Ear candling

Ysidro

I'm watching you
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
5,320
I've known about this for awhile, but never knew anyone who did it. Until now. Several folks at the dojo I go to were talking about it and...well... let's just say it annoyed me.

All the usual sayings "it worked for me", "how do you know if you haven't tried it" and my personal new favorite "I didn't even know there was a bug in my ear!"

*headdesk*

I sent along some links to one of them, but I'm sure all I did was annoy them.

I just wish I knew a better way of telling people they're crazy than saying "you're crazy!"
 
Never heard of it before.
After some investigoogling, I am once again stunned at what people are willing to believe. I candle. In one's ear. :drool:
 
It isn't a candle in be the traditional sense, it is more like a hollow slow burning or smouldering tube. As I understand it, the heat creates a king of vaccum that draws out or shifts any foreign matter or gunk build up.

A new agey friend of mine recommended it for me once some years ago when I had a waxy blockage on my eardrum. I used it once then and had a good result, I had a the same experience a few years later for the same ailment.

There seems to be something in them that that works from my experience, but I am far from being an expert, keen advocate or regular user. However, I would recommend that one does a little more investigation before condemning them as stoopid.
 
Last edited:
It isn't a candle in be the traditional sense, it is more like a hollow slow burning or smouldering tube. As I understand it, the heat creates a king of vaccum that draws out or shifts any foreign matter or gunk build up.

Nope- any of the gunk found in the tube later came from the burning of the beeswax, not the earwax. If a vacuum is applied to a sealed tube, nothing in the tube will shift. If it's pulling something through, that would indicate that air would be getting in from the other end of the ear....

However, I would recommend that one does a little more investigation before condemning them as stoopid.

Like reading this: http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/candling.html ?
 
Yeah, like that. And the Skepdic article and the article on What's the Harm. I'm going to assume you can google them yourself.

Personally, if I have wax troubles I either see a specialist or use the OTC medication that the specialist says works. Never has an actual MD suggested ear candling to me.
 
Nope- any of the gunk found in the tube later came from the burning of the beeswax, not the earwax. If a vacuum is applied to a sealed tube, nothing in the tube will shift. If it's pulling something through, that would indicate that air would be getting in from the other end of the ear....

Like reading this: http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/candling.html ?

Fair enough. You did compare it to pouring acid on your crotch, they hardly seem the same to me hence my suggestion about research.

Nor did I claim I saw anything in the candle afterwards, I just said that the candling seemed to "draw out or shift" the gunk.

So why do some people (such as myself) claim it has worked for them? What happened do you think?
 
Last edited:
I never said I saw anything in the candle afterwards, I just said that the candling removed the gunk.

So why do some people (such as myself) claim it has worked for them? What happened do you think?

I would suspect that if the candle makes your ear feel warm, it might either soften the wax, or just feel nice enough that you assume it has somehow "worked". But I don't know how people have checked to quantify the amount of gunk in their ears before and after.
 
Right. So the wax is softened which then allows it to move through the ear canal naturally. That would seem to confirm that it worked for what ailed me, no?
 
Last edited:
Right. So the wax is softened which then allows it to move through the ear canal naturally. That would seem to confirm that it worked for what ailed me, no?
Or it softens it enough that it doesn't bother you.
 
I've known about this for awhile, but never knew anyone who did it. Until now. Several folks at the dojo I go to were talking about it and...well... let's just say it annoyed me.

All the usual sayings "it worked for me", "how do you know if you haven't tried it" and my personal new favorite "I didn't even know there was a bug in my ear!"

*headdesk*

I sent along some links to one of them, but I'm sure all I did was annoy them.

I just wish I knew a better way of telling people they're crazy than saying "you're crazy!"

I know a family of ear candlers too. It is a dangerous practice for sure and probably gives no benifit at all beyond what any pampering type of treatment would do for you. I hope to eventually get them to see that.

Here's a method I like to use;

Try not to think of people with different beliefs as 'crazy' or 'stupid' or other derogatory terms.

Most people hold some sort of belief without good reason or proper evidence. Many perfectly sane, intelligent and educated people believe in things that are not true. sometimes bizarre things. I would say that it is more normal to do that than not to. It is human nature, not insanity. If it weren't, the amazing one would be out of a job, right? ;)

Try not to look down on other people, or get annoyed with them for being humans. I know it's not easy at times, but if you stop thinking of them as being crazy, which they are not, I am sure the words to speak to them will come to you.

I like to talk to them like they are my friend. (they usually are) Instead of sending them a load of links, which sort of implies that you feel they need educating but don't think they are worth the time to talk to, just talk to them.

No matter what I think of someone's beliefs, I try to approach a discussion the same way. I like to ask questions, and really listen to their answers. In short, I cultivate & display a genuine interest in them as fellow humans. You can actually have a pretty interesting discussion that way. If there are holes in their thinking it will become evident to both of you, if you ask the right questions. If you find you are waiting for them to stop talking so you can make a brilliant point about how wrong they are, you are not going to succeed. If you don't think they are worth the time to talk to like this, then you should consider why their beliefs are so annoying to you. It probably should not matter to you.

Not that I don't get where you are coming from. Another person's beliefs can be as annoying as one of those cymbal-clashing monkey toys, but unfortunatly, you cant just flip a switch and shut them off like a toy. If you want to change ideas, you usually have to take a genuine interest in the person, treat them as an equal and respect their right to arrive at their own conclusions. You can't really fake that, either. If you engage someone only to 'save them from their own craziness' or something like that, they will be able to tell that and will give your words & ideas the same amount of respect that you are giving theirs. That is about zero.

Divesting someone of an inncorrect belief or idea is not a task that should be entered into lightly. Many times, these beliefs fill some emotional need or have a psychological component to them. people allow themselves these ideas because they want them in their lives for some reason. Getting them to let go of a thing like that usually can't be done in a single conversation or with a wall of text or without a lot of effort.

regards, Canis
 
Older thread with some good info countering the ear candle claim:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=183905

OH, and some bad info that I forgot about countering the claim as well :):

Did it really take 68 posts for someone to say this? I can't believe so many posts on the first page recommended a q-tip being inserted into one's ear! ...and some of the posters were real jerks about it too. Not knowing that they were recommending a worse idea than the one being suggested?

I thought putting a q-tip into one's ear was outed as being a horrible idea years ago? Didn't they have to add a "Q-Tips are for external use only." warning to the box? A quick google search for "q-tip warning" seems to agree.
 
Last edited:
I recently met ear candling in China, in a foot-massage parlour. (Chinese foot massage is tough, but great ;))

We were a group of business people and it seems our Chinese host had ordered a combine for us all: Foot massage and ear candling. Most of us Europeans refused the candles, but some of the others had it. Someone told me of having ear problems for two weeks after such a procedure, others like it, but note that the Cinese procedure is not just the candle: It entails a thorough massage of the head around the ears, and a rather invasive cleaning, so of course it has some effect.

Hans
 
my left ear is blocked up right now with wax :( its so annoying.

had the same thing about 10 years ago and almond oil did the trick. This time i've had no luck but have an appointment on monday to syringe my ear :)

i wont be sticking candles in my ear if the almond oil doesnt clear it by monday i'll be visiting the nurse.
 
Right. So the wax is softened which then allows it to move through the ear canal naturally. That would seem to confirm that it worked for what ailed me, no?

Or you could just hold a warm damp cloth to your ear, and reduce the risk of hot candlewax falling in your ear. Or your eye. Or your face. Or you setting fire to your pillow.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom