Ear Candle Worked?

You're right, I can't be. That's why I was doing some research and asking questions. I find it highly unlikely though that my ear purely randomly cleared up and stayed clear at the exact moment I removed the candle.

nvidiot suggested it was the fact that I was laying on my side, but that's how I sleep and I had the problem for several days.

You still don't have enough data to draw any conclusion.
 
On the notion of a Q-tip or similar implement, using one with a bad blockage can actually WORSEN it since you can end up pushing the wax plug towards your ear drum. I've done it several times.

Instead you should get some fluid that dissolves it from the chemist and then wash it out, or go to the doctor and have it removed (but this will probably be quite painful if it's stuck to the eardrum).
 
<snip>

Edit: Furthermore the suggestion of sticking "a damn Q-tip" into your ear in order to clear wax is frowned upon by medical types, for what ought to be pretty bloody obvious reasons.

On the notion of a Q-tip or similar implement, using one with a bad blockage can actually WORSEN it since you can end up pushing the wax plug towards your ear drum. I've done it several times.

<snip>

Did it really take 68 posts for someone to say this? I can't believe so many posts on the first page recommended a q-tip being inserted into one's ear! ...and some of the posters were real jerks about it too. Not knowing that they were recommending a worse idea than the one being suggested?

I thought putting a q-tip into one's ear was outed as being a horrible idea years ago? Didn't they have to add a "Q-Tips are for external use only." warning to the box? A quick google search for "q-tip warning" seems to agree.
 
Well, I stopped using them for internal swabbing after I accidentally rubbed (more like b battered, really) my eardrum with one. Ouuuuuuuuuch. Noises hurt for a week after that.
 
Otex* is a proprietary solution of hydrogen peroxide which works but can feel uncomfortable initially as it bubbles inside the ear. It may take several applications over the course of a few days and your ears may still need syringing after this. But don't use if there is any inflammation or perforation, such as that which might be caused by sticking a Q-Tip/cotton bud inside your canal in order to see if it comes out the other side.

* - Brands may vary depending on where you stay.
 
after using 2 or 3 it actually did clear the blockage in my ear.
Something puzzles me. After it didn't work with one why did you try a second time? After it didn't work the second time why did you try a third?

After the blockage cleared for some reason why to you attribute the blockage being cleared, to the process you'd twice proven doesn't work?

I don't know why the blockage cleared. Either it had something to do with the ear candling process (e.g. lying still with your head in a certain position) or far more likely it was something unrelated. Various types of ear blockage can be self limiting. They get worse, they get better.

Seems to me that what we have is likely a case of regression to the mean. The severity of the condition fluctuates, you're mo9st likely to take some sort of action (pray, cast a spell, submit a cosmic order, make a dietary change or sick burning wax in your ear) when the severity peaks, if as is likely the severity decreases afterwards then by post hoc ergo propter hocWP it's natural to assume that it was this action that caused the improvement. Natural but not necessarily true.
 
Where I once worked a colleague regaled us with an account of what happened when he was younger and tried to clean his ears by poking something into them. He perforated one of his ear drums and got a mid-ear infection with lots of nasty brown stuff coming out. He is now deaf in that ear.
 
My doctors at the Royal National Throat, Nose & Ear Hospital always say that they don't recommend sticking anything in your ear other than your elbow. (And good luck with that.)
 
Did it really take 68 posts for someone to say this? I can't believe so many posts on the first page recommended a q-tip being inserted into one's ear! ...and some of the posters were real jerks about it too. Not knowing that they were recommending a worse idea than the one being suggested?

I thought putting a q-tip into one's ear was outed as being a horrible idea years ago? Didn't they have to add a "Q-Tips are for external use only." warning to the box? A quick google search for "q-tip warning" seems to agree.
Yeah, but what else do you think a Q-Tip is really useful for, that couldn't be accomplished better, easier and cheaper with something else ?
 
Yeah, but what else do you think a Q-Tip is really useful for, that couldn't be accomplished better, easier and cheaper with something else ?

Cleaning the inside of anything small that isn't an ear? They have many other uses, unlike something that is bad and doesn't have other uses, say cigarettes.

(I wasn't saying people don't still buy them for the [improper] inner ear use.)
 
Otex* is a proprietary solution of hydrogen peroxide which works but can feel uncomfortable initially as it bubbles inside the ear. It may take several applications over the course of a few days and your ears may still need syringing after this. But don't use if there is any inflammation or perforation, such as that which might be caused by sticking a Q-Tip/cotton bud inside your canal in order to see if it comes out the other side.

* - Brands may vary depending on where you stay.

I was recommended olive oil - on the grounds that it's comparatively cheap and there's no good reason to think Otex or other ear wax drops are any better. Not sure if there's any good research behind Otex etc. now?

And putting q tips into your ear is a bad idea - can make things worse. Not actually sure if q tip or ear candle is a worse idea.

In terms of what the OP is saying about ear syringing at the Dr - I know I found it pretty unpleasant (more uncomfortable than getting a filling or a minor burn). Maybe some of us have sensitive ears :( I can certainly understand why people would want to avoid this - just a shame that ear candles etc. are worse than useless.
 
I use nose candles for mild congestion. They look really cool hanging from my schnazz.
 
Something puzzles me. After it didn't work with one why did you try a second time? After it didn't work the second time why did you try a third?
Yeah, that was another thing that set off my 'woo impersonating skeptic' alarm: "I was very skeptical about this, but after trying it three times it actually worked!" .....

Come ON. :rolleyes:

I don't think this boat can float, but let's try it.
- Nope, it sank. Let us try it once more.
- Nope, it sank. Let us try it still again. ...... :nope:

Hans
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that was another thing that set off my 'woo impersonating skeptic' alarm: "I was very skeptical about this, but after trying it three times it actually worked!" .....

Come ON. :rolleyes:

I don't think this boat can float, but let's try it.
- Nope, it sank. Let us try it once more.
- Nope, it sank. Let us try it still again. ...... :nope:

Hans
The instructions said that sometimes more than 1 is needed, in the same way other ear flushing techniques recommend that you "Repeat as necessary." I noticed improvement in my hearing with each candle, so it was not "Nope, it sank." more like "Huh, it seems to be doing something."

I wasn't going to not post anymore, but I really need to comment on the causation thing.
Post hoc ergo propter hoc?
I absolutely agree that this is a logical fallacy, but so is post hoc ergo non propter hoc. In fact, I'd say an even more ridiculous one. I firmly believe multiple angles should be explored. I perhaps sounded more concrete in my assertion that the ear candle alone cleared my ear than I really intended to be. I never intended to "prove" causation, I'm not a scientist and my test was no where near scientific, more a simple curiosity. I do, however, have more (albeit far from impenetrable) reasons than my simple one uncontrolled experience to suspect the ear candle helped. As I mentioned above, it wasn't a sudden pop, but an improvement with each application. I also have the accounts of my uncle and grandparents, whom I trust. Forgive me for not calling my grandmother a liar. As I said this is not unquestionable proof, just fuel for my speculation. Plus, if I had found even one experiment online that bothered to look at the effect the smoke/heat could have or that used multiple candles on people whose hearing was being muffled by the wax, instead of just looking at the idea that it created suction, I would never have come here to pick your brains.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom