Ear candling

You missed something. I'm sorry, but I don't have the time to teach you how to read academic papers, except to point out that you should check their references.

This paper actually goes a lot further than those claiming that ear candling has nothing more than a placebo effect. What it establishes is that there is no evidence whatsoever of ear candling having any effects whatsoever apart from running the risk of injuring people.

Indeed. /thread. Now, for something actually interesting. Is it possible to make a candle out of earwax?

 
So far, I've managed to perforate my left eardrum, twice. I'm no stranger to the ear, nose and throat doc so on one occasion when I was sitting in the chair having my ear canal scraped out I asked about ear candling.

Her response..

If it was in anyway effective, we'd be doing it instead of all this scraping and sucking.
 
If it was in anyway effective, we'd be doing it instead of all this scraping and sucking.
What Dara O'Briain said about herbal medicine also applies to these 'alternative' medicines:

"I'm sorry, 'herbal medicine'; 'Oh, herbal medicine's been around for thousands of years!' Indeed it has, and then we tested it all, and the stuff that worked became 'medicine', and the rest of it is just a nice bowl of soup and some potpourri, so knock yourselves out".
 
Right. So the wax is softened which then allows it to move through the ear canal naturally. That would seem to confirm that it worked for what ailed me, no?

No, there is not enough heat from the "candle" to soften ear wax. Anything "drawn out" is also produced if you burn the candle outside the ear under certain conditions.

What does work on over-waxy ears is several drops of warm food-grade or cosmetics-grade oil into the ear canal, followed several minutes later by some warm soapy water. Or buy the commercial ear wax solvent solutions and use them. Some people just have very dry, thick wax.

What convinced a friend of mine that it was a pile of quackery was when she encountered the "Hopi priests ear candling" image (http://www.quackometer.net/blog/uploaded_images/hopi-701784.jpg ) and realized it was taken from a gift shop in the Grand Canyon.
 
I have to say, the concept of "Rear Candling" made me laugh. I am almost surprised that it isn't real.
 
That's the spirit! :D

...but I didn't actually mean to tell you how to think. I was just relating what works for me.

If this stuff gets you that bothered, my way is probably not going to work for you.

Eh, it's just that because the OP involves people I care about I've been taking it a bit personally. At least I recognize the need to bow out and let cooler heads prevail.
 
Of course, the Hopis have asked the manufacturer to stop associating the woo with them; predictably, perhaps, the manufacturer has ignored them.

Whenever we have visitors, a trip to Sedona is called for. As well as its natural beauty, it still clings on to the title of the Woo capital of the world.
Quite a lot of the stuff is pushed as being of 'Native American' origin, even though much was actually made in China.

There have been voices raised, if not actual protests, that the Indian culture has been exploited.

As they have no political power, their complaints are summarily dismissed.

V.
 
My brother had been introduced to this goofy practice by a woman he worked with, so he brought a couple ear candles to my parents' place one evening when we were all gathered together.

He insisted I try it, so I did. The experience was weird, but overall rather relaxing until the candle burned down enough for the heat to start bothering me. I stopped it when I became afraid the thing might set my hair on fire.

Afterwards, we unpeeled the remaining stub of candle and recoiled in disgust at the powdery, burnt gook inside. My brother told me that all that stuff had been drawn out of my ear, and I immediately became skeptical. There seemed to be more blobs of wax inside that thing than a human ear could produce in a lifetime. I proposed a test. We had one ear candle left, so I stuck it into a coffee mug and lighted it. We waited for the thing to burn down to the same length as the stub that was left over from my in-ear test, and unpeeled it the same way as the first one.

Lo and behold, the candle that had burned down in the cup contained the same kind of powdery, waxy stuff in roughly the same amount as the one that had burned in my ear.

So yeah, I'm convinced it's total BS.

There seems to be a whole branch of quackery built around things that generate disgusting-looking substances, with claims that the "medicines" and "treatments" are removing "toxins" from the body.

Anybody familiar with the "all-natural colon cleanser" capsules that create a stringy, goopy gelatin-like substance in the stool? The claim is that the material is "toxins" being leached out of the large intestine, when in fact it's the chemical reaction of the pill contents with the fluids of the digestive system.

There's also some kind of foot-cleaner pads that purport to remove "toxic excretions" that the body releases through the soles of the feet. In reality they're just exfoliating alcohol pads that remove regular-old dirt and dead skin.
 
Last edited:
So yeah, I'm convinced it's total BS.

There seems to be a whole branch of quackery built around things that generate disgusting-looking substances, with claims that the "medicines" and "treatments" are removing "toxins" from the body.

Anybody familiar with the "all-natural colon cleanser" capsules that create a stringy, goopy gelatin-like substance in the stool? The claim is that the material is "toxins" being leached out of the large intestine, when in fact it's the chemical reaction of the pill contents with the fluids of the digestive system.

There's also some kind of foot-cleaner pads that purport to remove "toxic excretions" that the body releases through the soles of the feet. In reality they're just exfoliating alcohol pads that remove regular-old dirt and dead skin.

Looks like you did the same experiment they did over on The Dope and got the same results.

tea, toxins. i hear chatter about these things IRL and when I press for more information, like what kind of toxins ? I get a vague response like, "toxins, you know"

I never really explored the colon cleansing thing, the whole idea kind of creeps me out but remember that old adage that the average person dies with something like 2 pounds of undigested meat in their colon. Maybe this is true for someone who succumbs to a heart attack in the all you can eat steak buffet, but I've never found anything credible to substantiate the statement.

The Kinoki footpads ? There was a thread around here about them. A quick search reveals they appear to have changed their name to The Suresafe Foot Detox Patches and they appear to have abandoned their monthly subscription method of marketing in favour of "just buy a bunch of them".
 
wow, did you even bother to read the article? Here's another link in case that one was broken:

http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=403194

This isn't an opinion piece, apart from the final conclusion. It's a review article, looking at every mention of ear candling in the academic literature, including trials of ear candling.
I wanted to read your link, but the article costs $45. Do you have a link to the full article that is free?
 
Me too, I was hoping something that would confirm the placebo effect claim might have been forthcoming.

When I was very young, my grandmother would gently breathe into my ear, and that would make my earache feel better for a few minutes.
I suppose, looking back, it was a placebo, though I suppose the warmth and moisture might have had some effect.

In fairness to my grandmother, this was a temporary measure while my mom was out getting the antibiotic prescription filled.
 
I never really explored the colon cleansing thing, the whole idea kind of creeps me out but remember that old adage that the average person dies with something like 2 pounds of undigested meat in their colon. Maybe this is true for someone who succumbs to a heart attack in the all you can eat steak buffet, but I've never found anything credible to substantiate the statement.

Some of the infomercials hawking colon cleansing products claim that coroners report something like 20 pounds of undigested food and other matter in the colon and digestive system.

Now, some time ago I had a colonoscopy (fun!) and had to prepare the night before with some vile-tasing liquid that purged everything out of me. After two trips to the bathroom nothing but water was coming out. I never weighed it but I'm quite certain that it was not 20 pounds of solid matter that came out of me.
 
I have twice had a cleansing for a colonoscopy and have also had colonic irrigation. I have no idea about the benefits, but in terms of the experience the fprmer was far more unpleasant.
 
Last edited:
Some of the infomercials hawking colon cleansing products claim that coroners report something like 20 pounds of undigested food and other matter in the colon and digestive system.

Now, some time ago I had a colonoscopy (fun!) and had to prepare the night before with some vile-tasing liquid that purged everything out of me. After two trips to the bathroom nothing but water was coming out. I never weighed it but I'm quite certain that it was not 20 pounds of solid matter that came out of me.
They've been claiming that particular bit of woo for generations. I've heard every number from 8 pounds and up. All of it c@@@. I remember once reading a flyer for vegetarianism that claimed meat took longer to digest that veggies and that tigers had longer (and more "poo" filled) intestines than cows.

Uh, no.
 
I have twice had a cleansing for a colonoscopy and have also had colonic irrigation. I have no idea about the benefits, but in terms of the experience the fprmer was far more unpleasant.

(my bolding)

There may be no benefits. From here: http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/gastro.html

In 2009, Dr. Edzard Ernst tabulated the therapeutic claims he found on the Web sites of six "professional organizations of colonic irrigations." The themes he found included detoxification, normailzation of intestinal function, treatment of inflammatory bowel disease, and weight loss. He also found claims elated to asthma, menstrual irregularities, circulatory disorders, skin problems, and improvements in energy levels. Searching Medline and Embase, he was unable to find a single controlled clinical trial that substantited any of these claims [13].


[13] Ernst E. Colonic irrigation: therapeutic claims by professional organizations, a review. International Journal of Clinical Practcie 64:429-431, 2010.
 
They've been claiming that particular bit of woo for generations. I've heard every number from 8 pounds and up. All of it c@@@. I remember once reading a flyer for vegetarianism that claimed meat took longer to digest that veggies and that tigers had longer (and more "poo" filled) intestines than cows.

Uh, no.


I understand that some vegetarians have up to 20 pounds of pork pies lodged between their ears.
 
well I got my ear syringed this morning by the nurse at my doctors.

It was a big stainless steel thing and it blasted warm water into my ear for about 5 seconds and it did the job. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom