Ear candling

Some of the infomercials hawking colon cleansing products claim that coroners report something like 20 pounds of undigested food and other matter in the colon and digestive system.

Now, some time ago I had a colonoscopy (fun!) and had to prepare the night before with some vile-tasing liquid that purged everything out of me. After two trips to the bathroom nothing but water was coming out. I never weighed it but I'm quite certain that it was not 20 pounds of solid matter that came out of me.

I like the commercials that refer to fecal matter in the colon as "toxins" that you must get rid of. Yes...I guess you could call them toxins. However, the large intestine is the ideal place to keep these "toxins" until we can flush them away.
 
Some of the infomercials hawking colon cleansing products claim that coroners report something like 20 pounds of undigested food and other matter in the colon and digestive system.

Now, some time ago I had a colonoscopy (fun!) and had to prepare the night before with some vile-tasing liquid that purged everything out of me. After two trips to the bathroom nothing but water was coming out. I never weighed it but I'm quite certain that it was not 20 pounds of solid matter that came out of me.

20 pounds ??? Holy crap !! Can a digestive system even hold 20 pounds of undigested food ?

I've never had a colonoscopy, but I have had amoebic dysentery. Same effect, you end up pissing out your bum. All I could think of was how clean and shiny my colon is going to be after I finish up.

Then the clinic opened up, I entered the waiting room, took my number and retreated to the bathroom after requesting that they call my number really loudly, they thoughtfully gave me a sample bottle to take in with me. After I got the diagnosis, I took the drugs everything got back to normal and I started looking at business advertising colon hydrotherapy in a new, terrifying light.

I did get lots of well meaning woo "cures" for my ailment from herbs, to "eat lots of bananas"
 
(my bolding)

There may be no benefits. From here: http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/gastro.html


Yeah, colonic irrigation is quackery. As far as I've heard, no benefit has ever been proven, and it can even cause digestive problems by disrupting the intestinal microflora.


They've been claiming that particular bit of woo for generations. I've heard every number from 8 pounds and up. All of it c@@@. I remember once reading a flyer for vegetarianism that claimed meat took longer to digest that veggies and that tigers had longer (and more "poo" filled) intestines than cows.

Uh, no.


I heard it the other way round, that tigers and other carnivores have a much shorter tract because meat tends to spoil faster and starts to produce toxins, whereas plant matter is "cleaner," does not decay as fast, and therefore can be kept in the body longer without releasing "toxins," so herbivores have a longer digestive tract.

This is for the most part true, right up to the part about the "toxins" and related problems. Carnivores do have a shorter alimentary canal, but that has nothing to do with toxins. The plain fact is, it requires less energy to break down and derive energy from meat than from plant stuffs. Plant cells have tough cell walls that must be broken down to access the nutritious stuff inside, and more chemical energy is needed to break the plant stuffs down into smaller nutritional components that animals can use.

The wooish argument goes that humans have a long digestive tract, therefore we are biologically unsuited to eating meat, and doing so releases toxins into the body. That is bunkum, as is the notion that pounds and pounds of meat accumulate within the intestines throughout our lives. The human digestive tract is not overly long, and we have only one stomach unlike most herbivores. The fact is that we are omnivores. Of course a balanced diet is necessary for good health, and overeating read meat can cause medical problems, but healthy people on every continent on Earth eat meat. Whether or not we do so is a matter of cultural, economic or ideological choice.

So there's no need to get your butthole power-washed to remove "meat residue."
 
As it happens, the suggested mechanisms behind ear candling have been put to the test.
It was found that:
1) A suction effect caused by lowering the pressure in the ear canal does not appear
2) The temperature in the ear canal doesn't become high enough for the earwax to melt

Ben Goldacre suggests (In his book "Bad science") a few tests that can easily be done by anybody who wants:

1) Try and light one of the candles over some dust you can find at home, and check if it gets sucked into the light.
2) Light one candle without sticking it into the ear, and another one in the ear as instructed. Afterwards cut both lights, and put a little bit of the ear wax resembling stuff in the middle on your finger, and briefly touch your tongue. Note if they both taste like candle wax or only one of them does.
 
2) Light one candle without sticking it into the ear, and another one in the ear as instructed. Afterwards cut both lights, and put a little bit of the ear wax resembling stuff in the middle on your finger, and briefly touch your tongue. Note if they both taste like candle wax or only one of them does.


Gross!
 
I use the warm water/peroxide/syringe technique as soon as I get out of the shower, and get out a chunk of wax about the size of a pencil eraser.

I use a homeopathic dilution of earwax. It seems to work well with the syringe (but strangely doesn't work without the syringe).
 
When I got to my duty station, I once assisted the doctor with one of these. He tried the little rubber bulb syringe with no luck....
He got one of those huge stainless steel jobs and proceeded to shoot fire-hose pressure solution straight into the ear canal, causing the poor GI to sort of rock sideways in his chair. Got the crud out, though.

Likewise. I've had very little luck with the rubbber bulb you can buy at the drugstore. I ordered myself a nice stainless syringe on Amazon, and ever since then my Homeopathic earwax dilution has worked very well.
 
A pharmacy I sometimes go to has them on their counter. I voiced my skepticism on the matter to the pharmacist but his reply was, "Well, people buy them." :confused::confused::confused:
 
When I was very young, my grandmother would gently breathe into my ear, and that would make my earache feel better for a few minutes.
I suppose, looking back, it was a placebo, though I suppose the warmth and moisture might have had some effect.

In fairness to my grandmother, this was a temporary measure while my mom was out getting the antibiotic prescription filled.

People used to do this maneuver by breathing cigarette smoke into kids' ears too.:eye-poppi
 
A pharmacy I sometimes go to has them on their counter. I voiced my skepticism on the matter to the pharmacist but his reply was, "Well, people buy them." :confused::confused::confused:
That's worrying.

Question posed to creduloid: "Why have you bought ear candles?"
Creduloid: "Because the pharmacy stocks them, so they must work"
Pharmacist: "People buy them so I stock 'em".

Oh dear.... :(

ETA: if it was me, Burning Beard, I would return to said pharmacist and ask him why he doesn't stock lucky rabbits' feet, talismans, magic wands and the Book of Shadows. Because, people would buy that **** too if they thought it would work.
 
Last edited:
I wanted to read your link, but the article costs $45. Do you have a link to the full article that is free?

strange, it was freely accessible when I linked to it. Maybe I was accidentally using an exploit, or maybe I was signed into Athens without realizing it.

If you want me to locate & send you a copy, drop me a PM.

EDIT: I just signed in with Athens and was unable to get at the article. It must have been an exploit that they've now closed.
 
Last edited:
I quite often remark to pharmacy assistants, in a loud voice, that I find it puzzling that a business staffed by a trained medical professionals would stock such nonsense.

The last one fired back "but lots of people swear by them". I countered with a list of stuff people swear by that they could also stock, including homeopathic remedies, acupuncture needles, etc etc. Perhaps she would like me to realign her chakras for $50. If it didnt work we could simply pray to Allah. Or perhaps we could sacrifice a virgin to the volcano gods. Something's gotta work.

She shut up after that. I cant understand why. People are so damn sensitive.
 
I've seen homeopathic stuff and magnet therapy stuff at the pharmacy. Also plenty of herbal supplements that aren't FDA regulated.
 
The rubber bulbs work fine, as long as you can squeeze them hard enough. Think "Superman compressing lumps of coal into diamonds in his hand" and you'll have the pressure just about right.
 
The rubber bulbs work fine, as long as you can squeeze them hard enough. Think "Superman compressing lumps of coal into diamonds in his hand" and you'll have the pressure just about right.


The ones that they include in the earwax kits are just too small to be very effective unless you work hard at it.

I learned this after misplacing the one I had been using, during a move. It had originally been sold as an 'infant nasal aspirator' (snot-sucker) we had gotten when the young-uns were small, and was about twice the size of the ones that come in the earwax kits. You actually don't have to squeeze it as hard. The added duration makes a big difference.

Buy one of those and a big bottle of peroxide. It's loads cheaper in the long run. (Taking a really hot shower right before you use it makes a huge difference too.)
 
Last edited:
--
written by TDjazz, April 07, 2011
Don't these people who use ear candles know the combustible nature of the brain? They could start a brain fire that could cause an explosion. Don't they know anything about science?
 
Now, some time ago I had a colonoscopy (fun!) and had to prepare the night before with some vile-tasing liquid that purged everything out of me. After two trips to the bathroom nothing but water was coming out. I never weighed it but I'm quite certain that it was not 20 pounds of solid matter that came out of me.

Couple of years ago, I had a simultaneous bronchoscopy, endoscopy(stomach) and colonoscopy. 24 hour fast before and a vile drink every 6 hours.

At first I thought it wasn't working. Then I found out different. It was incredible.

But there is no way that amount of matter was evacuated, so I fully agree.

Wasn't nice though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom