process.

Önel and Mann said:
The basic idea of this mechanism is to generate the flare energy by photospheric plasma motions in active regions. This is in contradiction to the reconnection model in which the magnetic field energy in the corona is taken for the flare.


So in effect, arguing for Dungey's model would be in conflict with this model to some degree.

In fact, it puzzles me that you are holding Dungey's paper as support for your contentions but I will assume that you have some esoteric reasons that I cannot yet fathom.

Regarding your objections to Dr. Clinger's presentation. I am having some difficulties parsing your argument. It appears to me that you are attacking it on two points; as a violation of the conservation of energy and because you think it breaks the continuity of the magnetic field. Please correct me if these are not your contentions.

Dr. Clinger,
Thank you for your most generous presentation. I very much appreciate the amount of work you have put into it. I eagerly await the final part. My only criticism so far would be your use of the term “freshman” mathematics in your posts. Perhaps “undergraduate” would be more appropriate. I do not think a freshman would be savvy to your conversion of the tensor of the magnetic field B(x,y,z,t) to its vector form B(t)(x,y,z) for example. Then again, I may just have been a slow undergraduate student. I suspect that your intent was to convey that firstly, it is a fundamental principle and secondly, to agitate Mr. Mozina.
 
Dr. Clinger,
Thank you for your most generous presentation. I very much appreciate the amount of work you have put into it. I eagerly await the final part.
Thank you. I have a lot of grading to do and an exam to finish this week, so the final part will probably have to wait until the weekend.

My only criticism so far would be your use of the term “freshman” mathematics in your posts. Perhaps “undergraduate” would be more appropriate. I do not think a freshman would be savvy to your conversion of the tensor of the magnetic field B(x,y,z,t) to its vector form B(t)(x,y,z) for example. Then again, I may just have been a slow undergraduate student. I suspect that your intent was to convey that firstly, it is a fundamental principle and secondly, to agitate Mr. Mozina.
Your criticisms are perceptive. I studied first-year physics at the University of Texas, where the Berkeley physics sections were limited to students majoring in physics or math, so I may not have a very good idea of what more typical freshman-level courses in electromagnetism would cover. I cannot pretend to have been an average student, and I understand the relevant math better today than when I was learning the basics of electromagnetism, so I may be over-estimating the mathematical sophistication of first-year physics majors.
 
To the best of my knowledge, I have never violated any fundamental laws of physics.

The operative phrase in your sentence is "to the best of my knowledge". You are in fact violating basic physics, starting with Gauss's law of magnetism because no monopoles exist. Your mythical "exception" in your math formula isn't an exception at all! It's a NULL POINT, not a "beginning" or an "ending" of any of the those B lines that you keep claiming ORIGIN THE NULL CREATED! OMG. I've never seen someone DO THE MATH but have absolutely NO UNDERSTANDING AT ALL of what it actually MEANS until today!

The only way magnetic lines might "begin" or "end" would be if someone found a MONOPOLE, not a NULL POINT! Oy Vey.

If I have violated any laws of physics, then they shouldn't be laws of physics. It should be impossible to violate a law of physics.

Yes, I can see that laws of physics don't mean a damn thing to you.

What Michael Mozina means, of course, is that he thinks the experiment I've been recommending to him since last December somehow violates the laws of physics,

It does. It absolutely, positively violates Gauss's law of magnetism. You don't have any monopoles hiding in your pocket do you?

Note well, however, that Michael Mozina has been unable to identify any law of physics that is inconsistent with my derivation.

Bull.

[He has tried to suggest that my calculations are inconsistent with Gauss's law for magnetism,

Yes, because you keep prattling on and on about how Origin is the beginning and the and ending of the EM universe!

but it's absolutely trivial to prove that all of the magnetic fields I have described satisfy Gauss's law for magnetism. (Michael Mozina is unable to confirm that fact for himself, because he doesn't bark math.)

All your "math" demonstrates is that 0+0=0 and magnetic fields exist in a quadrapole experiment. What you have not done, and never could do without a monopole is demonstrate that magnetic fields "begin" or "end". You're *STILL* completely clueless to the fact that any NULL is not the "beginning" nor the "ending" of any line! OMG. This is like a twilight zone episode. You think a NULL is a monopole! What in your opinion *IS* a monopole good for anyway?

Congratulations Clinger. You just demonstrated that you can do the math, without actually UNDERSTANDING any of those formulas. You're confused to the point that you can't even properly explain those math formulas. Wow!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#B-field_lines_never_end
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#Magnetic_monopole_.28hypothetical.29

A magnetic monopole is a hypothetical particle (or class of particles) that has, as its name suggests, only one magnetic pole (either a north pole or a south pole). In other words, it would possess a "magnetic charge" analogous to an electric charge. Magnetic field lines would start or end on magnetic monopoles, so if they exist, they would give exceptions to the rule that magnetic field lines neither start nor end.

Unless you have a monopole hiding in your pocket, you just violated Guass's law of magnetism, not to mention pure common sense. As I've been telling you, only PHYSICAL THINGS, like moving charged particles can even "create" (not begin or end) magnetic fields. Your Origin the vacuum god isn't capable of even "creating" fields, let alone "beginning or ending" them! Your explanation of your own math formulas was utterly and completely FUBAR!
 
Last edited:
Thank you. I have a lot of grading to do and an exam to finish this week, so the final part will probably have to wait until the weekend.

Don't even bother or think about starting the plasma switcheroo part of your presentation until you've lost your religion in "Origin the Null, the great beginor and endor of every magnetic line in the B field vacuum universe." You're Kludging the vacuum part of your own experiment to the point of pure absurdity, starting with the fact that you believe that NULL point is a "beginning" and "ending" of a magnetic line, and monopoles are unrelated to the B field "beginning and ending" rule that you're KLUDGING TO HELL.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Mozina,
Thank you for the link to H. Önel and G. J. Mann paper. I had already downloaded it some time ago but had yet to thoroughly examine it. I am currently assimilating the paper but I am also reading several other books so it may take me some time. However, from my brief sampling, I can say that this is the type of work I was encouraging you to undertake or at least investigate.

Oh, I've been investigating. :)

Be it known though, that Önel and Mann are proposing an energy release mechanism that relegates reconnection as a ancillary process.

Not necessarily. I'm just suggesting as Alfven did that that it's an INDUCED E field oriented process in plasma that involves massive releases of energy in a double layer. It's still an "electrical discharge" process in plasma. It still involves INDUCED E fields and large current flows. IMO Alfven's double layer paper and Dungey's reconnection paper describe the same process with different "names" to describe the process. Alfven is clear that it's an induced E field process, whereas Dungey was sloppy in terms of terminology IMO, but he got the physics right.

So in effect, arguing for Dungey's model would be in conflict with this model to some degree.

Not really. They actually mention "magnetic reconnection/discharges" as a possible source of energy in that paper. It's actually the closest thing to working the process from both ways that I have seen, up until that paper by the UCLA group that explained their experiments using ordinary circuit theory. Still, the Mann and Onel paper includes solar observations which is why I really like it.

In fact, it puzzles me that you are holding Dungey's paper as support for your contentions but I will assume that you have some esoteric reasons that I cannot yet fathom.

I'm still trying to teach Clinger the difference between magnetic flux changes in a vacuum, and an electrical discharge process in a plasma.

Regarding your objections to Dr. Clinger's presentation. I am having some difficulties parsing your argument. It appears to me that you are attacking it on two points; as a violation of the conservation of energy and because you think it breaks the continuity of the magnetic field. Please correct me if these are not your contentions.

I'm irked and upset because he keeps calling a NULL point of a B line a "beginning and ending" point of that very same line. The only way that magnetic fields could exchange energy directly, or begin or end, would be if monopoles existed. His B line reconnection "animation" relates to mythical "monopoles" not to ordinary B line behaviors at "NULL POINTS"!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom